Skip to main content
×
Home

Not by technique alone. A methodological comparison of development analysis with Esther Duflo and Elinor Ostrom

  • AGNÈS LABROUSSE (a1)
Abstract
Abstract

This contribution aims at an original comparison of development analysis with Elinor Ostrom and Esther Duflo from a methodological standpoint, scrutinising their relationship to theory and their operative research strategies. Both perspectives are investigated as case studies for a broader discussion about significant trends in economics and social sciences. Duflo and the J-PAL's approach illustrates – in its own way – new trends and some blind alleys in contemporary forms of mainstream economics, whereas Ostrom and the Bloomington school point towards the marked theoretical and methodological reflexivity of institutionalism, its sensitivity to historical diversity and openness towards social sciences. Distinct social philosophies and episteme are at stake displaying a great divide between two brands of realism and pragmatism, two relationships to development, expertise and knowledge. The paper also contrasts Duflo's methodological monism and mechanistic piecemeal analysis with Ostrom's methodological pluralism and adaptive complex systems analysis.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Email: agnes.labrousse@u-picardie.fr
References
Hide All
Acemoglu D. (2010), ‘Theory, General Equilibrium, and Political Economy in Development Economics’, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 24 (3): 1732.
Aligica P. (2003), Rethinking Institutional Analysis and Development: The Bloomington School. Interviews with Vincent and Elinor Ostrom, George Mason University, Arlington (VA).
Aligica P. (2005), ‘Institutional Analysis and Economic Development Policy: Notes on the Applied Agenda of the Bloomington School’, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 57 (2): 159165.
Aligica P. (2013), Institutional Diversity and Political Economy. The Ostroms and Beyond, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Aligica P. and Boettke P. (2011), ‘The Two Social Philosophies of Ostroms’ Institutionalism’, The Policy Studies Journal, 39 (1): 2949.
Angrist J. D. and Pischke J. S. (2010), ‘The Credibility Revolution in Empirical Economics: How Better Research Design is Taking the Con out of Econometrics’, NBER Working Paper, 15794, Cambridge (Mass.).
Ashraf N., Giné X., and Karlan D. (2008), ‘Finding Missing Markets (and a disturbing epilogue): Evidence from an Export Crop Adoption and Marketing Intervention in Kenya’, http://poverty-action.org/sites/default/files/FindingMissingMarkets.pdf (accessed the January 28, 2014).
Banerjee A. (2007), Making Aid Work, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Banerjee A. and Duflo E. (2009), ‘L’approche Expérimentale en économie du Développement’, Revue d’économie Politique, 119 (5): 691726.
Banerjee A. and Duflo E. (2011), Poor Economics: A Radical Rethinking of the Way to Fight Global Poverty, New York: Public Affairs.
Bernard T., Delarue J., and Naudet J. D. (2012), ‘Impact Evaluations: A Tool for Accountability? Lessons from Experience at Agence Française de Développement’, The Journal of Development Effectiveness, 4 (2): 314327.
Berriet-Solliec M., Labarthe P., and Laurent C., (2014), ‘Empirical validity of the evaluation of public policies: models of evaluation and quality of evidence’, Evaluation, 2 (2): 195213.
Boettke P., Palagashvili L., and Lemke J. (2013), ‘Riding in Cars with Boys: Elinor Ostrom's Adventures with the Police’, Journal of Institutional Economics, 9 (4): 407425.
Boyer R., Chavance B., and Godard O. (eds.), (1991), Les Figures de L’irréversibilité en Économie, Paris: EHESS.
Boyer R., Hiroyasu U., and Isogai A. (eds.), (2011), Diversity and Transformations of Asian Capitalisms, London: Routledge.
Bureau M.-C., Sarfati F., Simha J., and Tuchszirer C. (2013), ‘L’expérimentation dans l’action publique’, Travail et Emploi, 135: 4155.
Chanteau J. P. and Labrousse A. (2013), ‘L’institutionnalisme Méthodologique d’Elinor Ostrom: Quelques Enjeux et Controverses’, Revue de la régulation, 14 Autumn http://regulation.revues.org/10555.
Cohen J. and Dupas P. (2007), ‘Free Distribution or Cost-Sharing? Evidence from a Randomized Malaria Prevention Experiment’, Brookings Global Economy and Development Working Paper 11, December.
Cole D. and McGinnis M. (eds.), (2015), Elinor Ostrom and the Bloomington School of Political Economy, Lanham: Lexington Books.
Connolly P. (2015), ‘The Campbell Collaboration, and the application of evidence-based practice in education’, Workshop on Evidence Based Policy, Académie des Sciences, Paris, 11th September.
Crawford S. and Ostrom E. (1995), ‘A Grammar of Institutions’, American Political Science Review, 89 (3): 582600.
Crawford S. and Ostrom E. (2005), “A Grammar of Institutions”, in Ostrom E. (ed.), Understanding Institutional Diversity, Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press: 137174.
De Angelis C. and Fontanarosa B., (2008), ‘Impugning the Integrity of Medical Science: The Adverse Effects Of Industry Influence’, Journal of the American Medical Association, 299 (15): 8331835.
Deaton A. (2009), ‘Instruments of Development: Randomization in the Tropics, and the Search for the Elusive Keys to Economic Development’, Manuscript, Princeton, January 2009.
Desrosières A. (2008), L’argument Statistique, I & II, Paris: Presse de l’École des Mines.
Devaux-Spatarakis A. (2014), La méthode expérimentale par assignation aléatoire : un instrument de recomposition de l'interaction entre sciences sociales et action publique en France?, PhD Thesis in Political Science, Bordeaux: University of Bordeaux.
Duflo E. (2003), ‘Poor but Rational?’, MIT Working Paper, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, http://econ-www.mit.edu/files/747, last accessed February 15, 2013.
Duflo E. (2009), Expérience, Science et Lutte Contre La pauvreté, Paris: Fayard.
Duflo E. (2010a), Le Développement Humain. Lutter Contre la Pauvreté (I), Paris: Seuil.
Duflo E. (2010b), La Politique de L’autonomie. Lutter Contre la Pauvreté (II), Paris: Seuil.
Duflo E. (2012), ‘Human Values and the Design of the Fight against Poverty. Paternalism versus Freedom?’, Tanner Lecture, May 2, Harvard University.
Duflo E. and Kremer M. (2003), ‘Use of Randomization in the Evaluation of Development Effectiveness’, Paper prepared for the World Bank Operations Evaluation Department, Conference on Evaluation and Development Effectiveness, Washington DC, 15–16 July.
Earl P. and Potts J. (2011), ‘A Nobel Prize for Governance and Institutions – Oliver Williamson and Elinor Ostrom’, Review of Political Economy, 23 (1): 124.
Eucken W. (1939), Die Grundlagen der Nationalökonomie, 6th ed., Berlin-Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag.
Fagot-Largeault A. (2010), Médecine et Philosophie, Paris: PUF.
Ferguson J. (1990), The Anti-Politics Machine: ‘Development’, Depoliticization and Bureaucratic Power in Lesotho, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Fligstein N. and Zhang J. (2011), ‘A New Agenda for Research on the Trajectory of Chinese Capitalism’, Management and Organization Review, 7 (1): 3962.
Foucault M. (1980), Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 1972–1977, New York: Pantheon.
Fourcade M. (2006), “The Construction of a Global Profession: The Transnationalization of Economics”, American Journal of Sociology, 112 (1): 145195.
Gibson C. C., Andersson K., Ostrom E., and Shivakumar S., (2005), The Samaritan's Dilemma: The Political Economy of Development Aid, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Glewwe P., Kremer M., Moulin S., and Zitzewitz E. (2004), "Retrospective vs. prospective analyses of school inputs: the case of flip charts in Kenya," Journal of Development Economics, 74 (1), 251–68.
Gomel B. and Serverin E. (2013), ‘L’expérimentation Sociale Aléatoire en France en Trois Questions’, Travail et Emploi, 135: 5771.
Groenewegen J. (2011), ‘The Bloomington School and American Institutionalism’, The Good Society, 20 (1): 1536.
Hacking I. (1988), ‘Telepathy: Origins of Randomization in Experimental Design’, Isis, 79 (3): 427451.
Heilmann S. (2008), ‘Policy Experimentation in China's Economic Rise’, Studies in Comparative International Development, 43 (1): 126.
Hirschman A. O. (1958), The Strategy of Economic Development, Yale: Yale University Press.
Hirschman A. O. (1981), Essays in Trespassing: Economics to Politics and Beyond, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hirshleifer J. (1985), ‘The Expanding Domain of Economics’, American Economic Review, 75 (6): 5356.
Hodgson G. (2001), How Economics forgot History, London: Routledge.
Janssen M., Bousquet F., and Ostrom E. (2011), ‘A Multimethod Approach to Study the Governance of Social-Ecological Systems’, Natures, Sciences, Sociétés, 19 (4): 382394www.nss-journal.org.
Jatteau A. (2013), ‘Expérimenter le Développement? Des économistes et leurs Terrains’, Genèses, 4 (93): 828.
Keel O. (2011), La Médecine des Preuves - Une Histoire de L’expérimentation Thérapeutique par Essais Cliniques Contrôlés, Montréal: Presses Universitaires de Montréal.
Kirman A. (1992), ‘Whom or What Does the Representative Individual Represents?’, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 6 (2): 117136.
Kiser L. and Ostrom E. (1982), ‘The Three Worlds of Action: A Metatheoretical Synthesis of Institutional Approaches’, in Ostrom E. (ed.), London, Sage, 179–222.
Miguel E. and Kremer M. (2004), ‘Worms: Identifying Impacts on Education and Health in the Presence of Treatment Externalities’, Econometrica, 72 (1): 159217.
Labrousse A. (2010), ‘Nouvelle économie du Développement et Essais Cliniques Randomisés : Une Mise en Perspective d’un Outil de Preuve et de Gouvernement’, Revue de la régulation, 7, Spring, http://regulation.revues.org/7818.
Labrousse A. and Zamora P. (2013), ‘Expérimentations de Terrain et Politiques Publiques du Travail et de l’emploi. Apports récents et mises en perspective – Introduction’, Travail et Emploi, 135: 513.
Laurent C., Baudry J., Berriet-Solliec M., Kirsch M., Perraud D., Tinel B., Trouvé A., Allsopp N., and Bonnafou P. (2009), ‘Pourquoi s’intéresser à la notion d’evidence-based policy?’, Tiers-Monde, 200 (4): 853873.
Lee A. and Done M. L. (1999), ‘The Use of Nonpharmacologic Techniques to Prevent Postoperative Nausea and Vomiting: A Meta-Analysis’, Anesthesia and Analgesia, 88 (6): 1362.
Low B., Ostrom E., Simon C., and Wilson J. (2003), ‘Redundancy and Diversity: Do They Influence Optimal Management?’, in Berkes F., Colding J., and Folke L. (eds.), Navigating Social-Ecological Systems: Building Resilience for Complexity and Change, New York: Cambridge University Press, pp. 83114.
Marks H. (1997), The Progress of Experiment: Science and Therapeutic Reform in the United States, 1900–1990, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Masquelet A. (2006), Le Raisonnement Médical, Paris: PUF.
McCartney M. (2004), ‘Dynamic versus Static Efficiency: The Case of Textile Exports from Bangladesh and the Developmental State’, Post-autistic Economics Review, 26, August, http://www.paecon.net/PPAEReview/issue26/McCartney26.htm.
McGinnis M. D. (2011) ‘An Introduction to IAD and the Language of the Ostrom Workshop: A Simple Guide to a Complex Framework for the Analysis of Institutions and Their Development’, Policy Studies Journal, 39 (1): 169183.
Meager R. (2015), ‘Understanding the Impact of Microcredit Expansions: A Bayesian Hierarchical Analysis of 7 Randomised Experiments’, Preliminary Working Paper, MIT, September 9.
Monnier E. (1992), Évaluations de l’action des Pouvoirs Publics, Paris: Economica.
Morvant-Roux S., Guérin I., Roesch M., and Moisseron J. Y. (2014), ‘Adding Value to Randomization with Qualitative Analysis: The Case of Microcredit in Rural Morocco’, World Development, 56, 302312.
Myrdal G. (1957), Economic Theory and Underdeveloped Regions, London: Duckworth and Co.
Ostrom E. (1965), Public Entrepreneurship: A Case Study in Ground Water Basin Management, PhD Thesis in political science, Los Angeles: UCLA.
Ostrom E. (ed.), (1982), Strategies of Political Inquiry, London: Sage.
Ostrom E. (1990), Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Actions, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ostrom E. (1996), ‘Crossing the Great Divide: Coproduction, Synergy, and Development’, World Development, 24 (6): 10731087.
Ostrom E. (1998), “A behavioral approach to the rational choice theory of collective action: Presidential address”, American Political Science Review, 92 (1): 122.
Ostrom E. (1999), ‘Coping With Tragedies of the Commons’, Annual Review of Political Science, 2 (1): 493535.
Ostrom E. (2005), Understanding Institutional Diversity, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
Ostrom E. (2007a), ‘A Diagnostic Approach for Going Beyond Panaceas’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 104 (39): 1518115187.
Ostrom E. (2007b), ‘Challenges and Growth: The Development of the Interdisciplinary Field of Institutional Analysis’, Journal of Institutional Economics, 3 (3): 39264.
Ostrom E. (2011), ‘Background on the Institutional Analysis and Development Framework’, Policy Studies Journal, 39 (1): 727.
Ostrom E., Gibson C., Shivakumar S. J., and Andersson K. (2001), Aid, Incentives, and Sustainability: An Institutional Analysis of Development Cooperation, Stockholm: Sida.
Ostrom E., Parks R., and Whitaker G. (1977), Policing Metropolitan America, Washington DC: US Government Printing Office.
Ostrom E. and Basurto X. (2011), “Crafting Analytical Tools to Study Institutional Change”, Journal of Institutional Economics, 7 (3): 317343.
Ostrom V. (1973), ‘Order and Change Amid Increasing Relative Ignorance’, Working Paper n°W73-1, Bloomington: Indiana University.
Ostrom V. (1980), ‘Artisanship and Artifact’, Public Administration Review, 40 (4): 309317.
Ostrom V. (1997), The Meaning of Democracy and the Vulnerabilities of Democracies, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Ostrom V. (1999), ‘Crypto-Imperialism, Predatory States, and Self-governance’, in McGinnis M. (ed.), Polycentric Governance and Development, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, pp. 166185.
Peirce C. S. (1905), The Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce, Hartshorne C., Weiss P. (eds.), Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, vol. 5 (1935).
Perroux F. (1961), L’économie du XXe siècle, Paris: PUF.
Poteete A., Janssen M. A., and Ostrom E. (2010), Working Together: Collective Action, the Commons, and Multiple Methods in Practice, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Quentin A. and Guérin I. (2013), ‘La Randomisation à l’épreuve du Terrain – L’exemple du Projet de Microassurance Sky au Cambodge’, Revue Tiers Monde, 213 (1): 179200.
Ramsey S. and Scoggins J. (2008), ‘Practicing on the Tip of an Information Iceberg? Evidence of Under-publication of Registered Clinical Trials in Oncology’, The Oncologist, 13 (9): 925929.
Rodrik D. (2009), “The New Development Economics: We Shall Experiment, But How Shall We Learn?”, in Cohen J. and Easterly W., (eds)., What Works in Development? Thinking Big and Thinking Small, Washington D.C.: Brookings Institution Press.
Schulz K. F. (1995), ‘Subverting Randomization in Controlled Trials’, JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association, 274 (18), 14561458.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Institutional Economics
  • ISSN: 1744-1374
  • EISSN: 1744-1382
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-institutional-economics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 8
Total number of PDF views: 121 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 543 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 22nd November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.