Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

A critical review of age-related research on L2 ultimate attainment

  • Carmen Muñoz (a1) and David Singleton (a2)
Abstract

This article addresses age-related attainment effects in second language acquisition, posing the question of whether such effects are to be explained in terms of a Critical Period with a predictable and abrupt offset point or in terms of the impact of a wider range of factors. It attempts to explore this question by focusing on four discussion points in the current debate: (i) the wide use of native-speaker behaviour as the key L2 attainment yardstick; (ii) the degree of compatibility of prevailing views regarding the notion of a critical period for L2 acquisition; (iii) the relative narrowness of much research in this area, where age of L2 onset is often regarded as the crucial if not the only critical variable; and (iv) insights relative to maturational constraints on language acquisition offered by recent brain research. The article concludes that a loosening of the association between ultimate L2 attainment research and Critical Period Hypothesis (CPH) issues would shed more light on L2 attainment in terms both of the comprehensiveness and of the acuity of the insights which would result.

Copyright
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

N. Abrahamsson & K. Hyltenstam (2009). Age of acquisition and nativelikeness in a second language: Listener perception vs. linguistic scrutiny. Language Learning 59, 249306.

J. Abutalebi (2008). Neural aspects of second language representation and language control. Acta Psychologica 128, 466478.

J. Abutalebi & D. Green (2007). Bilingual language production: The neurocognition of language representation and control. Journal of Neurolinguistics 20.3, 242275.

T. K. Au , L. M. Knightly , S. Jun & J. S. Oh (2002). Overhearing a language during childhood. Psychological Science 13.3, 238243.

D. B. Jr. Bailey (2002). Are critical periods critical for early childhood education? The role of timing in early childhood pedagogy. Early Childhood Research Quarterly 17.3, 281294.

E. Bialystok (1997). The structure of age: In search of barriers to second language acquisition. Second Language Research 13.2, 116137.

D. Birdsong (1992). Ultimate attainment in second language acquisition. Language 68.4, 706755.

D. Birdsong (2004). Second language acquisition and ultimate attainment. In A. Davies & C. Elder (eds.), The handbook of applied linguistics. London: Blackwell, 82105.

D. Birdsong (2006). Age and second language acquisition and processing: A selective overview. Language Learning 56.1, 949.

D. Birdsong & J. Paik (2008). Second language acquisition and ultimate attainment. In B. Spolsky & F. Hult (eds.), Handbook of educational linguistics. Oxford: Blackwell, 424436.

T. Bongaerts , S. Mennen & F. Van Der Slik (2000). Authenticity of pronunciation in naturalistic second language acquisition: The case of very advanced late learners of Dutch as a second language. Studia Linguistica 54.2, 298308.

T. Bongaerts , C. van Summeren , B. Planken , B. & E. Schils (1997). Age and ultimate attainment in the pronunciation of a foreign language. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 19.4, 447465.

R. S. Briellmann , M. M. Saling , A. B. Connell , A. B. Waites , D. F. Abbott & G. D. Jackson (2004). A high-field functional MRI study of quadrilingual subjects. Brain and Language 89, 531542.

C. Burstall (1975). Primary French in the balance. Foreign Language Annals 10.3, 245252.

E. Bylund (2009). Maturational constraints and first language attrition. Language Learning 59.3, 687715.

E. Bylund , N. Abrahamsson & K. Hyltenstam (2010). The role of language aptitude in first language attrition: The case of pre-pubescent attriters. Applied Linguistics, 31 (3), 443464.

M. W. L. Chee , N. Hon , H. Ling Lee & C. S. Soon (2001). Relative language proficiency modulates BOLD signal change when bilinguals perform semantic judgments. NeuroImage 13.6, 1155–63.

H. T. Chugani , M. E. Behen , O. Muzik , C. Juhasz , F. Nagy & D. C. Chugani (2001). Local brain functional activity following early deprivation: A study of post-institutionalized Romanian orphans. NeuroImage 14.6, 12901301.

V. Cook (1992). Evidence for multi-competence. Language Learning 42.4, 557591.

V. Cook (1999). Going beyond the native speaker in language teaching. TESOL Quarterly 33.2, 185209.

A. Davies (2004) The native speaker in applied linguistics. In A. Davies & C. Elder (eds.), The handbook of applied linguistics. Malden: Blackwell Publishing, 431450.

K. De Bot (2004). The multilingual lexicon: modelling selection and control. International Journal of Multilingualism 1.1, 1732.

G. S. Ding , C. Perry , D. L. Peng , L. Ma , D. J. Li & S. Y. Xu (2003). Neural mechanisms underlying semantic and orthographic processing in Chinese-English bilinguals. NeuroReport 14, 1557–62.

C. J. Doughty & M. H. Long (eds.) (2003). Handbook of second language acquisition. London: Blackwell.

C. Felser & H. Clahsen (2009). Grammatical processing of spoken language in child and adult language learners. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 38.3, 305319.

J. E. Flege , D. Birdsong , E. Bialystok , M. Mack , H. Sung & K. Tsukada (2006). Degree of foreign accent in English sentences produced by Korean children and adults. Journal of Phonetics 34.2, 153175.

J. E. Flege , E. M. Frieda & T. Nozawa (1997). Amount of native language (L1) use affects the pronunciation of an L2. Journal of Phonetics 25.2, 169186.

J. E. Flege & I. R. A. MacKay (2004). Perceiving vowels in a second language. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 26.1, 134.

J. E. Flege , I. R. A. MacKay & D. Meador (1999). Native Italian speakers’ perception and production of English vowels. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 106.5, 2973–87.

J. E. Flege , M. J. Munro & I. R. A. MacKay (1995). Effects of age of second-language learning on the production of English consonants. Speech Communication 16.1, 126.

W. S. Francis (1999). Cognitive integration of language and memory in bilinguals: Semantic representation. Psychological Bulletin 125.2, 193222.

B. F. Freed , D. P. Dewey & N. Segalowitz (2004). The language contact profile. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 26.2, 349356.

D. W. Green (2003). The neural basis of the lexicon and the grammar in L2 acquisition. In R. van Hout , A. Hulk , F. Kuiken & R. Towell (eds.), The interface between syntax and the lexicon in second language acquisition. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.

S. G. Guion , J. E. Flege & J. Loftin (2000). The effect of L1 use on pronunciation in Quichua–Spanish bilinguals. Journal of Phonetics 28.1, 2742.

K. Hakuta , E. Bialystok & E. W. Wiley (2003). Critical evidence: A test of the Critical Period Hypothesis for second-language acquisition. Psychological Science 14.1, 3138.

R. Hawkins (2001). Second language syntax: A generative introduction. Oxford: Blackwell.

A. E. Hernández , M. Dapretto , J. Mazziotta & S. Bookheimer (2001). Language switching and language representation in Spanish–English bilinguals: An fMRI study. Neuroimage 14, 510520.

J. Hill (1970). Foreign accents, language acquisition and cerebral dominance revisited. Language Learning 20.2, 237248.

K. Hyltenstam (1992). Non-native features of non-native speakers: On the ultimate attainment of childhood L2 learners. In R. J. Harris (ed.), Cognitive processing in bilinguals. New York: Elsevier, 351368.

K. Hyltenstam & N. Abrahamsson (2000). Who can become native-like in a second language? All, some, or none? On the maturational controversy in second language acquisition. Studia Linguistica 54.2, 150166.

J. Illes , W. S. Francis , J. E. Desmond , J. D. E. Gabrieli , G. H. Glover , R. Poldrack , C. J. Lee & A. D. Wagner (1999). Convergent cortical representation of semantic processing in bilinguals. Brain and Language 70.3, 347363.

H. Jeong , M. Sugiura , Y. Sassa , T. Haji , N. Usui , M. Taira , K. Horie , S. Sato & R. Kawashima (2007). Effect of syntactic similarity on cortical activation during second language processing: A comparison of English and Japanese among native Korean trilinguals. Human Brain Mapping 28.3, 194204.

J. S. Johnson & E. L. Newport (1989). Critical period effects in second language learning: The influence of maturational state on the acquisition of ESL. Cognitive Psychology 21.1, 6099.

P. E. Jones (1995). Contradictions and unanswered questions in the Genie case: A fresh look at the linguistic evidence. Language and Communication 15.3, 261280.

E. Kellerman (1995). Age before beauty: Johnson and Newport revisited. In L. Eubank , L. Selinker & M. Sharwood Smith (eds.), The current state of interlanguage: Studies in honor of William E. Rutherford. Amsterdam: John Benjamins, 219231.

J. F. Kroll & E. Stewart (1994). Category interference in translation and picture naming: Evidence for asymmetric connections between bilingual memory representations. Journal of Language and Memory 33.2, 149174.

J. Larson-Hall (2008). Weighing the benefits of studying a foreign language at a younger starting age in a minimal input situation. Second Language Research 24.1, 3563.

M. H. Long (2005). Problems with supposed counter-evidence to the Critical Period Hypothesis. International Review of Applied Linguistics 43.4, 287317.

J. McDonald (2000). Grammaticality judgments in a second language: Influences of age of acquisition and native language. Applied Psycholinguistics 21.3, 395423.

I. R. A. MacKay , D. Meador & J. E. Flege (2001). The identification of English consonants by native speakers of Italian. Phonetica 58.1–2, 103125.

S. H. Marinova-Todd , D. B. Marshall & C. E. Snow (2000). Three misconceptions about age and L2 learning. TESOL Quarterly 34.1, 934.

N. Marx (2002). Never quite a ‘native speaker’: Accent and identity in the L2 and the L1. The Canadian Modern Language Review/La Revue canadienne des langues vivantes 59.2, 264281.

R. Mayberry (1993). First-language acquisition after childhood differs from second-language acquisition: The case of American Sign Language. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research 36.6, 1258–70.

R. I. Mayberry & E. Eichen (1991). The long-lasting advantage of learning sign language in childhood: Another look at the critical period for language acquisition. Journal of Memory and Language 30.4, 486512.

S. Montrul (2008). Incomplete Acquisition in Bilingualism. Re-examining the Age Factor. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins.

A. Moyer (1999). Ultimate attainment in L2 phonology. The critical factors of age, motivation, and instruction. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 21.1, 81108.

A. Moyer (2005). Formal and informal experiential realms in German as a foreign language: A preliminary investigation. Foreign Language Annals 38.3, 377387.

C. Muñoz (2008b). Age-related differences in foreign language learning. Revisiting the empirical evidence. International Review of Applied Linguistics in Language Teaching 46.3, 197220.

C. Muñoz & D. Singleton (2007). Foreign accent in advanced learners: two successful profiles. The EUROSLA Yearbook 7, 171190.

M. Nikolov (2000). The Critical Period Hypothesis reconsidered: Successful adult learners of Hungarian and English. International Review of Applied Linguistics in Language Teaching 38.2, 109124.

J. Oller & N. Nagato (1974) The long-term effect of FLES: An experiment. The Modern Language Journal 58.1–2, 1519.

C. Pallier , S. Dehaene , J.-B. Poline , D. LeBihan , A.-M. Argenti , E. Dupoux & J. Mehler (2003). Brain imaging of language plasticity in adopted adults: Can a second language replace the first? Cerebral Cortex 13.2, 155161.

M. Paradis (2004). A neurolinguistic theory of bilingualism. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.

D. Perani & J. Abutalebi (2005). The neural basis of first and second language processing. Current Opinion in Neurobiology 15.2, 202206.

D. Perani , J. Abutalebi , E. Paulesu , S. Brambati , P. Scifo , S. F. Cappa et al. (2003). The role of age of acquisition and language usage in early, high-proficient bilinguals: An fMRI study during verbal fluency. Human Brain Mapping 19.3, 170182.

C. C. Peterson & M. Siegal (1995). Deafness, conversation, and theory of mind. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 36.3, 459474.

J., J. Araque Pillai , J. Allison , S. Sethuraman , D. Loring , D. Thiruvaiyaru , C. B. Ison , A. Balan & T. Lavin (2003). Functional MRI study of semantic and phonological language processing in bilingual subjects: Preliminary findings. NeuroImage 19, 565576.

I. Piller (2002). Passing for a native speaker: Identity and success in second language learning. Journal of Sociolinguistics 6.2, 179206.

T. Piske , I. R. A. MacKay & J. E. Flege (2001). Factors affecting degree of foreign accent in an L2: A review. Journal of Phonetics 29.2, 191215.

R. V. Reichle (2010b). Judgments of information structure in L2 French: Nativelike performance and the Critical Period Hypothesis. International Review of Applied Linguistics in Language Teaching 48.1, 5385.

J. Rothman (2008). Why all counter-evidence to the Critical Period Hypothesis is not equal or problematic. Language and Linguistics Compass 2.6, 1063–88.

R. J. Ruben (1997). A time frame of critical/sensitive periods of language development. Acta Otolaryngologica 117.2, 202205.

S. A. Rueschemeyer , S. Zysset & A. D. Friederici (2006). Native and non-native reading of sentences: An fMRI experiment. NeuroImage 31, 354365.

D. Singleton (2005). The Critical Period Hypothesis: A coat of many colours. International Review of Applied Linguistics in Language Teaching 43.4, 269285.

J. L. Singleton & E. L. Newport (2004). When learners surpass their models: The acquisition of American Sign Language from inconsistent input. Cognitive Psychology 49.4, 370407.

G. Stevens (2006). The age-length-onset problems in research on second language acquisition among immigrants. Language Learning 56.4, 671692.

L. A. Stowe & L. Sabourin (2005). Imaging the processing of a second language: Effects of maturation and proficiency on the neural processes involved. International Review of Applied Linguistics in Language Teaching 43.4, 329353.

S. L. Thompson-Schill , M. D'Esposito & I. P. Kan (1999). Effects of repetition and competition on activity in left prefrontal cortex during word generation. Neuron 23.3, 513522.

M. T. Ullman (2001). A neurocognitive perspective on language: The declarative/procedural model. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 2, 717726.

M. T. Ullman (2004). Contributions of memory circuits to language: The declarative/procedural model. Cognition 92.1–2, 231270.

I. Wartenburger , H. R. Heekeren , J. Abutalebi , S. F. Cappa , A. Villringer & D. Perani (2003). Early setting of grammatical processing in the bilingual brain. Neuron 37.1, 159170.

C. M. Weber-Fox & H. J. Neville (1996). Maturational constraints on functional specializations for language processing: ERP and behavioral evidence in bilingual speakers. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 8.3, 231256.

L. White & F. Genesee (1996). How native is near-native? The issue of ultimate attainment in adult second language acquisition. Second Language Research 12.3, 233265.

E. W. Wiley , E. Bialystok & K. Hakuta (2005). New approaches to using census data to test the Critical-Period Hypothesis for second-language acquisition. Psychological Science 16.4, 341343.

H. Winitz , B. Gillespie & J. Starcev (1995). The development of English speech patterns of a 7-year-old Polish-speaking child. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 24.2, 117143.

T. Woolfe , S. C. Want & M. Siegal (2002). Signposts to development: Theory of mind in deaf children. Child Development 73.3, 768778.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Language Teaching
  • ISSN: 0261-4448
  • EISSN: 1475-3049
  • URL: /core/journals/language-teaching
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 81
Total number of PDF views: 777 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 2010 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 21st September 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.