Skip to main content

Questioning the universality of the syllable: evidence from Japanese*

  • Laurence Labrune (a1)

This paper reexamines the issue of the mora, the foot and the syllable in Tokyo Japanese, and shows that whereas the mora and the foot are indisputably present and active, the evidence for the syllable is inconspicuous and disputable. Building on this observation, I claim that Tokyo Japanese makes no use of the syllable. Instead, two types of mora are distinguished: regular CV moras and weak (deficient) moras. Weak moras include the moraic nasal, the first part of a geminate and the second part of a long vowel, as well as moras containing an onsetless vowel, a devoiced vowel or an epenthetic vowel. I further argue that feet obey a set of structural constraints stipulating that they be properly headed by a regular full mora. With this enriched notion of mora type, the paper argues that neither the syllable nor any other level of the prosodic hierarchy is obligatory in all languages.

Hide All
Akinaga Kazue (1968). Iwayuru tokushu onsetsu (tokushu haku) ni tsuite. [Concerning the so-called special syllables (special moras).] Kôza nihongo kyôiku [Teaching Japanese as a second language] 4. 3651.
Bagemihl Bruce (1991). Syllable structure in Bella Coola. LI 22. 589646.
Beckman Jill N. (1999). Positional faithfulness: an Optimality Theoretic treatment of phonological asymmetries. New York: Garland.
Beckman Mary & Shoji Atsuko (1984). Spectral and perceptual evidence for CV coarticulation in devoiced /si/ and /syu/ in Japanese. Phonetica 41. 6171.
Bloch Bernard (1950). Studies in colloquial Japanese IV: phonemics. Lg 26. 86–125. Reprinted in Roy Andrew Miller (ed.) (1970). Bernard Bloch on Japanese. New Haven & London: Yale University Press. 113–165.
Burzio Luigi (1994). Principles of English stress. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Campbell Nick & Sagisaka Yoshinori (1991). Moraic and syllable-level effects on speech timing. IEICJ Technical Report SP90-107. 3540.
Chomsky Noam & Halle Morris (1968). The sound pattern of English. New York: Harper & Row.
Davis Stuart (1988). Syllable onsets as a factor in stress rules. Phonology 5. 119.
Downing Laura J. (1998). On the prosodic misalignment of onsetless syllables. NLLT 16. 152.
Durand Jacques & Lyche Chantal (2004). Structure et variation dans quelques systèmes vocaliques du français: l'enquête Phonologie du français contemporain (PFC). In Coveney Aisan, Hintze Marie-Anne & Sanders Carol (eds.) Variation et francophonie. Paris: L'Harmattan. 217240.
Evans Nicholas & Levinson Stephen C. (2009). The myth of language universals: language diversity and its importance for cognitive science. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 32. 429448.
Everett Dan & Everett Keren (1984). On the relevance of syllable onsets to stress placement. LI 15. 705711.
Faber Alice & Vance Timothy J. (2000). More acoustic traces of ‘deleted’ vowels in Japanese. In Nakayama Mineharu & Quinn Charles J. Jr. (eds.) Japanese/Korean linguistics. Vol. 9. Stanford: CSLI. 100113.
Féry Caroline & de Vijver Ruben van (eds.) (2003). The syllable in Optimality Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Fudge E. C. (1969). Syllables. JL 5. 253286.
Golston Chris & van der Hulst Harry (1999). Stricture is structure. In Hermans Ben & van Oostendorp Marc (eds.) The derivational residue in phonological Optimality Theory. Amsterdam: Benjamins. 153173.
Han Mieko S. (1994). Acoustic manifestations of mora timing in Japanese. JASA 96. 7382.
Haraguchi Shosuke (1977). The tone pattern of Japanese: an autosegmental theory of tonology. Tokyo: Kaitakusha.
Haraguchi Shosuke (1991). A theory of stress and accent. Dordrecht: Foris.
Haraguchi Shosuke (1999). Accent. In Tsujimura (1999). 130.
Haraguchi Shosuke (2003). The phonology–phonetics interface and Syllabic Theory. In de Weijer Jeroen van, van Heuven Vincent J. & Hulst Harry van der (eds.) The phonological spectrum. Vol. 2: Suprasegmental structure. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: Benjamins. 3158.
Hattori Shirô (1954). On'inron kara mita kokugo no akusento. [Japanese accent from a phonological perspective.] Kokugo KenkyÛ 2–3. Reprinted in Takeshi Shibata, Hajime Kitamura & Haruhiko Kindaichi (eds.) (1980). Nihon no gengogaku. [Linguistics in Japan.] Vol. 2: On'in. [Phonology.] Tokyo: TaishÛkan. 364404.
Hayes Bruce (1989). Compensatory lengthening in moraic phonology. LI 20. 253306.
Hayes Bruce (1995). Metrical stress theory: principles and case studies. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Higurashi Yoshiko (1983). The accent of extended word structures in Tokyo Standard Japanese. Tokyo: EDUCA.
Hirayama Teruo et al. (1993). Gendai nihongo hôgen daijiten. [Comprehensive dictionary of Modern Japanese dialects.] 9 vols. Tokyo: Meiji Shoin.
Hockett Charles F. (1955). A manual of phonology. Baltimore: Waverly Press.
Homma Yayoi (1981). Durational relationship between Japanese stops and vowels. JPh 9. 273281.
Hyman Larry M. (2003). A theory of phonological weight. Reissue edition, with a foreword by William R. Leben. Stanford: CSLI. Originally published 1985, Dordrecht: Foris.
Hyman Larry M. (2008). Universals in phonology. The Linguistic Review 25. 83–137.
Hyman Larry M. (2009). How (not) to do phonological typology: the case of pitch-accent. Language Sciences 31. 213238.
Hyman Larry M. (2011). Does Gokana really have no syllables? Or: what's so great about being universal? Phonology 28. 5585.
Idemaru Kaori (2005). An acoustic and perceptual investigation of the geminate and singleton stop contrast in Japanese. PhD dissertation, University of Oregon.
Itô Junko (1990). Prosodic minimality in Japanese. CLS 26:2. 213239.
Ito Junko & Mester Armin (2003). Weak layering and word binarity. In Honma Takeru, Okazaki Masao, Tabata Toshiyuki & Tanaka Shin'ichi (eds.) A new century of phonology and phonological theory: a Festschrift for Professor Shosuke Haraguchi on the occasion of his sixtieth birthday. Tokyo: Kaitakusha. 2665.
Kager René (1997). Rhythmic vowel deletion in Optimality Theory. In Roca Iggy (ed.) Derivations and constraints in phonology. Oxford: Clarendon. 463499.
Katada Fusa (1990). On the representation of moras: evidence from a language game. LI 21. 641646.
Kelly Michael H. (2004). Word onset patterns and lexical stress in English. Journal of Memory and Language 50. 231244.
Kenstowicz Michael (1994). Sonority-driven stress. Ms, MIT. Available as ROA-33 from the Rutgers Optimality Archive.
Kindaichi Haruhiko (1972). Onsetsu, môra oyobi haku. [Syllable, mora and haku.] Nihongo on'in no kenkyÛ. [Research in Japanese phonology.] Tokyo: Tôkyôdô Shuppan. 5877.
Kindaichi Haruhiko & Akinaga Kazue (eds.) (2001). Shinmeikai nihongo akusento jiten. [Shinmeikai Japanese accent dictionary.] Tokyo: Shinmeikai.
Kohler K. J. (1966). Is the syllable a phonological universal? JL 2. 207208.
Kubozono Haruo (1985). Speech errors and syllable structure. Linguistics and Philology 6. 220243.
Kubozono Haruo (1989). The mora and syllable structure in Japanese: evidence from speech errors. Language and Speech 32. 249278.
Kubozono Haruo (1994). Nihongo no onsetsuryô ni tsuite. [Syllable quantity in Japanese.] Kokugogaku 178. 7–17.
Kubozono Haruo (1995). Perceptual evidence for the mora in Japanese. In Connell Bruce & Arvaniti Amalia (eds.) Phonology and phonetic evidence: papers in laboratory phonology IV. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 141156.
Kubozono Haruo (1996). Syllable and accent in Japanese: evidence from loanword accentuation. Onsei Kaihô [Bulletin of the Phonetic Society of Japan] 211. 7182.
Kubozono Haruo (1998). Môra to onsetsu no huhensei. [On the universality of mora and syllable.] Journal of the Phonetic Society of Japan 2:1. 5–15.
Kubozono Haruo (1999). Mora and syllable. In Tsujimura (1999). 3161.
Kubozono Haruo (2003). The syllable as a unit of prosodic organization in Japanese. In Féry & van de Vijver (2003). 99–122.
Kubozono Haruo (2006a). Phonetic and phonological organization of speech in Japanese. In Nakayama Mineharu, Mazuka Reiko & Shirai Yasuhiro (eds.) The handbook of East Asian psycholinguistics. Vol. 2: Japanese. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 191200.
Kubozono Haruo (2006b). Where does loanword prosody come from? A case study of Japanese loanword accent. Lingua 116. 11401170.
Kureta Yoichi, Fushimi Takao & Tatsumi Itaru F. (2006). The functional unit of phonological encoding: evidence for moraic representation in native Japanese speakers. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition 32. 11021119.
Labrune Laurence (2002). The prosodic structure of simple abbreviated loanwords in Japanese: a constraint-based account. Journal of the Phonetic Society of Japan 6:1. 98–120.
Labrune Laurence (2007). Morphophonologie des emprunts abrégés en japonais: aspects prosodiques et mélodiques. In Delais-Roussarie Elisabeth & Labrune ( Laurenceeds.) Des sons et des sens, données et modèles en phonologie et en morphologie. Paris: Hermès. 173198.
Labrune Laurence (2012). The phonology of Japanese. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lin Yen-Hwei (1997). Syllabic and moraic structures in Piro. Phonology 14. 403436.
Lowenstamm Jean (1996). CV as the only syllable type. In Durand Jacques & Laks Bernard (eds.) Current trends in phonology: models and methods. Salford: ESRI. 419441.
McCawley James D. (1968). The phonological component of a grammar of Japanese. The Hague & Paris: Mouton.
Maddieson Ian (1985). Phonetic cues to syllabification. In Fromkin Victoria A. (ed.) Phonetic linguistics: essays in honor of Peter Ladefoged. Orlando: Academic Press. 203221.
Mehler Jacques, Dommergues Jean Yves & Frauenfelder Uli (1981). The syllable's role in speech segmentation. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 20. 298305.
Miyake Takeo (1943). Kokumin gakkô akusento kaisetsu daiichigakunen yô. [Comments on accent for first year level in public schools.] Tokyo: Kokugo Bunka Kenkyuujo.
Nespor Marina & Vogel Irene (1986). Prosodic phonology. Dordrecht: Foris.
Newman Stanley (1947). Bella Coola I: phonology. IJAL 13. 129134.
NHK (1998). Nihongo hatsuon akusento jiten. [A dictionary of Japanese pronunciation and accentuation.] Tokyo: NHK.
Ogasawara Naomi & Warner Natasha (2009). Processing missing vowels: allophonic processing in Japanese. Language and Cognitive Processes 24. 376411.
Otake Takashi & Cutler Anne (1996). Phonological structure and language processing: cross-linguistic studies. Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Otake Takashi, Hatano Giyoo, Cutler Anne & Mehler Jacques (1993). Mora or syllable? Speech segmentation in Japanese. Journal of Memory and Language 32. 258278.
Pierrehumbert Janet B. & Beckman Mary E. (1988). Japanese tone structure. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
Poser William J. (1984). The phonetics and phonology of tone and intonation in Japanese. PhD dissertation, MIT.
Poser William J. (1990). Evidence for foot structure in Japanese. Lg 66. 78–105.
Prince Alan & Smolensky Paul (1993). Optimality Theory: constraint interaction in generative grammar. Ms, Rutgers University & University of Colorado, Boulder. Published 2004, Malden, Mass. & Oxford: Blackwell.
Satô Ryôichi (2002). Gendai nihongo no hatsuon bunpu. [Geographical distribution of phones in modern Japanese.] In Hida Yoshifumi & Satô Takeyoshi (eds.) Gendai nihongo kôza. [Lectures on Contemporary Japanese.] Vol. 3. Tokyo: Meiji Shoin. 2039.
Scheer Tobias (2004). A lateral theory of phonology: what is CVCV, and why should it be? Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Schiering René, Bickel Balthazar & Hildebrandt Kristine A. (2010). The prosodic word is not universal, but emergent. JL 46. 657709.
Selkirk Elisabeth (1984). Phonology and syntax: the relation between sound and structure. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.
Selkirk Elisabeth (1995). The prosodic structure of function words. In Beckman Jill N., Dickey Laura Walsh & Urbanczyk Suzanne (eds.) Papers in Optimality Theory. Amherst: GLSA. 439469.
Shinohara Shigeko (2000). Default accentuation and foot structure in Japanese: evidence from Japanese adaptations of French words. Journal of East Asian Linguistics 9. 5596.
Tanaka Shin'ichi (1998). Hutto-nai ni okeru boin no kikoe to hukugôgo akusento. [Compound accent and vowel sonority within the foot.] Journal of the Phonetic Society of Japan 2:1. 5062.
Tanaka Shin'ichi (2008). Rizumu-akusento no ‘yure’ to on'in-keitai kôzô. [Accent rhythm variation and the phonological and morphological structure of words.] Tokyo: Kurosio.
Tanaka Shin-ichi (2001). Optional optimality and optimal optionality: an integrated model of accent and accent shift phenomena in Japanesecitation id="ref089". Paper presented at the Phonology Forum, Meikai University, Tokyo.
Terao Yasushi (1992). Bunsanshutsu kenkyÛ kara mita onsetsu – mora. [Mora and syllable from the point of view of dispersion theory.] Nihongo no môra to onsetsu kôzô ni kansuru sôgôteki kenkyÛ. [Comprehensive studies on mora and syllable structure in Japanese.] Vol. 1. Tsukuba: University of Tsukuba. 6275.
Terao Yasushi (2002). Iimachigai ha dôshite okoru? [Why do slips of the tongue occur?] Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.
Terao Yasushi (2008). Iimachigai shiryô ni yoru gengo sanshutsu moderu no kenshô. [Comparing language production models: evidence from Japanese speech errors.] Journal of the Phonetic Society of Japan 12. 1727.
Topintzi Nina (2010). Onsets: suprasegmental and prosodic behaviour. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Trubetzkoy Nikolai S. (1939). Grundzüge der Phonologie. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
Tsujimura Natsuko (ed.) (1999). The handbook of Japanese linguistics. Malden, Mass. & Oxford: Blackwell.
Ujihira Akira & Kubozono Haruo (1994). A phonetic and phonological analysis of stuttering in Japanese. Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Spoken Language Processing (ICSLP 94). Yokohama: Acoustical Society of Japan. 11951199.
Uwano Zendô (2003). Akusento no taikei to shikumi. [The mechanics and system of Japanese accent.] In Kitahara Yasuo & Uwano Zendô (eds.) Asakura nihongo kôza. [Asakura lectures on Japanese.] Vol. 3: Onsei – on'in. [Phonetics – phonology.] Tokyo: Asakura Shuppan. 6184.
Vance Timothy J. (1987). An introduction to Japanese phonology. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Vance Timothy J. (2008). The sounds of Japanese. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Verdonschot Rinus (2011). Word processing in languages using non-alphabetic scripts: the case of Japanese and Chinese. PhD dissertation, University of Leiden.
Warner Natasha & Arai Takayuki (2001). Japanese mora-timing: a review. Phonetica 58. 125.
Yokotani Teruo (1997). Hutto gyôkai wo koeru akusento idô: tôkyô hôgen hukugô meishi kara no shôko. [Accent shift beyond the foot boundary: evidence from Tokyo Japanese compound nouns.] Journal of the Phonetic Society of Japan 1. 5462.
Yoshida Shohei (1990). A government-based analysis of the ‘mora’ in Japanese. Phonology 7. 331351.
Yoshida Shohei (1991). Some aspects of governing relations in Japanese phonology. PhD dissertation, SOAS.
Zec Draga (1988). Sonority constraints on syllable structure. PhD dissertation, Stanford University.
Zec Draga (2003). Prosodic weight. In Féry & van de Vijver (2003). 123143.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

  • ISSN: 0952-6757
  • EISSN: 1469-8188
  • URL: /core/journals/phonology
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 6
Total number of PDF views: 105 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 235 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 23rd January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.