[The High German shift of West Germanic initial [k-], currently defined as a shift to an affricate, can be defined in the phoneme system of the dialects only as a shift to a combination of stop plus related spirant [kx-, kh-, gh-]. This definition enables us to apply an exact criterion to some of the dialects. The shift of [k-] covers a larger territory than appears under the current formulation: it covers all the Upper German (Apfel) dialects and in the west extends beyond them.]