Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

How children start arguments*

  • Douglas W. Maynard (a1)

Previous research on children's arguments has neglected their initial phases, particularly how they arise out of children's ongoing practical activities. This paper examines how any utterance or activity can be opposed, the concept of opposition being at the center of any definition of argument. However, once opposition has occurred, it can be treated in a variety of ways, and a full-blown argument or dispute is only one possible and contingent outcome. Children analyze others's moves not only verbally, but nonverbally as well. Thus, bodily actions and presupposition are necessary components in the analysis of how arguments are started. Nonverbal oppositional moves may be at the base of semantically constructed disputes. When opposition occurs, it is to be taken to imply the violation of some rule or value. The meaning of that rule or value relative to children's culture is taken to have to do not with its content, but its usage in promoting a local social organization. (Conversational analysis, child language, social organization, presupposition, dispute genres, American English [middle class, Caucasian])

Hide All
Boggs S. T. (1978). The development of verbal disputing in part-Hawaiian children. Language in Society 7:325–44.
Brenneis D., & Lein L.. (1977). You fruithead: A sociolinguistic approach to dispute settlement. In S. Ervin-Tripp & C. Mitchell-Kernan (1977). 49–65.
Button G., & Casey N. (1981). Topic nomination. Unpublished ms. Devon. England: Plymouth Polytechnic.
Churchill L. (1978). Questioning strategies in sociolinguistics. Rowley. Mass.: Newbury House.
Cook-Gumperz J. (1981). Persuasive talk — The social organization of children's talk. In Green S. L. & Wallat C. (eds.). Ethnography and language in educational settings. Norwood, N.J.: Ablex. 2550.
Corsaro W. A. (1979). Young children's conception of status and role. Sociology of Education 53:4659.
Coulter J. (1979). Beliefs and practical understanding. In Psathas G. (ed), Everyday language: Studies in ethnomethodology. New York: Irvington. 163–86.
Eisenberg A., & Garvey C. (1981). Children's use of verbal strategies in resolving conflicts. Discourse Processes 4: 149–70.
Ervin-Tripp S. (1976). Is Sybil there? The structure of some American English directives. Language in Society 5:2566.
Ervin-Tripp S. (1977). Wait for me, roller skate! In S. Ervin-Tripp & C. Mitchell-Kernan (1977). 165–88.
Ervin-Tripp S. (1982). Structures of control. In Wilkinson L. C. (ed.), Communicating in the classroom. New York: Academic. 2747.
Ervin-Tripp S., & Mitchell-Kernan C. (eds.) (1977). Child discourse. New York: Academic.
Felstiner W. L. F., Abel R. L., & Sarat A. (1981). The emergence and transformation of disputes: Naming, blaming, claiming … Law and Society Review 15(3/4):631–54.
Fillmore C. J. (1972). Subjects, speakers and roles. In Davidson D. & Harman G. (ed.), Semantics of natural language. Dordrecht, Holland: D. Reidel. 124.
Fine G. A. (1979). Small groups and culture creation. American Sociological Review 44(5):733–45.
Fitzgerald J., & Dickins R. (1981). Disputing in legal and nonlegal contexts: Some questions for sociologists of law. Law and Society Review. 15(3/4):681706.
Garfinkel H. (1967). Studies in ethnomethodology. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.
Genishi C., & DiPaolo M. (1982). Learning through argument in a preschool. In Wilkinson L. C. (ed.). Communicating in the classroom. New York: Academic. 4968.
Goffman E. (1963). Stigma: Notes on the management of spoiled identity. Englewood Cliffs. N.J.: Prentice-Hall.
Goffman E. (1967). Interaction ritual. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday.
Goffman E. (1974). Frame analysis. New York: Harper & Row.
Goffman E. (1976). Replies and responses. Language in Society, 5:257313.
Goffman E. (1981). Forms of talk. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Goffman E. (1983). Felicity's condition. American Journal of Sociology 89(1): 153.
Goodwin C. (1981). Conversational organization: Interaction between speakers and hearers. New York: Academic.
Goodwin M. H. (1980). He-said-she-said: Formal cultural procedures for the construction of a gossip dispute activity. American Ethnologist 7(4):674–95.
Goodwin M. H. (1982a). Processes of dispute management among urban Black children. American Ethnologist 9(1 ):7696.
Goodwin M. H. ( 1982b). “Instigating” Storytelling as social process. American Ethnologist 9(4):799–89.
Goodwin M. H. (1983). Aggravated correction and disagreement in children's conversation. Journal of Pragniatics VII(6).
Grimshaw A. (1980). Mishearings, misunderstandings, and other non-successes in talk: A plea for redress of speaker oriented bias. Sociological Inquiry 50 (3/4):3174.
Hilbert R. A. (1981). Toward an improved understanding of “role” Theory and Society 10 (2):207–26.
Hopper R. (1981). The taken-for-granted. Human Communication Research 7(3):195211.
Hymes D. 1974 Foundations in sociolinguistics: An ethnographic approach. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Jefferson G. (1974). Error correction as an interactional resource. Language in Society 3:181–99.
Jefferson G. (1979). A technique for inviting laughter and its subsequent acceptance inclination. In Psathas G. (ed.) Everyday language: Studies in ethnomethodology. New York: lrvington. 7996.
Karttunen L. & Peters S. (1979). Conventional implicature. In Oh C. & Dinneen D. A. (eds.), Syntax and semantics: Presupposition. New York: Academic. 156.
Kochman T. (1983). The boundary between play and nonplay in black verbal dueling. Language in Society 12:329–37.
Labov W. (1972). Rules for ritual insults. In Sudnow D. (ed.), Studies in social interaction. New York: Free Press. 120–69.
Labov W., & Fanshel D. (1977). Therapeutic discourse. New York: Academic.
Mather L., & Yngvesson B. (1981). Language, audience, and the transformation of disputes. Language and Society 15(314):775822.
Maynard D. W. (1980). Placement of topic changes in conversation. Semiotica 49(3/4):263–90.
Maynard D. W. (1982). Person-descriptions in plea bargaining. Semiotica 42(2/4):, 95213.
Maynard D. W. (1984). The development of argumentative skills among children. Paper presented at the annual meetings of the Society for the Study of Symbolic Interaction,San Antonio.August.
Mehan H. (1979). Learning lessons: Social organization in the classroom. Cambridge. Mass.: Harvard University Press.
Mitchell-Kernan C., & Kernan K. T. (1975). Children's insults: American and Samoan. In Sanches M. & Blount B. G. (eds.). Sociocultural dimensions of language use. New York: Academic. 307–15.
Mitchell-Kernan C. & Kernan K. T.. (1977) Pragmatics of directive choice among children. In S. Ervin-Tripp & C. Mitchell Kernan (1977). 189–208.
Nader L., & Todd H. F. (eds.) (1978). The disputing process: Law in ten societies. New York: Columbia University Press.
Pomerantz A. (1975). Second assessments. A study of some features of agreement/disagreement. Ph.D. dissertation. University of California, Irvine.
Pomerantz A. (1980). Telling my side: ‘Limited access’ as a ‘fishing’ device. Sociological Inquiry 50(314): 186–98.
Sacks H. (1972). An initial investigation of the usability of conversational data fordoing sociology. In Sudnow D. (ed.), Studies in social interaction. New York: Free Press. 3174.
Sacks H. (1973). On some puns with some intimations. In Shuy R. W. (ed.), Report of the Twenty-Third Annual Round Table Meetings in Linguistics and Language Studies. Washington. D.C.: Georgetown University Press. 135–44.
Sacks H., Schegloff E. A., & Jefferson G. (1974) A simplest systematics for the organization of turn-taking for conversation. Language 50:696735.
Schegloff E. A. (1968). Sequencing in conversational openings. American Anthropologist 70(4): 1075–95.
Schegloff E. A., Jefferson G., & Sacks H. (1977). The preference for self-correction in the organization of repair in conversation. Language 53 (2):361–82.
Schegloff E. A. & Sacks H. (1973). Opening up closings. Semiotica 8:289327.
Schenkein J. (1978). Studies in the organization of conversation. New York: Academic.
Sherzer J. (1973). On linguistic semantics and linguistic subdisciplines: A review article. Language in Society 2:269–89.
Stalnaker R. (1973). Presuppositions. Journal of Philosophical Logic 2:447–57.
Stalnaker R. (1974). Pragmatic presuppositions. In Munitz M. K. & Unger P. K. (eds.), Semantics and philosophy. New York: New York University Press. 197213.
Volterra V., & Antinucci F. (1979). Negation in child language: A pragmatic study In Ochs E. & Schieffelin B. B. (eds.). Developmental pragmnatics. New York: Academic. 281303.
Willard C. A. (1978). A reformulation of the concept of argument: The construclivist/interactionist foundations of a sociology of argument. Journal of the American Forensic Association 14 (Winter): 121–40.
Wilkinson L. C., & Dollaghan C. (1979). Peer communications in first-grade reading groups. Theory into practice XVIII(4):267–74.
Wilkinson L. C. & Calculator S. (1982). Requests and responses n peer-directed reading groups. American Educational Research Journal 19(1): 107–22.
Zimmerman D. H. (1970). The practicalities of rule use. In Douglas J. D. (ed.). Understanding everyday life. Chicago: Aldine. 221–38
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Language in Society
  • ISSN: 0047-4045
  • EISSN: 1469-8013
  • URL: /core/journals/language-in-society
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 17 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 166 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 24th October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.