Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

Recognizing sexual dimorphism in the fossil record: lessons from nonavian dinosaurs

  • Jordan C. Mallon (a1)
Abstract
Abstract

The demonstration of sexual dimorphism in the fossil record can provide vital information about the role that sexual selection has played in the evolution of life. However, statistically robust inferences of sexual dimorphism in fossil organisms are exceedingly difficult to establish, owing to issues of sample size, experimental control, and methodology. This is particularly so in the case of dinosaurs, for which sexual dimorphism has been posited in many species, yet quantifiable data are often lacking. This study presents the first statistical investigation of sexual dimorphism across Dinosauria. It revisits prior analyses that purport to find quantitative evidence for sexual dimorphism in nine dinosaur species. After the available morphological data were subjected to a suite of statistical tests (normality and unimodality tests and mixture modeling), no evidence for sexual dimorphism was found in any of the examined taxa, contrary to conventional wisdom. This is not to say that dinosaurs were not sexually dimorphic (phylogenetic inference suggests they may well have been), only that the available evidence precludes its detection. A priori knowledge of the sexes would greatly facilitate the assessment of sexual dimorphism in the fossil record, and it is suggested that unambiguous indicators of sex (e.g., presence of eggs, embryos, medullary bone) be used to this end.

Copyright
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

T. W. Anderson , and D. A. Darling . 1952. Asymptotic theory of certain “goodness-of-fit” criteria based on stochastic processes. Annals of Mathematical Statistics 23:193212.

R. J. Asher , K. H. Lin , N. Kardjilov , and L. Hautier . 2011. Variability and constraint in the mammalian vertebral column. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 24:10801090.

H. E. Barden , and S. C. R. Maidment . 2011. Evidence for sexual dimorphism in the stegosaurian dinosaur Kentrosaurus aethiopicus from the Upper Jurassic of Tanzania. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 31:641651.

M. J. Benton , L. Juul , G. W. Storrs , and P. M. Galton . 2000. Anatomy and systematics of the prosauropod dinosaur Thecodontosaurus antiquus from the Upper Triassic of southwest England. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 20:77108.

M. F. Bonnan , J. O. Farlow , and S. L. Masters . 2008. Using linear and geometric morphometrics to detect intraspecific variability and sexual dimorphism in femoral shape in Alligator mississippiensis and its implications for sexing fossil archosaurs. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 28:422431.

E. Bonucci , and G. Gherardi . 1975. Histochemical and electron microscope investigations on medullary bone. Cell and Tissue Research 163:8197.

B. Borkovic , and A. Russell . 2014. Sexual selection according to Darwin: a response to Padian and Horner’s interpretation. Comptes Rendus Palevol 13:701707.

B. Brown , and E. M. Schlaikjer . 1940. The structure and relationships of Protoceratops . Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 40:133265.

C. M. Brown , J. H. Arbour , and D. A. Jackson . 2012. Testing of the effect of missing data estimation and distribution in morphometric multivariate data analyses. Systematic Biology 61:941954.

H. N. Bryant , and A. P. Russell . 1992. The role of phylogenetic analysis in the inference of unpreserved attributes of extinct taxa. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 337:405418.

M. W. Caldwell , and M. S. Y. Lee . 2001. Live birth in Cretaceous marine lizards (mosasauroids). Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 268:23972401.

K. Carpenter 2010. Variation in a population of Theropoda (Dinosauria): Allosaurus from the Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry (Upper Jurassic), Utah, USA. Paleontological Research 14:250259.

K. Carpenter , and P. J. Currie , eds. 1990. Dinosaur systematics: approaches and perspectives. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

K. Carpenter , S. Hayashi , Y. Kobayashi , T. Maryańska , R. Barsbold , K. Sato , and I. Obata . 2011. Saichania chulsanensis (Ornithischia, Ankylosauridae) from the Upper Cretaceous of Mongolia. Palaeontographica Abteilung A 294:161.

Y.-N. Cheng , X.-C. Wu , and Q. Ji . 2004. Triassic marine reptiles gave birth to live young. Nature 432:383386.

Y.-N. Cheng , R. Holmes , X.-C. Wu , and N. Alfonso . 2009. Sexual dimorphism and life history of Keichousaurus hui (Reptilia: Sauropterygia). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 29:401408.

A. Chinsamy , and A. Tumarkin‐Deratzian . 2009. Pathologic bone tissues in a turkey vulture and a nonavian dinosaur: implications for interpreting endosteal bone and radial fibrolamellar bone in fossil dinosaurs. Anatomical Record 292:14781484.

A. Chinsamy , L. M. Chiappe , J. Marugán-Lobón , G. Chunling , and Z. Fengjiao . 2013. Gender identification of the Mesozoic bird Confuciusornis sanctus . Nature Communications 4:1381.

C. H. Danforth 1930. Numerical variation and homologies in vertebrae. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 14:463481.

C. Darwin 1871. The descent of man, and selection in relation to sex. J. Murray, London.

T. Deng 2005. New discovery of Iranotherium morgani (Perissodactyla, Rhinocerotidae) from the late Miocene of the Linxia Basin in Gansu, China, and its sexual dimorphism. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 25:442450.

P. Dodson 1975. Taxonomic implications of relative growth in lambeosaurine hadrosaurs. Systematic Biology 24:3754.

Z. Dong 1997. Mixture analysis and its preliminary application in archaeology. Journal of Archaeological Science 24:141161.

J. O. Farlow 1990. Review: dynamic dinosaurs. Paleobiology 16:234241.

P. M. Galton 1982a. Juveniles of the stegosaurian dinosaur Stegosaurus from the Upper Jurassic of North America. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 2:4762.

P. M. Galton 1985. British plated dinosaurs (Ornithischia, Stegosauridae). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 5:211254.

P. M. Galton , and P. Upchurch . 2004. Stegosauria. Pp. 343362 in D. B. Weishampel, P. Dodson, and H. Osmólska, eds. The Dinosauria, 2nd ed. University of California Press, Berkeley.

R. A. Gangloff 1995. Edmontonia sp., the first record of an ankylosaur from Alaska. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 15:195200.

P. Gingerich 1981. Cranial morphology and adaptations in Eocene Adapidae. 1. Sexual dimorphism in Adapis magnus and Adapis parisiensis . American Journal of Physical Anthropology 56:217234.

L. R. Godfrey , S. K. Lyon , and M. R. Sutherland . 1993. Sexual dimorphism in large-bodied primates: the case of the subfossil lemurs. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 90:315334.

W. Goymann , M. Makomba , F. Urasa , and I. Schwabl . 2015. Social monogamy vs. polyandry: ecological factors associated with sex roles in two closely related birds within the same habitat. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 28:13351353.

Ø. Hammer , and D. A. Harper . 2001. Paleontological data analysis. Blackwell Publishing: Malden, Mass.

N. Handa , M. Watabe , and K. Tsogtbaatar . 2012. New specimens of Protoceratops (Dinosauria: Neoceratopsia) from the Upper Cretaceous in Udyn Sayr, southern Gobi area, Mongolia. Paleontological Research 16:179198.

W. D. Handley , A. Chinsamy , A. M. Yates , and T. H. Worthy . 2016. Sexual dimorphism in the late Miocene mihirung Dromornis stirtoni (Aves: Dromornithidae) from the Alcoota Local Fauna of central Australia. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 36:e1180298. doi: 10.1080/02724634.2016.1180298.

J. A. Hartigan , and P. M. Hartigan . 1985. The dip test of unimodality. Annals of Statistics 13:7084.

A. V. Hedrick , and E. J. Temeles . 1989. The evolution of sexual dimorphism in animals: hypotheses and tests. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 4:136138.

D. W. Hone , D. Naish , and I. C. Cuthill . 2012. Does mutual sexual selection explain the evolution of head crests in pterosaurs and dinosaurs? Lethaia 45:139156.

D. W. Hone , A. A. Farke , and M. J. Wedel . 2016a. Ontogeny and the fossil record: what, if anything, is an adult dinosaur? Biology Letters 12:20150947. doi: 10.1098/rsbl.2015.0947.

J. A. Hopson 1975. The evolution of cranial display structures in hadrosaurian dinosaurs. Paleobiology 1:2143.

J. R. Horner , and K. Padian . 2004. Age and growth dynamics of Tyrannosaurus rex . Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 271:18751880.

T. R. Hübner 2012. Bone histology in Dysalotosaurus lettowvorbecki (Ornithischia: Iguanodontia)–variation, growth, and implications. PLoS ONE 7:e29958. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0029958.

T. E. Isles 2009. The socio-sexual behaviour of extant archosaurs: implications for understanding dinosaur behaviour. Historical Biology 21:139214.

S. C. Josephson , K. E. Juell , and A. R. Rogers . 1996. Estimating sexual dimorphism by method‐of‐moments. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 100:191206.

N. Klein , and P. M. Sander . 2008. Ontogenetic stages in the long bone histology of sauropod dinosaurs. Paleobiology 34:247263.

R. J. Knell , and R. A. Fortey . 2005. Trilobite spines and beetle horns: sexual selection in the Palaeozoic? Biology Letters 1:196199.

R. J. Knell , and S. Sampson . 2011. Bizarre structures in dinosaurs: species recognition or sexual selection? A response to Padian and Horner. Journal of Zoology 283:1822.

R. J. Knell , D. Naish , J. L. Tomkins , and D. W. Hone . 2013b. Sexual selection in prehistoric animals: detection and implications. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 28:3847.

A. H. Lee , and S. Werning . 2008. Sexual maturity in growing dinosaurs does not fit reptilian growth models. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 105:582587.

B. C. Livezey , and P. S. Humphrey . 1984. Sexual dimorphism in continental steamer-ducks. Condor 86:368377.

J. , D. Unwin , D. C. Deeming , X. Jin , Y. Liu , and Q. Ji . 2011. An egg-adult association, gender and reproduction in pterosaurs. Science 331:321324.

L. Maiorino , A. A. Farke , T. Kotsakis , and P. Piras . 2015. Males resemble females: re-evaluating sexual dimorphism in Protoceratops andrewsi (Neoceratopsia, Protoceratopsidae). PLoS ONE 10:e0126464. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0126464.

J. C. Mallon , and R. B. Holmes . 2006. A reevaluation of sexual dimorphism in the postcranium of the chasmosaurine ceratopsid Chasmosaurus belli (Dinosauria: Ornithischia). Canadian Field-Naturalist 120:403412.

T. C. Mendelson , and K. L. Shaw . 2013. Further misconceptions about species recognition: a reply to Padian and Horner. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 28:252253.

C. C. O’Harra 1930. A fossil mammal with unborn twins. Science 71:341342.

K. Padian , and J. R. Horner . 2011a. The evolution of “bizarre structures” in dinosaurs: biomechanics, sexual selection, social selection or species recognition? Journal of Zoology 283:317.

K. Padian , and J. R. Horner . 2011b. The definition of sexual selection and its implications for dinosaurian biology. Journal of Zoology 283:2327.

K. Padian , and J. R. Horner . 2013. Misconceptions of sexual selection and species recognition: a response to Knell et al. and to Mendelson and Shaw. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 28:249250.

K. Padian , and J. R. Horner . 2014a. The species recognition hypothesis explains exaggerated structures in non-avian dinosaurs better than sexual selection does. Comptes Rendus Palevol 13:97107.

K. Padian , and J. R. Horner . 2014b. Darwin’s sexual selection: understanding his ideas in context. Comptes Rendus Palevol 13:709715.

S. G. Platt , T. R. Rainwater , J. B. Thorbjarnarson , A. G. Finger , T. A. Anderson , and S. T. McMurry . 2009. Size estimation, morphometrics, sex ratio, sexual size dimorphism, and biomass of Morelet’s crocodile in northern Belize. Caribbean Journal of Science 45:8093.

J. M. Plavcan 1994. Comparison of four simple methods for estimating sexual dimorphism in fossils. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 94:465476.

A. Prieto-Marquez , P. M. Gignac , and S. Joshi . 2007. Neontological evaluation of pelvic skeletal attributes purported to reflect sex in extinct non-avian archosaurs. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 27:603609.

B. M. Rothschild , and D. S. Berman . 1991. Fusion of caudal vertebrae in Late Jurassic sauropods. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 11:2936.

T. Rowe 1989. A new species of the theropod dinosaur Syntarsus from the Early Jurassic Kayenta Formation of Arizona. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 9:125136.

E. T. Saitta 2015. Evidence for sexual dimorphism in the plated dinosaur Stegosaurus mjosi (Ornithischia, Stegosauria) from the Morrison Formation (Upper Jurassic) of western USA. PLoS ONE 10:e0123503. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0123503.

I. Sanchez , V. Quiralte , J. Morales , B. Azanza , and M. Pickford . 2010. Sexual dimorphism of the frontal appendages of the early Miocene African pecoran Prolibytherium Arambourg, 1961 (Mammalia, Ruminantia). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 30:13061310.

P. M. Sander 2000. Long bone histology of the Tendaguru sauropods: implications for growth and biology. Paleobiology 26:466488.

T. Sato , Y.-N. Cheng , X.-C. Wu , D. K. Zelenitsky , and Y.-F. Hsiao . 2005. A pair of shelled eggs inside a female dinosaur. Science 308:375.

T. W. Schoener 1967. The ecological significance of sexual dimorphism in size in the lizard Anolis conspersus . Science 155:474477.

R. K. Schott , D. C. Evans , M. B. Goodwin , J. R. Horner , C. M. Brown , and N. R. Longrich . 2011. Cranial ontogeny in Stegoceras validum (Dinosauria: Pachycephalosauria): a quantitative model of pachycephalosaur dome growth and variation. PLoS ONE 6:e21092. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0021092.

M. H. Schweitzer , J. L. Wittmeyer , and J. R. Horner . 2005. Gender-specific reproductive tissue in ratites and Tyrannosaurus rex . Science 308:14561460.

M. H. Schweitzer , R. M. Elsey , C. G. Dacke , J. R. Horner , and E.-T. Lamm . 2007. Do egg-laying crocodilian (Alligator mississippiensis) archosaurs form medullary bone? Bone 40:11521158.

M. H. Schweitzer , W. Zheng , L. Zanno , S. Werning , and T. Sugiyama . 2016. Chemistry supports the identification of gender-specific reproductive tissue in Tyrannosaurus rex . Scientific Reports 6:23099.

S. S. Shapiro , and M. B. Wilk . 1965. An analysis of variance test for normality (complete samples). Biometrika 52:591611.

R. Shine 1989. Ecological causes for the evolution of sexual dimorphism: a review of the evidence. Quarterly Review of Biology 64:419461.

D. K. Smith 1998. A morphometric analysis of Allosaurus . Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 18:126142.

W. Stacklies , H. Redestig , M. Scholz , D. Walther , and J. Selbig . 2007. pcaMethods—a bioconductor package providing PCA methods for incomplete data. Bioinformatics 23:11641167.

R. A. Thulborn 1974. A new heterodontosaurid dinosaur (Reptilia: Ornithischia) from the Upper Triassic Red Beds of Lesotho. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society of London 55:151175.

J. L. Tomkins , N. R. LeBas , M. P. Witton , D. M. Martill , and S. Humphries . 2010. Positive allometry and the prehistory of sexual selection. American Naturalist 176:141148.

B. Van Valkenburgh , and T. Sacco . 2002. Sexual dimorphism, social behavior, and intrasexual competition in large Pleistocene carnivorans. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 22:164169.

P. Ward 1965. Feeding ecology of the black‐faced dioch Quelea quelea in Nigeria. Ibis 107:173214.

G. J. W. Webb , and H. Messel . 1978. Morphometric analysis of Crocodylus porosus from the north coast of Arnhem Land, northern Australia. Australian Journal of Zoology 26:127.

D. B. Weishampel 1981. Acoustic analyses of potential vocalization in lambeosaurine dinosaurs (Reptilia: Ornithischia). Paleobiology 7:252261.

H. N. Woodward , E. A. Freedman Fowler , J. O. Farlow , and J. R. Horner . 2015. Maiasaura, a model organism for extinct vertebrate population biology: a large sample statistical assessment of growth dynamics and survivorship. Paleobiology 41:503527.

D. K. Zelenitsky , F. Therrien , W. G. Joyce , and D. B. Brinkman . 2008. First fossil gravid turtle provides insight into the evolution of reproductive traits in turtles. Biology Letters 4:715718.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Paleobiology
  • ISSN: 0094-8373
  • EISSN: 1938-5331
  • URL: /core/journals/paleobiology
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 351
Total number of PDF views: 710 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 2684 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 27th March 2017 - 22nd July 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.