1 Cutterham, Tom, “Charles A. Beard and the Politics of Radical Public History,” American Political Thought 2:2 (Fall 2013): 315CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Barrow, Clyde W., More Than a Historian: The Political and Economic Thought of Charles A. Beard (New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers, 2000)Google Scholar.

3 Erskine, John, My Life as a Teacher (Philadelphia: J.B Lippincott, 1948), 93Google Scholar.

4 Luther Gulick to Mary Ritter Beard, Nov. 17, 1948, fol. 95, Charles Austin Beard and Mary Ritter Beard Papers (MSD-1898-002), DePauw University Archives and Special Collections, Greencastle, IN.

5 Skowronek, Stephen, Engel, Stephen M., and Ackerman, Bruce, eds., The Progressives’ Century: Political Reform, Constitutional Government and the Modern American State (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2016), 1CrossRefGoogle Scholar. As legal scholar Pope McCorkle has pointed out, the misleading image of Beard “as a cranky old populist muckraker” has prevented scholars from unpacking his more “sophisticated notions.” McCorkle, Pope, “The Historian as Intellectual: Charles Beard and the Constitution Reconsidered,” The American Journal of Legal History 28:4 (Oct. 1984): 363CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Lowe, Jessica K., “Ideas that Matter: Parting Thoughts on Charles Beard on the 100th Anniversary of An Economic Interpretation,” Constitutional Commentary 29:3 (Summer 2014): 525–32Google Scholar.

7 Noble, David W., The Paradox of Progressive Thought (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1958), 30–31Google Scholar.

8 Seidelman, Raymond, Disenchanted Realists: Political Science and the American Crisis, 1884–1984 (Albany: State University of New York Press, 2015 [1985]), 80–98Google Scholar; Gunnell, John G., Imagining the American Polity: Political Science and the Discourse of Democracy (University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 2005), 109–10Google Scholar.

9 Hofstadter, Richard, “Beard and the Constitution: The History of an Idea,” American Quarterly 2:3 (Autumn 1950): 195–213CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hofstadter, Richard, The Age of Reform: From Bryan to F. D. R (New York: Vintage, 1955)Google Scholar; Hofstadter, Richard, The Progressive Historians: Turner, Beard, Parrington (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1969), 167–346Google Scholar.

10 Goldman, Eric F., Rendezvous with Destiny: A History of Modern American Reform (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1953), 149–55Google Scholar; Goldman, Eric F., “The Origins of Beard's Economic Interpretation of the Constitution,” Journal of the History of Ideas 13:2 (Apr. 1952): 234–49CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Rauchway, Eric, The Refuge of Affections: Family and American Reform Politics, 1900–1920 (New York: Columbia University Press, 2001): 61–90, 156–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Mehrotra, Ajay K., “Charles A. Beard & the Columbia School of Political Economy: Revisiting the Intellectual Roots of the Beardian Thesis,” Constitutional Commentary 29:3 (Summer 2014): 475–510Google Scholar; White, G. Edward, “Charles Beard & Progressive Legal Historiography,” Constitutional Commentary 29:3 (Summer 2014): 353Google Scholar.

12 Nore, Ellen, Charles A. Beard: An Intellectual Biography (Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, 1983), 38–50Google Scholar.

13 Smith, Mark C., Social Science in the Crucible: The American Debate over Objectivity and Purpose, 1918–1941 (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1994), 159–211CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14 Bender, Thomas, Intellect and Public Life: Essays on the Social History of Academic Intellectuals in the United States (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1993), 91–105Google Scholar.

15 White, Morton, review of The Progressive Historians: Turner, Beard, Parrington, by Hofstadter, Richard, The American Historical Review 75:2 (Dec. 1969): 601CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Brown, David, Beyond the Frontier: The Midwestern Voice in American Historical Writing (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 2009), 51–71Google Scholar.

16 Beard, Charles A., “New York, The Metropolis of Today,” The American Review of Reviews 69 (June 1924): 608–24Google Scholar; Beard, Charles A., “The City's Place in Civilization,” National Municipal Review 17:12 (Nov. 1928): 726–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 “The State and Nation Draw Upon Columbia University for Advice and Aid,” New-York Daily Tribune, Oct. 29, 1911, A5.

18 Davidann, Jon Thares, The Limits of Westernization: American and East Asian Intellectuals Create Modernity, 1860–1960 (New York: Routledge, 2019), 112–32Google Scholar.

19 Bender, Thomas, A Nation Among Nations: America's Place in World History (New York: Hill and Wang, 2006), 282Google Scholar; Kwak, Nancy H., “Interdisciplinarity in Planning History,” in The Routledge Handbook of Planning History, ed. Hein, Carola (Abingdon: Routledge, 2018): 25–34Google Scholar.

20 Ethington, Philip J., The Public City: The Political Construction of Urban Life in San Francisco, 1850–1900 (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 2001)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Connolly, James J., The Triumph of Ethnic Progressivism: Urban Political Culture in Boston, 1900–1925 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1998)Google Scholar; Ethington, Philip J., “The Metropolis and Multicultural Ethics,” in Progressivism and the New Democracy, eds. Milkis, Sidney M. and Mileur, Jerome M. (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1999), 193Google Scholar; Johnston, Robert D., “Re-Democratizing the Progressive Era: The Politics of Progressive Era Political Historiography,” The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era 1:1 (Jan. 2002): 69–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Westhoff, Laura M., A Fatal Drifting Apart: Democratic Social Knowledge and Chicago Reform (Columbus: The Ohio State University Press, 2007)Google Scholar; Recchiuti, John Louis, Civic Engagement: Social Science and Progressive Era Reform in New York City (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2007)Google Scholar.

21 Stears, Marc, Demanding Democracy: American Radicals in Search of a New Politics (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2013), 21–55Google Scholar.

22 Hofstadter, The Progressive Historians, 248.

23 Rodgers, Daniel T., “In Search of Progressivism,” Reviews in American History 10:4 (Dec. 1982): 115CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Schumpeter, Joseph A., Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy (New York: Routledge, 1994 [1942]), 269–83Google Scholar.

25 Ross, Dorothy, The Origins of American Social Science (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990), 274–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

26 Rosenblum, Nancy L., On the Side of the Angels: An Appreciation of Parties and Partisanship (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2008), 25–107Google Scholar; Dish, Lisa Jane, The Tyranny of the Two-Party System (New York: Columbia University Press, 2002), 64–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27 Ethington, The Public City, 11; Gunnell, John G., “The Rise and Fall of the Democratic Dogma and the Emergence of Empirical Democratic Theory,” in Modern Pluralism: Anglo-American Debates since 1880, ed. Bevir, Mark (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012), 129–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

28 Alan Lessoff and James J. Connolly have argued that the functional analysis Beard helped to fashion has “steered research away from thoughtful, imaginative treatment of the ideas and ethical concerns that coursed through big-city public life.” Lessoff, Alan, and Connolly, James J., “From Political Insult to Political Theory: The Boss, the Machine, and the Pluralist City,” Journal of Policy History 25:2 (Apr. 2013): 165CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

29 Beard, Charles A., “A Living Empire I,” Young Oxford 3:25 (Oct. 1901): 24–25Google Scholar; Beard, Charles A. “A Living Empire II,” Young Oxford 3:26 (Nov. 1901): 39–43Google Scholar.

30 Ruskin, John, Unto This Last (London: Allen, 1892): 160Google Scholar; Beard, Charles A., “Men Who Have Helped Us, I: William Cobbett, Friend of Man” Young Oxford 2:17 (February 1901): 172Google Scholar; Beard, Charles A., “Men Who Helped Us, II: William Morris,” Young Oxford 2:20 (May 1901): 293Google Scholar.

31 Borning, Bernard C., The Political and Social Thought of Charles A. Beard (Seattle: University of Washington Press, 1962)Google Scholar; Marcell, David W., Progress and Pragmatism: James, Dewey, Beard, and the American Idea of Progress (Westport: Greenwood Press, 1974), 258–334Google Scholar; Diggins, John Patrick, The Promise of Pragmatism: Modernism and the Crisis of Knowledge and Authority (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1994), 423–26Google Scholar; Snider, Keith F., “Rethinking Public Administration's Roots in Pragmatism: The Case of Charles A. Beard,” The American Review of Public Administration 30:2 (June 2000): 123–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32 According to Mary Beard, her husband kept a copy of Unto This Last “as an acme of wisdom and usually had it in his hand or pocket as bracer.” Beard also had an etching of Ruskin hanging at his desk. Beard, Mary Ritter, The Making of Charles A. Beard (New York: Exposition Press, 1955), 19Google Scholar; William Beard, Photography 31, The Urban and Rural Cycle, Series V: Family Correspondences and Papers, Correspondence: William Beard, 1927–1974, 24, DC 1636, Charles Austin Beard and Mary Ritter Beard Papers (MSD-1898-002), DePauw University Archives and Specials Collections, Greencastle, IN; Beard, Charles A., “Individualism and Capitalism,” in Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences 1, eds.Seligman, E.R.A. and Johnson, Alvin (New York: Macmillan, 1930)Google Scholar.

33 Beard, Charles A., “Political Science,” in Research in the Social Sciences, ed. Gee, Wilson (New York: Macmillan, 1929): 269–91Google Scholar; Williams, William Appleman, “A Note on Charles Austin Beard's Search for a General Theory of Causation,” The American Historical Review 62:1 (Oct. 1956): 59–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

34 Beard defeated many professors with longer teaching experience, receiving 106 votes out of 418. “Straw Balloting for Dean,” Columbia Daily Spectator 53, no. 59, Dec. 4, 1909, 1.

35 Munroe Smith to Nicholas Butler, Nov. 14, 1914, box: 399, fol. 10, Central Files, 1890–1984 (UA#0001), University Archives, Rare Book & Manuscript Library, Columbia University, New York, NY.

36 Johnson, Alvin S., Pioneer's Progress (New York: Viking Press, 1952), 279Google Scholar.

37 Edman, Irwin, Philosopher's Holiday (London: Constable & Co., 1939), 130Google Scholar.

38 Somit, Albert and Tanenhaus, Joseph, The Development of American Political Science: From Burgess to Behavioralism (Boston: Allyn & Bacon, 1967), 45Google Scholar.

39 Woodbury, Willoughby W., The Rights and Duties of American Citizenship (New York: American Book Company, 1898)Google Scholar.

40 Haines, Charles Grove, The Teaching of Government: Report to American Political Science Association by the Committee on Instruction (New York: Macmillan, 1916), 2Google Scholar.

41 Report on the Committee of Five of the American Political Science Association on Instruction in American Government in Secondary Schools, Proceedings of the American Political Science Association, vol. 5, Fifth Annual Meeting (1908): 235.

42 Nicholas Murray Butler to Charles A. Beard, Feb. 15, 1909, box 317, fol. 9, Central Files, 1890–1984 (UA#0001), University Archives, Rare Book & Manuscript Library, Columbia University, New York, NY.

43 Charles A. Beard to George E. Brett, Sept. 3, 1907, box: 34, Macmillan Company Records 1889–1960 (Collection 1830), Manuscripts and Archives Division, The New York Public Library, New York, NY.

44 Haines, Charles G., of, reviewAmerican Government and Politics, by Charles A. Beard (New York: Macmillan, 1911)Google Scholar, American Political Science Review 5:1 (Feb. 1911): 142Google Scholar.

45 Anonymous, review of American Government and Politics, by Charles A. Beard, The Journal of Education 72:16 (Nov. 1910): 441; Macmillan to Charles A. Beard, Nov. 10, 1910, box: 34, Macmillan Company Records, 1889–1960 (Collection 1830), Manuscripts and Archives Division, The New York Public Library, New York, NY.

46 American Government and Politics has gone throughout ten editions and dozen reprints, the last one appeared in 2013. Charles Grove Haines, The Teaching of Government; Report to the American Political Science Association (New York: Macmillan, 1916).

47 Brigham, John, “Political Science and Law,” in Oxford Companion to American Law, eds. Clark, David Scott and Hall, Kermit L. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002), 619Google Scholar.

48 Goebel, Julius Jr., A History of the School of Law, Columbia University (New York: Columbia University Press, 1955), 194Google Scholar.

49 Beard, Charles A., “Time, Technology, and the Creative Spirit of Political Science,” American Political Science Review 21:1 (Feb. 1927): 6CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

50 Duxbury, Neil, Patterns of American Jurisprudence (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995), 9–64Google Scholar.

51 Beard, Charles A., Politics (New York: Columbia University Press, 1908), 24Google Scholar.

52 Beard, Charles A., American Government and Politics (New York: Macmillan, 1911), 126Google Scholar.

53 Stokes, Susan C., “Political Parties and Democracy,” Annual Review of Political Science 2 (June 1999): 245CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Norris, Pippa, Political Parties and Democracy in Theoretical and Practical Perspectives (Washington: National Democratic Institute for International Affairs, 2005), 3Google Scholar.

54 Pomper, Gerald M., Passions and Interests: Political Party Concepts of American Democracy (Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 1992)Google Scholar.

55 Hofstadter, Richard, The idea of a Party System: The Rise of Legitimate Opposition in the United States, 1780–1840 (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1969)Google Scholar; Altschuler, Glenn C. and Blumin, Stuart M., Rude Republic: Americans and Their Politics in the Nineteenth Century (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2000)Google Scholar; Blumin, Stuart M., “Antiparty Sentiment,” in The Concise Princeton Encyclopedia of American Political History, ed. Kazin, Michael (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2011), 20–21Google Scholar.

56 Scarrow, Susan E., “The Nineteenth-Century Origins of Modern Political Parties: The Unwanted Emergence of Party-Based Politics,” in Handbook of Party Politics, eds. Katz, Richard S. and Crotty, William (London: SAGE, 2006), 16CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

57 Stickney, Albert, A True Republic (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1879), 151Google Scholar.

58 Clark, Charles C.P., The “Machine” Abolished and the People Restored to Power by the Organization of All the People on the Lines of Party Organization (New York: G.P. Putnam's Sons, 1900), 16Google Scholar.

59 Velde, Henk te, “The Domestication of a Machine: The Debate About Political Parties Around 1900,” in Organizing Democracy: Reflections on the Rise of Political Organizations in the Nineteenth Century, eds., te Velde, Henk and Janse, Maartje (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2017), 255CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

60 Epstein, Leon D., Political Parties in the American Mold (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1986), 9–39Google Scholar; McCormick, Richard L., The Party Period and Public Policy: American Politics from the Age of Jackson to the Progressive Era (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986), 228–62Google Scholar.

61 Bryce, James, The American Commonwealth, vol. 1 (London: Macmillan, 1888), 6Google Scholar.

62 Bryce, The American Commonwealth, vol. 2, 3.

63 Beard, American Government and Politics, 126.

64 Beard, Politics, 24.

65 Charles A. Beard, “Party Government in the United States,” Columbia University syllabus, 1908; “Party Government in the U.S.: Prof. Beard Describes Growth of Essential Part of Our Government in Lecture at P.S.,” Columbia Daily Spectator 42, no. 14, Oct. 8, 1908, 2; “Party Government in United States,” Columbia Daily Spectator 42, no. 26, Oct. 22, 1908, 2; “Discussion of Direct Primary Law,” Columbia Daily Spectator 42, no. 49, Nov. 19, 1908, 2.

66 Beard, “Party Government in the United States,” 5.

67 “Dr. Beard on Party Machine,” Columbia Daily Spectator 42, no. 20, Oct. 15, 1908, 1.

68 “Mock Convention to Open: Novel Feature of Prof. Beard's Courses on Workings of Political Parties,” Columbia Daily Spectator 41, no. 27, Oct. 25, 1907, 1.

69 “Convention Great Success: Governor Hughes Nominated for Presidency—Fifteen Hundred Attend,” Columbia Daily Spectator 41, no. 54, Nov. 27, 1907, 1Google Scholar; “Silver Cup Presented to Prof. Beard,” Columbia Daily Spectator 41, no. 68, Dec. 17, 1907, 1.

70 “Mock Elections Approved: Professors Beard and Spingarn Favor Spectator's Plan-First Election Next Wednesday,” Columbia Daily Spectator 42, no. 24 Oct. 20, 1908, 1Google Scholar. Beard collaborated as “superintendent of the election,” mainly supervising the ballot box. Eventually, Nicholas Butler selected Beard as “Faculty Supervisor of Partisan Activities,” thus putting him in charge of organizing all elections at Columbia University. “Large Number of Voters: Mock Elections Make Promising Start—Faculty Shows Great Interest Voting Continues Today,” Columbia Daily Spectator 42, no. 31, Oct. 28, 1908, 1, 4, 8Google Scholar; “Third Lecture by Professor Beard,” Columbia Daily Spectator 42, no. 25, Oct. 21, 1908, 3Google Scholar; Beard, American Government and Politics, 179; “National Campaigns by Prof. Beard,” Columbia Daily Spectator 42, no. 37, Nov. 4, 1908, 5Google Scholar.

71 “Taft Elected President,” Columbia Daily Spectator 42, no. 32, Oct. 29, 1908, 1Google Scholar.

72 “Trying to Get Our ‘Civic Biography,’” Columbia Daily Spectator 42, no. 98, Feb. 9, 1909, 3Google Scholar.

73 Ranney, Austin, The Doctrine of Responsible Party Government (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1954)Google Scholar.

74 Goodnow, Frank J., Politics and Administration (New York: Macmillan, 1910), 133–35Google Scholar.

75 Goodnow, Politics and Administration, 146.

76 Goodnow, Politics and Administration, 149.

77 Beard, American Government and Politics, 155.

78 Beard, Politics, 22.

79 Beard, Charles A., The American Party Battle (New York: Macmillan, 1928), 20Google Scholar.

80 Beard, The American Party Battle, 20.

81 Beard, American Government and Politics, 126 [my emphasis].

82 Beard, Politics, 26.

83 Emerson, Blake, “The Democratic Reconstruction of the Hegelian State in American Progressive Political Thought,” The Review of Politics 77:4 (Oct. 2015): 545–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

84 Enroth, Henrik, Political Science and the Concept of Politics: A Twentieth-Century Genealogy (Stockholm: Department of Political Science, Stockholm University, 2004), 62–88Google Scholar.

85 Bentley, Arthur F., The Process of Government: A Study of Social Pressure (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1967 [1908]), 258–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

86 Beard, Charles A., of, reviewThe Process of Government: A Study of Social Pressure, by Bentley, Arthur F., Political Science Quarterly 23:4 (Dec. 1908): 739CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Tal, Diana and Gordon, Avishag, “Sleeping Beauties of Political Science: The Case of AF Bentley,” Society 54:4 (2017): 355–61CrossRefGoogle Scholar; As MacMahon recalled it Beard showed more admiration for Bentley's book than what his review conveys. Beard, MacMahon pointed out, “declared that The Process of Government was the best thing in American political science since The Federalist. It was not Beard's fault that many oversimplified the book's message, perhaps without reading it.” Arthur W. MacMahon, reviews of Political Power and Social Change, by Peter H. Odegard, and The Process of Government, by Arthur F. Bentley, with an introduction by Odegard, Peter H., The American Political Science Review 61:3 (Sept. 1967): 780–81Google Scholar.

87 Hartz, Louis, The Liberal Tradition in America (New York: Harcourt, Brace & World, 1955), 30Google Scholar; Ratner, Sidney, “Arthur F. Bentley, 1870–1957,” The Journal of Philosophy 55:14 (July 1957): 574–75Google Scholar; McDonald, Forrest, “Charles A. Beard,” in Pastmasters: Some Essays on American Historians, eds. Cunliffe, Marcus and Winks, Robin (New York: Harper & Row, 1969), 125Google Scholar.

88 Even Beard's fiercest critic, Robert E. Brown, refuted this charge. Brown, Robert Eldon, Charles Beard and the Constitution (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1956), 31CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For a more balanced account of the role of economic interests in Beard's thesis, see Samuel DuBois Cook, “Charles A. Beard's Correspondence Theory of Economics and Politics” (master's thesis, Ohio State University, 1950).

89 Ratner, Sidney and Altman, Jules, eds. John Dewey and Arthur F. Bentley: A Philosophical Correspondence, 1932–1951 (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1964)Google Scholar; Ward, James F., Language, Form, and Inquiry: Arthur F. Bentley's Philosophy of Social Science (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1984)Google Scholar. Beard knew that other factors were important, like race and religion; however, he considered them difficult to measure. “They are awfully intangible. I suppose I take this interest in economic forces because they are relatively so tangible.” Braeman, John, “Charles A. Beard at Mid-Career: Reflections,” International Journal of Social Education 2:1, (1987): 82, 84Google Scholar.

90 McDonald, Forrest, We The People: The Economic Origins of the Constitution (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1958)Google Scholar.

91 McGuire, Robert A., To Form a More Perfect Union: A New Economic Interpretation of the United States Constitution (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003)Google Scholar.

92 McDonald, “Charles A. Beard,” 114.

93 Maier, Charles S., “‘Fictitious Bonds … of Wealth and Law’: On the History and Practice of Interest Representation,” in Organizing Interest in Western Europe: Pluralism, Corporatism, and the Transformation of Politics, ed. Berger, Suzanne (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981), 28–29Google Scholar.

94 Wiebe, Robert H., The Search for Order (New York: Hill and Wang, 1967), 185Google Scholar; Dinan, John, “Framing a ‘People's Government’: State Constitution-Making in the Progressive Era,” Rutgers Law Journal 30:4 (Summer 1999): 933–85Google Scholar; Gerstle, Gary, Liberty and Coercion: The Paradox of American Government from the Founding to the Present (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2015), 90Google Scholar.

95 Beard, Charles A., “The Constitution of Oklahoma,” Political Science Quarterly 24:1 (Mar. 1909): 95–114CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

96 Goodnow, Politics and Administration, 163.

97 Beard, Charles A and Beard, Mary R., The Rise of American Civilization (New York: Macmillan, 1934 [1927]), 305Google Scholar.

98 Beard and Beard, The Rise of American Civilization, 396.

99 Connolly, James J., An Elusive Unity: Urban Democracy and Machine Politics in Industrializing America (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2010), 163–64Google Scholar.

100 Thelen, David P., “Two Traditions of Progressive Reform, Political Parties and American Democracy,” in The American Constitutional System Under Strong and Weak Parties, eds. Bonomi, Patricia et al. , (New York: Praeger, 1981), 37–63Google Scholar.

101 Croly, Herbert, Progressive Democracy (New York: Macmillan, 1914), 348Google Scholar.

102 Beard, Charles A., “Political Parties in City Government: A Reconsideration of Old View Points,” National Municipal Review 6:2 (Mar. 1917): 201CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

103 Beard, Charles A., The Republic: Conversations on Fundamentals, (New York: Viking, 1946 [1943]), 268Google Scholar. Beard's understanding of the function of political parties as buffers in the political process has a striking resemblance to Ira Katznelson's account. Katznelson, Ira, “The Crisis of the Capitalist City: Urban Politics and Social Control,” in Theoretical Perspectives on Urban Politics, ed., Hawley, Willis et al. (Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1976), 214–29Google Scholar.

104 Ostrogorski, Moisei, Democracy and the Organization of Political Parties (New York: Macmillan, 1902), 2: 539–604Google Scholar.

105 Michels, Robert, Political Parties: A Sociological Study of the Oligarchical Tendencies of Modern Democracy, trans. Eden and Paul, Cedar (New York: Hearst's International Library, 1915), 377–92Google Scholar.

106 Beard, Charles A., review of Political Parties: A Sociological Study of the Oligarchical Tendencies of Modern Democracy, by Michels, Robert, Political Science Quarterly 32 (Mar. 1917): 153–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

107 George E. Brett to Charles A. Beard, Sept. 24–25, 1907, box 34, Macmillan Company Records, 1889–1960 (Collection 1830), Manuscripts and Archives Division, The New York Public Library, New York, NY; Charles A. Beard to George E. Brett, Jan. 31, 1908, box 34, Macmillan Company Records, 1889–1960 (Collection 1830), Manuscripts and Archives Division, The New York Public Library, New York, NY; George E. Brett to Charles A. Beard, Feb. 18, 1908; box 34, Macmillan Company Records, 1889–1960 (Collection 1830), Manuscripts and Archives Division, The New York Public Library, New York, NY.

108 Epstein, Political Parties in the American Mold, 166–69; Ware, Alan, The American Direct Primary: Party Institutionalization and Transformation in the North (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002), 57CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

109 Charles A. Beard, review of Primary Elections, by Merriam, Charles Edward, Political Science Quarterly 24 (June 1909): 317Google Scholar.

110 Charles A. Beard, “The Direct Primary Movement in New York,” Proceedings of the American Political Science Association, vol. 7, May 1910, 187. Historian Richard L McCormick reached a similar conclusion. See McCormick, Richard L., From Realignment to Reform: Political Change in New York State 1893–1910 (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1981), 243–50Google Scholar.

111 Bryce, The American Commonwealth, vol. 2, 92.

112 Bryce, The American Commonwealth, vol. 2, 247.

113 Charles A. Beard to Nicholas Butler, Jan. 17, 1910, box 317, fol. 9, Central Files, 1890–1984 (UA#0001), University Archives, Rare Book & Manuscript Library, Columbia University, New York, NY.

114 Charles A. Beard, “The City's Place in Civilization,” The Survey 51, Nov. 15, 1928, 215.

115 Goodnow, Politics and Administration, 200.

116 Childs, Richard S., “The Short Ballot Movement and Simplified Politics,” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 64:1 (1916): 168–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

117 Beard, American Government and Politics, 493.

118 Beard, Charles A. and Shultz, Birl E., Documents on the State Wide Initiative, Referendum and Recall (New York: Macmillan, 1912), 54Google Scholar; Hirschhorn, Bernard, Democracy Reformed: Richard Spencer Childs and His Fight for Better Government (Westport: Greenwood Press, 1997), 33Google Scholar.

119 Beard, Charles A., “The Ballot's Burden,” Political Science Quarterly 24:4 (Dec. 1909): 614CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

120 Charles A. Beard, Introduction to “Budget Systems: A Discussion before the New York Constitutional Convention,” Municipal Research (monthly publication of the Bureau of Municipal Research, New York) 62 (June 1915): i.

121 The records of the New York of Municipal Research—almost 700 boxes—have been finally processed, catalogued, and stored at Baruch College of the City University of New York. Dahlberg, Jane S., The New York Bureau of Municipal Research: Pioneer in Government Administration (New York: New York University Press, 1966)Google Scholar; “Gulick's Guru,” on Adventures in Democracy (blog), The Institute of Public Administration Collection: A Processing Blog, Nov. 21, 2014 (https://blogs.baruch.cuny.edu/ipaprocessing/2014/11/charles-beard, accessed Sept. 24, 2019).

122 Mosher, Frederick C., Democracy and the Public Service (New York: Oxford University Press, 1968), 75Google Scholar; Schachter, Hindy Lauer, Frederick Taylor and the Public Administration Community: A Reevaluation (Albany: State University of New York Press, 1989), 90–94Google Scholar.

123 Gulick, Luther, “Beard and Municipal Reform,” in Charles A. Beard: An Appraisal, ed. Beale, Howard K. (Lexington: University of Kentucky Press, 1954), 49Google Scholar.

124 Beard, Charles A., “The Role of Administration in Government,” in The Work Unit in Federal Administration (Chicago: Public Administration Service Publication, 1937), 1Google Scholar.

125 The Constitution and Government of the State of New York (New York: Bureau of Municipal Research, 1915)Google Scholar.

126 Charles A. Beard, “Reconstructing State Government,” The New Republic, Special Supplement, Aug. 21, 1915, 7–8.

127 Beard, “Reconstructing State Government,” 9–10.

128 Hofstadter, The Age of Reform, 257; Miller, Kenneth P., Direct Democracy and the Courts (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009), 19–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kincaid, John, “Early State History and Constitutions,” in The Oxford Handbook of State and Local Government, ed. Haider-Markel, Donald P. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014), 248Google Scholar.

129 Beard, “Reconstructing State Government,” 7.

130 Beard, “The Ballot's Burden,” Political Science Quarterly 24:4 (Dec. 1909): 607.

131 Beard, American Government and Politics, 479. Beard's hunch that private interests profited from direct democracy measures has been recently validated. See Gerber, Elisabeth R., The Populist Paradox: Interest Group Influence and the Promise of Direct Legislation (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1999)Google Scholar; Smith, Daniel A. and Lubinski, Joseph, “Direct Democracy During the Progressive Era: A Crack in the Populist Veneer?,” Journal of Policy History 14 (Oct. 2002): 349–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

132 Beard, Charles A., “Transitions in Politics,” review of Fenwick, Charles G., Political Systems in Transition: War-Time and After (New York: The Century Co., 1920)Google Scholar, The Nation 16 (Feb. 23, 1921): 298.

133 Beard, Charles A., “The Fiction of Majority Rule,” Atlantic Monthly 140 (Dec. 1927): 831Google Scholar.

134 Beard and Shultz, Documents on the State-Wide Initiative, Referendum and Recall, 34.

135 Beard, “The Fiction of Majority Rule,” 836.

136 Beard, “The Fiction of Majority Rule,” 834–35.

137 Beard, American Government and Politics, 466–68; Beard and Shultz, Documents on the State-Wide Initiative, Referendum and Recall, 24.

138 Beard and Shultz, Documents on the State-Wide Initiative, Referendum and Recall, 33.

139 Beard and Shultz, Documents on the State-Wide Initiative, Referendum and Recall, 32–69.

140 Beard, Charles A., “In Defense of Congress: Citadel of Our Freedom,” The American Mercury 55 (Nov. 1942): 529–35Google Scholar.

141 Charles A. Beard, The Republic, 192–206.

142 Cleveland, Frederick A., “Evolution of the Budget Idea in the United States,” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 62:1 (Nov. 1915): 15–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Rubin, Irene S., “Who Invented Budgeting in the United States?,” Public Administration Review 53:5 (Sep.–Oct. 1993): 438–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Rubin, Irene S., “Early Budget Reformers: Democracy, Efficiency, and Budget Reforms,” The American Review of Public Administration 24:3 (Sept. 1994): 229–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kahn, Jonathan, Budgeting Democracy: State Building and Citizenship in America, 1890–1928 (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1997)Google Scholar.

143 Beard, Charles A., “The Budgetary Provisions of the New York Constitution,” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 62:1 (Nov. 1915): 64–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

144 Charles A. Beard, American City Government, 129; Charles A. Beard and David Zukerman, “Bringing the Budget Home to Every New Yorker,” The New York Times, Oct. 12, 1919, 41; Beard, Charles A., The Administration and Politics of Tokyo (New York: Macmillan, 1923), 77Google Scholar.

145 Charles A. Beard, “What a Budget Should Be,” The New Republic, Feb. 17, 1917, 66–67.

146 Charles A. Beard, “What a Budget Means,” The Nation, Sept. 4, 1920, 275.

147 Kahn, Budgeting Democracy, 96.

148 Cleveland, Frederick A. and Buck, Arthur Eugene, The Budget and Responsible Government: A Description and Interpretation of the Struggle for Responsible Government in the United States, with Special Reference to Recent Changes in State Constitutions and Statute Laws Providing for Administrative Reorganization and Budget Reform (New York: Macmillan, 1920)Google Scholar; Allen, William H., Efficient Democracy (New York: Dodd, Mead & Co., 1912)Google Scholar.

149 Beard, The Administration and Politics of Tokyo, 24–25.

150 Mattson, Kevin, Creating a Democratic Public: The Struggle for Urban Participatory Democracy During the Progressive Era (University Park: Penn State University Press, 1997), 7Google Scholar.

151 Schiesl, Martin J., The Politics of Efficiency: Municipal Reform and Administration in America, 1880–1920 (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1977), 4Google Scholar.

152 Link, Arthur S. and McCormick, Richard L, Progressivism (Arlington Heights, IL: Harlan Davidson, 1983), 61–62Google Scholar.

153 Haber, Samuel, Efficiency and Uplift: Scientific Management in the Progressive Era, 1890–1920 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1964), 99–116Google Scholar; Fox, Kenneth, Better City Government: Innovation in American Urban Politics, 1850–1937 (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1977), 61–137Google Scholar; Finegold, Kenneth, Experts and Politicians: Reform Challenge to Machine Politics in New York, Cleveland and Chicago (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1995)Google Scholar.

154 Beard, American Government and Politics, 101.

155 Beard, Charles A., “It is not true,” In Review (Washington, D.C.: Governmental Research Association, 1948), 3Google Scholar.

156 Beard, Politics, 11.

157 Connolly, An Elusive Unity, 135–64.

158 Beard, Charles A., prefatory note to The New York City Budget (New York: Bureau of Municipal Research, 1917), iii–xiiiGoogle Scholar.

159 Beard, Charles A., An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of United States (New York: Free Press 1941 [1913]), 151Google Scholar; John Braeman, “Charles A. Beard at Mid-Career,” 74–75.

160 Charles A. Beard, “John Purroy Mitchel,” The Survey 40, July 13, 1918, 422, 436–37.

161 John F. McClymer, “Of ‘Mornin' Glories’ and ‘Fine Old Oaks’: Mitchel, John Purroy, Smith, Al, and Reform as an Expression of Irish-American Aspiration,” in The New York Irish, eds. Bayor, Ronald H. and Meager, Timothy J. (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1997), 374–76Google Scholar.

162 Charles A. Beard, “Japan's Problem,” The New York Times, Sept. 17, 1923, 14; Beard, Charles A., “Rebuilding in Japan,” American Review of Reviews 68 (Oct. 1923): 373–82Google Scholar.

163 Count Shinpei Gotō to Charles A. Beard, Apr. 1, 1922, DC 1686, fol. 7, Charles Austin Beard and Mary Ritter Beard Papers (MSD-1898-002), DePauw University Archives and Special Collections, Greencastle, IN; Yusuke Tsurumi to Charles A. Beard, Apr. 20, 1922, DC 1579; fol. 16, Charles Austin Beard and Mary Ritter Beard Papers (MSD-1898-002), DePauw University Archives and Special Collections, Greencastle, IN; Beard, The Administration and Politics of Tokyo, 1; Beard, Charles A., “Japan's Statesman of Research,” American Review of Reviews 68 (Sept. 1923): 296–98Google Scholar. Even today, Beard's “good-hearted guidance and advice on the institute's organization and research activities” continues to be deeply appreciated in Japan. “About TIMR,” Tokyo Institute for Municipal Research website (www.timr.or.jp/eng/about/about.html, accessed Sept. 24, 2019).

164 Beard, The Administration and Politics of Tokyo, 11–12.

165 Schencking, J. Charles, The Great Kantō Earthquake and the Chimera of National Reconstruction in Japan (New York: Columbia University Press, 2013), 153–262 [quote at 154]CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

166 Braeman, “Charles A. Beard at Mid-Career,” 76.

167 Beard, “Conflicts in City Planning,” Yale Review 17 (Oct. 1927): 68.

168 Charles A. Beard, “Government by Technologist,” The New Republic, June 18, 1930, 119.

169 Beard, An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of United States, 100.

170 Charles A. Beard to George E. Sokolsky, Nov. 21. 1930, box 22, George E. Sokolsky Papers, Hoover Institution Archives, Stanford, CA; Braeman, “Charles A. Beard at Mid-Career,” 83.

171 Beard, Charles A., “Some Aspects of Regional Planning,” American Political Science Review 20:2 (May 1926): 273–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

172 Caro, Robert A., The Power Broker: Robert Moses and the Fall of New York (New York: Vintage, 1975), 107–8Google Scholar.

173 Paul Goldberger, “Robert Moses: Patron Saint of Public Places,” The New York Times, Dec. 18, 1988, H38; Ballon, Hilary and Jackson, Kenneth T., eds. Robert Moses and the Modern City: The Transformation of New York (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2007)Google Scholar

174 Kenneth T. Jackson, “Robert Moses and the Rise of New York: The Power Broker in Perspective,” in Robert Moses and the Modern City, 67–71; Jackson, Kenneth T., “Robert Moses and the Planned Environment,” in Robert Moses: Singled Minded Genius, ed. Krieg, Joann P. (Interlaken, NY: Heart of the Lakes Publishing, 1988), 30Google Scholar.

175 Peter Bales, “Rockefeller, Moses and the Bridge That Never Was,” in Robert Moses: Singled Minded Genius, 79–88.

176 Ewen, Shane and Saunier, Pierre-Yves, eds. Another Global City: Historical Explorations into the Transnational Municipal Moment, 1850–2000 (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008)Google Scholar.

177 Rodgers, Daniel T., Atlantic Crossings: Social Politics in a Progressive Age (Cambridge, MA: Belknap, 2008), 160–208Google Scholar.

178 Noll, Mark A., God and Race in American Politics: A Short History (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2001)Google Scholar; Hutchings, Vincent L. and Valentino, Nicholas A., “The Centrality of Race in American Politics,” Annual Review of Political Science 7 (2004): 383–408CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Frymer, Paul, Uneasy Alliances: Race and Party Competition in America (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2010)Google Scholar.

179 Michael Powell, “A Tale of Two Cities,” The New York Times, May 6, 2007, CY1; Schindler, Sarah, “Architectural Exclusion: Discrimination and Segregation Through Physical Design of the Built Environment,” Yale Law Journal 124 (Apr. 2015): 1934–46Google Scholar.

180 Millett, John D., “The Department of Public Law and Government,” in A History of the Faculty of Political Science, Columbia University, ed., Hoxie, Gordon (New York: Columbia University Press, 1955), 266Google Scholar.

181 E.E. Schattschneider, Party Government (New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, 2004 [1942]), 1.

182 Odegard, in fact, thanked MacMahon for suggesting to him that he write his book. Odegard, Peter H., Pressure Politics: The Story of the Anti-Saloon League (New York: Columbia University Press, 1928), ixGoogle Scholar.

183 Rauchway, Eric, “Armchair Warriors,” Reviews in American History 32:2 (June 2004): 229CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hamby, Alonso L., “Progressivism: A Century of Change and Rebirth,” in Progressivism and New Democracy, ed., Milkis, Sidney M. and Mileur, Jerome M. (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1999), 44Google Scholar.

184 Ethington, The Public City, 11.

185 Charles A. Beard, “Political Science in the Crucible,” The New Republic, Nov. 17, 1917, 4 [my emphasis].

186 Charles A. Beard, review of Municipal Administration in the Roman Empire, by Abbott, Frank Frost and Johnson, Allan Chester, National Municipal Review 16:9 (Sept. 1927): 587–88Google Scholar.

187 Charles A. Beard to Richard M. Huber, Apr. 23, 1946, box I:12, Eric F. Goldman Papers (MSS80597), Manuscript Division, Library of Congress, Washington, DC.

188 Kallen, Horace M., “In Remembrance of Charles Beard, Philosopher-Historian,” Social Research 18:2 (Jan. 1951): 248Google Scholar.

189 Beard, Charles A., “The Problem of Training for Public Service,” Municipal Research Bulletin 68 (Dec. 1915): 5–14Google Scholar; Goodsell, Charles T., “Charles A. Beard, Prophet for Public Administration,” Public Administration Review 46:2 (Mar. 1986): 105–107CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

190 Cornell, Saul, “Evidence, Explanation, and the Ghost of Charles Beard,” The William and Mary Quarterly 69:2 (Apr. 2012): 393–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

191 Achen, Christopher H. and Bartels, Larry M., Democracy for Realists: Why Elections Do Not Produce Responsive Government (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2016), 22CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

192 Beard, Charles A., “Essentials of Democracy,” Vital Speeches of the Day 5:23 (Sept. 15, 1939): 729–32Google Scholar.

193 Kloppenberg, James T., “From Hartz To Tocqueville: Shifting the Focus from Liberalism to Democracy in America,” in The Democratic Experiment: New Directions in American Political History, eds. Jacobs, Meg, Novak, William J., and Zelizer, Julian (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2003): 350–80Google Scholar.