Skip to main content

Lexical contrast maintenance and the organization of sublexical contrast systems

  • Andrew Wedel (a1)

Variationist/evolutionary models of phonology assume a causal chain that links biases at the utterance level to the development and consolidation of abstract phonological patterns over time. Some of the properties of linguistic cognition that have been proposed to underlie this chain are (i) storage of experienced detail at multiple levels of description, (ii) feedback between perception and production, (iii) a similarity bias in the production and perception of variation, and (iv) enhancement of cues to potentially ambiguous lexical items in usage. I review evidence for these properties and argue that they interact to provide a pathway for individual usage events to influence the evolution of contrastive sublexcal category systems, i.e phoneme inventories. Specifically, the proposed Network-Feedback model predicts that the organization of sublexical category systems is shaped by a conflict between a general drive toward greater similarity among sublexical categories on the one hand, and a bias toward maintaining contrast between tokens of competing lexical categories on the other. The model provides testable hypotheses about the conditions favoring phoneme merger, chain-shifts, and phonemic splits, and more generally about the influence of lexical contrast on the packing of sublexical categories along gestural/perceptual dimensions. Finally, this pathway of change is consistent with proposals that sublexical categories such as features and segments are not primitives of language, but emerge through more general properties of performance, perception, categorization and learning.

Hide All
Aylett, M. & Turk, A.. 2004. The smooth signal redundancy hypothesis: A functional explanation for relationships between redundancy, prosodic prominence, and duration in spontaneous speech. Language and Speech 47. 3156.
Baayen, R. H. 2007. Storage and computation in the mental lexicon. In Jarema, G. & Libben, G. (eds.), The mental lexicon: Core perspectives, 81104. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Baese, M. & Goldrick, M.. 2009. Mechanisms of interaction in speech production. Language and cognitive processes 24. 527554.
Barr, D. J. 2004. Establishing a conventional communication system: Is common knowledge necessary? Cognitive Science 28. 937–62.
Baudoin de Courtenay, J. 1895. Versuch einer Theorie phonetischer Alternationen: ein Capitel aus der Psychophonetik. Strassburg, Germany/Crakow, Poland: Trübner. [English translation (‘An attempt at a theory of phonetic alternations’). Published in E. Stankiewicz (ed.) 1972, A Baudouin de Courtenay anthology: The beginnings of structural linguistics, 144-212. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
Beckner, C., Blythe, R., Bybee, J., Christiansen, M. H., Croft, W., Ellis, N. C., Holland, J., Ke, J., Larsen-Freeman, D. & Schoenemann, T.. 2009. Language is a complex adaptive system. Language Learning 59. 4S1.
Beddor, P. S. 2009. A coarticulatory path to sound change. Language 85(4). 785821.
Blevins, J. 2004. Evolutionary phonology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Blevins, J. 2009. Structure-preserving sound change: A look at unstressed vowel syncope in Austronesian. In Adelaar, A. & Pawley, A. (eds.), Austronesian historical linguistics and culture history: A festschrift for Bob Blust, 3349. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.
Blevins, J. & Wedel, A.. 2009. Inhibited sound change: An evolutionary approach to lexical competition. Diachronica 26. 143183.
Brighton, H., Kirby, S. & Smith, K.. 2005. Cultural selection for learnability: Three principles underlying the view that language adapts to be learnable. In Tallerman, M. (ed.), Language origins: Perspectives on evolution, 291309. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Bybee, J. 2001. Phonology and language use. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bybee, J. 2002a. Word frequency and context of use in the lexical diffusion of phonetically conditioned sound change. Language Variation and Change 14. 261290.
Bybee, J. 2002b. Phonological evidence for exemplar storage of multiword sequences. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 24. 215221.
Bybee, J. & McClelland, J. L.. 2005. Alternatives to the combinatorial paradigm of linguistic theory based on domain general principles of human cognition. The Linguistic Review 22. 381410.
Christiansen, M. H. & Chater, N.. 2008. Language as shaped by the brain. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 31(5). 489509.
Cornish, H., Tamariz, M. & Kirby, S.. 2009. Complex adaptive systems and the origins of adaptive structure: What experiments can tell us. Language Learning 59(s1). 187205.
Currie-Hall, K. 2009. A probabilistic model of phonological relationships from contrast to allophony. The Ohio State University doctoral dissertation.
de Boer, B. 2001. The origins of vowel systems. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
de Boer, B. 2006. Computer modelling as a tool for understanding language evolution. In Gontier, N., Bendegem, J. P. Van & Aerts, D. (eds.), Evolutionary epistemology, language and culture, 381406. Dordrecht: Springer.
Dell, G. S. 1986. A spreading-activation theory of retrieval in sentence production. Psychological Review 93. 283321.
