Skip to main content Accessibility help


  • Goulven Rubin (a1)


A few years after the publication of The General Theory, a number of economists began to present John Maynard Keynes’s model, identified with IS-LM, as a particular case of the Walrasian model. This view of IS-LM has often been rationalized by a basic syllogism: IS-LM was invented by John Hicks, Hicks was a Walrasian, hence IS-LM was Walrasian. But as some historians of macroeconomics have shown, this syllogism is false. Considering this confusion as an established fact, this article studies how and why IS-LM came to be considered as Walrasian. It shows that the standard view took its roots in “The Rate of Interest and the Optimum Propensity to Consume,” a paper published by Oskar Lange in 1938, and resulted from a need to clarify the foundations of Keynes’s theory.



Hide All
Arrow, Kenneth. J. 1967. “Samuelson Collected.” Journal of Political Economy 75: 730737.
Asimakopulos, Athanasios. 1984. “The General Theory and Its Marshallian Microfoundations.” Metroeconomica 36 (2–3): 161175.
Asimakopulos, Athanasios. 1991. Keynes’s General Theory and Accumulation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Assous, Michaël, and Lampa, Roberto. 2014. “Lange’s 1938 Model: Dynamics and the ‘Optimum Propensity to Consume.’” European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 21 (5): 871898.
Barens, Ingo. 1999. “From Keynes to Money, Markets and Method.” In Essays in Honour of Robert W. Clower. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 85120.
Barens, Ingo, and Caspari, Volker. 1999. “Old View and New Perspectives: On Rereading ‘Mr Keynes and the Classics.’” European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 6 (2): 216241.
Barro, Robert J., and Grossman, Herschel I.. 1971. “A General Disequilibrium Model of Income and Employment.” American Economic Review 61: 8293.
Benetti, Carlo. 1998. “La structure logique de la Théorie générale.” Cahiers d’économie politique 30–31: 1152.
Béraud, Alain. 2014. “La formulation du modèle keynésien et le choix de l’unité de mesure.” Recherches économiques de Louvain 80 (3) 2014: 2150.
Breit, Marek, and Lange, Oskar. [1934] 2003. “The Way to the Socialist Planned Economy.” Translated by Toporowski, Jan. History of Economics Review: 5170.
Boianovsky, Mauro. 2004. “The IS-LM Model and the Liquidity Trap Concept: From Hicks to Krugman.” History of Political Economy 36 (Annual Supplement): 92126.
Cartelier, Jean. 1995. L’économie de Keynes. Bruxelles: De Boeck Université.
Champernowne, David G. 1936. “Unemployment, Basic and Monetary: The Classical Analysis and the Keynesian.” Review of Economic Studies 3 (3): 201216.
Clower, Robert. 1965. “The Keynesian Counter-Revolution: A Theoretical Appraisal.” In Hahn, F. H. and Bretchling, F. P. R., eds., The Theory of Interest Rate. London: Macmillan, pp. 103125.
Darity, William, and Young, Warren. 1995. “IS-LM: An Inquest.” History of Political Economy 27 (1): 141.
De Vroey, Michel. 1999a. “The Marshallian Market and the Walrasian Economy. Two Incompatible Bedfellows.” Scottish Journal of Political Economy 46 (3): 1938.
De Vroey, Michel. 1999b. “Keynes and the Marshall-Walras Divide.” Journal of the History of Economic Thought 21 (2): 117136.
De Vroey, Michel. 2004a. “The History of Macroeconomics Viewed Against the Background of the Marshall–Walras Divide.” History of Political Economy 36 (Annual Supplement): 5791.
De Vroey, Michel. 2004b. Involuntary Unemployment: The Elusive Quest for a Theory. London, New York: Routledge.
De Vroey, Michel. 2006. “Getting Rid of Keynes? A Reflection on the History of Macroeconomics.” Discussion paper 51. Louvain-la-Neuve: Département des sciences économiques de l’université de Louvain.
De Vroey, Michel. 2009. Keynes, Lucas d’une macroéconomie à l’autre. Paris: Dalloz.
De Vroey, Michel, and Garcia Duarte, P.. 2013. “In Search of Lost Time: The Neoclassical Synthesis.” The B. E. Journal of Macroeconomics 13 (1): 131.
Dimand, Robert. 2007. “Keynes, IS-LM, and the Marshallian Tradition.” History of Political Economy 39 (1): 8195.
Dos Santos Ferreira, Rodolphe. 2000. “Keynes et le développement la théorie de l’emploi dans une économie monétaire.” In Béraud, A. and Faccarello, G., eds., Nouvelle histoire de la pensée économique. Paris: La Découverte & Syros, pp. 236293.
Dos Santos Ferreira, Rodolphe, and Michel, Phillipe. 1985. “Réflexions sur les fondements microéconomiques de la fonction keynésienne d’offre globale.” In Barrère, A., ed., Keynes aujourd’hui: théories et politiques. Paris: Economica, pp. 241252.
Friedman, Milton. 1946. “Lange on Price Flexibility and Employment: A Methodological Criticism.” The American Economic Review 36 (4): 613631.
Garcia Duarte, Pedro, and Tadeu Lima, Gilberto. 2012. Microfoundations Reconsidered: The Relationship of Micro and Macroeconomics in Historical Perspective. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Groenewegen, Peter. 1995. “Keynes and Marshall: Methodology, Society, and Politics.” In Cottrell, A. F. and Lawlor, M. S., eds., New Perspectives on Keynes. History of Political Economy 27 (Annual Supplement): 29155.
Harrod, Roy. 1937. “Mr Keynes and Traditional Theory.” Econometrica 5 (1): 7486.
Harrod, Roy. 1946. “Price Flexibility and Employment by Oscar Lange.” The Economic Journal 56 (221): 102107.
Harrod, Roy. 1956. “Walras: A Re-Appraisal.” The Economic Journal 66 (262): 307316.
Hicks, John R. 1934. “Leon Walras.” Econometrica 2 (4): 338348.
Hicks, John R. 1935. “Wage and Interest: The Dynamic Problem.” The Economic Journal 45 (179): 456468.
Hicks, John R. 1937. “Mr Keynes and the Classics: A Suggested Interpretation.” Econometrica 5: 147159.
Hicks, John R. [1939] 1946. Value and Capital. An Inquiry Into Some Fundamental Principles of Economic Theory. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Hicks, John R. 1950. A Contribution to the Theory of the Trade Cycle. Oxford: The Clarendon Press.
Hicks, John R. 1974. The Crisis in Keynesian Economics. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Hicks, John R. 1980. “IS-LM: An Explanation.” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 3: 139154.
Hoover, Kevin D. 2006. “Doctor Keynes: Economic Theory in a Diagnostic Science.” In Backhouse, R. and Bateman, B., eds., The Cambridge Companion to Keynes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 7897.
Hoover, Kevin D. 2012. “Microfoundational Programs.” In Garcia Duarte, P. and Tadeu Lima, G., eds., Microfoundations Reconsidered: The Relationship of Micro and Macroeconomics in Historical Perspective. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 1961.
Keynes, John Maynard. [1936] 1991. The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money. San Diego, New York, London: Harvest/Harcourt Brace.
King, John E. 2011. The Microfoundation Delusion, Metaphor and Dogma in the History of Macroeconomics. Cheltenham, Northampton: Edward Elgar.
Klein, Lawrence. 1946. “Macroeconomic and the Theory of Rational Behavior.” Econometrica 14 (2): 93108.
Klein, Lawrence. 1947. “Theories of Effective Demand and Employment.” Journal of Political Economy 55 (2): 108131.
Klein, Lawrence. 1947. The Keynesian Revolution. Second edition. New York: The Macmillan Company.
Kriesler, Peter, and Nevile, John. 2002. “IS-LM and Macroeconomics after Keynes.” In Arestis, P., Desai, M., and Dow, S., eds., Money, Macroeconomics and Keynes: Essays in Honour of Victoria Chick. Volume One. London and New York: Routledge, pp. 103114.
Lampa, Roberto. 2014. “A ‘Walrasian Post-Keynesian’ Model? Resolving the Paradox of Oskar Lange’s 1938 Theory of Interest.” Cambridge Journal of Economics 38 (1): 5063.
Lange, Oskar. 1932. “Die allgemeine Interdependenz der Wirtschaftsprognosen und die Isolierungsmethode.” Zeitschrift für Nationalökonomie 4 (1): 5278.
Lange, Oskar. 1937. “On the Economic Theory of Socialism Part II.” Review of Economic Studies 4 (2): 123142.
Lange, Oskar. 1938. “The Rate of Interest and the Optimum Propensity to Consume.” Economica 5: 1232.
Lange, Oskar. 1942. “Say’s Law: A Restatement and Criticism.” In Lange, O., McIntyre, F., and Yntema, T. O., eds., Studies in Mathematical Economics and Econometrics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 4968.
Lange, Oskar. 1945. Price Flexibility and Employment. San Antonio: Principia Press of Trinity University.
Lawlor, Michael S. 2006. The Economics of Keynes in Historical Context: An Intellectual History of the General Theory. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Lendjel, Emeric. 2001. “Le tâtonnement marshallien dans les premiers écrits d’Oskar Lange.” Cahiers d’économie politique 38: 79134.
Lucas, Robert E. 2004. “Keynote Address to the 2003 HOPE Conference: My Keynesian Education.” History of Political Economy 36 (Annual Supplement): 1224.
Meade, James. E. 1937. “A Simplified Model of Mr Keynes’s System.” Review of Economic Studies 4 (2): 98107.
Modigliani, Franco. 1944. “Liquidity Preference and the Theory of Interest and Money.” Econometrica 12: 4588.
Parrinello, Sergio. 1985. “Le noyau marshallien de la Théorie générale.” In Barrère, A., ed., Keynes aujourd’hui: théories et politiques. Paris: Economica, pp. 421430.
Patinkin, Don. 1947. “On the Consistency of Economic Models: A Theory of Involuntary Unemployment.” PhD dissertation, University of Chicago.
Patinkin, Don. 1956. Money, Interest and Prices. Row, Evanston: Peterson and Company.
Patinkin, Don. 1991. “John Maynard Keynes.” In Eatwell, J., Milgate, M., and Newman, P., eds., The New Palgrave: A Dictionary of Economics. Volume 3. London: Macmillan, pp. 1941.
Patinkin, Don. 1995. “The Training of an Economist.” Banco Nazionale Del Lavoro Quarterly Review 195: 359395.
Ramrattan, Lall, and Szenberg, Michael. 2008. Franco Modigliani. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Reddaway, Brian W. 1936. “The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money.” Economic Record 12 (June): 4488.
Robinson, Joan [1954] 1982. “The Generalisation of the General Theory.” In The Rate of Interest and Other Essays. Westport: Hyperion Press, pp. 173.
Rubin, Goulven. 2004. “Patinkin on IS-LM: An Alternative to Modigliani.” History of Political Economy 36 (Annual Supplement): 5791.
Rubin, Goulven. 2005. “Patinkin and the Pigou Effect: Or How a Keynesian Came to Accept an Anti-Keynesian Argument.” The European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 12 (1): 4772.
Rubin, Goulven. 2008. “Patinkin’s Interpretation of Keynesian Economics: A Genetic Approach.” In Leeson, R., ed., Archival Insights into the Evolution of Economics. Volume 1, The Keynesian Tradition. New York: Routledge, pp. 99125.
Rubin, Goulven. 2011a. “Hicks et l’économie de la dépression.” Recherches Economiques de Louvain 77 (4): 5787.
Rubin, Goulven. 2011b. “Oskar Lange and the Influence of Walrasian Theory during the Keynesian Revolution.” HAL working papers, ESHET conference, Bogazici University. halshs-00817758.
Rubin, Goulven. 2012. “Don Patinkin’s PhD Dissertation as the Prehistory of Disequilibrium Theories.” History of Political Economy 44 (1): 235276.
Rymes, Thomas K. 1989. Keynes’s Lectures, 1932–35, Notes of a Representative Student. London: Macmillan.
Samuelson, Paul A. [1941a] 1966. “Professor Pigou’s Employment and Equilibrium.” In Stiglitz, J. E., ed., The Collected Scientific Papers of Paul A. Samuelson. Cambridge and London: The MIT Press, pp. 11831190.
Samuelson, Paul A. 1941b. “The Stability of Equilibrium: Comparative Statics and Dynamics.” Econometrica 9: 97120.
Samuelson, Paul A. [1942] 1966. “Fiscal Policy and Income Determination.” In Stiglitz, J. E., ed., The Collected Scientific Papers of Paul A. Samuelson. Cambridge and London: The MIT Press, pp. 11401170.
Samuelson, Paul A. 1947a. Foundations of Economic Analysis. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Samuelson, Paul A. 1947b. “The General Theory by Paul A. Samuelson.” In Harris, S., ed., The New Economics. London: Dennis Dobson LTD, pp. 145160.
Schefold, Bertram. 1997. Normal Prices, Technical Change and Accumulation. London: Macmillan.
Solow, Robert M. 1991. “Cowles and the Tradition of Macroeconomics.” In Arrow, K. J., Debreu, E., and Solow, R., Cowles Fiftieth Anniversary: Four Essays and an Index of Publication. New Haven, CT: Cowles Foundation for Research inEconomics at Yale University, pp. 81108.
Timlin, Mabel F. 1942. Keynesian Economics. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Timlin, Mabel F. 1946. “Price Flexibility and Employment. Review Article.” The Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science 12 (2): 204213.
Vaizey, John. 1977. “Keynes and Cambridge.” In Skidelsky, R., ed., The End of the Keynesian Era. London: Macmillan, pp. 1017.
Vercelli, Alessandro. 1999. “The Evolution of IS-LM Models: Empirical Evidence and Theoretical Presuppositions.” Journal of Economic Methodology 6 (2): 199219.
Vines, David. 1991. “Meade, James.” In Eatwell, J., Milgate, M., and Newman, P., eds., The New Palgrave: A Dictionary of Economics. Volume 3. London: Macmillan, pp. 410416.
Young, Warren. 1987. Interpreting Mr Keynes: The IS-LM Enigma. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO


  • Goulven Rubin (a1)


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.