Skip to main content Accessibility help


  • Till Düppe (a1)


Tjalling C. Koopmans, research director of the Cowles Foundation of Research in Economics, was the first US economist after World War II who, in the summer of 1965, travelled to the Soviet Union for an official visit to the Central Economics and Mathematics Institute of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR. Koopmans left hoping to learn from the Soviet economists’ experience with applying linear programming to economic planning. Would his own theories, as discovered independently by Leonid V. Kantorovich, help increase allocative efficiency in a socialist economy? Inspired by a vague notion of universal reason spanning the iron curtain, Koopmans may have even envisioned a research community that transcends the political divide. Yet, he came home having discovered that learning about Soviet mathematical economists might be more interesting than learning from them. On top of that, he found the Soviet scene caught in the same deplorable situation he knew all too well from home: that mathematicians are the better economists. Reconstructing Koopmans’s voyage from a first-person perspective puts the spirit of universal economic knowledge at Cowles to test: Is it capable of establishing a dialogue across the political divide of the Cold War or is it limited to the Western academic cocoon?



Hide All
Barnett, Vincent. 2005. The History of Russian Economic Thought. New York: Taylor and Francis.
Bockman, Johanna. 2011. Markets in the Name of Socialism: The Left-Wing Origins of Neoliberalism. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Bockman, Johanna, and Bernstein, Michael A.. 2008. “Scientific Community in a Divided World: Economists, Planning, and Research Priority during the Cold War.” Comparative Studies in Society and History 50 (3): 581613.
Boumans, Marcel J. 1998. “Tinbergen.” In Wade Hands, D., Mäki, Uskali, and Davis, John, eds., The Handbook of Economic Methodology. Cheltenham/Northampton: Edward Elgar, pp. 501504.
Byrnes, Robert F. 1969. “American Scholars in Russia Soon Learn About the K.G.B. New York Times Magazine, November 16, pp. 84, 87–94.
Calvino, Italo. [1972] 2013. Invisible Cities. New York: Helen and Kurt Wolff.
Campbell, Robert W. 1961. “Marx, Kantorovich, and Novozhilov: Stoimost’ versus Reality.” Slavic Review 20 (3): 402418.
Charnes, Abraham, and Cooper, William W.. 1962. “On Some Works of Kantorovich, Koopmans and Others.” Management Science 8 (3): 246263.
Dalmedico, Amy D. 2001. “An Image Conflict in Mathematics After 1945.” In Bottazzini, Umberto and Dalmedico, Amy D., eds., Changing Images in Mathematics: From the French Revolution to the New Millenium. London and New York: Routledge, pp. 223253.
Dantzig, George B. 1955. “Linear Programming under Uncertainty.” Management Science 1 (3–4): 197206.
Dorfman, Robert. 1984. “The Discovery of Linear Programming.” Annals of the History of Computing 6 (3): 283295.
Düppe, Till. 2011. “How Economic Methodology Became a Separate Science.” Journal of Economic Methodology 18 (2): 163176.
Düppe, Till. 2013. “Talk Means Trouble—Don’t Talk: Angst und Wissen in ökonomischen Diskursen.” In Pahl, Hanno and Sparsam, Jan, eds., Wirtschaftswissenschaft als Oikodizee? Diskussionen im Anschluss an Joseph Vogls Gespenst des Kapitals. Wiesbaden: Springer, pp. 91112.
Düppe, Till, and Weintraub, E. Roy. 2014a. “Siting the New Economic Science: The Cowles Commission’s Activity Analysis Conference of June 1949.” Science in Context: 453483.
Düppe, Till, and Weintraub, E. Roy. 2014b. Finding Equilibrium: Arrow, Debreu, McKenzie, and the Problem of Scientific Credit. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Ellman, Michael. 1973. Planning Problems in the USSR: The Contribution of Mathematical Economics to Their Solution, 1960–1971. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Engerman, David. 2009. Know Your Enemy: The Rise and Fall of America’s Soviet Experts. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Erickson, Paul, Klein, Judy, Daston, Lorraine, Lemov, Rebecca, Sturm, Thomas, and Gordin, Michael. 2013. How Reason Almost Lost Its Mind: The Strange Career of Cold War Rationality. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Gass, Saul I. 1958. Linear Programming: Methods and Applications. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Gass, Saul I., and Rosenhead, Jonathan. 2011. “Leonid Vital’evich Kantorovich.” In Assad, A. A. and Gass, Saul I., eds., Profiles in Operations Research. International Series in Operations Research and Management Science. New York: Springer, pp. 157170.
Gelfand, Izrael M., Piatelki-Schapiro, Izrael I., and Zetlin, Mikhael L.. 1963. “On Some Classes of Games and of Games with Automata.” [In Russian.] Dokl. Akad. Nauk [USSR] 152 (4): 845848.
Gerovitch, Slava. 2002. From Newspeak to Cyberspeak: A History of Soviet Cybernetics. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Hagendorf, Klaus. 2012. “Victor Valentinovich Novozhilov: A Marxian Mathematical Economist.” Paper prepared for the All-Russian Scientific Conference Mathematics and Economics in the Works of V. V. Novozhilov at the Saint-Petersburg State University of Engineering and Economics on 15 October 2012.
Hardt, John P. 1965. “Rochester Meeting on Mathematical Techniques and Soviet Planning.” Association for the Study of Soviet-type Economies Bulletin 7 (3): 1417.
Hardt, John P., Hoffenberg, Marvin, Kaplan, Norman, and Levine, Herbert S., eds. 1967. Mathematics and Computers in Soviet Planning: Proceedings of a conference held in May 1965 at the University of Rochester. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Kantorovich, Leonid V. [1939] 1960. “Mathematical Methods in the Organization and Planning of Production.” [In Russian.] Leningrad: Leningrad University USSR. Translated 1960, Management Science 6: 366422.
Kantorovich, Leonid V. [1942] 1958. “On the Translocation of Masses.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences [USSR] 37 (7/7): 227230. Translated 1958, Management Science 5 (1): 1–4.
Kantorovich, Leonid V. 1959. The Best Use of Economic Resources. [In Russian.] Moscow: USSR Academy of Sciences. Translated 1965, Oxford: Pergamon Press.
Kantorovich, Leonid V. 1990. “My Journey in Science.” In Leifman, Lev J., ed., Functional Analysis, Optimization, and Mathematical Economics: A Collection of Papers Dedicated to the Memory of Leonid Vital’evich Kantorovich. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 845.
Iljina-Kantorovich, Natalie, and Rosenhead, Jonathan V.. 1990. “Silver Medal.” In Leifman, Lev J., ed., Functional Analysis, Optimization, and Mathematical Economics: A Collection of Papers Dedicated to the Memory of Leonid Vital’evich Kantorovich. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 4648.
Kassel, Simon. 1971. “Soviet Cybernetics Research: A Preliminary Study of Organizations and Personalities.” Report prepared for Advanced Research Project Agency (ARPA), R-909. Santa Monica: RAND.
Kats, Adolf I. 1960. “On the Wrong Concept of Economic Calculations.” [In Russian.] Problems of Economics 35: 256261.
Katsenelinboigen, Aron J. 1986. “Mathematical Economics in the Soviet Union: A Reflection on the 25th Anniversary of L.V. Kantorovich’s Book, The Best Use of Economic Resources.” Acta Slavica Iaponica 4: 88103.
Katsenelinboigen, Aron J. 1978. “L. V. Kantorovich: The Political Dilemma in Scientific Creativity.” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 1 (2): 129147.
Katsenelinboigen, Aron J. 1980. Soviet Economic Thought and Political Power in the USSR. New York: Pergamon Press.
Kirtchik, Olessia, and Boldyrev, Ivan. 2014. “General Equilibrium Theory behind the Iron Curtain: The Case of Victor Polterovich.” History of Political Economy 46 (3): 435461.
Konüs, Alexander A. 1939. “The Problem of the True Index of the Cost of Living.” Econometrica 7 (1): 1029.
Koopmans, Tjalling C. 1939. Tanker Freight Rates and Tankship Building: An Analysis of Cyclical Fluctuations. Netherlands Economic Institute, 27. Haarlem: De Erven Bohn.
Koopmans, Tjalling C. 1942. “Exchange Ratios between Cargoes on Various Routes (Non-refrigerating Dry Cargoes).” Memorandum for the Combined Shipping Adjustment Board, pp. 1–12.
Koopmans, Tjalling C, ed. 1951a. Activity Analysis of Production and Allocation: Proceedings of a Conference. Cowles Commission Monograph 13. New York: John Wiley and Sons.
Koopmans, Tjalling C. 1951b. “Efficient Allocation of Resources.” Econometrica 19: 455465.
Koopmans, Tjalling C. 1959. Three Essays on the State of Economic Science. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Koopmans, Tjalling C. 1960. “A Note about Kantorovich’s Paper Mathematical Methods of Organizing and Planning Production.” Management Science 6 (4): 363365.
Koopmans, Tjalling C. 1962. “On the Evaluation of Kantorovich’s Work of 1939.” Management Science 6 (4): 363365.
Koopmans, Tjalling C. 1965. “On the Concept of Optimal Economic Growth.” In The Econometric Approach to Development Planning. Rome: Pontif. Acad. Sc. Scripta Varia 28, pp. 225300.
Koopmans, Tjalling C. [1974] 1992. “Autobiography.” In Lindbeck, Assar, ed., Nobel Lectures: Economics 1969–1980. World Scientific Publishing: Singapore. < Accessed 26 October 2015.
Koopmans, Tjalling C. 1977. “Concepts of Optimality and Their Uses.” The American Economic Review 67 (3): 261274.
Koopmans, Tjalling C., and Montias, John M.. 1971. “On the Descriptions and Comparison of Economic Systems.” In Eckstein, Alexander, ed., Comparison of Economic Systems, Theoretical and Methodological Approaches. Berkeley: University of California Press, pp. 2778.
Koopmans, Tjalling Charles Papers (TKP). Manuscripts and Archives, Yale University Library.
Leeds, Adam. 2015. Spectral liberalisms: On the subjects of political economy in Moscow, PhD thesis, University of Pennsylvania.
Makarov, Valery L. 1962. “The Condition of Equilibrium in the von Neumann Model.” [In Russian.] Siberian Mathematical Journal 3: 476478.
Makarov, Valery L. 1965. “The State of Equilibrium of a Closed Linear Model of an Expanding Economy.” [In Russian.] Economics and Mathematical Methods 5: 736738.
Medow, Paul. 1965. “V. S. Nemchinow. Obituary.” Economics of Planning 5 (1–2): 14.
Montias, John M. 1961. “Review of L. Kantorovich’s Economic Calculation of the Best Utilization of Resources.” Econometrica 29 (2): 252254.
Morton, George, and Zauberman, Alfred. 1969. “Von Neumann’s Model and Soviet Long-Term (Perspective) Planning.” Kyklos 22: 4561.
Nemchinov, Vasily S., ed. [1959] 1964. The Use of Mathematics in Economics. Translation 1964 by A. Nove. Cambridge: MIT Press.
von Neumann, John. 1937. “Über ein ökonomisches Gleichungssystem und eine Verallgemeinerung des Brouwerschen Fixpunksatzes.” In Menger, Karl, ed., Ergebnisse eines Mathematischen Kolloquiums 1935–36. Volume 8. Leipzig and Vienna: Deuticke, pp. 7383. Translated by George Morton, 1945. “A Model of General Economic Equilibrium.” The Review of Economic Studies 13 (1): 1–9.
Novozhilov, Viktor V. 1964. “Mesures des dépenses (de production) et de leurs résultats en Economie Socialiste.” In Novozhilov, V. V., Johansen, L., Chambre, H. J., Fiszel, H., Kreyberg, H. J., Waelbroeck, Jean, and Stolz, G.. Rationalité et calcul économique en URSS. Cahiers de l’ISEA, Série G, 19 (146). Paris: ISEA.
Rindzeviciute, Egle. Forthcoming. System-Cybernetic Governmentality Across the Iron Curtain, Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Sutela, Pekka. 1991. Economic Thought and Economic Reform in the Soviet Union. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sutela, Pekka. 2008. “Soviet Economics after Stalin: Between Orthodoxy and Reform.” In Barnett, Vincent and Zweynert, Joachim, eds., Economics in Russia: Studies in Intellectual History. Burlington: Ashgate: 157172.
Tinbergen, Jan. 1961. “Do Communist and Free Economies Show a Converging Pattern?” Soviet Studies 12 (4): 331341.
Vorob’ev Nikolai N, . 1958. “Equilibrium Points in Bimatrix Games.” [In Russian.] Teorija verojatnostei i ee primenija 3: 318331. English translation in Theory of Probability and its Applications: 297–309.
Vorob’ev Nikolai N, . 1959. “Finite Non-coalitional Games.” Uspekhi Matematicheskikh Nauk 144: 156.
Zauberman, Alfred. 1975. The Mathematical Revolution in Soviet Economics. London: Oxford University Press.
Weintraub, E. Roy. 2014. “MIT’s Openness to Jewish Economists.” History of Political Economy 46 (Supplement): 4559.
Weintraub, E. Roy. 2015. “McCarthyism and the Mathematization of Economics.” Unpublished working paper.


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed