Skip to main content Accessibility help

Sexual dimorphism and sexual selection in cytheroidean ostracodes from the Late Cretaceous of the U.S. Coastal Plain

  • Gene Hunt (a1), M. João Fernandes Martins (a1), T. Markham Puckett (a2), Rowan Lockwood (a3), John P. Swaddle (a4), Christine M. S. Hall (a5) and James Stedman (a1)...


Sexual dimorphism is common in many extant animals, but it is difficult to demonstrate in fossil species. Working with material from the Late Cretaceous of the U.S. Coastal Plain, we herein analyze sexual dimorphism in ostracodes from the superfamily Cytheroidea, a group whose extant members have males that are relatively more elongate than females. We digitized outlines of more than 6000 individual ostracode valves or carapaces, extracted size (area) and shape (length-to-height ratio) information, and used finite mixture models to assess hypotheses of sexual dimorphism. Male and female clusters can be discerned in nearly all populations with sufficient data, resulting in estimates of size and shape dimorphism for 142 populations across 106 species; an additional nine samples are interpreted to consist only of females. Dimorphism patterns varied across taxa, especially for body size: males range from 30% larger to 20% smaller than females. Magnitudes of sexual dimorphism are generally stable within species across time and space; we can demonstrate substantial evolutionary changes in dimorphism in only one species, Haplocytheridea renfroensis. Several lines of evidence indicate that patterns of sexual dimorphism in these ostracodes reflect male investment in reproduction, suggesting that this study system has the potential to capture variation in sexual selection through the fossil record.



Hide All
Abe, K. 1990. What the sex ratio tells us: a case from marine ostracods. Pp. 175185. in R. Whatley, and C. Maybury, eds. Ostracoda and global events. Chapman and Hall, London.
Abe, K., and Vannier, J.. 1991. Mating behavior in the podocopid ostracode Bicornucythere bisanensis (Okubo, 1975): rotation of a female by a male with asymmetric 5th limbs. Journal of Crustacean Biology 11:250260.
Abouheif, E., and Fairbairn, D. J.. 1997. A comparative analysis of allometry for sexual size dimorphism: assessing Rensch’s rule. American Naturalist 149:540562.
Alexander, C. I. 1929. Ostracoda of the Cretaceous of north Texas. University of Texas Bulletin 2907:1137.
Alexander, C. I. 1932. Sexual dimorphism in fossil Ostracoda. American Midland Naturalist 12:302310.
Alexander, C. I. 1933. Shell structure of the ostracode genus Cytheropteron, and fossil species from the Cretaceous of Texas. Journal of Paleontology 7:181214.
Alexander, C. I. 1934a. Ostracoda of the genera Monoceratina and Orthonotacythere from the Cretaceous of Texas. Journal of Paleontology 8:5767.
Alexander, C. I. 1934b. Ostracoda of the Midway (Eocene) of Texas. Journal of Paleontology 8:206237.
Alexander, C. I. 1936. Ostracoda of the genera Eucythere, Cytherura, Eucytherura, and Loxoconcha from the Cretaceous of Texas. Journal of Paleontology 10:689694.
Alexander, C. I., and Alexander, C. W.. 1933. Reversal of valve size and hinge structure in a species of the genus Cytheridea . American Midland Naturalist 14:280283.
Andersson, M. 1994. Sexual selection. Princeton Unversity Press, Princeton, N.J.
Arnqvist, G. 1998. Comparative evidence for the evolution of genitalia by sexual selection. Nature 393:784786.
Astrop, T. I., Park, L. E., Brown, B., and Weeks, S. C.. 2012. Sexual discrimination at work: spinicaudatan ‘clam shrimp’ (Crustacea: Branchiopoda) as a model organism for the study of sexual system evolution. Palaeontologia Electronica 15(2).
Athersuch, J., Horne, D. J., and Whittaker, J. E.. 1989. Marine and brackish water ostracods. Bath Press, Avon, UK.
Berry, E. W. 1925. Upper Cretaceous ostracoda from Maryland. American Journal of Science 9:481487.
Blanckenhorn, W. U., Meier, R., and Teder, T.. 2007. Rensch’s rule in insects: pattens among and within species. Pp. 6070 in D. J. Fairbairn, W. U. Blanckenhorn, and T. Székely, eds. Sex, size and gender roles. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Bonnema, J. H. 1940. Ostracoden aus der Kreide des Untergrundes der nordoestlichen Niederlande. Naturhistorisch Maandblad 30.
Brouwers, E. M., and Hazel, J. E.. 1978. Ostracoda and correlation of the Severn Formation (Navarroan; Maestrichtian) of Maryland. Journal of Paleontology 52(Suppl. to No. 6):152.
Brouwers, E. M., and Hazel, J. E.. 1980. Eucytherl sohli, a new name for Eucythere alexanderi Brouwers and Hazel, 1978. Journal of Paleontology 54:13521352.
Brown, P. M. 1957. Upper Cretaceous Ostracoda from North Carolina. North Carolina Department of Conservation and Development Bulletin 70:127.
Bush, A., Powell, M. G., Arnold, W. S., Bert, T. M., and Daley, G. M.. 2002. Time-averaging, evolution and morphological variation. Paleobiology 28:925.
Butler, E. A., and Jones, D. E.. 1957. Cretaceous Ostracoda of Prothrop and Rayburns salt domes Bienville Parish, Louisiana. Louisiana Geological Society Geological Bulletins 32:165.
Butlin, R., Schön, I., and Martins, K.. 1998. Asexual reproduction in nonmarine ostracods. Heredity 81:473480.
Cederstrom, P., Ahlberg, P., Nilsson, C. H., Ahlgren, J., and Eriksson, M. E.. 2011. Moulting, ontogeny and sexual dimorphism in the Cambrian ptychopariid trilobite Strenuaeva inflata from the northern Swedish Caledonides. Palaeontology 54:685703.
Chapman, R. E., Galton, P. M., Sepkoski, J. J., and Wall, W. P.. 1981. A morphometric study of the cranium of the pachycephalosaurid dinosaur Stegoceras . Journal of Paleontology 55:608618.
Cohen, A. C., and Morin, J. G.. 1990. Patterns of reproduction in ostracodes: a review. Journal of Crustacean Biology 10:184211.
Crane, M. J. 1965. Upper Cretaceous ostracodes of the Gulf Coast area. Micropaleontology 11:191254.
Dale, J., Dunn, P. O., Figuerola, J., Lislevand, T., Szekely, T., and Whittingham, L. A.. 2007. Sexual selection explains Rensch’s rule of allometry for sexual size dimorphism. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 274:29712979.
Danielopol, D. L. 1980. On the carapace shape of some European freshwater interstitial Candoninae (Ostracoda). Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington 93:743756.
Darwin, C. 1871. The descent of man, and selection in relation to sex. John Murray, London.
Doherty, P. F., Sorci, G., Royle, J. A., Hines, J. E., Nichols, J. D., and Boulinier, T.. 2003. Sexual selection affects local extinction and turnover in bird communities. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 100:58585862.
Dunn, P. O., Whittingham, L. A., and Pitcher, T. E.. 2001. Mating systems, sperm competition, and the evolution of sexual dimorphism in birds. Evolution 55:161175.
Emlen, D. J., Marangelo, J., Ball, B., and Cunningham, C. W.. 2005. Diversity in the weapons of sexual selection: horn evolution in the beetle genus Onthophagus (Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae). Evolution 59:10601084.
Fairbairn, D. J. 2007. Introduction: the enigma of sexual size dimorphism. Pp. 112 in D. J. Fairbairn, W. U. Blanckenhorn, and T. Székely, eds. Sex, size and gender roles. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Fairbairn, D. J., Blanckenhorn, W. U., and Székely, T. eds. 2007. Sex, size and gender roles. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Fortey, R. A., and Hughes, N. C.. 1998. Brood pouches in trilobites. Journal of Paleontology 72:638649.
Fraley, C., Raftery, A., Murphy, B., and Scrucca, L.. 2012). mclust version 4 for R: normal mixture modeling for model-based clustering, classification, and density estimation. Technical Report 597. Department of Statistics, University of Washington, Seattle, Wash.
Fraley, C., and Raftery, A. E.. 2002. Model-based clustering, discriminant analysis and density estimation. Journal of the American Statistical Association 97:611631.
Fraley, C., and Raftery, A. E.. 2007. Bayesian regularization for normal mixture estimation and model-based clustering. Journal of Classification 24:155181.
Gage, M. J. G., Parker, G. A., Nylin, S., and Wiklund, C.. 2002. Sexual selection and speciation in mammals, butterflies and spiders. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 269:23092316.
Gingerich, P. D. 1981. Variation, sexual dimorphism, and social structure in the Early Eocene horse Hyracotherium (Mammalia, Perissodactyla). Paleobiology 7:443455.
Gosden, T. P., Shastri, K. L., Innocenti, P., and Chenoweth, S. F.. 2012. The B-matrix harbors significant and sex-specific constraints on the evolution of multicharacter sexual dimorphism. Evolution 66:21062116.
Hazel, J. E., and Paulson, O. L.. 1964. Some new ostracode species from the Austinian and Tayloran (Coniacian and Campanian) rocks of the East Texas Embayment. Journal of Paleontology 38:10471064.
Hill, B. L. 1954. Reclassification of winged Cythereis and winged Brachycythere . Journal of Paleontology 28:804826.
Hirst, A. G., and Kiorboe, T.. 2014. Macroevolutionary patterns of sexual size dimorphism in copepods. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 281(1791):20140739.
Horne, D. J., Baltanás, A., and Paris, G.. 1998a. Geographical distribution of reproductive modes in living ostracods. Pp. 7799 in K. Martens, ed. Sex and parthenogenesis: evolutionary ecology of reproductive modes in non-marine ostracods. Backhuys, Leiden.
Horne, D. J., Danielopol, D. L., and Martens, K.. 1998b. Reproductive behavior. Pp. 157195 in K. Martens, ed. Sex and parthenogenesis: evolutionary ecology of reproductive modes in non-marine ostracods. Backhuys, Leiden.
Howe, H. V., and Laurencich, L.. 1958. Introduction to the study of Cretaceous Ostracoda. Louisiana State University Press, Baton Rouge.
Hunt, G. 2004. Phenotypic variance inflation in fossil samples: an empirical assessment. Paleobiology 30:487506.
Ikeya, N., and Ueda, H.. 1988. Morphological variations of Cytheromorpha acupunctata (Brady) in continuous populations at Hamana-ko Bay, Japan. Pp. 319340 in T. Hanai, N. Ikeya, and K. Ishizaki, eds. Evolutionary biology of Ostracoda. Elsevier, Kodansha, Japan.
Israelsky, M. C. 1929. Upper Cretaceous Ostracoda of Arkansas. Arkansas Geological Survey Bulletin 2:128.
Jennings, P. H. 1936. A microfauna from the Monmouth and basal Rancocos of New Jersey. Bulletins of American Paleontology 23(78):159234.
Johnstone, R. A. 1995. Sexual selection, honest advertisement and the handicap principle: reviewing the evidence. Biological Reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 70(1):165.
Kamiya, T. 1992. Heterochronic dimorphism of Loxoconcha uranouchiensis (Ostracoda) and its implications for speciation. Paleobiology 18:221236.
Karubian, J., and Swaddle, J. P.. 2001. Selection on females can create “larger males.”. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 268:725728.
Knell, R. J., Naish, D., Tomkins, J. L., and Hone, D. W. E.. 2013. Sexual selection in prehistoric animals: detection and implications. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 28:3847.
, J., Unwin, D. M., Deeming, D. C., Jin, X., Liu, Y., and Ji, Q.. 2011. An egg-adult association, gender, and reproduction in pterosaurs. Science 331:321324.
Makowski, H. 1962. Problem of sexual dimoprhism in ammonites. Palaeontologia Polonica 12:190.
Marsson, T. 1880. Die Cirripeden und Ostracoden der weißen Schreibkreide der Insel Ruegen. Naturwissenschaft, Neu-Pommern, Ruegen 12:150.
Martins, M. J., Hunt, G., Lockwood, R., Swaddle, J. P., and Horne, D. J.. 2017. Correlation between investment in sexual traits and valve sexual dimorphism in Cyprideis species (Ostracoda). PLoS ONE 12:e0177791.
Matzke-Karasz, R., Neil, J. V., Smith, R. J., Symonova, R., Morkovsky, L., Archer, M., Hand, S. J., Cloetens, P., and Tafforeau, P.. 2014. Subcellular preservation in giant ostracod sperm from an early Miocene cave deposit in Australia. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 281(1786):20140394.
Morrow, E. H., and Pitcher, T. E.. 2003. Sexual selection and the risk of extinction in birds. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 270:17931799.
Ozawa, H. 2013. The history of sexual dimorphism in Ostracoda (Arthropoda, Crustacea) since the Palaeozoic. Pp. 5180 in H. Moriyama, ed. Sexual dimorphism. InTech, Rijeka, Croatia.
Price, J. J., Lanyon, S. M., and Omland, K. E.. 2009. Losses of female song with changes from tropical to temperate breeding in the New World blackbirds. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 276:19711980.
Puckett, T. M. 1994. New Ostracoda species from an Upper Cretaceous oyster reef, northern Gulf Coastal Plain, USA. Journal of Paleontology 68:13211335.
Puckett, T. M. 1996. Ecological atlas of Upper Cretaceous ostracodes of Alabama. Geological Survey of Alabama Monograph 14:1176.
Puckett, T. M. 2002. Systematics and paleobiogeography of brachycytherine Ostracoda. Micropaleontology 48:187.
Rohlf, F. J. 2013. tpsDIG, version 2.17. SUNY Stonybrook.
Schmidt, R. A. M. 1948. Ostracoda from the Upper Cretaceous and Lower Eocene of Maryland, Delaware, and Virginia. Journal of Paleontology 22:389431.
Shine, R. 1989. Ecological causes for the evolution of sexual dimorphism: a review of the evidence. Quarterly Review of Biology 64:419461.
Siveter, D. J., Sutton, M. D., Briggs, D. E. G., and Siveter, D. J.. 2003. An ostracode crustacean with soft parts from the Lower Silurian. Science 302:17491751.
Skinner, H. C. 1956. Ostracoda from basal Arkadelphia Marl exposures near Hope, Arkansas. Transactions of the Gulf Coast Association of Geological Societies 6:179204.
Smith, J. K. 1978. Ostracoda of the Prairie Bluff Chalk, Upper Cretaceous, (Maestrichtian) and the Pine Barren Member of the Clayton Formation, Lower Paleocene (Danian) from exposures along Alabama State Highway 263 in Lowndes County, Alabama. Transactions of the Gulf Coast Association of Geological Societies 28:539579.
Swain, F. M. 1948. Ostracoda in Cretaceous and Tertiary subsurface geology. Maryland Department of Geology, Mines, and Water Resources Bulletin 2:187212.
Swain, F. M. 1952. Ostracoda from wells in North Carolina: Part 2. Mesozoic Ostracoda. United States Geological Survey Professional Paper 234-B:59–93.
Swain, F. M., and Brown, P. M.. 1964. Cretaceous Ostracoda from wells in the southeastern United States. North Carolina Department of Conservation and Development Bulletin 78:155.
van Harten, D. 1983. Resource competition as a possible cause of sex ratio in benthic ostracodes. Pp. 568580 in R. F. Maddocks, ed. Applications of Ostracoda. Department of Geosciences, University of Houston, Houston, Tex.
van Morkhoven, F. P. C. M. 1962. Post-Paleozoic Ostracoda. Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Van Valkenburgh, B., and Sacco, T.. 2002. Sexual dimorphism, social behavior, and intrasexual competition in large Pleistocene carnivorans. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 22:164169.
Vandekerkhove, J., Matzke-Karasz, R., Mezquita, F., and Rossetti, G.. 2007. Experimental assessment of the fecundity of Eucypris virens (Ostracoda, Crustacea) under natural sex ratios. Freshwater Biology 52:10581064.


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed