Skip to main content

An experimental investigation into supercavity closure mechanisms

  • Ashish Karn (a1) (a2), Roger E. A. Arndt (a1) (a3) and Jiarong Hong (a1) (a2)

Substantial discrepancy in the conditions for attainment of different closure modes of a ventilated supercavity has existed widely in the published literature. In this study, supercavity closure is investigated with an objective to understand the physical mechanisms determining closure formation and transition between different closure modes and to reconcile the observations from prior studies under various flow settings. The experiments are conducted in a closed-wall recirculating water tunnel to image ventilated supercavity closure using high speed and high-resolution photography and simultaneously measure pressure inside the cavity. The flow conditions are varied systematically to cover a broad range of water velocity, ventilation flow rate and cavitator size, which correspond to different Froude numbers, air entrainment coefficients and blockage ratios, respectively. In addition to the classical closure modes reported in the literature (e.g. re-entrant jet, twin vortex, quad vortex, etc.), the study has revealed a number of new closure modes that occur during the transition between classical modes, or under very specific flow conditions. Closure maps are constructed to depict the flow regimes, i.e. the range of Froude number and air entrainment coefficient, for various closure modes at different blockage ratios. From the closure map at each blockage ratio, a critical ventilation flow rate, below which the supercavity collapses into foamy cavity upon reduction of Froude number, is identified. The air entrainment coefficients corresponding to such critical ventilation rate are found to be independent of blockage ratio. It has been observed that in the process of generating a supercavity by increasing ventilation flow rate, the cavitation number gradually reduces to a minimum value and stays fixed upon further increments in the ventilation rate. Once a supercavity is formed, the ventilation rate can be decreased to a much lower value with no change in cavitation number while still maintaining a supercavity. This process is accompanied by a change in closure modes, which generally goes from twin vortex, to quad vortex, and then to re-entrant jet. In addition, the blockage effect is shown to play an important role in promoting the occurrence of twin-vortex closure modes. Subsequently, a physical framework governing the variation of different closure modes is proposed, and is used to explain mode transition upon the change of flow conditions, including the blockage effect. This framework is further extended to shed light on the occurrence of closure modes for ventilated supercavitation experiments across different types of flow facilities, the natural supercavity closure and the pulsating supercavity reported in the literature. Finally, in combination with a recent numerical study, our research discusses the role of the internal flow physics on the observed features during supercavity formation and closure-mode transition, paving the way for future investigations in this direction.

Corresponding author
Email address for correspondence:
Hide All
Ahn B. K., Kim J., Jun Y., Kim H. & Lee C. 2013 Experimental and numerical study of natural supercavitating flows. In Proceedings of the PRADS2013, CECO, Changwon City, Korea.
Buyvol V. N. 1980 Slender Cavities in Flows With Perturbations, Nauvoka Dunka; (in Russian).
Callenaere M., Franc J., Michel J. & Riondet M. 2001 The cavitation instability induced by the development of a re-entrant jet. J. Fluid Mech. 444, 223256.
Cox R. & Clayden W. 1956 Air entrainment at the rear of a steady cavity. In Proceedings of the Symposium on Cavitation in Hydrodynamics, London.
Epshtein L. 1973 Characteristics of ventilated cavities and some scale effects. In Proceedings of the International Symposium IUTAM, Unsteady Water Flow with High Velocities, pp. 173185. Nauka.
Gadd G. & Grant S. 1965 Some experiments on cavities behind disks. J. Fluid Mech. 23 (4), 645656.
Gopalan S. & Katz J. 2000 Flow structure and modeling issues in the closure region of attached cavitation. Phys. Fluids 12 (4), 895911.
Campbell I. J. & Hilborne D.V. 1958 Air entrainment behind artificially inflated cavity. In Proceedings of the Second Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Washington.
Hrubes J. 2001 High-speed imaging of supercavitating underwater projectiles. Exp. Fluids 30 (1), 5764.
Kapankin Y. N. & Gusev A. V. 1984 Experimental research of joint influence of fluid and lift power of cavitator on character of flow in cavity rear part and gas departure from it. Proc. CAHI 2244, 1928.
Karlikov V., Reznichenko N., Khomyakov A. & Sholomovich G. 1987 A possible mechanism for the emergence of auto-oscillations in developed artificial cavitation flows and immersed gas jets. Fluid Dyn. 22 (3), 392398.
Karlikov V. & Sholomovich G. 1966 Method of approximate account for the wall effect in cavitation flow around bodies in water tunnels. Fluid Dyn. 1 (4), 6164.
Karn A., Arndt R. E. A. & Hong J. 2015a Dependence of Supercavity closure upon flow unsteadiness. Exp. Therm. Fluid Sci. 68, 493498.
Karn A., Monson G., Ellis C., Hong J., Arndt R. & Gulliver J. 2015b Mass transfer studies across ventilated hydrofoils: A step towards hydroturbine aeration. Intl J. Heat Mass Transfer 87, 512520.
Kinzel M. P., Lindau J. W. & Kunz R. F. 2009 Air entrainment mechanisms from artificial supercavities: insight based on numerical simulations. In Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Cavitation, CAV 2009, Ann Arbor, vol. 136.
Kawakami E.2010 Investigation of the behavior of ventilated supercavities, MS Thesis, University of Minnesota, Twin cities.
Kawakami E. & Arndt R. E. A. 2011 Investigation of the behavior of ventilated supercavities. J. Fluid Engng 133 (9), 091305,1–11.
Kshatriya S., Patwardhan A. & Eaglesham A. 2007 Experimental studies of ventilated cavities in a channel. Chem. Engng Sci. 62 (4), 979989.
Kuklinski R., Castano J. & Henoch C. 2001 Experimental study of ventilated cavities on dynamic test model. In CAV 2001: Fourth International Symposium on Cavitation. Naval Undersa Weapons Center, Newport, RI.
Logvinovich G. V. 1973 Hydrodynamics of Free-Boundary Flows. Halsted Press.
Michel J. 1984 Some features of water flows with ventilated cavities. Trans. ASME J. Fluids Engng 106 (3), 319326.
Nesteruk I. 2014 Shape of slender axisymmetric ventilated supercavities. J. Comput. Engng 2014, 501590,1–18.
Paryshev E. 2003 Mathematical modelling of unsteady cavity flows. In Proceedings of Fifth International Symposium on Cavitation (CAV 2003), Osaka, Japan, pp. 118.
Peng X., Wang Z., Pan S. & Yan K. 2006 Generation mechanism of ventilated supercavitation in an axisymmetric body with cavitator. In Proceedings of Sixth International Symposium on Cavitation, CAV2006, Wageningen, Netherlands.
Pan Z., Lu C., Chen Y. & Hu S. 2010 Numerical study of periodically forced-pitching of a supercavitating vehicle. In Proceedings of Ninth International Conference on Hydrodynamics, Shanghai, China.
Savchenko Y. 2001 Supercavitation-problems and perspectives. In Fourth International Symposium on Cavitation. California Institute of Technology Pasadena, California, vol. 200.
Semenenko V. N. 2001a Artificial Supercavitation: Physics and Calculation. Ukrainian Academy of Sciences, Kiev Inst of Hydromechanics.
Semenenko V. N. 2001b Dynamic Processes of Supercavitation and Computer Simulation. Ukrainian Academy of Sciences, Kiev Inst of Gydromechanics.
Shi H., Itoh M. & Takami T. 2000 Optical observation of the supercavitation induced by high-speed water entry. Trans. ASME J. Fluids Engng 122 (4), 806810.
Silberman E. & Song C. S. 1961 Instability of ventilated cavities. J. Ship. Res. 5 (1), 1333.
Skidmore G.2013 The pulsation of ventilated supercavities, Master of Science thesis, Department of Aerospace Engineering, Pennsylvania State University.
Skidmore G., Brungart T. A., Lindau J. W. & Moeny M. J. 2015 Noise generated by ventilated supercavities. Noise Control Engr. J. 63 (1), 94101.
Song C. S.1961 Pulsation of ventilated cavities. (No. 32 B). Saint Anthony Falls Laboratory, University of Minnesota.
Spurk J. & König B. 2002 On the gas loss from ventilated supercavities. Acta Mech. 155, 125135.
Stinebring D. R., Billet M. L., Lindau J. W. & Kunz R. F.2001 Developed cavitation-cavity dynamics, DTIC Document.
Tulin M. P.1964 Supercavitating propellers, momentum theory. (No. TR-121-4). Hydronautics Inc. Laurel MD: DTIC Document.
Vlasenko Y. D. 2003 Experimental investigation of supercavitation flow regimes at subsonic and transonic speeds. In Fifth International Symposium on Cavitation, Osaka, Japan.
Wu T., Whitney A. K. & Brennen C. 1971 Cavity-flow wall effects and correction rules. J. Fluid Mech. 49 (2), 223256.
Wu T. 1972 Cavity and wake flows. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 4, 243284.
Zhang X., Wei Y., Zhang J., Wang C. & Yu K. 2007 Experimental research on the shape characters of natural and ventilated supercavitation. J. Hydrodyn. B 19 (5), 564571.
Zhou J., Yu K., Min J. & Yang M. 2010 The comparative study of ventilated super cavity shape in water tunnel and infinite flow field. J. Hydrodyn. B 22 (5), 689696.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Fluid Mechanics
  • ISSN: 0022-1120
  • EISSN: 1469-7645
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-fluid-mechanics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Type Description Title

Karn et al. supplementary movie
A side view of the unstable/hybrid twin vortex - quad vortex closure mechanism. Note that in this unstable mode, one to three vortices might intermittently disappear. The lower pair of vortices are more stable compared to the upper pair.

 Video (7.5 MB)
7.5 MB

Karn et al. supplementary movie
A side view of the twin vortex closure mechanism. The individual vortices can be seen more clearly in the bottom view.

 Video (111 KB)
111 KB

Karn et al. supplementary movie
A side view of the interacting vortex closure mechanism. It can be clearly seen that the two vortices interact with each other to form one single thick vortex at the closure.

 Video (1.5 MB)
1.5 MB

Karn et al. supplementary movie
A bottom view of the twin vortex closure mechanism. Note that the re-circulation of the two vortices are in the opposite direction.

 Video (2.6 MB)
2.6 MB

Karn et al. supplementary movie
A side view of the quad-vortex closure mechanism. The viewing angle is at an angle to the normal to show the four vortices. Both the front and rear bottom vortex have a vortex lying above it.

 Video (1.0 MB)
1.0 MB

Karn et al. supplementary movie
A bottom view of the re-entrant jet closure mechanism. Note how the liquid outside the cavity closure gushes into the cavity and the air is entrained out of the cavity in the form of toroidal vortices.

 Video (2.1 MB)
2.1 MB

Karn et al. supplementary movie
A side view of the hybrid twin vortex - re-entrant jet closure mechanism. Along with the two vortices, liquid gushing into the cavity can be seen as well.

 Video (3.5 MB)
3.5 MB

Karn et al. supplementary movie
A side view of the hybrid quad-vortex - re-entrant jet closure mechanism. The two pairs of vortices can be seen along with the liquid gushing into the cavity. The lower pair of vortices are more stable compared to the upper pair.

 Video (4.7 MB)
4.7 MB

Karn et al. supplementary movie
A side view of the re-entrant jet closure mechanism. Note how the liquid outside the cavity closure gushes into the cavity and the air is entrained out of the cavity in the form of toroidal vortices.

 Video (785 KB)
785 KB


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 8
Total number of PDF views: 173 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 443 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 20th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.