Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

Disembodying cognition

  • Anjan Chatterjee (a1)
Abstract
Abstract

The idea that concepts are embodied by our motor and sensory systems is popular in current theorizing about cognition. Embodied cognition accounts come in different versions and are often contrasted with a purely symbolic amodal view of cognition. Simulation, or the hypothesis that concepts simulate the sensory and motor experience of real world encounters with instances of those concepts, has been prominent in psychology and cognitive neuroscience. Here, with a focus on spatial thought and language, I review some of the evidence cited in support of simulation versions of embodied cognition accounts. While these data are extremely interesting and many of the experiments are elegant, knowing how to best interpret the results is often far from clear. I point out that a quick acceptance of embodied accounts runs the danger of ignoring alternate hypotheses and not scrutinizing neuroscience data critically. I also review recent work from my lab that raises questions about the nature of sensory motor grounding in spatial thought and language. In my view, the question of whether or not cognition is grounded is more fruitfully replaced by questions about gradations in this grounding. A focus on disembodying cognition, or on graded grounding, opens the way to think about how humans abstract. Within neuroscience, I propose that three functional anatomic axes help frame questions about the graded nature of grounded cognition. First, are questions of laterality differences. Do association cortices in both hemispheres instantiate the same kind of sensory or motor information? Second, are questions about ventral dorsal axes. Do neuronal ensembles along this axis shift from conceptual representations of objects to the relationships between objects? Third, are questions about gradients centripetally from sensory and motor cortices towards and within perisylvian cortices. How does sensory and perceptual information become more language-like and then get transformed into language proper?

Copyright
Corresponding author
Correspondence addresses: Anjan Chatterjee, Department of Neurology and the Center for Cognitive Neuroscience, University of Pennsylvania, 3 West Gates, 3400 Spruce Street, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA. E-mail: anjan@mail.med.upenn.edu.
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

L. J. P. Altmann , A. Saleem , D. Kendall , K. M. Heilman & L. J. G. Rothi . 2006. Orthographic directionality and thematic role illustration in English and Arabic. Brain and Language 97(3). 306316.

L. W. Barsalou 1999. Perceptual symbol systems. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 22. 577660.

L. W. Barsalou 2007. Grounded cognition. Annual Review of Psychology 59(1). 617645.

M. Bedny , A. Caramazza , E. Grossman , A. Pascual-Leone & R. Saxe . 2008. Concepts are more than percepts: The case of action verbs. Journal of Neuroscience 28(44). 1134711353.

S. L. Beilock , I. M. Lyons , A. Mattarella-Micke , H. C. Nusbaum & S. L. Small . 2008. Sports experience changes the neural processing of action language. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 105. 1326913273.

R. S. Berndt , C. C. Mitchum , A. N. Haendiges & J. Sandson . 1997. Verb retrieval in aphasia: 2. Relationship to sentence processing. Brain and Language 56. 107137.

R. S. Berndt , A. N. Haendiges , C. C. Mitchum & J. Sandson . 1997. Verb retrieval in aphasia: 1. Characterizing single word impairments. Brain and Language 56. 68106.

J. R. Binder , C. F. Westbury , K. A. McKiernan , E. T. Possing & D. A. Medler . 2005. Distinct brain systems for processing concrete and abstract concepts. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 17. 905917.

A. M. Borghi , A. M. Glenberg & M. P. Kaschak . 2004. Putting words in perspective. Memory and Cognition 32(6). 863873.

I. Bornkessel , S. Zysset , A. D. Friederici , D. Y. von Cramon & M. Schlesewsky . 2005. Who did what to whom? The neural basis of argument hierarchies during language comprehension. Neuroimage 26(1). 221233.

D. N. Bub , M. E. J. Masson & G. S. Cree . 2008. Evocation of functional and volumetric gestural knowledge by objects and words. Cognition 106(1). 2758.

G. Buccino , F. Lui , N. Canessa , I. Patteri , G. Lagravinese , F. Benuzzi , C. A. Porro & G. Rizzolatti . 2004. Neural circuits involved in the recognition of actions performed by non-conspecifics: An fMRI study. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 16. 114126.

G. Buccino , L. Riggio , G. Melli , F. Binkofski , V. Gallese & G. Rizzolatti . 2005. Listening to action-related sentences modulates the activity of the motor system: A combined TMS and behavioral study. Cognitive Brain Research 24(3). 355363.

B. Calvo-Merino , D. E. Glaser & J. Grezes . 2005. Action observation and acquired motor skills: An fMRI study with expert dancers. Cerebral Cortex 15. 12431249.

D. Caplan 1995. Issues arising in contemporary studies of disorders of syntactic processing in sentence comprehension in agrammatic patients. Brain and Language 50. 325338.

S. F. Cappa , G. Binetti , A. Pezzini , A. Padovani , L. Rozzini & M. Trabucchi . 1998. Object and action naming in Alzheimer's disease and frontotemporal dementia. Neurology 50. 351355.

A. Caramazza & G. Miceli . 1991. Selective impairment of thematic role assignment in sentence processing. Brain and Language 41. 402436.

A. Chatterjee 2001. Language and space: Some interactions. Trends in Cognitive Science 5. 5561.

A. Chatterjee 2005. A madness to the methods in cognitive neuroscience? Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 17. 847849.

A. Chatterjee 2008. The neural organization of spatial thought and language. Seminars in Speech and Language 29. 226238.

A. Chatterjee , L. M. Maher , L. J. Gonzalez-Rothi & K. M. Heilman . 1995. Asyntactic thematic role assignment: The use of a temporal-spatial strategy. Brain and Language 49. 125139.

A. Chatterjee , L. M. Maher & K. M. Heilman . 1995. Spatial characteristics of thematic role representation. Neuropsychologia 33. 643648.

A. Chatterjee , M. H. Southwood & D. Basilico . 1999. Verbs, events and spatial representations. Neuropsychologia. 395402.

E. Chen , P. Widick & A. Chatterjee . 2008. Functional-anatomical organization of predicate metaphor processing. Brain and Language 107(3). 194202.

A. Clark 1999. An embodied cognitive science? Trends in Cognitive Sciences 3(9). 345351.

A. Damasio 1989. Time-locked multiregional retroactivation: A system level proposal for the neural substrates of recall and recognition. Cognition 33. 2562.

H. Damasio , T. J. Grabowski , D. Tranel , L. L. Ponto , R. D. Hichwa & A. R. Damasio . 2001. Neural correlates of naming actions and of naming spatial relations. Neuroimage 13 (6.1). 10531064.

J. Decety , J. Grezes , N. Costes , D. Perani , M. Jeannerod , E. Procyk , F. Grassi & F. Fazio . 1997. Brain activity during observation of actions. Influence of action content and subject strategy. Brain 120. 17631777.

S. Dehaene , S. Bossini & P. Giraux . 1993. The mental representation of parity and number magnitide. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 122. 371396.

G. Dove 2009. Beyond perceptual symbols: A call for representational pluralism. Cognition.

K. Emmorey , H. Damasio , S. McCullough , T. Grabowski , L. L. Ponto , R. D. Hichwa & U. Bellugi . 2002. Neural systems underlying spatial language in American Sign Language. Neuroimage 17(2). 812824.

R. Epstein & N. Kanwisher . 1998. A cortical representation of the local visual environment. Nature 392. 598601.

J. A. Fiez , M. E. Raichle , D. A. Balota , P. Tallal & S. E. Petersen . 1996. PET activation of posterior temporal regions during auditory word presentation and verb generation. Cerebral Cortex 6(1). 110.

M. H. Fischer & R. A. Zwaan . 2008. Embodied language: A review of the role of the motor system in language comprehension. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 61(6). 825850.

L. Fogassi , P. F. Ferrari , B. Gesierich , S. Rozzi , F. Chersi & G. Rizzolatti . 2005. Parietal lobe: From action organization to intention understanding. Science 308(5722). 662667.

A. Frederici 1982. Syntactic and semantic processing in aphasic deficits: The availability of prepositions. Brain and Language 15. 249258.

S. Gennari , S. A. Sloman , B. C. Malt & W. Fitch . 2002. Motion events in language and cognition. Cognition 83. 4979.

D. Gentner 1988. Metaphor as structure mapping: The relational shift. Child Development 59. 4759.

N. Geschwind 1965. Disconnexion syndromes in animals and man. Brain 88. 237–294, 585644.

R. W. Gibbs 1996. Why many concepts are metaphorical. Cognition 61. 309319.

R. W. Gibbs , P. L. Costa Lima & E. Francozo . 2004. Metaphor is grounded in embodied experience. Journal of Pragmatics 36(7). 11891210.

A. M. Glenberg & M. P. Kaschak . 2002. Grounding language in action. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review.

A. M. Glenberg & D. Robertson . 2000. Symbol grounding and meaning: A comparison of high-dimensional and embodied theories of meaning. Journal of Memory and Language 43. 379401.

A. M. Glenberg , M. Sato & L. Cattaneo . 2008. Use-induced motor plasticity afects the processing of abstract and concrete language. Current Biology 18(7). R290R291.

S. Glover , D. Rosenbaum , J. Graham & P. Dixon . 2004. Grasping the meaning of words. Experimental Brain Research 154(1). 103108.

G. Goldenberg 2003. Apraxia and beyond: Life and work of Hugo Liepmann. Cortex 39(3). 509524.

J. Grezes , P. Fonlupt , B. Bertenthal , D.-M. Chantal , C. Segebarth & J. Decety . 2001. Does perception of biological motion rely on specific brain regions? Neuroimage 13. 775785.

K. Grill-Spector & R. Malach . 2001. fMRI adaptation: A tool for studying the functional properties of human cortical neurons. Acta Psychologica 107. 293321.

E. D. Grossman & R. Blake . 2002. Brain areas active during visual perception of biological motion. Neuron 35. 11671175.

M. Grossman 1998. Not all words are created equal: Category-specific deficits in central nervous system disease. Neurology 50. 324325.

M. Grossman , C. Anderson , A. Khan , B. Avants , L. Elman & L. McCluskey . 2008. Impaired action knowledge in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Neurology 71(18). 13961401.

W. G. Hayward & M. J. Tarr . 1995. Spatial language and spatial representation. Cognition 55. 3984.

R. Jackendof 1987. On beyond zebra: The relation of linguistic and visual information. Cognition 26. 89114.

S. H. Johnson-Frey 2004. The neural bases of complex tool use in humans. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 8(2). 7178.

J. W. Kable & A. Chatterjee . 2006. The specificity of action representations in lateral occipitotemporal cortex. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 18. 14981517.

J. W. Kable , I. Kan , A. Wilson , S. Thompson-Schill & A. Chatterjee . 2005. Conceptual representations of action in lateral temporal cortex. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 17. 18551870.

J. W. Kable , J. Lease-Spellmeyer & A. Chatterjee . 2002. Neural substrates of action event knowledge. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 14. 795804.

N. Kanwisher , R. P. Woods , M. Iacoboni & J. C. Mazziotta . 1997. A locus in human extrastriate cortex for visual shape analysis. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 9. 33142.

M. P. Kaschak , C. J. Madden & D. J. Therriault . 2005. Perception of motion afects language processing. Cognition 94. 7989.

J. Kegl 1995. Levels of representation and units of access relevant to agrammatism. Brain and Language 50. 151200.

D. Kemmerer 2006. The semantics of space: Integrating linguistic typology and cognitive neuroscience. Neuropsychologia 44. 16071621.

D. Kemmerer , J. G. Castillo , T. Talavage , S. Patterson & C. Wiley . 2008. Neuroanatomical distribution of five semantic components of verbs: Evidence from fMRI. Brain and Language 107(1). 1643.

K. A. Kiehl , P. F. Liddle , A. M. Smith , A. Mendrek , B. B. Forster & R. D. Hare . 1999. Neural pathways involved in the processing of concrete and abstract words. Human Brain Mapping 7. 225233.

M. Kinsbourne 1987. Mechanisms of unilateral neglect. In M. Jeannerod (ed.), Neurophy-siological and neuropsychological aspects of spatial neglect, 6986. New York: North-Holland.

Z. Kourtzi & N. Kanwisher . 2000. Activation in human MT/MST by static images with implied motion. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 12. 4855.

G. Lakoff 1987. Women, fire and dangerous things. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

G. Lakoff 1990. The invariance hypothesis: Is abstract reason based on image-schemas? Cognitive Linguistics 1. 3974.

B. Landau & R. Jackendoff . 1993. ‘What’ and ‘where’ in spatial language and spatial cognition. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 16. 217265.

S. C. Levinson 1996. Language and space. Annual Review of Anthropology 25. 353382.

Y. Li , S. D. Van Hooser , M. Mazurek , L. E. White & D. Fitzpatrick . 2008. Experience with moving visual stimuli drives the early development of cortical direction selectivity. Nature 456(7224). 952956.

H. Lissauer 1890. Ein Fall von Seelenblindheit Nebst Einem Beitrage zur Theori derselben. Archiv fur Psychiatrie und Nervenkrankheiten 21. 222270.

A. Maass , D. Pagani & E. Berta . 2007. How beautiful is the goal and how violent is the fistfight? Spatial bias in the interpretation of human behavior. Social Cognition 25(6). 833852.

A. Maass & A. Russo . 2003. Directional bias in the mental representation of spatial events: Nature or culture? Psychological Science 14. 296301.

L. Maher , A. Chatterjee , L. Gonzalez-Rothi & K. Heilman . 1995. Agrammatic sentence production: The use of a temporal-spatial strategy. Brain and Language 49. 105124.

B. Z. Mahon & A. Caramazza . 2008. A critical look at the embodied cognition hypothesis and a new proposal for grounding conceptual content. Journal of Physiology-Paris 102. 5970.

R. Malach , J. Reppas , R. Benson , K. Kwong , H. Jiang , W. Kennedy , P. Ledden , T. Brady , B. Rosen & R. Tootell . 1995. Object related activity revealed by functional magnetic resonance imaging in human occipital cortex. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 92. 81358139.

J. Marshall , S. Chiat & T. Pring . 1998. Verb retrieval and sentence production in aphasia. Brain and Language 63. 159183.

A. Martin , J. V. Haxby , F. M. Lalonde , C. L. Wiggs & L. G. Ungerleider . 1995. Discrete cortical regions associated with knowledge of color and knowledge of action. Science 270. 102105.

A. Martin & J. Weisberg . 2003. Neural foundations for understanding social and mechanical concepts. Cognitive Neuropsychology 20. 575587.

T. Matlock 2004. Fictive motion as cognitive simulation. Memory andCognition 32. 13891400.

M.-M. Mesulam 1998. From sensation to cognition. Brain 121. 10131052.

L. Meteyard , B. Bahrami & G. Vigliocco . 2007. Motion detection and motion verbs. Psychological Science. 18(11). 10071013.

L. Meteyard , N. Zokaei , B. Bahrami & G. Vigliocco . 2008. Visual motion interferes with lexical decision on motion words. Current Biology 18(17). R732R733.

G. Miceli , M. C. Silveri , G. Villa & A. Caramazza . 1984. On the basis for the agrammatics difficulty in producing main verbs. Cortex 20. 207220.

V. Moro , C. Urgesi , S. Pernigo , P. Lanteri , M. Pazzaglia & S. M. Aglioti . 2008. The neural basis of body form and body action agnosia. Neuron 60(2). 235246.

G. L. Murphy 1996. On metaphoric representation. Cognition 60. 173204.

I. Nachson , E. Argaman & A. Luria . 1999. Effects of directional habits and handedness on aesthetic preference for left and right profiles. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 30. 106114.

G. A. L. Negri , R. I. Rumiati , A. Zadini , M. Ukmar , B. Z. Mahon & A. Caramazza . 2007. What is the role of motor simulation in action and object recognition? Evidence from apraxia. Cognitive Neuropsychology 24(8). 795816.

B. Neininger & F. Pulvermüller . 2003. Word-category specific deficits after lesions in the right hemisphere. Neuropsychologia 41(1). 5370.

M. W. Oram & D. I. Perrett . 1994. Responses of anterior superior temporal polysensory (STPa) neurons to ‘biological motion’ stimuli. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 6. 99116.

A. Paivio 1990. Mental representations: A dual coding approach. New York: Oxford University Press.

A. Papafragou , C. Massey & L. Gleitman . 2002. Shake, rattle, ‘n’ roll: The representation of motion in language and cognition. Cognition 84. 189212.

M. Pazzaglia , N. Smania , E. Corato & S. M. Aglioti . 2008. Neural underpinnings of gesture discrimination in patients with limb apraxia. Journal of Neuroscience 28(12). 30303041.

M. V. Peelen & P. E. Downing . 2007. The neural basis of visual body perception. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 8(8). 636648.

D. Perani , S. Cappa , M. Schnur , M. Tettamanti , S. Collina & M. Rosa . 1999. The neural correlates of verb and noun processing: A PET study. Brain 122. 23372344.

K. Pirog Revill , R. N. Aslin , M. K. Tanenhaus & D. Bavelier . 2008. Neural correlates of partial lexical activation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 105(35). 1311113115.

F. Pulvermüller , O. Hauk & V. V. Nikulin . 2005. Functional links between motor and language systems. European Journal of Neuroscience 21. 793797.

A. M. Rapp , D. T. Leube , W. Grodd & T. T. J. Kircher . 2004. Neural correlates of metaphor processing. Cognitive Brain Research 20. 395402.

T. Regier 1995. A model of human capacity for categorizing spatial relations. Cognitive Linguistics 6. 6388.

D. Richardson , M. Spivey , L. Barsalou & K. McRae . 2003. Spatial representations activated during real-time comprehension of verbs. Cognitive science 27. 768780.

G. Rizzolatti & L. Craighero . 2004. The mirror-neuron system. Annual Review of Neuro-science 27. 169192.

L. J. G. Rothi , C. Ochipa & K. M. Heilman . 1991. A cognitive neuropsychological model of limb praxis. Cognitive Neuropsychology 8(6). 443458.

E. M. Saffran , M. F. Schwartz & O. S. M. Marin . 1980. The word order problem in agrammatism. II. Production. Brain and Language 10. 263280.

M. F. Schwartz , E. M. Saffran & O. S. M. Marin . 1980. The word order problem in agram-matism. I. Comprehension. Brain and Language 10. 249262.

A. Serino , L. De Filippo , C. Casavecchia , M. Coccia , M. Shiffrar & E. Ladavas . 2009. Lesions to the motor system afect action perception. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience. 22(3). 413426.

L. P. Shapiro & B. A. Levine . 1990. Verb processing during sentence comprehension in aphasia. Brain Language 38. 2147.

E. Shetreet , D. Palti & N. Friedmann , U. Hadar . 2007. Cortical representation of verb processing in sentence comprehension: Number of complements, subcategorization, and thematic frames. Cerebral Cortex 17(8). 19581969.

W. K. Simmons & L. W. Barsalou . 2003. The similarity-in-topography principle: Reconciling theories of conceptual deficits. Cognitive Neuropsychology 20. 451486.

J. S. Simons , W. Koutstaal , S. Prince , A. D. Wagner & D. L. Schacter . 2003. Neural mechanisms of visual object priming: Evidence for perceptual and semantic distinctions in fusiform cortex. NeuroImage 19. 613626.

R. Stanfield & R. Zwaan . 2001. The effect of implied orientation derived from verbal context on picture recognition. Psychological Science 12. 153156.

E. Sweetser 1990. From etymology to pragmatics: The mind-body metaphor in semantic structure and semantic change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

E. Symes , R. Ellis & M. Tucker . 2007. Visual object affordances: Object orientation. Acta Psychologica 124(2). 238255.

L. Talmy 1983. How language structures space. In H. Pick & L. Acredolo (eds.), Spatial orientation: Theory, research and application, 225282. New York: Plenum Press.

M. K. Tanenhaus , M. J. Spivey-Knowlton , K. M. Eberhard & J. C. Sedivy . 1995. Integration of visual and linguistic information in spoken language comprehension. Science 268. 16321634.

M. Tettamanti , G. Buccino , M. Saccuman , V. Gallese , M. Danna , P. Scifo , F. Fazio , G. Rizzolatti , S. F. Cappa & D. Perani . 2005. Listening to action-related sentences activates fronto-parietal motor circuits. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 17(2). 273281.

D. Tranel & D. Kemmerer . 2004. Neuroanatomical correlates of locative prepositions. Cognitive Neuropsychology 21. 719749.

M. Tucker & R. Ellis . 2004. Action priming by briefly presented objects. Acta Psychologica 116(2). 185203.

B. Tversky , S. Kugelmass & A. Winter . 1991. Cross-cultural and developmental trends in graphic productions. Cognitive Psychology 23. 515557.

C. Urgesi , V. Moro , M. Candidi & S. M. Aglioti . 2006. Mapping implied body actions in the human motor system. Journal of Neuroscience 26(30). 79427949.

M. Wallentin , S. Ostergaard , T. Lund , L. Ostergaard & A. Roepstorff . 2005. Concrete spatial language: See what I mean? Brain and Language 92. 221233.

E. Warburton , R. J. S. Wise , C. J. Price , C. Weiller , U. Hadar , S. Ramsay & R. S. J. Frackowiak . 1996. Noun and verb retrieval by normal subjects. Studies with PET. Brain 119. 159179.

E. K. Warrington & T. Shallice . 1984. Category specific semantic impairments. Brain 107. 829854.

M. Weliky , W. H. Bosking & D. Fitzpatrick . 1996. A systematic map of direction preference in primary visual cortex. Nature 379(6567). 725728.

M. Wilson 2002. Six views of embodied cognition. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 9(4). 625636.

R. J. Wise , D. Howard , C. J. Mummery , P. Fletcher , A. Lef , C. Buchel & S. K. Scott . 2000. Noun imageability and the temporal lobes. Neuropsychologia 38. 985994.

D. H. Wu , A. Morganti & A. Chatterjee . 2008. Neural substrates of processing path and manner information of a moving event. Neuropsychologia 46. 704713.

D. H. Wu , S. Waller & A. Chatterjee . 2007. The functional neuroanatomy of thematic role and locative relational knowledge. The Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 19. 15421555.

L. B. Zingeser & R. S. Berndt . 1990. Retrieval of nouns and verbs in agrammatism and anomia. Brain and Language 39. 1432.

R. A. Zwaan & L. J. Taylor . 2006. Seeing, acting, understanding: Motor resonance in language comprehension. Journal of Experimental Psychology-General 135. 111.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Language and Cognition
  • ISSN: 1866-9808
  • EISSN: 1866-9859
  • URL: /core/journals/language-and-cognition
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 84 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 409 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 24th September 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.