Skip to main content

THE INTELLIGIBILITY OF EXTRALEGAL STATE ACTION: A General Lesson for Debates on Public Emergencies and Legality

  • François Tanguay-Renaud (a1)

Some legal theorists deny that states can conceivably act extralegally in the sense of acting contrary to domestic law. This position finds its most robust articulation in the writings of Hans Kelsen and has more recently been taken up by David Dyzenhaus in the context of his work on emergencies and legality. This paper seeks to demystify their arguments and ultimately contend that we can intelligibly speak of the state as a legal wrongdoer or a legally unauthorized actor.

Hide All
Appiah K. A. (2005) The Ethics of Identity (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
Austin J. (1954) The Province of Jurisprudence Determined (New York: Weidenfeld).
Copp D. (2006) “On the Agency of Certain Collective Entities: An Argument from ‘Normative Autonomy.’“ In French P. and Wettstein H.K., eds., Midwest Studies in Philosophy: Shared Intentions and Collective Responsibility, vol. 30 (Boston: Blackwell).
de Doelder H. and Tiedemann K., eds. (1996) Criminal Liability of Corporations (The Hague: Kluwer).
Dicey A.V. (1959) An Introduction to the Law of the Constitution, 10th ed. (London: MacMillan 1959).
Dworkin R. (2004) “Hart's Postscript and the Character of Political Philosophy.” Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 24: 137.
Dyzenhaus D. (1991) Hard Cases in Wicked Legal Systems: South African Law in the Perspective of Legal Philosophy (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Dyzenhaus D. (2005) “The State of Emergency in Legal Theory.” In Ramraj V.V., Hor M., and Roach K., eds., Global Anti-Terrorism Law and Policy, 6589 (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press).
Dyzenhaus D. (2006) The Constitution of Law: Legality in a Time of Emergency (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press).
Dyzenhaus D. (2007) “States of Emergency.” In Goodin R.E., Pettit P., and Pogge T., eds., A Companion to Contemporary Political Philosophy, 804812 (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Dyzenhaus D. (2008) “The Compulsion of Legality.” In Ramraj V.V., ed., Emergencies and the Limits of Legality, 3359 (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press).
Dyzenhaus D. (2009) “The Puzzle of Martial Law.” University of Toronto Law Journal 59: 164.
Dyzenhaus D. (forthcoming 2010) “L'état d'exception.” In Troper M. and Chagnollaud D., eds., Traité international de droit constitutionnel (Paris: Dalloz).
Erskine T. (2003) “Assigning Responsibilities to Institutional Moral Agents: The Case of States and ‘Quasi-States.’“ In Erskine T., ed., Can Institutions Have Responsibilities: Collective Agency and International Relations, 1940 (New York: Palgrave MacMillan).
Feinberg J. (1965) “The Expressive Function of Punishment.” The Monist 49: 397423.
Finnis J. (1973) “Revolutions and Continuity of Law.” In Simpson A.W.B., ed., Oxford Essays in Jurisprudence: Second Series, 4476 (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Finnis J. (1980) Natural Law and Natural Rights (Oxford: Clarendon Press).
French P. (1984) Collective and Corporate Responsibility (New York: Columbia University Press).
Fuller L. (1967) Legal Fictions (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press).
Gardner J. (2008) “Hart and Feinberg on Responsibility.” In Kramer M.H., Grant C., Colburn B., and Hatzistavrou A, eds., The Legacy of H.L.A. Hart: Legal, Political, and Moral Philosophy, 143164 (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Gee G. and Webber G.C.N.. (2010) “What Is a Political Constitution?Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 30: 127.
Green L. (1990) The Authority of the State (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Hart H.L.A. (1968) Punishment and Responsibility: Essays in the Philosophy of Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Hart H.L.A. (1982) Essays on Bentham: Jurisprudence and Political Theory (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Hart H.L.A. (1994) The Concept of Law, 2nd ed. (Oxford: Clarendon Press).
Hobbes Thomas (1996) Leviathan, edited by Gaskin J.C.A. (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Jaconelli J. (1999) “The Nature of Constitutional Convention.” Legal Studies 19: 2446.
Kant I. (1991) The Metaphysics of Morals, edited by Gregor Mary (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press).
Kelsen H. (1976) Pure Theory of Law, translated by Knight Max (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press).
Kelsen H. (1997) Introduction to the Problems of Legal Theory, translated by Paulson B. Litschewski and Paulson S.L. (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Kelsen H. (2006) General Theory of Law and State (New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers).
List C. and Pettit P.. (2008) “Group Agency and Supervenience.” In Hohwy J. and Kallestrup J., eds., Being Reduced: New Essays on Reduction, Explanation, and Causation, 7592 (New York: Oxford University Press).
MacCormick N. (1999) Questioning Sovereignty (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
McMahan J. (2009) Killing in War (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Nussbaum M.C. (2007) The Clash Within: Democracy, Religious Violence, and India's Future (Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press).
Pettit P. (2007) “Responsibility Incorporated.” Ethics 117: 171201.
Raz J. (1979) The Authority of Law: Essays on Law and Morality (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Raz J. (1980) The Concept of a Legal System, 2nd ed. (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Raz J. (1990) Practical Reason and Norms, 2nd ed. (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Raz J. (2006) “The Problem of Authority: Revisiting the Service Conception.” Minnesota Law Review 90: 10031044.
Ripstein A. (2009) Force and Freedom: Kant's Legal and Political Philosophy (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
Schmitt C. (2005) Political Theology: Four Chapters on the Concept of Sovereignty, translated by Schwab G. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).
Tamir Y. (1995) Liberal Nationalism (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
Thompson D.F. (1985) “Criminal Responsibility in Government.” In Pennock J.R. and Chapman J.W., eds., Nomos XXVII: Criminal Justice, 201240 (New York: New York University Press).
Thorburn M. (2008) “Justifications, Powers, and Authority.” Yale Law Journal 117: 10701130.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Legal Theory
  • ISSN: 1352-3252
  • EISSN: 1469-8048
  • URL: /core/journals/legal-theory
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 2
Total number of PDF views: 19 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 71 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 20th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.