Skip to main content
×
Home

From fictions and aggregates to real entities in the theory of the firm

  • DAVID GINDIS (a1)
Abstract
Abstract

According to the dominant ‘nexus of contracts’ and ‘collection of assets’ views of the firm, the firm is a either a fiction or an aggregate. Although legal personality is important in both accounts, everything is said to be achieved by private contract alone and the law's role in creating legal entity status is dismissed. The paper challenges both these aspects by reconsidering an alternative ‘real entity theory’ that dominated debates at the turn of the twentieth century. This forgotten view holds that the firm is neither a fiction nor an aggregate but a real entity, and underlines the creation of legal entity status as a fundamental role of the law. The paper discusses this view's ontological and legal insights, clarifies the proposition that the firm is a real entity, and proposes it as a starting point for a theory of the firm.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Email: david.gindis@univ-lyon2.fr
References
Hide All
Alchian Armen A. (1984), ‘Specificity, Specialization and Coalitions’, Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, 140 (1): 3449.
Alchian Armen A. and Demsetz Harold (1972), ‘Production, Information Costs and Economic Organization’, American Economic Review, 62 (5): 777795.
Alchian Armen A. and Woodward Susan (1988), ‘The Firm Is Dead; Long Live the Firm: A Review of Oliver E. Williamson's The Economic Institutions of Capitalism’, Journal of Economic Literature, 26 (1): 6579.
Aristotle, Metaphysics, in McKeon Richard (2001) (ed.), The Basic Works of Aristotle, New York: Modern Library.
Avi-Yonah Reuven S. (2005), ‘The Cyclical Transformations of the Corporate Form: A Historical Perspective on Corporate Social Responsibility’, Delaware Journal of Corporate Law, 30 (3): 767818.
Baker Lynne R. (2004), ‘The Ontology of Artifacts’, Philosophical Explorations, 7 (2): 99111.
Barzel Yoram (1989), Economic Analysis of Property Rights, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Berle Adolf A. (1947), ‘The Theory of Enterprise Entity’, Columbia Law Review, 47 (3): 343358.
Berle Adolf A. and Means Gardiner C. (1932), The Modern Corporation and Private Property, New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.
Biondi Yuri (2007), ‘Accounting and the Economic Nature of the Firm as an Entity’, in Biondi Yuri, Canziani Arnaldo, and Kirat Thierry (eds), The Firm as an Entity: Implications for Economics, Accounting and the Law, London and New York: Routledge.
Blackwell Thomas F. (1999), ‘The Revolution is Here: The Promise of a Unified Business Entity Code’, Journal of Corporation Law, 24 (2): 333378.
Blair Margaret M. (1999), ‘Firm-Specific Human Capital and Theories of the Firm’, in Blair Margaret M. and Roe Mark J. (eds), Employees and Corporate Governance, Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
Blair Margaret M. (2003), ‘Locking-In Capital: What Corporate Law Achieved for Business Organizers in the Nineteenth Century’, UCLA Law Review, 51 (2): 387455.
Blair Margaret M. (2004), ‘The Neglected Benefits of the Corporate Form: Entity Status and the Separation of Asset Ownership from Control’, in Grandori Anna (ed.), Corporate Governance and Firm Organization: Microfoundations and Structural Forms, New York: Oxford University Press.
Blumberg Phillip I. (1990), ‘The Corporate Personality in American Law: A Summary Review’, American Journal of Comparative Law, 38 (S): 4969.
Blumberg Phillip I. (1993), The Multinational Challenge to Corporation Law: The Search for a New Corporate Personality, New York: Oxford University Press.
Bratton William W. (1989a), ‘The “Nexus-of-Contracts” Corporation: A Critical Appraisal’, Cornell Law Review, 74 (2): 407465.
Bratton William W. (1989b), ‘The New Economic Theory of the Firm: Critical Perspectives from History’, Stanford Law Review, 41 (6): 14711527.
Brown W. Jethro (1905), ‘The Personality of the Corporation and the State’, Law Quarterly Review, 21 (4): 365379.
Bunge Mario (2003), Emergence and Convergence: Qualitative Novelty and the Unity of Knowledge, Toronto: Toronto University Press.
Bunge Mario (2006), Chasing Reality: Strife over Realism, Toronto: Toronto University Press.
Butler Henry N. (1989), ‘The Contractual Theory of the Corporation’, George Mason University Law Review, 11 (4): 99123.
Cheung Steven N. S. (1983), ‘The Contractual Nature of the Firm’, Journal of Law and Economics, 26 (1): 121.
Coase Ronald H. (1937), ‘The Nature of the Firm’, Economica, 4 (16): 386405.
Cohen Felix S. (1935), ‘Transcendental Nonsense and the Functional Approach’, Columbia Law Review, 35 (6): 809849.
Commons John R. (1924), Legal Foundations of Capitalism, New York: Macmillan.
Copp David (1979), ‘Collective Actions and Secondary Actions’, American Philosophical Quarterly, 24 (4): 177186.
Copp David (1984), ‘What Collectives Are: Agency, Individualism and Legal Theory’, Dialogue, 23 (2): 249269.
Davis John B. (2003), The Theory of the Individual in Economics: Identity and Value, London and New York: Routledge.
Dejnožka Jan (2003), The Ontology of the Analytic Tradition and Its Origins: Realism and Identity in Frege, Russell, Wittgenstein and Quine, 2nd edition, New York: Rowman & Littlefield.
Dejnožka Jan (2006), Corporate Entity, unpublished book manuscript (available online at http://www.members.tripod.com/~Jan_Dejnozka/corporate_entity_book.pdf).
Demsetz Harold (1988), ‘The Theory of the Firm Revisited’, Journal of Law, Economics and Organization, 4 (1): 141161.
Dewey John (1925), Experience and Nature, Chicago: Open Court.
Dewey John (1926), ‘The Historic Background of Corporate Legal Personality’, Yale Law Journal, 35 (6): 655673.
Dicey Albert V. (1905), Lectures on the Relation between Law and Public Opinion in England during the Nineteenth Century, London: Macmillan.
Dix Maurice J. (1953), ‘The Economic Entity’, Fordham Law Review, 22 (3): 254273.
Dodd E. Merrick (1932), ‘For Whom Are Corporate Managers Trustees?’, Harvard Law Review, 45 (7): 11451163.
Easterbrook Frank H. and Fischel Daniel R. (1985), ‘Limited Liability and the Corporation’, University of Chicago Law Review, 52 (1): 89117.
Easterbrook Frank H. and Fischel Daniel R. (1991), The Economic Structure of Corporate Law, Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Elder-Vass Dave (2005), ‘Emergence and the Realist Account of Cause’, Journal of Critical Realism, 4 (2): 315338.
Fama Eugene F. (1980), ‘Agency Problems and the Theory of the Firm’, Journal of Political Economy, 88 (2): 288307.
Fama Eugene F. and Jensen Michael C. (1983), ‘Separation of Ownership and Control’, Journal of Law and Economics, 26 (2): 301325.
French Peter A. (1982), ‘Crowds and Corporations’, American Philosophical Quarterly, 19 (3): 271277.
Freund Ernst (1897), The Legal Nature of Corporations, Chicago: Chicago University Press.
Gierke Otto von (1900), Political Theories of the Middle Age, translated with an introduction by Maitland Frederick W., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Gindis David (2007), ‘Some Building Blocks for a Theory of the Firm as a Real Entity’, in Biondi Yuri, Canziani Arnaldo, and Kirat Thierry (eds), The Firm as an Entity: Implications for Economics, Accounting and the Law, London and New York: Routledge.
Goldstein Jeffrey (1999), ‘Emergence as a Construct: History and Issues’, Emergence, 1 (1): 4972.
Grossman Sanford and Hart Oliver D. (1986), ‘The Costs and Benefits of Ownership: A Theory of Vertical and Lateral Integration’, Journal of Political Economy, 94 (2): 691719.
Hager Mark M. ((1989)), ‘Bodies Politic: The Progressive History of Organizational “Real Entity” Theory’, University of Pittsburgh Law Review, 50 (3): 575654.
Hansmann Henry and Kraakman Reinier (2000), ‘The Essential Role of Organizational Law’, Yale Law Journal, 110 (3): 387440.
Hansmann Henry, Kraakman Reinier, and Squire Richard (2005), ‘The New Business Entities in Evolutionary Perspective’, University of Illinois Law Review (February): 5–14.
Hansmann Henry, Kraakman Reinier, and Squire Richard (2006), ‘Law and the Rise of the Firm’, Harvard Law Review, 119 (5): 13331403.
Harré Rom and Madden Edward H. (1975), Causal Powers: A Theory of Natural Necessity, Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Harris Ron (2006), ‘The Transplantation of the Legal Discourse on Corporate Personality Theories: From German Codification to British Political Pluralism and American Big Business’, Washington and Lee Law Review, 63 (4): 14211478.
Hart Oliver D. (1989), ‘An Economist's Perspective on the Theory of the Firm’, Columbia Law Review, 89 (7): 17571774.
Hart Oliver D. (1995), Firms, Contracts and Financial Structure, New York: Oxford University Press.
Hart Oliver D. and Moore John (1990), ‘Property Rights and the Nature of the Firm’, Journal of Political Economy, 98 (6): 11191158.
Hessen Robert (1979), ‘A New Concept of Corporations: A Contractual and Private Property Model’, Hastings Law Journal, 30 (5): 13271350.
Hodgson Geoffrey M. (2002), ‘The Legal Nature of the Firm and the Myth of the Firm-Market Hybrid’, International Journal of the Economics of Business, 9 (1): 3660.
Hodgson Geoffrey M. (2003), ‘The Hidden Persuaders: Institutions and Individuals in Economic Theory’, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 27 (2): 159175.
Hodgson Geoffrey M. (2004), On the Evolution of Institutional Economics: Agency, Structure and Darwinism in American Institutionalism, London and New York: Routledge.
Hodgson Geoffrey M. and Knudsen Thorbjørn (2004), ‘The Firm as an Interactor: Firms as Vehicles for Habits and Routines’, Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 14 (2): 281307.
Horwitz Morton J. (1992), The Transformation of American Law, 1870–1960: The Crisis of Legal Orthodoxy, New York: Oxford University Press.
Humphreys Paul (1997), ‘Emergence, Not Supervenience’, Philosophy of Science, 64 (S): S337S345.
Iacobucci Edward M. and Triantis George G. (2007), ‘Economic and Legal Boundaries of the Firm’, Virginia Law Review, 93 (3): 515570.
Iwai Katsuhito (1999), ‘Persons, Things and Corporations: The Corporate Personality Controversy and Comparative Corporate Governance’, American Journal of Corporation Law, 47 (4): 583632.
Jensen Michael C. and Meckling William H. (1976), ‘Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior, Agency Costs and Capital Structure’, Journal of Financial Economics, 3 (4): 305360.
Jhering Rudolf (1852) Der Geist des römischen Rechts, Leipzig: Auflage.
Khalil Elias L. (1997), ‘Is the Firm an Individual?’, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 21 (4): 519544.
Kim Jaegwon (2006), ‘Emergence: Core Ideas and Issues’, Synthese, 151 (3): 547559.
Klein William A. and Coffee John C. (2002), Business Organization and Finance: Legal and Economic Principles, 8th edition, New York: Foundation Press.
Lamoreaux Naomi R. (1998), ‘Partnerships, Corporations and the Theory of the Firm’, American Economic Review, 88 (2): 6671.
Laski Harold J. (1916), ‘The Personality of Associations’, Harvard Law Review, 29 (4): 404426.
Lawson Tony (1997), Economics and Reality, London and New York: Routledge.
Leibniz Gottfried W. (1902) [1687], Correspondence with Arnauld, in McCormack Thomas J. (ed.), Leibniz: Basic Writings, La Salle, IL: Open Court.
Lowe Jonathan E. (2003), ‘Identity, Individuality and Unity’, Philosophy, 78 (3): 321336.
Machen Arthur W. (1911), ‘Corporate Personality’, Harvard Law Review, 24 (4): 253267.
Mahoney Paul G. (2000), ‘Contract or Concession? An Essay on the History of Corporate Law’, Georgia Law Review, 34 (2): 873893.
Maitland Frederick W. (1900), ‘The Corporation Sole’, Law Quarterly Review, 16 (4): 335354.
Maitland Frederick W. (1905), ‘Moral Personality and Legal Personality’, Journal of the Society of Comparative Legislation, 6 (2): 192200.
Mäki Uskali (2001), ‘The Way the World Works (www): Towards an Ontology of Theory Choice’, in Mäki Uskali (ed.), The Economic World View: Studies in the Ontology of Economics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mark Gregory A. (1987), ‘The Personification of the Business Corporation in American Law’, University of Chicago Law Review, 54 (4): 14411483.
Masten Scott E. (1988), ‘A Legal Basis for the Firm’, Journal of Law, Economics and Organization, 4 (1): 181198.
Millon David (1990), ‘Theories of the Corporation’, Duke Law Journal, 1990 (2): 201262.
Molnar George (2003), Powers: A Study in Metaphysics, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Moore John (1992), ‘The Firm as a Collection of Assets’, European Economic Review, 36 (2–3): 493507.
Naffine Ngaire (2003), ‘Who are Law's Persons? From Cheshire Cats to Responsible Subjects’, Modern Law Review, 66 (3): 346367.
Nelson Richard R. and Winter Sidney G. (1982), An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Orts Eric W. (1998), ‘Shirking and Sharking: A Legal Theory of the Firm’, Yale Law and Policy Review, 16 (2): 254329.
Orts Eric W. (forthcoming), Rethinking the Firm: Theories of the Business Enterprise, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Penrose Edith T. (1959), The Theory of the Growth of the Firm, Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Pettit Philip (2002), ‘Collective Persons and Powers’, Legal Theory, 8 (4): 443470.
Phillips Michael J. (1994), ‘Reappraising the Real Entity Theory of the Corporation’, Florida State University Law Review, 21 (4): 10611123.
Plato, Sophist, in Hamilton Edith and Cairns Huntington (1980) (eds), Plato: The Collected Dialogues, 10th edition, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Quine Willard V. O. (1969), Ontological Relativity and Other Essays, New York: Columbia University Press.
Radin Max (1932), ‘The Endless Problem of Corporate Personality’, Columbia Law Review, 32 (4): 643667.
Ribstein Larry E. (2006), ‘Should History Lock In Lock-In?’, Tulsa Law Review, 41 (3): 523539.
Rowley Scott (1931), ‘The Individuality of Business Associations’, Virginia Law Review, 17 (6): 557569.
Savigny Friedrich C. (1841), System des heutigen Römischen Rechts, vol. 2, Berlin: Veit.
Searle John R. (2005), ‘What Is an Institution?’, Journal of Institutional Economics, 1 (1): 122.
Simon Herbert A. (1991), ‘Organizations and Markets’, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 5 (2): 2544.
Singleton W. E. (1912), ‘Entities and Real and Artificial Persons’, Journal of the Society of Comparative Legislation, 12 (2): 291298.
Stauss James H. (1944), ‘The Entrepreneur: The Firm’, Journal of Political Economy, 52 (2): 112127.
Stout Lynn A. (2005), ‘The Nature of Corporations’, University of Illinois Law Review, 2005 (1): 253267.
Thomasson Amie L. (2003), ‘Realism and Human Kinds’, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 67 (3): 580609.
Vanberg Viktor J. (1992), ‘Organizations as Constitutional Systems’, Constitutional Political Economy, 3 (3): 223253.
Vinogradoff Paul (1924), ‘Juridical Persons’, Columbia Law Review, 24 (6): 594604.
Weissman David (2000), A Social Ontology, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Williamson Oliver E. (1975), Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications, New York: Free Press.
Wimsatt William C. (1997), ‘Aggregativity: Reductive Heuristics for Finding Emergence’, Philosophy of Science, 54 (S): S372S384.
Winter Sidney G. (1988), ‘On Coase, Competence and the Corporation’, Journal of Law, Economics and Organization, 4 (1): 163180.
Wormser I. Maurice (1912), ‘Piercing the Veil of Corporate Entity’, Columbia Law Review, 12 (6): 496518.
Zingales Luigi (2000), ‘In Search of New Foundations’, Journal of Finance, 55 (4): 16231653.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Institutional Economics
  • ISSN: 1744-1374
  • EISSN: 1744-1382
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-institutional-economics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 19
Total number of PDF views: 133 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 314 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 22nd November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.