Skip to main content Accessibility help

The punitive consequences of organizational structures in England, France and the United States



We develop a framework for understanding how legal structures relate to imprisonment. We hypothesize that relatively more hierarchy within criminal justice institutions, compared to commercial law, fosters higher rates of incarceration. Our framework predicts that incarceration reflects asymmetric opportunities for rent seeking across differently organized legal institutions. Instead of comparing criminal justice institutions across nations in absolute terms, we investigate the relative degrees of institutional centralization across legal spheres. To provide support, we document the separate historical experiences that shaped divergent organizations across England and France. Within each country, criminal legal institutions developed inverse organizational traits from commercial legal processes. As a result, the contrasting organizations created asymmetric opportunities for rent seeking. Divergent contemporary outcomes can be understood by recognizing these initial organizational choices, the relative opportunities they created, and their subsequent path dependencies. We document contemporary England, France, and the United States’ incarceration trends and penal outcomes to provide empirical support.


Corresponding author


Hide All
Abramson, J. (2000), We, the Jury: The Jury System and the Ideal of Democracy. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Acemoglu, D. and Robinson, J. (2012), Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty. New York: Crown Business.
Allen, D. and Barzel, Y. (2011), ‘The Evolution of Criminal Law and Police During the Pre-Modern Era’, Journal of Law, Economics and Organization, 27 (3): 540567.
Apple, J. and Deyling, R. (1995), A Primer on the Civil-Law System, Washington, DC: Federal Judicial Center.
Ashworth, A. (1998), The Criminal Process (2nd edn), Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ashworth, A. (2001), ‘The Decline of English Sentencing and Other Stories’, in Tonry, M. and Frase, R. (eds), Sentencing and Sanctions in Western Countries, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Avio, K. (2003), ‘The Economics of Prisons’, in Tabarrok, A. (ed.) Changing of the Guard: Private Prisons and the Control of Crime. Oakland: The Independent Institute.
Beaumont, G. and Tocqueville, A. (1833 [1968]), On the Penitentiary System in the United States, and Its Application to France: With an Appendix on Penal Colonies, New York: Augustus M. Kelley.
Bauer, L. (2004), Criminal Justice Expenditure and Employment Extracts Program. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
Beccaria, C. (1764 [1995]), On Crimes and Punishments, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Beck, T., Demirguc Kunt, A., and Levine, R. (2003), ‘Law and Finance: Why Does Legal Origin Matter?Journal of Comparative Economics, 31 (4): 653675.
Benson, B. (1992), ‘The Development of Criminal Law and its Enforcement: Public Interest or Political Transfers?Journal des Economistes et des Etudes Humaines, 3 (1): 79108.
Benson, B. and Wollan, L. (1989), ‘Prison Overcrowding and Judicial Incentives’, Madison Paper Series. 3: 122.
Berinzon, M. and Briggs, R. (2016), ‘Legal Families without the Laws: The Fading of Colonial Law in French West Africa’, American Journal of Comparative Law, 64 (2): 329370.
Berman, H. (1983), Law and Revolution: The Formation of the Western Legal Tradition. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Berman, H. (2006), Law and Revolution II: The Impact of the Protestant Reformations on the Western Legal Tradition. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Besser, T. and Hanson, M. (2004), ‘Development of Last Resort: The Impact of New State Prisons on Small Town Economies in the United States’, Journal of the Community Development Society, 35 (2): 116.
Blackstone, W. (1893), Commentaries on the Laws of England, Volume II, Sharswood, G. (ed.) Philadelphia: Lippincott.
Bodenhorn, H. (2016), ‘Prison Crowding, Recidivism, and Early Release in Early Rhode Island’, Explorations in Economic History, 59 (C): 5574.
Boettke, P., Lemke, J., and Palagashvili, L. (2016), ‘Re-evaluating Community Policing in a Polycentric System’, Journal of Institutional Economics, 12 (2): 305325.
Bomhoff, J. (2017), ‘Beyond Proportionality: Thinking Comparatively About Constitutional Review and Punitiveness’, in Jackson, V. and Tushnet, M. (eds), Proportionality: New Frontiers, New Challenges, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Borricand, J. (1993), ‘France’, World Factbook of Criminal Justice Systems, Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
Brodeur, J. (2007), ‘Comparative Penology in Perspective’, Crime and Justice, 36: 4991.
