Skip to main content Accesibility Help

Shifted baselines and the policy placebo effect in conservation

  • Samantha Lovell (a1), Ayana Elizabeth Johnson (a2), Robin Ramdeen (a3) and Loren McClenachan (a1)

Coastal ecosystems have been degraded by human activity over centuries, with loss of memory about past states resulting in shifted baselines. More recently conservation efforts have resulted in localized recoveries of species and ecosystems. Given the dynamism of ecosystem degradation and recovery, understanding how communities perceive long-term and recent changes is important for developing and implementing conservation measures. We interviewed stakeholders on three Caribbean islands and identified a shifted baseline with respect to the extent and degree of long-term declines in marine animal populations; stakeholders with more experience identified more species as depleted and key species as less abundant than those with less experience. Notably, the average respondent with < 15 years of experience listed no species as depleted despite clear evidence of declines. We also identified a phenomenon we call the policy placebo effect, in which interviewees perceived some animal populations as recently recovering following passage of new conservation legislation but in the absence of evidence for actual recovery. Although shifted baselines have a negative effect on conservation as they can lower recovery goals, the outcomes of a policy placebo effect are unclear. If the public prematurely perceives recovery, motivation for continued conservation could decline. Alternatively, perception of rapid success could lead communities to set more ambitious conservation goals.

Corresponding author
(Corresponding author) E-mail
Hide All

Also at: Environmental Defense Fund, Washington, DC, USA

Supplementary material for this article is available at

Hide All
Albuquerque, K.D. & McElroy, J.L. (1995) Antigua and Barbuda: A Legacy of Environmental Degradation, Policy Failure, and Coastal Decline. Environmental and Natural Resources Policy and Training Project/Midwest Universities Consortium for International Activities, Arlington, USA.
Alvarez-Filip, L., Dulvy, N.K., Gill, J.A., Cote, I.M. & Watkinson, A.R. (2009) Flattening of Caribbean coral reefs: regionwide declines in architectural complexity. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 276, 30193025.
Baker, R. (1748) A New and Exact Map of the Island of Antigua in America. Museum of Antigua and Barbuda, St. John's, Antigua and Barbuda.
Barbuda Council (2013) The Fisheries Regulations. Antigua and Barbuda. ATG-2013-R-93554.
Barbuda Council (2014) The Barbuda (Fisheries) Regulations. Antigua and Barbuda. ATG-2014-R-99617.
Carpenter, R.C. & Edmunds, P.J. (2006) Local and regional scale recovery of Diadema promotes recruitment of scleractinian corals. Ecology Letters, 9, 271280.
Coleridge, H.N. (1826) Six Months in the West Indies. Digitized by the Internet Archive. John Murray, London, UK.
Cramer, K.L., Jackson, J.B.C., Angioletti, C.V., Leonard-Pingel, J. & Guilderson, T.P. (2012) Anthropogenic mortality on coral reefs in Caribbean Panama predates coral disease and bleaching. Ecology Letters, 15, 561567.
Cramer, K.L., Leonard-Pingel, J., Rodriguez, F. & Jackson, J.B.C. (2015) Molluscan subfossil assemblages reveal the long-term deterioration of coral reef environments in Caribbean Panama. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 96, 176187.
Cramer, K.L., O'Dea, A., Clark, T.R., Zhao, J. & Norris, R.D. (2017) Prehistorical and historical declines in Caribbean coral reef accretion rates driven by loss of parrotfish. Nature Communications, 8, 14160.
De La Rochette, L.S. (1784) A Chart of the Antilles of Charibbee or Caribs Islands with the Virgin Islands. Museum of Antigua and Barbuda, St. John's, Antigua and Barbuda.
Edmunds, P.J. & Carpenter, R.C. (2001) Recovery of Diadema antillarum reduces macroalgal cover and increases abundance of juvenile corals on a Caribbean reef. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 98, 5067–5071.
Ferguson, A. & Daniel, S. (2015) Montserrat: Coral Cay Conservation Annual Marine Survey Report, Year 2013–2014. Unpublished report. Coral Cay Conservation Expeditions, Farnham, UK.
Fielding, L. (1824) Antigua. Digitized by Caribmap. Altea Gallery, London, UK.
Francis, J.G. (2010) Fourth National Report to the Convention on Biological Diversity: Antigua and Barbuda. Unpublished report. Government of Antigua & Barbuda, St. Johns, Antigua.
Giglio, V.J., Luiz, O.J. & Gerhardinger, L.C. (2015) Depletion of marine megafauna and shifting baselines among artisanal fishers in eastern Brazil. Animal Conservation, 18, 348358.
Godley, B.J., Broderick, A.C., Campbell, L.M., Ranger, S. & Richardson, P.B. (2004) An assessment of the status and exploitation of marine turtles in Montserrat. In An Assessment of the Status and Exploitation of Marine Turtles in the UK Overseas Territories in the Wider Caribbean, pp. 155–179. Final project report for the Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, Penryn, UK.
Green, S.J., Akins, J.L., Maljković, A. & Côté, I. (2012) Invasive lionfish drive Atlantic coral reef fish declines. PLoS ONE, 7(3), e32596.
Groombridge, B. & Luxmoore, R. (1989) The Green Turtle and Hawksbill: World Status Exploitation, and Trade. CITES, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Hays, G.C. (2004) Good news for sea turtles. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 19, 349351.
Hoegh-Guldberg, O., Mumby, P.J., Hooten, A.J., Steneck, R.S., Greenfield, P., Gomez, E. et al. (2007) Coral reefs under rapid climate change and ocean acidification. Science, 318, 17371742.
Jackson, J.B.C., Donovan, M., Cramer, K. & Lam, V. (2014) Status and Trends of Caribbean Coral Reefs: 1970–2012. Global Coral Reef Monitoring Network, IUCN, Gland, Switzerland.
Jackson, J.B.C., Kirby, M.X., Berger, W.H., Bjorndal, K.A., Botsford, L.W., Bourque, B.J. et al. (2001) Historical overfishing and the recent collapse of coastal ecosystems. Science, 293, 629637.
Jeffers, J. (1996) Status of the queen conch, Strombus gigas in Montserrat. In Proceedings of the First International Queen conch conference, San Juan, Puerto Rico, 29–31 July 1996 (eds J. Posada & G. Garcia-Moliner), pp. 108–109. Caribbean Fisheries Management Council, San Juan, Puerto Rico.
Johnson, A.E. & Jackson, J.B.C. (2015) Fisher and diver perceptions of coral reef degradation and implications for sustainable management. Global Ecology and Conservation, 3, 890899.
Luckhurst, B. & Marshalleck, S. (1995) Current status and assessments of the fisheries for the spiny lobster and conch in the CARICOM region. Proceedings of the 48th Gulf and Caribbean Fisheries Institute, 48, 73–89.
Luffman, J. (1788) Antigua in the West Indies America. Museum of Antigua and Barbuda, St John's, Antigua and Barbuda.
Maylan, A.B. (1983) Marine turtles of the Leeward Islands, Lesser Antilles. Atoll Research Bulletin, 278, 124.
McClenachan, L. & Cooper, A.B. (2008) Extinction rate, historical population structure and ecological role of the Caribbean monk seal. Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences, 275, 13511358.
McClenachan, L., Ferretti, F. & Baum, J.K. (2012) From archives to conservation: why historical data are needed to set baselines for marine animals and ecosystems. Conservation Letters, 5, 349–259.
McClenachan, L., Jackson, J.B.C. & Newman, M.J.H. (2006) Conservation implications of historic sea turtle nesting beach loss. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environmental, 4, 290296.
McClenachan, L., Matsuura, R., Shah, P. & Dissanayake, S.T.M. (2018) Shifted historical baselines reduce willingness to pay for conservation. Frontiers in Marine Science, 5, 19.
McClenachan, L., O'Connor, G.E., Neal, B.P., Pandolfi, J.M. & Jackson, J.B.C. (2017) Ghost reefs: nautical charts document large spatial scale of coral reef loss over 240 years. Science Advances, 3, e1603155.
Mumby, P.J. & Harborne, A.R. (2010) Marine reserves enhance the recovery of corals on Caribbean reefs. PLoS One, 5(1), e8657.
Nicholson, V.E.B. & Sons (1977) Coco Point and Spanish Point Barbuda. Museum of Antigua and Barbuda, St John's, Antigua and Barbuda.
Nuttting, C.C. (1919) Barbados–Antigua expedition. Narrative and preliminary report of scientific expedition from the University of Iowa to the Lesser Antilles under the auspices of the Graduate College. University of Iowa Studies in Natural History, 8, 8283.
O'Farrell, S., Luckhurst, B.E., Box, S.J. & Mumby, P.J. (2016) Parrotfish sex ratios recover rapidly in Bermuda following a fishing ban. Coral Reefs, 35, 421425.
Paddack, M.J., Reynolds, J.D., Aguilar, C., Appeldoorn, R.S., Beets, J., Burkett, E.W. et al. (2009) Recent region-wide declines in Caribbean reef fish abundance. Current Biology, 19, 590595.
Pauly, D. (1995) Anecdotes and the shifting baseline syndrome of fisheries. Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 10, 430.
Peacock, N.A. (1974) A study of the spiny lobster fishery of Antigua and Barbuda. Proceedings of the Gulf and Caribbean Fisheries Institute, 26, 117130.
Price, D.D., Finniss, D.G. & Benedetti, F. (2008) A comprehensive review of the placebo effect: recent advances and current thought. Annual Review of Psychology, 59, 1672.
Randall, C.J. & van Woesik, R. (2015) Contemporary white-band disease in Caribbean corals driven by climate change. Nature Climate Change, 5, 375379.
Riddell, M. (1792) Voyages to the Madeira and Leeward Caribbean Isles. P. Hill, Edinburgh, UK.
Ruttenberg, B., Johnson, A.E., Caselle, J., Estep, A., Grenda, D., Marhaver, K. et al. (2013) Ecological Assessment of Barbuda's Marine Ecosystems: Science Supporting the Barbuda Blue Halo Initiative. Waitt Institute, San Diego, USA.
Sáenz-Arroyo, A., Robert, C., Torre, J., Carño-Olvera, M. & Enriquez-Andrade, R. (2005) Rapidly shifting environmental baselines among fisheries of the Gulf of California. Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences, 272, 19571962.
Troëng, S. & Rankin, E. (2005) Long-term conservation efforts contribute to positive green turtle Chelonia mydas nesting trend at Tortuguero, Costa Rica. Biological Conservation, 121, 111116.
Waitt Institute (2016) The Blue Halo Initiative. Http:// [accessed 2 January 2016].
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

  • ISSN: 0030-6053
  • EISSN: 1365-3008
  • URL: /core/journals/oryx
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Type Description Title
Supplementary materials

Lovell et al. supplementary material
Tables S1-S3 and Figures S1-S2

 PDF (622 KB)
622 KB


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed