Skip to main content


  • Steven Kates (a1)

John Stuart Mill’s Fourth Fundamental Proposition Respecting Capital, first stated in 1848, had become an enigma well before the nineteenth century had come to an end. Never challenged in Mill’s own lifetime and described in 1876 as “the best test of a sound economist,” it has become a statement that not only fails to find others in agreement, but fails even to find an internally consistent interpretation that would make clear why Mill found it of such fundamental importance. Yet the fourth proposition should be easily understood as a continuation of the general glut debate. Economists led by Malthus had argued that demand deficiency was the cause of recession and a body of unproductive consumers was needed to raise the level of demand if everyone who wished to work was to find employment. Mill’s answer was that to buy goods and services would not increase employment, or, in Mill’s own words, “demand for commodities is not demand for labour.”

Hide All
Ahiakpor James. 2003. “Say’s Law: Keynes Success with its Misrepresentation.” In Kates Steven, ed., Two Hundred Years of Say’s Law: Essays on Economic Theory’s Most Controversial Principle. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 107132.
Becker Gary, and Baumol William J.. 1952. “The Classical Economic Theory: the Outcome of the Discussion.” Economica 19: 355376.
Hayek Friedrich A. [1941] 2009. Pure Theory of Capital. Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute.
Hayek Friedrich A. [1966] 1995. “Personal Recollections of Keynes and the ‘Keynesian Revolution.’” In Caldwell Bruce, ed., Contra Keynes and Cambridge: Essays, Correspondence. Vol. 9, The Collected Works of F. A. Hayek. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund.
Hollander Samuel. 1985. The Economics of John Stuart Mill. Vols. I and II. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Hollander Samuel. 1987. Classical Economics. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Hollander Samuel. 2000. John Stuart Mill on Economic Theory and Method. Collected Essays III. New York: Routledge. E-book.
Kates Steven. 1998. Say’s Law and the Keynesian Revolution: How Macroeconomic Theory Lost its Way. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Kates Steven. 2003. “Economic Management and the Keynesian Revolution: The Policy Consequences of the Disappearance of Say’s Law.” In Kates Steven, ed., Two Hundred Years of Say’s Law: Essays on Economic Theory’s Most Controversial Principle. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 6781.
Kates Steven. 2014. Free Market Economics: An Introduction for the General Reader. Second edition. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Keynes John Maynard. [1936] 1973. The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money. Vol. VII, The Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes. Edited by Moggridge Donald. London: The Macmillan Press Ltd.
Malthus Thomas Robert. 1986. The Works of Thomas Robert Malthus. Edited by Wrigley E. A. and Souden David. Vol 5, Principles of political economy: The second edition (1836) with variant readings from the first edition (1820). Part I. Vol. 6, Principles of political economy: The second edition (1836) with variant readings from the first edition (1820). Part II. London: William Pickering.
Marshall Alfred. [1920] 1947. Principles of Economics. Eighth edition. London: Macmillan.
Mill James. [1808] 1966a. “Commerce Defended.” In Winch Donald, ed., James Mill: Selected Economic Writings. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd Ltd, pp. 85159.
Mill James. [1826] 1966b. “Elements of Political Economy.” In Winch Donald, ed., James Mill: Selected Economic Writings. Third edition. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd Ltd, pp. 203366.
Mill John Stuart. [1871] 1921. Principles of Political Economy with Some of their Applications to Social Philosophy. Edited with an introduction by Sir Ashley W. J.. Seventh edition. London: Longmans, Green, and Co.
Newcomb Simon. 1886. Principles of Political Economy. New York: Harper & Brothers.
Ricardo David. 1951–1973. The Works and Correspondence of David Ricardo. Edited by Sraffa P. with the collaboration of Dobb M. H.. Eleven volumes. Vol. II, Notes on Malthus's principles of political economy. Vol. VIII, Letters, 1819–June 1821. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sandilands Roger J. 1990. “Nicholas Kaldor’s Notes on Allyn Young’s LSE Lectures 1927–29.” Journal of Economic Studies 17 (3/4): 18170.
Say Jean-Baptiste. 1821. A treatise on political economy; or the production, distribution, and consumption of wealth. Translated from the fourth edition of the French by Prinsep C. R. with notes by the translator. Two volumes. London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme, and Brown.
Say Jean-Baptiste. [1821] 1967. Letters to Mr Malthus on several subjects of political economy and on the cause of the stagnation of commerce to which is added a catechism of political economy or familiar conversations on the manner in which wealth is produced distributed and consumed in society. Translated by Richter John. New York: Augustus M. Kelly.
Sowell Thomas. 1972. Say's Law: An Historical Analysis. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Spence William. 1807. Britain independent of commerce; or, proofs, deduced from an investigation into the true causes of the wealth of nations, that our riches, prosperity, and power, are derived from resources inherent in ourselves, and would not be affected, even though our commerce were annihilated. Second edition. London: W. Savage, Bedford Bury for T. Cadell and W. Davies.
Stephen Leslie. 1876. History of English Thought in the Eighteenth Century. Two volumes. London: Smith, Elder & Co.
Taylor Fred Manville. 1909. “Methods of Teaching Elementary Economics at the University of Michigan.” Journal of Political Economy 17: 688701.
Taylor Fred Manville.1925. Principles of Economics. Ninth edition. New York: The Ronald Press Company.
Thompson James H. 1975. “Mill’s Fourth Fundamental Proposition: A Paradox Revisited.” History of Political Economy 7 (2): 174192.
Thweatt William O. 1979. “Early Formulations of Say’s Law.” Quarterly Review of Economics and Business 19: 7996.
Wikipedia. 2011. “Fermat’s Last Theorem.”'s_Last_Theorem. Accessed November 2014.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of the History of Economic Thought
  • ISSN: 1053-8372
  • EISSN: 1469-9656
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-the-history-of-economic-thought
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 2
Total number of PDF views: 44 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 359 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 23rd January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.