Skip to main content
×
Home

Digging deeper into Hardin's pasture: the complex institutional structure of ‘the tragedy of the commons’

  • DANIEL H. COLE (a1), GRAHAM EPSTEIN (a2) and MICHAEL D. MCGINNIS (a2)
Abstract
Abstract

A revised application of Ostrom's (Ostrom, 2007) Social-Ecological System (SES) framework to Hardin's ‘tragedy of the commons’ (Hardin, G. (1968), Science, 162(3859): 1243–1248) demonstrates that its institutional structure is more complex than either Hardin or Ostrom had imagined. The ‘tragedy’ arises from several interacting resources and institutions. If the grass on the pasture was not subject to appropriation, the cattle were not privately owned, or property- and contract-enforcement institutions supporting market exchange were absent, then the ‘tragedy of the commons’ would not have arisen regardless of the open-access pasture. This paper highlights the utility of the SES framework and the care required to apply it precisely to specific social-ecological situations.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Email: dancole@indiana.edu
**Email: gepstein@indiana.edu
***Email: mcginnis@indiana.edu
References
Hide All
Acheson J. M. (2006), ‘Institutional Failure in Resource Management’, Annual Review of Anthropology, 35 (1): 117134.
Agrawal A. and Yadama G. (1997), ‘How Do Local Institutions Mediate Market and Population Pressures on Resources? Forest Panchayats in Kumaon, India’, Development and Change, 28 (3): 435465.
Andersen P. (trans) (1983), ‘On Rent of Fishing Grounds: A Translation of Jens Warming's 1911 Article, with an Introduction’, History of Political Economy, 15 (3): 391396.
Araral E. (2013), ‘What Makes Socio-Ecological Systems Robust? An Institutional Analysis of the 2,000 Year-Old Ifugao Society’, Human Ecology, 41 (6): 859870.
Araral E. (2014), ‘Ostrom, Hardin and the Commons: A Critical Appreciation and a Revisionist View’, Environmental Science & Policy, 36: 1123.
Aristotle (1941), The Basic Works of Aristotle, McKeon R. (ed. and trans.), New York, NY: Random House, pp. 11271324.
Arnold E. C. (1921), ‘The Law of Possession Governing the Acquisition of Animals Ferae Naturae’, American Law Review, 55 (3): 393404.
Axelrod R. (1984), The Evolution of Cooperation, New York, NY: Basic Books.
Baland J.-M. and Platteau J.-P. (1996), Halting Degradation of Natural Resources, Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Ban N. C., Mills M., Tam J., Hicks C. C., Klain S., Stoeckl N., Bottrill M. C., Levine J., Pressey R. L., Satterfield T., and Chan K. M. A. (2013), ‘A Social-Ecological Approach to Conservation Planning: Embedding Social Considerations’, Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 11 (4): 194202.
Basurto X. and Ostrom E. (2009), ‘Beyond the Tragedy of the Commons’, Economia delle fonti di energia e dell'ambiente, 52 (1): 3560.
Birks P. and McLeod G. (trans.) (1987), Justinian's Institutes, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Blanco E. (2011), ‘A Social-Ecological Approach to Voluntary Environmental Initiatives: The Case of Nature-Based Tourism’, Policy Sciences, 44 (1): 3552.
Brook B. W., Sodhi N. S., and Ng P. K. L. (2003), ‘Catastrophic Extinctions Follow Deforestation in Singapore’, Nature, 424 (6947): 420426.
Chhatre A. and Agrawal A. (2009), ‘Trade-Offs and Synergies Between Carbon Storage and Livelihood Benefits from Forest Commons’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, 106 (42): 1766717670.
Cinner J. E., McClanahan T. R., MacNeil M. A., Graham N. A. J., Daw T. M., Ahmad Mukminin, Feary D. A., et al. (2012), ‘Comanagement of Coral Reef Social-Ecological Systems’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, 109 (14): 52195222.
Clark C. W. (1973a), ‘The Economics of Overexploitation’, Science, 181: 630634.
Clark C. W. (1973b), ‘Profit Maximization and the Extinction of Animal Species’, Journal of Political Economy, 81 (4): 950961.
Clement F. (2010), ‘Analysing Decentralised Natural Resource Governance: Proposition for a “Politicised” Institutional Analysis and Development Framework’, Policy Sciences, 43 (2): 129156.
Cole D. H. (2002), Pollution and Property: Comparing Ownership Institutions for Environmental Protection, Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Cole D. H. and Grossman P. Z. (2010), ‘Institutions Matter! Why the Herder Problem is not a Prisoner's Dilemma’, Theory and Decision, 69 (2): 219231.
Cole D. H. and E. Ostrom (2012), ‘The Variety of Property Systems and Rights in Natural Resources’, in Cole D. H. and Ostrom E. (eds.), Property in Land and Other Resources, Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, pp. 3764.
Coleman J. S. (1987), ‘Norms as Social Capital’, in Radnitzky G. and Bernholz P. (eds.), Economic Imperialism: The Economic Approach Applied Outside the Field of Economics, New York, NY: Paragon House, pp. 133155.
Cox M., Arnold G., and Tomas S. Villamayor (2010), ‘A Review of Design Principles for Community-Based Natural Resource Management’, Ecology and Society, 15 (4): 38.
Crawford S. E. S. and Ostrom E. (1995), ‘A Grammar of Institutions’, American Political Science Review, 89 (3): 582600.
Edmondson W. T., Anderson G. C., and Peterson D. R. (1956), ‘Artificial Eutrophication of Lake Washington’, Limnology and Oceanography, 1 (1): 4753.
Elster J. (2007), Explaining Social Behavior: More Nuts and Bolts for the Social Sciences, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Ensminger J. and Rutten A. (1991), ‘The Political Economy of Changing Property Rights: Dismantling a Pastoral Commons’, American Ethnologist, 18 (4): 683699.
Epstein G., Vogt J. M., Mincey S. K., Cox M., and Fischer B. (2013), ‘Missing Ecology: Integrating Ecological Perspectives with the Social-Ecological System Framework’, International Journal of the Commons, 7 (2): 432453.
Feeny D., Berkes F., McCay B. J., and Acheson J. M. (1990), ‘The Tragedy of the Commons: Twenty-Two Years Later’, Human Ecology, 18 (1): 119.
Fehr E., Fischbacher U., and Gächter S. (2002), ‘Strong Reciprocity, Human Cooperation, and the Enforcement of Social Norms’, Human Nature, 13 (1): 125.
Fleischman F., Boenning K., Garcia-Lopez G., Mincey S., Schmitt-Harsh M., Daedlow K., Lopez M. C., Basurto X., Fischer B., and Ostrom E. (2010), ‘Disturbance, Response, and Persistence in Self-Organized Forested Communities: Analysis of Robustness and Resilience in Five Communities in Southern Indiana’, Ecology and Society, 15 (4): 9.
Folke C., Pritchard L., Berkes F., Colding J., and Svedin U. (2007), ‘The Problem of Fit Between Ecosystems and Institutions: Ten Years Later’, Ecology and Society, 12 (1): 30.
Gordon H. S. (1954), ‘The Economic Theory of a Common-Property Resource: The Fishery’, Journal of Political Economy, 62 (2): 124.
Greif A. (2005), ‘Commitment, Coercion, and Markets: The Nature and Dynamics of Institutions Supporting Exchange’, in Ménard C. and Shirley M. (eds.), Handbook of New Institutional Economics, Amsterdam, Netherlands: Springer, pp. 727786.
Gutiérrez N. L., Hilborn R., and Defeo O. (2011), ‘Leadership, Social Capital and Incentives Promote Successful Fisheries’, Nature, 470 (7334): 386389.
Hardin G. (1968), ‘The Tragedy of the Commons’, Science, 162 (3859): 12431248.
Hobbes T. ([1651] 1994), Leviathan, Cambridge, MA: Hackett.
Holling C. S. and Meffe G. K. (1996), ‘Command and Control and the Pathology of Natural Resource Management’, Conservation Biology, 10 (2): 328337.
Hugo V. ([1862] 1887), The Works of Victor Hugo, Hapgood I. F. (trans.), New York, NY: Thomas Y. Crowell.
Ingham J. H. (1900), Law of Animals: A Treatise on Property in Animals: Wild and Domestic and the Rights and Responsibilities Arising Therefrom, Philadelphia, PA: T & J Johnson.
Johnston J. S. (2005), ‘The Rule of Capture and the Economic Dynamics of Natural Resource Use and Survival Under Open Access Management Regimes’, Environmental Law, 35 (4): 855898.
Larson A. M. and Soto F. (2008), ‘Decentralization of Natural Resource Governance Regimes’, Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 33 (1): 213239.
Libecap G. D. (1989), Contracting for Property Rights, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Ludwig D., Hilborn R., and Waters C. (1993), ‘Uncertainty, Resource Exploitation and Conservation: Lessons from History’, Science, 260 (5104): 1736.
Mors P. O. (1954), ‘Cattle in Buhaya’, Anthropology Quarterly, 27 (1): 2329.
Myers R. A., Hutchings J. A., and Barrowman N. J. (1997), ‘Why Do Fish Stocks Collapse? The Example of Cod in Atlantic Canada’, Ecological Applications, 7 (1): 91106.
North D. C. (1990), Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Ostrom E. (1990), Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action, New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Ostrom E. (1998), ‘A Behavioral Approach to the Rational Choice Theory of Collective Action’, American Political Science Review, 92 (1): 122.
Ostrom E. (2007), ‘A Diagnostic Approach for Going Beyond Panaceas’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, 104 (39): 1518115187.
Ostrom E. (2009), ‘A General Framework for Analyzing Sustainability of Social-Ecological Systems’, Science, 325 (5939): 419422.
Ostrom E. and Cox M. (2010), ‘Moving Beyond Panaceas: A Multi-Tiered Diagnostic Approach for Social-Ecological Analysis’, Environmental Conservation, 37 (4): 451463.
Ostrom V. (2008), The Intellectual Crisis in American Public Administration, 3rd edn, Tuscaloosa, AL: University of Alabama Press.
Ostrom V. and Ostrom E. (1997), ‘Public Goods and Public Choices’, in Savas E. S. (ed.), Alternatives for Delivering Public Services: Toward Improved Performance, Boulder, CO: Westview Press, pp. 749.
Pierson P. (2000), ‘Increasing Returns, Path Dependence, and the Study of Politics’, American Political Science Review, 94 (2): 251267.
Poteete A. R. and Ostrom E. (2004), ‘Heterogeneity, Group Size and Collective Action: The Role of Institutions in Forest Management’, Development and Change, 35 (3): 435461.
Rechlin M. A., Hammett A. L., Burch W. R., and Song Y. (2002), ‘Sharing the Wealth: A Comparative Study of the Distribution of Benefits from Community Forestry Management in Southern China and Nepal’, Journal of Sustainable Forestry, 15 (2): 123.
Ribot J. C., Agrawal A., and Larson A. M. (2006), ‘Recentralizing While Decentralizing: How National Governments Reappropriate Forest Resources’, World Development, 34 (11): 18641886.
Scott A. D. (1955), ‘The Fishery: The Objectives of Sole Ownership’, Journal of Political Economy, 63 (2): 116124.
Searle J. R. (1995), The Construction of Social Reality, London: Penguin.
Simon H. A. (1962), ‘The Architecture of Complexity’, Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 106 (6): 467482.
Smith A. ([1776] 1994), An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, New York, NY: Modern Library.
Wade R. (1994), Village Republics, San Francisco, CA: ICS Press.
Young O. R. (2002), The Institutional Dimensions of Environmental Change: Fit, Interplay, and Scale, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Young O. R. (2008), ‘The Architecture of Global Environmental Governance: Bringing Science to Bear on Policy’, Global Environmental Politics, 8 (1): 1432.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Institutional Economics
  • ISSN: 1744-1374
  • EISSN: 1744-1382
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-institutional-economics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 11
Total number of PDF views: 111 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 473 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 20th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.