Skip to main content Accessibility help

Phylogenetic revision of the Late Ordovician orthid brachiopod genera Plaesiomys and Hebertella from Laurentia

  • David F. Wright (a1) and Alycia L. Stigall (a2)


The orthidine brachiopod genera Plaesiomys and Hebertella are significant constituents of Late Ordovician benthic marine communities throughout Laurentia. Species-level phylogenetic analyses were conducted on both genera to inform systematic revisions and document evolutionary relationships. Phylogenetic analyses combined discrete and continuous characters, from which character states were determined using a statistical approach, and utilized both cladistic and Bayesian methodologies. Plaesiomys cutterensis, P. idahoensis, and P. occidentalis are herein recognized as distinct species rather than subspecies of P. subquadratus. Similarly, Hebertella montoyensis and H. prestonensis are recognized as distinct species separate from H. occidentalis, and H. richmondensis is recognized as a distinct species rather than a geographical variant of H. alveata. Hebertella subjugata is removed from its tentative synonymy with H. occidentalis and revalidated.

The development of species-level evolutionary hypotheses for Plaesiomys and Hebertella provides a detailed framework for assessing evolutionary and paleobiogeographic patterns of Late Ordovician brachiopods from Laurentia. The geographic range of Hebertella expanded throughout Laurentia during the Richmondian into both intracratonic and marginal basins. Plaesiomys subquadratus participated in the Late Ordovician Richmondian Invasion. The recovered phylogenetic topology for Plaesiomys suggests that P. subquadratus may have migrated into the Cincinnati region from a basin situated to the paleo-northeast.



Hide All
Alberstadt, L. P. 1973. Articulate brachiopods of the Viola Formation (Ordovician) in the Arbuckle Mountains, Oklahoma. Oklahoma Geological Survey, Bulletin 117, 90p.
Alexander, R. R. 1984. Comparative hydrodynamic stability of brachiopod shells on current-scoured arenaceous substrates. Lethaia, 17:1732.
Alexander, R. R. and Scharpf, C. D. 1990. Epizoans on Late Ordovician brachiopods from southeastern Indiana. Historical Biology, 4:179202.
Alroy, J. 1994. Four permutation tests for the presence of phylogenetic structure. Systematic Biology, 43:430437.
Bassler, R. S. 1932. The stratigraphy of the Central Basin of Tennessee. Tennessee Division of Geology Bulletin 38, 268p.
Billings, E. 1862. New species of fossils from different parts of the lower, middle, and upper Silurian rocks of Canada. Geological Survey of Canada, Palaeozoic Fossils, 1:96168.
Bradley, J. H. 1921. The brachiopoda of the Maquoketa of Iowa, Harvard College Museum of Comparative Zoology Bulletin, 64:503525.
Davis, M. A. 2009. Invasion Biology. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 244p.
Davis, R. A. 1985. Cincinnati fossils, an elementary guide to the Ordovician rocks and fossils of the Cincinnati, Ohio, region. Cincinnati Museum of Natural History Popular Publication Series 10, 60p.
Castor, K. E., Dalve, E. A., and Pope, J. K. 1961. Elementary guide to the fossils and strata of the Ordovician in the vicinity of Cincinnati, Ohio. Cincinnati Museum of Natural History, 47p.
Cocks, L. R. M. 2008. A revised review of British lower Palaeozoic brachiopods. Palaeontographical Society Monograph 161, 231p.
Cocks, L. R. M. and Torsvik, T. H. 2011. The Palaeozoic geography of Laurentia and western Laurussia: A stable craton with mobile margins. Earth Sciences Reviews, 106:151.
Cooper, G. A. 1930. The brachiopod genus Pionodema and its homeomorphs. Journal of Paleontology, 4:369382.
Cooper, G. A. 1956. Chazyan and related brachiopods. Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections, 127 (1):11024; 127(2):1025–1245.
Cummings, E. R. 1908. The stratigraphy and paleontology of the Cincinnati series of Indiana. Indiana Department of Geology and Natural Resources Annual Report, 32:6071189.
Emmons, E. 1842. Geology of New York, Part 2, comprising the survey of the second geological district. White and J. Visscher, Albany, 437p.
Felsenstein, J. 2004. Inferring Phylogenies. Sinauer, Sunderland, Massachusetts, 664p.
Foerste, A. F. 1909a. Preliminary notes on Cincinnati fossils. Bulletin of the Scientific Laboratory of Denison University, 14:208232.
Foerste, A. F. 1909b. Preliminary notes on Cincinnati and Lexington fossils. Bulletin of the Scientific Laboratory of Denison University, 14:298324.
Foerste, A. F. 1910. Preliminary notes on Cincinnatian and Lexington fossils of Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, and Tennessee. Bulletin of the Scientific Laboratory of Denison University, 16:17100.
Foerste, A. F. 1912. The Arnheim Formation within the areas traversed by the Cincinnati Geanticline. The Ohio Naturalist, 12:429456.
Foerste, A. F. 1914a. Notes on the Lorraine faunas of New York and the Province of Quebec. Bulletin of the Scientific Laboratory of Denison University, 17:247340.
Foerste, A. F. 1914b. The Rogers Gap fauna of central Kentucky. Cincinnati Society of Natural History Journal, 21:109156.
Freudenstein, J. V. and Davis, J. I. 2002. Branch support via resampling: An empirical study. Cladistics, 26:643656.
Gregor, D. K. and Born, K. E. 1936. Stratigraphy and fauna of the Fernvale Formation (Illinois). Washington University Studies, Science and Technology, 6:6777.
Hall, J. 1847. Descriptions of the organic remains of the lower division of the New York System. New York State Geological Survey, Palaeontology of New York, 1, 338p.
Hall, J. and Clark, J. M. 1892. An introduction to the study of the genera of Palaeozoic Brachiopoda. New York State Geological Survey, Palaeontology of New York, 8 (1), 367p.
Hammer, T., Harper, D. A. T., and Ryan, P. D. 2001. PAST: Paleontological statistics software package for education and data analysis. Paleontologia Electronica, 4:19.
Harper, D. A. T. 1984. Brachiopods from the upper Ardmillan succession (Ordovician) of the Girvan District, Scotland, Part 1. Monograph of the Palaeontographical Society, 136:178.
Hennig, W. 1966. Phylogenetic Systematics. Translated byDavis, D. D. and Zangerl, R.University of Illinois Press, Chicago, 263p.
Hiller, N. 1980. Ashgill Brachiopoda from the Glyn Ceiriog District, north Wales. Bulletin of the British Museum (Natural History), Geology Series, 34:109216.
Hillis, D. M. 1995. Approaches to assessing phylogenetic accuracy. Systematic Biology, 44:316
Hillis, D. M. and Huelsenbeck, J. P. 1992. Signal, noise, and reliability in molecular phylogenetic analyses. Journal of Heredity, 83:189195.
Holland, S. M. and Patzkowsky, M. E. 1996. Sequence stratigraphy and long-term paleooceanographic change in the Middle and Upper Ordovician of the eastern United States, p. 117129. InWitzke, B. J., Ludvigson, G. A., and Day, J.(eds.), Paleozoic Sequence Stratigraphy: Views from the North American Craton. Geological Society of America Special Paper 306.
Hopkins, M. J. 2011. Species-level phylogenetic analysis of Pterocephaliids (Trilobita, Cambrian) from the Great Basin, Western U.S.A. Journal of Paleontology, 85:11281153.
Howe, H. J. 1966. Orthacea from the Montoya Group (Ordovician) of Trans-Pecos Texas. Journal of Paleontology, 40:241257.
Howe, H. J. 1988. Articulate brachiopods from the Richmondian of Tennessee. Journal of Paleontology, 62:204218.
Huelsenbeck, J. P. 1991. Tree-length distribution skewness: An indicator of phylogenetic information. Systematic Zoology, 40:257270.
Hunt, G. 2007. Morphology, ontogeny, and phylogenetics of genus Poseidonamicus (Ostracoda: Thaerocytherinae). Journal of Paleontology, 81:607631.
International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature. 1999. International Code of Zoological Nomenclature. International Trust for Zoological Nomenclature, London, 306p.
James, U. P. 1871. Catalogue of Lower Silurian fossils, Cincinnati Group, Ohio, 14p.
Jin, J. 2001. Evolution and extinction of the North American Hiscobeccus Fauna during the Late Ordovician. Canadian Journal of Earth Science, 38:143151.
Jin, J. and Norford, B. S. 1996. Upper Ordovician (Caradoc) brachiopods from the Advance Formation, northern Rocky Mountains, British Columbia, p. 2077. InAdvance Formation: Stratigraphy and Biostratigraphy of a New Ordovician Formation from the Rocky Mountains, Northeastern British Columbia. Geological Survey of Canada Bulletin 491.
Jin, J. and Zhan, R.-B. 2001. Late Ordovician articulate brachiopods from the Red River and Stony Mountain formations, southern Manitoba. National Research Council of Canada, Ottawa, 117p.
Jin, J. and Zhan, R.-B. 2008. Late Ordovician Orthide and Billingsellide Brachiopods from Anticosti Island, Eastern Canada: Diversity Change Through Mass Extinction. National Research Council of Canada, Ottawa, 151p.
Jin, J., Zhan, R.-B., Copper, P., and Caldwell, W. G. E. 2007. Epipunctae and phosphatized setae in Late Ordovician Plaesiomyid brachiopods from Anticosti Island, Eastern Canada. Journal of Paleontology, 81:666683.
Jin, J. W., Caldwell, G. E., and Norford, B. S. 1997. Late Ordovician brachiopods and biostratigraphy of the Hudson Bay lowlands, Northern Manitoba and Ontario. Geological Survey of Canada Bulletin 513, 258p.
Klassen, G. J., Mooi, R. D., and Locke, A. 1991. Consistency indices and random data. Systematic Zoology, 50:446457.
Kulkov, N. P. and Severgina, L. G. 1989. Stratigrafiya I brakhiopody ordovika I nizhnego silura Gornogo Altaya. Akademiya Nauk SSSR, Sibirskoe Otdelenie, Trudy Instituta Geologii I Geofiziki, 717, 223p.
Labarbera, M. 1981. Water flow patterns in and around three species of Articulate brachiopods. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 55:185206.
Ladd, H. S. 1929. The stratigraphy and paleontology of the Maquoketa Shale of Iowa, Pt. 1. In Annual Report, 1928, Iowa Geological Survey Report, 34:309448.
Laurie, J. R. 1991. Articulate brachiopods from the Ordovician and lower Silurian of Tasmania. Association of Australasian Palaeontologists Memoir, 11:1106.
Leighton, L. R. and Maples, C. G. 2002. Evaluating internal versus external characters: Phylogenetic analyses of Echinoconchidae, Bruxtoniinae, and Juresaniinae (phylum Brachiopoda). Journal of Paleontology, 76:659671.
Lewis, P. O. 2001. A likelihood approach to estimating phylogeny from discrete morphological character data. Systematic Biology, 50:913925.
Macomber, R. W. 1970. Articulate brachiopods from the Upper Bighorn Formation (Late Ordovician) of Wyoming. Journal of Paleontology, 44:416450.
Maddison, W. P. and Maddison, D. R. 2003. MacClade: Analysis of phylogeny and character evolution, v. 4.06. Sinauer, Sunderland, Massachusetts.
Malizia, R. and Stigall, A. L. 2011. Niche stability in Late Ordovician articulated brachiopod species before, during, and after the Richmondian Invasion. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 311:154170.
Meek, F. B. 1873. Descriptions of invertebrate fossils of the Silurian and Devonian systems. Ohio Geological Survey. Vol. 1, Pt. 2. Palaeontology, 243p.
Meyer, D. L. and Davis, R. A. 2009. A Sea Without Fish: Life in the Ordovician Sea of the Cincinnati Region. Indiana University Press, Bloomington, 346p.
Mitchell, W. I. 1977. The Ordovician Brachiopoda from Pomeroy, Co. Tyrone. Palaeontographical Society Monographs, 130, 138p.
Morton, C. M. and Kincaid, D. T. 1995. A model for coding pollen size in reference to phylogeny using examples from the Ebenaceae. American Journal of Botany, 82:11731178.
Okultich, V. J. 1943. The Stony Mountain Formation of Manitoba. Transactions of the Royal Society of Canada, 37:5974.
Oraspold, A. L. 1959. Some representatives of the superfamily Orthacea from the Upper Ordovician of Estonia. Tartu Ulikooli Geoloogia Instituudi Toimetised, 75:5181. (In Russian)
Pagel, M. and Meade, A. 2004. A phylogenetic mixture model for detecting pattern-heterogeneity in gene sequence or character-state data. Systematic Biology, 53:571581.
Patzkowsky, M. E. and Holland, S. M. 2007. Diversity partitioning of a Late Ordovician marine biotic invasion: Controls on diversity in regional ecosystems. Paleobiology, 33:295309.
Popov, L. E. and Cocks, L. R. M., 2006. Late Ordovician brachiopods from the Dulankara Formation of the Chu-Ili Range, Kazakhstan: Their systematics, palaeoecology and palaeobiogeography. Palaeontology, 49:247283.
Popov, L. E., Nikitin, I. F., and Cocks, L. R. M. 2000. Late Ordovician brachiopods from the Otar Member of the Chu-Ili Range, South Kazakhstan. Palaeontology, 42:625661.
Raymond, P. E. 1928. The brachiopods of the Lenoir and Athens Formations of Tennessee and Virginia. Harvard University Museum of Comparative Zoology Bulletin, 68:293.
Reed, F. R. C. 1952. Revision of certain Ordovician fossils from County Tyrone. Proceedings from the Royal Irish Academy, 55:29136.
Richards, R. P. 1972. Autecology of Richmondian brachiopods. Journal of Paleontology, 46:386405.
Rode, A. L. 2004. Phylogenetic revision of the Devonian bivalve, Leptodesma (Leiopteria). Yale University Postilla, 229:126.
Rode, A. L. and Lieberman, B. S. 2004. Using GIS to unlock the interactions between biogeography, environment, and evolution in Middle and Late Devonian brachiopods and bivalves. Palaeogoegraphy, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeogeography, 211:345359.
Ronquist, F., Teslenko, M., Van Der Mark, P., Ayres, D. L., Darling, A., Höhna, S., Larget, B., Liu, L., Suchard, M. A., and Huelsenbeck, J. P. 2012. MrBayes 3.2: Efficient Bayesian phylogenetic inference and model choice across a large model space. Systematic Biology, 61:539542.
Ross, R. J. 1959. Brachiopod fauna of Saturday Mountain Formation, southern Lemhi Range, Idaho. U. S. Geological Survey Professional Paper, 294-L:441461.
Roy, S. K. 1941. The Upper Ordovician fauna of Frobisher Bay, Baffin Land, Field Museum of Natural History (Geology) Memoir 2, 212p.
Sardeson, R. W. 1892. The range and distribution of the lower Silurian fauna of Minnesota with descriptions of some new species. Minnesota Academy of Natural Sciences Bulletin, 3:326343.
Schuchert, C. 1900. On the lower Silurian (Trenton) fauna of Baffin Land. Proceedings of the United States National Museum, 22:143177
Schuchert, C. 1913. Class 2. Brachiopoda, p. 355420. Invon Zittel, K. A.(ed.), Textbook of Paleontology, 2. Macmillan, London.
Schuchert, C. and Cooper, G. A. 1930. Upper Ordovician and Lower Devonian stratigraphy and paleontology of Percé, Quebec. American Journal of Science, 2:161176.
Schuchert, C. and Cooper, G. A. 1931. Synopsis of the brachiopod genera of the suborders Orthoidea and Pentameroidea, with notes on the Telotremata. American Journal of Science, 5:241255.
Schuchert, C. and Cooper, G. A. 1932. Brachiopod genera of the suborders Orthoidea and Pentameroidea. Peabody Museum of Natural History Memoir, 4 (1), 270p.
Schuchert, C. and Levene, C. M. 1929. New names for brachiopod homonyms. American Journal of Science, 17:119122.
Schwimmer, B. A. and Sandy, M. R. 1996. Phylum Brachiopoda, p. 210241. InFeldmann, R. M. and Hackathorn, M.(eds.), Fossils of Ohio. Ohio Department of Natural Resources Bulletin, 70.
Shaler, N. S. 1865. List of the Brachiopoda from the island of Anticosti sent by the Museum of Comparative Zoology to different institutions for exchange for other specimens, with annotations. Harvard University, Museum of Comparative Zoology Bulletin, 1:6170.
Sober, E. 2004. The contest between parsimony and likelihood. Systematic Biology, 53:644653.
Spencer, M. R. and Wilberg, E. W. 2013. Efficacy or convenience? Model-based approaches to phylogeny estimation using morphological data. Cladistics, doi:10.1111/cla.12018.
Stigall, A. L. 2010a. Using GIS to assess the biogeographic impact of species invasions on native brachiopods during the Richmondian Invasion in the Type-Cincinnatian (Late Ordovician, Cincinnati Region). Palaeontologia Electronica, 13 (1):5A.
Stigall, A. L. 2010b. Speciation decline during the Late Devonian Biodiversity Crisis related to species invasions. PLoS ONE, 5 (12):e15584.
Stigall, A. L. 2012. Using ecological niche modeling to evaluate niche stability in deep time. Journal of Biogeography, 39:772781.
Stigall, A. L. 2005. Systematic revision of the Middle and Late Devonian brachiopods Schizophoria (Schizophoria) and ‘Schuchertella' from North America. Journal of Systematic Palaeontology, 3:133167.
Swiderski, D. L., Zelditch, M. L., and Fink, W. L. 1998. Why morphometrics is not special: Coding quantitative data for phylogenetic analysis. Systematic Biology, 47:508519.
Swofford, D. L. 2002. PAUP∗. Phylogenetic analysis using parsimony∗ 4.0. Sinauer, Sunderland, Massachusetts.
Twenhofel, W. H. 1928. Geology of Anticosti Island, Geological Survey of Canada Memoir 154, 481p.
Ulrich, E. O. and Cooper, G. A. 1942. New genera of Ordovician brachiopods. Journal of Paleontology, 16:620626.
Wagner, P. J. 2000. Phylogenetic analyses and the fossil record: Tests and inferences, hypotheses and models. Paleobiology, 26:341371.
Wagner, P. J. 2011. Modelling rate distributions using character compatibility: Implications for morphological evolution among fossil invertebrates. Biology Letters, 8:143146.
Walker, L. G. 1982. The brachiopod genus Hebertella, Dalmanella, and Heterothina from the Ordovician of Kentucky. U. S. Geological Survey Paper 1066-M, 17p.
Wang, Y. 1949. Maquoketa Brachiopoda of Iowa. Geological Society of America Memoir, 42, 55p.
Wiley, E. O. and Lieberman, B. S. 2011. Phylogenetics: Theory and Practice of Phylogenetic Systematics (second edition). John Wiley and Sons, New Jersey, 406p.
Williams, A. and Harper, D. A. T. 2000. Order Orthida, p. H733H734. InKaesler, R. L.(ed.), Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology. Pt. H. Brachiopoda (revised) 3. Geological Society of America and University of Kansas Press, Lawrence.
Williams, A. and Wright, A. D. 1965. Orthida, p. 299395. InMoore, R. C.(ed.), Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, Pt. H1. Geological Society of America and University of Kansas Press, Lawrence.
Wilson, A. E. 1926. An Upper Ordovician fauna from the Rocky Mountains, British Columbia. Canada Geological Survey Museum Bulletin, 44:134.
Winchell, N. H. 1881. New brachiopoda from the Trenton and Hudson River formations in Minnesota, Minnesota Geological and Natural History Survey Annual Report, 9:115122.
Winchell, N. H. and Schuchert, C. 1892. Preliminary descriptions of new Brachiopoda from the Trenton and Hudson River groups of Minnesota. American Geologist, 9:284294.
Winchell, N. H. and Schuchert, C. 1893. The Lower Silurian Brachiopoda of Minnesota. Geological and Natural history Survey Final Report, 3:333374.
Wilkinson, M. 1964. The permutation method and character compatibility. Systematic Biology, 43:274277.
Wright, A. D. 1964. The fauna of the Portrane Limestone, II. Bulletin of the British Museum of Natural History, Geology, 9:159256.
Wright, D. F. and Stigall, A. L. 2012. Paleobiogeography of the Late Ordovician Richmondian Invasion: Inferring source regions from phylogenetic patterns. Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs, 44:5.
Wright, D. F. and Stigall, A. L.In press. Species-level phylogenetic revision of the Ordovician orthide brachiopod genus Glyptorthis from North America. Journal of Systematic Palaeontology.
Woodward, S. P. 1852. A manual of the Mollusca; or rudimentary treatise of recent and fossil shells. London, 486p.
Yang, Z. and Rannala, B. 2012. Molecular phylogenetics: Principles and practice. Nature Reviews Genetics, 13:303314.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO

Phylogenetic revision of the Late Ordovician orthid brachiopod genera Plaesiomys and Hebertella from Laurentia

  • David F. Wright (a1) and Alycia L. Stigall (a2)


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.