Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-xtgtn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-19T17:51:27.084Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

WALLS, GATES AND STORIES: DETECTING ROME'S RIVERSIDE DEFENCES

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  31 March 2021

T.P. Wiseman
Get access

Abstract

The construction date of the ‘Servian’ wall and its layout in the riverside area between the Aventine and the Capitol are the two main questions addressed in this article. The interlocking topographical problems were addressed in 1988 by Filippo Coarelli, whose interpretation has become the generally accepted orthodoxy. But not all the difficulties have been solved, and with Coarelli's recent return to the subject a fresh examination of the evidence may be helpful. Careful attention is given here to stories of early Rome that involve the walls and gates, as reported in Livy, Dionysius and Plutarch; they are not, of course, taken as authentic evidence for the time of the alleged events, but as indicating what was taken for granted when the stories were first composed. New suggestions are made about a revision of the line of the city wall in 212 BC and the consequent restructuring of two important gates, the Porta Carmentalis and the Porta Trigemina; the mysterious ‘Porta Triumphalis’ is discussed separately in an appendix.

La data di costruzione delle mura “serviane” e la loro disposizione nell'area della riva del fiume tra l'Aventino e il Campidoglio sono le due principali questioni affrontate in questo articolo. Gli intricati problemi topografici sono stati affrontati nel 1988 da Filippo Coarelli, la cui interpretazione è diventata l'ortodossia generalmente accettata. Ma non tutte le difficoltà sono state risolte, e con il recente ritorno di Coarelli sull'argomento un nuovo riesame delle evidenze può essere utile. Particolare attenzione è data in questa sede alle storie della prima Roma che coinvolgono le mura e le porte, come riportato in Livio, Dionisio e Plutarco. Queste non sono, ovviamente, prese come prove autentiche per l'epoca dei presunti eventi, ma come un'indicazione di ciò che era dato per scontato quando le storie furono composte per la prima volta. Vengono avanzati nuovi suggerimenti in merito a una revisione della linea della cinta muraria nel 212 a.C. e alla conseguente ristrutturazione di due importanti porte, la Porta Carmentalis e la Porta Trigemina. La misteriosa “Porta Triumphalis” è discussa separatamente in un'appendice.

Type
Articles
Information
Papers of the British School at Rome , Volume 89 , October 2021 , pp. 9 - 40
Copyright
Copyright © British School at Rome 2021

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Ammerman, A.J. (1990) On the origins of the Roman Forum. American Journal of Archaeology 94: 627–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ammerman, A. (2006) Adding time to Rome's imago. In Haselberger, L. and Humphrey, J. (eds), Imaging Ancient Rome: Documentation — Visualization — Imagination (JRA Supplement 61): 297–308. Portsmouth (RI), Journal of Roman Archaeology.Google Scholar
Armstrong, J. (2016) War and Society in Early Rome: From Warlords to Generals. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bariviera, C. (2012) Regione XI: Circus Maximus. In Carandini, A. and Carafa, P. (eds), Atlante di Roma antica: biografia e ritratti della città: 421–5. Milan, Electa.Google Scholar
Beard, M. (2007) The Roman Triumph. Cambridge (MA), Belknap Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bernard, S.G. (2012) Continuing the debate on Rome's earliest circuit walls. Papers of the British School at Rome 80: 1–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brands, G. (1988) Republikanische Stadttore in Italien (British Archaeological Reports, International Series 458). Oxford, British Archaeological Reports.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bruno, D. (2012a) Regione X: Palatium. In Carandini, A. and Carafa, P. (eds), Atlante di Roma antica: biografia e ritratti della città: 5–80. Milan, Electa.Google Scholar
Bruno, D. (2012b) Regione XIII: Aventinus. In Carandini, A. and Carafa, P. (eds), Atlante di Roma antica: biografia e ritratti della città: 388–420. Milan, Electa.Google Scholar
Campbell, B. (2000) The Writings of the Roman Land Surveyors: Introduction, Text, Translation and Commentary (JRS Monograph 9). London, Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies.Google Scholar
Carandini, A. and Carafa, P. (2012) (eds) Atlante di Roma antica: biografia e ritratti della città. Milan, Electa.Google Scholar
Carandini, A. and Carafa, P. (2017) (eds) The Atlas of Ancient Rome: Biography and Portraits of the City. Princeton and Oxford, Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Cifani, G. (2008) Architettura romana arcaica: edilizia e società tra monarchia e repubblica. Rome, “L'Erma” di Bretschneider.Google Scholar
Cifani, G. (2012) Le mura serviane. In Carandini, A. and Carafa, P. (eds), Atlante di Roma antica: biografia e ritratti della città: 81–4. Milan, Electa.Google Scholar
Coarelli, F. (1968) La porta trionfale e la via dei trionfi. Dialoghi di archeologia 2: 55–103.Google Scholar
Coarelli, F. (1974) Guida archeologica di Roma. Milan, Mondadori.Google Scholar
Coarelli, F. (1985) Il foro romano: periodo repubblicano e augusteo. Rome, Quasar.Google Scholar
Coarelli, F. (1988) Il foro boario dalle origini alle fine della repubblica. Rome, Quasar.Google Scholar
Coarelli, F. (1996) Porta Triumphalis. In Steinby, E.M. (ed.), Lexicon Topographicum Urbis Romae III: 333–4. Rome, Quasar.Google Scholar
Coarelli, F. (1999) Pons Aemilius. In Steinby, E.M. (ed.), Lexicon Topographicum Urbis Romae IV: 106–7. Rome, Quasar.Google Scholar
Coarelli, F. (2007) Rome and Environs: An Archaeological Guide. Berkeley and Los Angeles, University of California Press.Google Scholar
Coarelli, F. (2011) Le origini di Roma: la cultura artistica dalle origini al III secolo a.C. Milan, Jaca Book.Google Scholar
Coarelli, F. (2019) Statio: i luoghi di amministrazione nell'antica Roma. Rome, Quasar.Google Scholar
Crawford, M.H. (1974) Roman Republican Coinage. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
D'Alessio, M.T. (2012) Regione IX: Circus Flaminius. In Carandini, A. and Carafa, P. (eds), Atlante di Roma antica: biografia e ritratti della città: 493–541. Milan, Electa.Google Scholar
D'Arms, J.H. (1967) Roman Campania: two passages from Cicero's correspondence. American Journal of Philology 88: 195–202.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davies, P.J.E. (2017) Architecture and Politics in Republican Rome. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Diffendale, D., Brocato, P., Terrenato, N. and Brock, A. (2016) Sant'Omobono: an interim status quaestionis. Journal of Roman Archaeology 29: 7–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Favro, D. (2018) Urban commemoration: the pompa triumphalis in Rome. In Holleran, C. and Claridge, A. (eds), A Companion to the City of Rome: 599–618. Hoboken (NJ), Wiley Blackwell.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Feeney, D. (2007) Caesar's Calendar: Ancient Time and the Beginnings of History (Sather Classical Lectures 65). Berkeley and Los Angeles, University of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Filippi, D. (2012) Regione VIII: Forum Romanum Magnum. In Carandini, A. and Carafa, P. (eds), Atlante di Roma antica: biografia e ritratti della città: 143–206. Milan, Electa.Google Scholar
Flower, H.I. (1996) Ancestor Masks and Aristocratic Power in Roman Culture. Oxford, Clarendon Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fraioli, F. (2012) Regione IV: Templum Pacis. In Carandini, A. and Carafa, P. (eds), Atlante di Roma antica: biografia e ritratti della città: 281–306. Milan, Electa.Google Scholar
Fulminante, F. (2014) The Urbanization of Rome and Latium Vetus: From the Bronze Age to the Archaic Era. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goodman, P.J. (2018) Defining the city: the boundaries of Rome. In Holleran, C. and Claridge, A. (eds), A Companion to the City of Rome: 71–91. Hoboken (NJ), Wiley Blackwell.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Grandazzi, A. (2017) Urbs: Histoire de la ville de Rome, des origines à la mort d'Auguste. Paris, Perrin.Google Scholar
Haselberger, L. (2002) Muri: Forum Bovarium-Tiberis. In Haselberger, L., Romano, D.G., Dumser, E.A. and Borbonus, D. (eds), Mapping Augustan Rome (JRA Supplementary Series 50): 174–6. Portsmouth (RI): Journal of Roman Archaeology.Google Scholar
Haselberger, L., Romano, D.G., Dumser, E.A. and Borbonus, D. (2002) (eds) Mapping Augustan Rome (JRA Supplementary Series 50). Portsmouth (RI): Journal of Roman Archaeology.Google Scholar
Häuber, C. (2014) The Eastern Part of the Mons Oppius in Rome (BCAR Supplement 22). Rome, “L'Erma” di Bretschneider.Google Scholar
Holleran, C. and Claridge, A. (2018) (eds) A Companion to the City of Rome. Hoboken (NJ), Wiley Blackwell.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hölscher, T. (2018) Visual Power in Ancient Greece and Rome (Sather Classical Lectures 73). Oakland, University of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hopkins, J.N. (2016) The Genesis of Roman Architecture. New Haven and London, Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Le Gall, J. (1953) Le Tibre fleuve de Rome dans l'Antiquité. Paris, Presses universitaires de France.Google Scholar
Lugli, G. (1970) Itinerario di Roma antica. Milan, Periodici scientifici.Google Scholar
Lugli, F. and Rosa, C. (2001) Prime evidenze di opere di terrazzamento del Capitolium nell'età del Bronzo recente. Bullettino della Commissione Archeologica Comunale di Roma 102: 281–90.Google Scholar
Lyngby, H. (1954) Beiträge zur Topographie des Forum-boarium-Gebietes in Rom: Testimonien nebst Kommentar und kritischen Apparat (Acta Instituti Romani Regni Sueciae 7). Lund, Gleerup.Google Scholar
Lyngby, H. (1959a) Clivus Publicius und Porta Trigemina. Eranos 57: 62–6.Google Scholar
Lyngby, H. (1959b) Topographische Fragen des Forum-Boarium-Gebietes in Rom. Eranos 57: 132–49.Google Scholar
Lyngby, H. (1961) Porta Minucia. Eranos 59: 136–64.Google Scholar
Lyngby, H. (1963) Das Problem der Porta Triumphalis im Licht der neuesten archäologischen Entdeckungen. Eranos 61: 161–75.Google Scholar
Lyngby, H. (1968) Ricerche sulla Porta Trigemina. Opuscula Romana 6 (Acta Instituti Romani Regni Sueciae 29): 75–96.Google Scholar
Lyngby, H., Polia, M. and Pisano Sartorio, G. (1974) Ricerche sulla Porta Flumentana. Opuscula Romana 8 (Acta Instituti Romani Regni Sueciae 31): 33–52.Google Scholar
Nash, E. (1968) Pictorial Dictionary of Ancient Rome. London, Thames and Hudson.Google Scholar
Oakley, S.P. (1997) A Commentary on Livy Books VI–X, vol. I. Oxford, Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Östenberg, I. (2010) Circum metas fertur: an alternative reading of the triumphal route. Historia 59: 303–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Palmer, R.E.A. (1976–7) The Vici Luccei in the Forum Boarium and some Lucceii in Rome. Bullettino della Commissione Archeologica Comunale di Roma 85: 135–61.Google Scholar
Panciera, S. (2006) Epigrafi, epigrafia, epigrafisti: scritti vari editi e inediti (1956–2005) con note complementari e indici (Vetera 16). Rome, Quasar.Google Scholar
Parisi Presicce, C. (2019) La prima Roma. Uno sguardo d'insieme. In Damiani, I. and Presicce, C. Parisi (eds), La Roma dei re. Il racconto dell'archeologia: 19–28. Rome, Gangemi.Google Scholar
Pensabene, P. (1998) Vent'anni di studi e scavi dell'Università di Roma “La Sapienza” nell'area sud-ovest del Palatino (1977–1997). In Giavarini, C. (ed.), Il Palatino: area sacra sud-ovest e Domus Tiberiana (Studia archaeologica 95): 1–154. Rome, “L'Erma” di Bretschneider.Google Scholar
Pisani Sartorio, G. (1995) Fortuna et Mater Matuta, aedes. In Steinby, E.M. (ed.), Lexicon Topographicum Urbis Romae 2: 281–5. Rome, Quasar.Google Scholar
Platner, S.B. and Ashby, T. (1929) A Topographical Dictionary of Ancient Rome. London, Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Rice, C.M. (2018) Rivers, roads, and ports. In Holleran, C. and Claridge, A. (eds), A Companion to the City of Rome: 199–217. Hoboken (NJ), Wiley Blackwell.Google Scholar
Richardson, L. jr (1992) A New Topographical Dictionary of Ancient Rome. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Richardson, J.H. (2012) The Fabii and the Gauls: Studies in Historical Thought and Historiography in Republican Rome (Historia Einzelschriften 222). Stuttgart, Franz Steiner.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Richardson, J.H. (2015) Andreas Alföldi and the adventure(s) of the Vibenna brothers. In Richardson, J.H. and Santangelo, F. (eds), Andreas Alföldi in the Twenty-First Century (HABES 56): 111–30. Stuttgart, Franz Steiner.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Richardson, J.H. (2020) Kings and Consuls: Eight Essays on Roman History, Historiography and Political Thought. Oxford, Peter Lang.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rodgers, R.H. (2004) (ed.) Frontinus: De Aquaeductu (Cambridge Classical Texts and Commentaries 42). Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Ruggiero, I. (1991) La cinta muraria presso il Foro Boario in età arcaica e medio-repubblicana. Archeologia laziale 10: 23–30.Google Scholar
Säflund, G. (1932) Le mura di Roma repubblicana (Acta Instituti Romani Regni Sueciae 1). Lund, Gleerup.Google Scholar
Scheid, J. (1998) Commentarii fratrum Arvalium qui supersunt: Les copies épigraphiques des protocols annuels de la confrérie arvale (21 av.–304 ap. J.-C.) (Roma antica 4). Rome, École française de Rome.Google Scholar
Sumi, G.S. (2018) The triumphal procession. In Holleran, C. and Claridge, A. (eds), A Companion to the City of Rome: 583–97. Hoboken (NJ), Wiley Blackwell.Google Scholar
Torelli, M. (1993) Columna Minucia. In Steinby, E.M. (ed.), Lexicon Topographicum Urbis Romae I: 305–7. Rome, Quasar.Google Scholar
von Gerkan, A. (1931) Der Lauf der römischen Stadtmauer vom Kapitol zum Aventin. Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts, Römische Abteilung 46: 153–88.Google Scholar
von Gerkan, A. (1955) Review of Lyngby (1954). Göttingische gelehrte Anziegen 209: 256–63.Google Scholar
von Gerkan, A. (1963) Porta Trigemina. Archäologische Anzeiger 83: 104–18.Google Scholar
Weinstock, S. (1971) Divus Julius. Oxford, Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Wiseman, T.P. (1979) Topography and rhetoric: the trial of Manlius. Historia 28: 32–50.Google Scholar
Wiseman, T.P. (1990) Review of Coarelli (1988). Gnomon 62: 730–4.Google Scholar
Wiseman, T.P. (1996) The Minucii and their monument. In Linderski, J. (ed.), Imperium Sine Fine: T. Robert S. Broughton and the Roman Republic (Historia Einzelschriften 105): 57–74. Stuttgart, Franz Steiner.Google Scholar
Wiseman, T.P. (2008a) Rethinking the triumph. Journal of Roman Archaeology 21: 389–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wiseman, T.P. (2008b) Unwritten Rome. Exeter, University of Exeter Press.Google Scholar
Wiseman, T.P. (2016) Varro's biography of the Roman people. Histos 10: cxi–cxxviii.Google Scholar
Wiseman, T.P. (2020) Romulus to Tarquin: reconstructing Rome's expansion. Journal of Roman Archaeology 33: 527–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ziółkowski, A. (2019) From Roma Quadrata to la grande Roma dei Tarquini: A Study of the Literary Tradition on Rome's Territorial Growth under the Kings (Potsdamer Altertumswissenschaftliche Beiträge 70). Stuttgart, Franz Steiner.CrossRefGoogle Scholar