Elman, J. L. 1995. Language as a dynamical system. In Port, R. & van Gelder, T. (eds.), Mind as motion: Dynamical perspectives on behavior and cognition, 195223. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Ernestus, M. 2011. Gradience and categoricality in phonological theory. In Oostendorp, M. Van, Ewen, C. J., Hume, E. & Rice, K. (eds.), The Blackwell companion to phonology, 21152136. Oxford: Blackwell.
Ettlinger, M. 2007. Shifting categories: An exemplar-based computational model of chain shiftsProceedings of the 29th Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society, 239244. Austin, TX: Cognitive Science Society.
Frisch, S. 1996. Similarity and frequency in phonology. Chicago: Northwestern University doctoral dissertation.
Ganong, W. F. 1980. Phonetic categorization in auditory word perception. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance 6. 110125.
Gessner, S. & Hansson, G.. 2004. Anti-homophony effects in Dakelh (Carrier) valence morphology. In Ettlinger, M., Fleischer, N. & Park-Doob, M. (eds.), BLS 30: Proceedings of Berkeley Linguistic Society, 93104. Berkeley: Berkeley Linguistics Society.
Gilliéron, J. 1918. Généalogie des mots qui désignent l'abeille d'après l'atlas linguistique de la France. Paris: E. Champion.
Goldinger, S. D. 2000. The role of perceptual episodes in lexical processing. In Cutler, A., McQueen, J. M. & Zondervan, R. (eds.), Proceedings of SWAP (Spoken Word Access Processes), 155158. Nijmegen: Max-Planck-Institute for Psycholinguistics.
Gordon, M. J. 2002. Investigating chain shifts and mergers. In Chambers, J. K., Trudgill, P. & Schilling-Estes, N. (eds.), Handbook of language variation and change, 244266. Oxford: Blackwell.
Griffiths, T. L. & Kalish, M. L.. 2007. Language evolution by iterated learning with Bayesian agents. Cognitive Science 31. 441480.
Guenther, F. H. & Gjaja, M. N.. 1996. The perceptual magnet effect as an emergent property of neural map formation. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 100. 11111121.
Hare, M. & Elman, J. L.. 1995. Learning and morphological change. Cognition 56. 6198.
Harrington, J., Palethorpe, S. & Watson, C. I.. 2000. Does the Queen speak the Queen's English? Nature 408. 927928.
Hay, J. & Maclagan, M.. 2012. /r/-sandhi in early 20th Century New Zealand English. Linguistics 50. 745763.
Hintzman, D. 1986. “Schema abstraction” in a multiple-trace memory model. Psychological Review 93. 411428.
Hockett, C. 1960. The origin of speech. Scientific American 203. 8996.
Hockett, C. 1967. The quantification of functional load. Word 23. 320339.
Hombert, J.-M., Ohala, J. J. & Ewan, W. G.. 1979. Phonetic explanations for the development of tones. Language 55. 3758.
Hume, E. & Johnson, K.. 2001. A model of the interplay of speech perception and phonology. In Hume, & Johnson, (eds.), The role of speech perception in phonology, 326. New York: Academic Press.
Joanisse, M. F. & Seidenberg, M. S.. 1997. [i e a u] and sometimes [o]: Perceptual and computational constraints on vowel inventories. In Shafto, M. & Langley, P. (eds.), Proceedings of the 19th Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society, 331336. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Johnson, K. 1997. Speech perception without speaker normalization. In Johnson, K. & Mullennix, J. W. (eds.), Talker variability in speech processing, 145166. San Diego: Academic Press.
Ju, M. & Luce, P. A.. 2006. Representational specificity of within-category phonetic variation in the long-term mental lexicon. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance 32. 120138.
Kaplan, A. 2011. How much homophony is normal? Journal of Linguistics 47(3). 631671.
Kenstowicz, M. 1994. Phonology in generative grammar. Oxford: Blackwell.
King, R. 1967. Functional load and sound change. Language 43. 831852.
Kirby, S. 1999. Function, selection and innateness: The emergence of language universals. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kraljic, T. & Samuel, A.. 2005a. Generalization in perceptual learning for speech. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 13. 262268.
Kraljic, T. & Samuel, A.. 2005b. Perceptual learning for speech: Is there a return to normal? Cognitive Psychology 51(2). 141178.
Kuhl, P. K. 1991. Human adults and human infants show a ‘perceptual magnet effect’ for the prototypes of speech categories, monkeys do not. Perception and Psychophysics 50. 93107.
Labov, W. 1994. Principles of linguistic change, Volume 1, Internal Factors. Oxford: Blackwell.
Labov, W. 2001. Principles of linguistic change, Volume 2, External Factors. Oxford: Blackwell.
Labov, W., Ash, S. & Boberg, C.. 2006. Atlas of North American English: Phonetics, phonology, and sound change. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Labov, W. & Baranowski, M.. 2006. 50 milliseconds. Language Variation and Change 18. 118.
Lindblom, B. 1990. Explaining phonetic variation: A sketch of the H and H theory. In Hardcastle, W. & Marchal, A. (eds.), Speech production and speech modeling, 403439. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Lindblom, B., MacNeilage, P. & Studdert-Kennedy, M.. 1984. Self-organizing processes and the explanation of language universals. In Butterworth, B., Comrie, B. & Dahl, Ö. (eds.), Explanations for language universals, 181203. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Luce, P. A. & Pisoni, D. B.. 1998. Recognizing spoken words: The neighborhood activation model. Ear and Hearing 19. 136.
Maclagan, M. & Hay, J.. 2007. Getting fed up with our feet: Contrast maintenance and the New Zealand English ‘short’ front vowel shift. Language Variation and Change 19(1). 125.
Maddieson, I. 1984. Patterns of sounds. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Martinet, A. 1952. Function, structure, and sound change. Word 8(1). 132.
Martinet, A. 1960. Éléments de linguistique générale. Paris: Armand Colin.
McMillan, C. T. & Corley, M.. 2010. Cascading influences on the production of speech: Evidence from articulation. Cognition 117. 243260.
McMurray, B., Tanenhaus, M. & Aslin, R.. 2002. Gradient effects of within-category phonetic variation on lexical access. Cognition 86. B33B42.
Mielke, J. 2008. The emergence of distinctive features. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Munson, B. 2007. Lexical access, lexical representation, and vowel production. In Cole, J. S. & Hualde, J. I. (eds.), Laboratory phonology IX, 201228. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Munson, B. & Solomon, N. P.. 2004. The effect of phonological neighborhood density on vowel articulation. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research 47. 10481058.
Nielsen, K. 2007. The interaction between spontaneous imitation and linguistic knowledge. UCLA Working Papers in Phonetics 105. 125137.
Norris, D., McQueen, J. M. & Cutler, A.. 2003. Perceptual learning in speech. Cognitive Psychology 47. 204238.
Nosofsky, R. 1988. Similarity, frequency, and category representations. Journal of Experimental Psychology, Learning, Memory and Cognition 14. 5465.
Ohala, J. 1989. Sound change is drawn from a pool of synchronic variation. In Breivik, L. E. & Jahr, E. H. (eds.), Language change: Contributions to the study of its causes. [Series: Trends in Linguistics, Studies and Monographs No. 43], 173198. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Oudeyer, P.-I. 2002. Phonemic coding might be a result of sensory-motor coupling dynamics. In Hallam, B., Floreano, D., Hallam, J., Hayes, G. & Meyer, J.-A. (eds.), Proceedings of the 7th international conference on the simulation of adaptive behavior, 406416. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Pardo, J. S. 2006. On phonetic convergence during conversational interaction. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 119. 23822393.
Phillips, B. S. 2006. Word frequency and lexical diffusion. Bastingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Pierrehumbert, J. 2001. Exemplar dynamics: Word frequency, lenition, and contrast. In Bybee, J. & Hopper, P. (eds.), Frequency effects and the emergence of linguistic structure, 137157. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Pierrehumbert, J. 2002. Word-specific phonetics. In Gussenhoven, C. & Warner, N. (eds.), Laboratory phonology 7, 101139. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Pierrehumbert, J. 2003. Phonetic diversity, statistical learning, and acquisition of phonology. Language and Speech 46. 115154.
Pierrehumbert, J. 2006. The new toolkit. Journal of Phonetics 34. 516530.
Pisoni, D. B. & Levi, S. V.. 2007. Some observations on representations and representational specificity in speech perception and spoken word recognition. In Gaskell, G. (ed.), The Oxford handbook of psycholinguistics, 318. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Purnell, T., Salmons, J. & Tepeli, D.. 2005. German substrate effects in Wisconsin English: Evidence for final fortition. American Speech 80. 135164.
Raphael, L. 1971. Preceding vowel duration as a cue to the voicing characteristic of word-final consonants in American English. Journal of the American Acoustical Society 51. 12961303.
Repp, B. H. 1982. Phonetic trading relations and context effects: New experimental evidence for a speech mode of perception. Psychological Bulletin 92. 81110.
Sanchez, K. 2011. Do you hear what i see? The voice and face of a talker similarly influence the speech of multiple listeners. University of California at Riverside Doctoral dissertation.
Sancier, M. L. & Fowler, C. A.. 1997. Gestural drift in a bilingual speaker of Brazilian Portuguese and English. Journal of Phonetics 25. 421436.
Sandler, W., Aronoff, M., Meir, I. & Padden, C.. 2011. The gradual emergence of phonological form in a new language. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 29. 503543.
Scarborough, R. A. 2004. Coarticulation and the structure of the lexicon. University of California Los Angeles Doctoral dissertation.
Scarborough, R. A. 2010. Lexical and contextual predictability: Confluent effects on the production of vowels. Papers in Laboratory Phonology 10. 557586.
Shannon, C. 1948. A mathematical theory of communication. Bell System Technical Journal 27. 379–423, 623656.
Shattuck-Hufnagel, S. & Klatt, D. H.. 1979. The limited use of distinctive features and markedness in speech production: Evidence from speech error data. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 18. 4155.
Silverman, D. 2010. Neutralization and anti-homophony in Korean. Journal of Linguistics 46(2). 453482.
Smith, K., Kirby, S. & Brighton, H.. 2003. Iterative learning: A framework for the emergence of language. Artificial Life 9. 371386.
Studdert-Kennedy, M. & Goldstein, L.. 2003. Launching language: The gestural origin of discrete infinity. In Christiansen, M. H. & Kirby, S. (eds.), Language evolution: The state of the art, 235254. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Surendran, D. & Niyogi, P.. 2006. Quantifying the functional load of phonemic oppositions, distinctive features, and suprasegmentals. In Thomsen, O. Nedergaard (ed.), Competing models of language change: Evolution and beyond, 4358. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Trubetzkoy, N. 1939. Grundzüge der Phonologie. Prague: Travaux du cercle linguistique de Prague.
van Son, R. J. J. H. & Pols, L. C. W.. 2003. How efficient is speech? Paper presented at the Proceedings of the Institute of Phonetic Sciences, Amsterdam.
Verhoef, T. & de Boer, B.. 2011. Cultural emergence of feature economy in an artificial whistled language. In Zee, E. & Lee, W. (eds.), The 17th international congress of phonetic sciences: Hong Kong, China, Augustus 17–21, 2011: Congress proceedings, 20662069. Hong Kong: City University of Hong Kong.
Walker, A. & Hay, J.. 2011. Congruence between ‘word age’ and ‘voice age’ facilitates lexical access. Laboratory Phonology 2(1). 219237.
Walsh, M., Möbius, B., Wade, T. & Schütze, H.. 2010. Multilevel exemplar theory. Cognitive Science 34. 537582.
Wang, W. S.-Y. 1969. Competing changes as a cause of residue. Language 45. 925.
Wedel, A. 2004a. Self-organization and categorical behavior in phonology. University of California Santa Cruz doctoral dissertation.
Wedel, A. 2004b. Category competition drives contrast maintenance within an exemplar-based production/perception loop. In Goldsmith, J. & Wicentowski, R. (eds.), Proceedings of the seventh meeting of the ACL special interest group in computational phonology, 110. Barcelona: Association for Computational Linguistics.
Wedel, A. 2006. Exemplar models, evolution and language change. The Linguistic Review 23. 247274.
Wedel, A. 2007. Feedback and regularity in the lexicon. Phonology 24. 147185.
Wedel, A. 2009. Variation, multi-level selection and conflicts between phonological and morphological regularities. In Blevins, J. & Blevins, J. (eds.), Analogy in grammar: Form and acquisition, 83100. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Wedel, A. 2011. Self-organization phonology. In Oostendorp, M. Van, Ewen, C. J., Hume, E. & Rice, K. (eds.), The Blackwell companion to phonology, 130147. Oxford: Blackwell.
Wedel, A., Jackson, S. & Kaplan, A.. In press. Functional load and the lexicon: Evidence that syntactic category and frequency relationships in minimal lemma pairs predict the loss of phoneme contrasts. Language and Speech.
Whalen, D. H. 1981. Effects of vocalic formant transitions and vowel quality on the English [s]-[∫] boundary. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 69. 275282.
Whalen, D. H., Abramson, A. S., Lisker, L. & Mody, M.. 1993. F0 gives voicing information even with unambiguous voice onset times. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 47. 3649.
Wright, R. 2004. Factors of lexical competition in vowel articulation. In Local, J. J., Ogden, R. & Temple, R. (eds.), Laboratory phonology, Volume 6, 2650. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wright, R. & Frisch, S.. 2002. The phonetics of phonological speech errors: An acoustic analysis of slips of the tongue. Journal of Phonetics 30. 139162.
Yao, Y. 2009. Effect of phonological neighborhood density on word duration in spontaneous speech. Paper presented at the Fall Meeting of the Acoustical Society of America.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Language and Cognition
  • ISSN: 1866-9808
  • EISSN: 1866-9859
  • URL: /core/journals/language-and-cognition
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 1
Total number of PDF views: 54 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 176 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 26th May 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.