Buchanan, J. (1983), ‘Rent seeking, noncompensating transfers, and laws of succession’, Journal of Law and Economics, 26 (1): 7185.
Buchanan, J. (1999), ‘Politics without Romance: A Sketch of Positive Public Choice Theory and its Normative Implications’, in Buchanan, J., The Logical Foundations of Constitutional Liberty, Indianapolis: Liberty Fund, pp. 4559.
Buchanan, J. and Tullock, G. (1962), The Calculus of Consent: Logical Foundations of Constitutional Democracy, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Castel, R. (1988), The Regulation of Madness: The Origins of Incarceration in France, Berkley: University of California Press.
Cavadino, M. and Dignan, J. (2006a), Penal Systems: A Comparative Approach, Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Cavadino, M. and Dignan, J. (2006b), ‘Penal policy and political economy’, Criminology & Criminal Justice, 6 (4): 435456.
Coke, E. (1628), Selected Writings of Sir Edward Coke, Shepherd, S. (ed.), Indianapolis: Liberty Fund.
Cretenot, M. and Liaras, B. (2013), Prison Conditions in France, Rome: European Prison Observatory.
Damaska, M. (1986), The Faces of Justice and State Authority: A Comparative Approach to the Legal Process, New Haven: Yale University Press.
D'Amico, D. and Williamson, C. (2015), ‘Do Legal Origins Affect Cross-Country Incarceration Rates?Journal of Comparative Economics, 43 (3): 595612.
Dari-Mattiacci, G. and Guerriero, C. (2011), ‘Law, Economics and History: Endogenous Institutional Change and Legal Innovation’, in Faure, M. and Smits, J. (eds), Does Law Matter? On Law and Economic Growth, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 137154.
DeMichele, M. (2013), ‘Using Weber's Rechtssoziologie to Explain Western Punishment: A Typological Framework’, European Journal of Crime, Criminal Law and Criminal Justice, 21 (1): 85109.
DeMichele, M. (2014), ‘A Panel Analysis of Legal Culture, Political Economics, and Punishment among 15 Western Countries, 1960–2010’, International Criminal Justice Review, 24 (4): 117.
Djankov, S., Glaeser, E., La Porta, R., Lopez-de-Silanes, F. and Shleifer, A. (2003), ‘The New Comparative Economics’, Journal of Comparative Economics, 31 (4): 595619.
Djankov, S., La Porta, R., Lopez-de-Silanes, F. and Shleifer, A. (2008), ‘The Law and Economics of Self-Dealing’, Journal of Financial Economics, 88 (3): 430465.
Dubber, M. (2005), The Police Power: Patriarchy and the Foundations of American Government. New York: Columbia University Press.
Durkheim, E. (1895 [1982]), The Rules of Sociological Method, New York: The Free Press.
Enns, P. (2014), ‘The Public's Increasing Punitiveness and Its Influence on Mass Incarceration in the United States’, American Journal of Political Science, 58 (4): 857872.
Faugeron, C. (ed.) (1992), Les politiques penales, Problemes politiques et sociaux, La Documentation Francaise.
Foucault, M. (1975 [1995]), Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. New York: Vintage Books.
Frey, B. (2005), ‘Functional, Overlapping, Competing Jurisdictions: Redrawing the Geographic Borders of Administration’, European Journal of Law Reform, 5 (3–4): 543555.
Friedman, L. (1993), Crime and Punishment in American History. New York: Basic Books.
Garoupa, N. (2001), ‘An Economic Viewpoint of Criminal Systems in Civil Law Countries’, in Deffains, B. and Kirat, T. (eds) Law and Economics in Civil Law Countries. Somerville: JAI Press, pp. 199216.
Giertz, J. and Nardulli, P. (1985), ‘Prison Overcrowding’, Public Choice, 46 (1): 7178.
Glaeser, E. and Shleifer, A. (2002), ‘Legal Origins’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 107 (4): 11931229.
Goebel, J. (1976), Felony and Misdemeanor: A Study in the History of Criminal Law. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Greve, M. (2012), The Upside-Down Constitution. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Graff, M. (2008), ‘Law and Finance: Common-law and Civil-law Countries Compared, An Empirical Critique’, Economica, 75 (297): 6083.
Guerriero, C. (2011), ‘Legal Traditions and Economic Performances: Theory and Evidence’, in Bouckaert, B. and Geest, G. De (eds) Chapter 9 in Encyclopedia of Law and Economics. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Helland, E. and Klick, J. (2011), ‘Legal Origins and Empirical Credibility’, in Faure, M. and Smits, J. (eds) Does Law Matter? On Law and Economic Growth. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 99114.
Hirsch, A. (1992), The Rise of the Penitentiary Prisons and Punishment in Early America. New Haven: Yale Historical Publications.
Home Office (1985), The Cautioning of Offenders. London: Home Office.
Huling, T. (2002), ‘Building a Prison Economy in Rural America’, in Invisible Punishment: The Collateral Consequences of Mass Imprisonment, Mauer, M. and Chesney-Lind, M. (eds), New York: The New Press.
Jellinek, G. (1901), The Declaration of the Rights of Man and of Citizens: A Contribution to Modern Constitutional History. New York: Henry Holt.
Kaeble, D., Glaze, L., Tsoutis, A. and Minton, T. (2015), Correctional Populations in the United States 2014. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
King, R., Mauer, M. and Huling, T. (2003). Big Prisons, Small Towns: Prison Economics in Rural America. Washington DC: Sentencing Project.
Klerman, D., Mahoney, P., Spamann, H., Weinstein, M. (2011), ‘Legal Origin or Colonial History?Journal of Legal Analysis, 0: 131.
Koyama, M. (2012), ‘Prosecution Associations in Industrial Revolution England: Private Providers of Public Goods?Journal of Legal Studies, 41 (1): 95130.
Koyama, M. (2014), ‘The Law and Economics of Private Prosecutions in Industrial Revolution England’, Public Choice, 159 (1–2): 277298.
Kyckelhahn, T. (2012–2015), Justice Expenditure and Employment Extracts Series. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
Lacey, N. (2008), The Prisoners’ Dilemma: Political Economy and Punishment in Contemporary Democracies, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lacey, N. (2012), ‘Political Systems and Criminal Justice: The Prisoners’ Dilemma after the Coalition’, Current Legal Problems, 65 (1): 203239.
La Porta, R., Lopez-de-Silanes, F., Pop-Eleches, C. and Shleifer, A. (2004), ‘Judicial Checks and Balances’, Journal of Political Economy, 112 (2): 445470.
La Porta, R., Lopez-de-Silanes, F. and Shleifer, A. (2008), ‘The Economic Consequences of Legal Origins’, Journal of Economic Literature, 46 (2): 285332.
McGinnis, M. (1999), Polycentricity and Local Public Economies, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Merryman, J. (1969), The Civil Law Tradition: An Introduction to the Legal Systems of Europe and Latin America (3rd edn). Palo Alto: Stanford University Press.
Milgrom, P. and Roberts, J. (1992), Economics, Organization and Management. Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall.
Ministry of Justice (2014), ‘Costs per place and costs per prisoner’, National Offender Management Service Annual Report and Accounts 2013–2014. London: Ministry of Justice.
Murakawa, N. (2014), The First Civil Right: How Liberals Built Prison America, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Nardulli, P. (1984), ‘ The Misalignment of Penal Responsibilities and State Prison Crises: Costs, Consequences, and Corrective Actions’, University of Illinois Law Review, 365–387.
Neapolitan, J. (2001), ‘Examination of cross-national variation in punitiveness’, International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 45 (6): 691710.
Newburn, T. (2007), ‘Tough on Crime: Penal Policy in England and Wales’, Crime and Justice, 36: 425470.
Niskanen, W. (1968), ‘The Peculiar Economics of Bureaucracy’, American Economic Review, 58 (2): 293305.
North, D. and Thomas, R. (1976), The Rise of the Western World: A New Economic History, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
North, D. (1990), Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Nunn, N. (2009), ‘The Importance of History for Economic Development’, Annual Review of Economics, 1: 6592.
Ostrom, V. (1973), The Intellectual Crisis in American Public Administration. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press.
Pistor, K. (2006), ‘Legal Ground Rules in Coordinated and Liberal Market Economies’, in Hopt, K., Wymeersch, E., Kanda, H. and Baum, H. (eds) Corporate Governance in Context: Corporations, States, and Markets in Europe, Japan, and the US. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 249–80.
Pistor, K. and Deakin, S. (eds) (2012), Legal Origin Theory. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Pfaff, J. (2017), Locked in: The True Causes of Mass Incarceration – and How to Achieve Actual Reform. New York: Basic Books.
Plucknett, T. (1929 [2010]), A Concise History of the Common Law, Indianapolis: Liberty Fund.
Pollock, F. and Maitland, F. (1898 [1968]), The History of English Law Before the Time of Edward I: Volumes I and II. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund.
Roche, S. (2007), ‘Criminal Justice Policy in France: Illusions of Severity’, Crime and Justice, 36 (1): 471550.
Rosenberg, N. and Birdzell, L. (1986), How the West Grew Rich: The Economic Transformation of the Industrial World, New York: Basic Books.
Rothman, D. (1971), The Discovery of the Asylum. New York: Book Service.
Rothman, D. (1980), Conscience and Convenience: The Asylum and Its Alternatives in Progressive America. Abingdon: Routledge.
Ruddell, R. (2005), ‘Social Disruption, State Priorities, and Minority Threat: A Cross-national Study of Imprisonment’, Punishment & Society, 7 (1): 728.
Rusche, G. and Kirschheimer, O. (1939 [2003]), Punishment and Social Structure. New York: Transaction Publishers.
Sah, R. and Stiglitz, J. (1986), ‘The Architecture of Economic Systems: Hierarchies and Polyarchies’, American Economic Review, 76 (4): 716727.
Shleifer, A. (2012), The Failure of Judges and the Rise of Regulators. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Siems, M. (2016). ‘Varieties of legal systems: towards a new global taxonomy’, Journal of Institutional Economics, 12 (3): 579602.
Skarbek, D. (2016), ‘Covenants without the Sword? Comparing Prison Self-Governance Globally’, American Political Science Review, 110 (4): 845862.
Soares, R. (2004a), ‘Crime Reporting as a Measure of Institutional Development’, Economic Development and Cultural Change, 851871.
Soares, R. (2004b), ‘Development, Crime and Punishment: Accounting for the International Differences in Crime Rates’, Journal of Development Economics, 73: 155184.
Spamann, H. (2010), ‘Legal Origins, Civil Procedure, and the Quality of Contract Enforcement’, Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, 166 (1): 149165.
Spamann, H. (2016), ‘The US Crime Puzzle: A Comparative Perspective on US Crime & Punishment’, American Law and Economics Review, 18 (33): 3387.
Spierenburg, P. (1991), The Prison Experience: Disciplinary Institutions and Their Inmates in Early Modern Europe. Amsterdam: Amsterdam Academic Archive.
Stephen, J. (1883 [1963]), A History of the Criminal Law of England, New York: Burt Franklin.
Stuntz, W. (2011), The Collapse of American Criminal Justice, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Sutton, J. (2000), ‘Imprisonment and Social Classification in Five Common-Law Democracies, 1955–1985’, American Journal of Sociology, 106 (2): 350386.
Sutton, J. (2004), ‘The Political Economy of Imprisonment in Affluent Western Democracies, 1960–1990’, American Sociological Review, 69 (2): 170189.
Tobias, J. (1979), Crime and Police in England 1700–1900, New York: St. Martin's Press.
Tocqueville, A. (1835), Democracy in America. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund.
Tullock, G. (1965 [2005]), ‘The Politics of Bureaucracy’, in Rowley, C. (ed.), The Selected Works of Gordon Tullock, Volume 6: Bureaucracy. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund: 13235.
United Nations Office on Drug and Crime, Data. Washington DC. Available at: (last accessed 19 March 2018).
Walmsley, R. (2003), ‘Global Incarceration and Prison Trends’, Forum on Crime and Society, 3: (1–2): 6578.
Walmsley, R. (2016), ‘World Prison Population List, Eleventh Edition’, World Prison Brief. Washington, DC: Institute for Criminal Policy Research.
Weber, M. (1922 [1978]), Economy and Society, Berkley: University of California Press.
Whitman, J. (2007), ‘What Happened to Tocqueville's America?Social Research, 74 (2): 251268.
Williamson, O. (1981), ‘The Economics of Organization: The Transaction Cost Approach’, The American Journal of Sociology, 87 (3): 548577.


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed