Skip to main content

Vowel dispersion and Kazakh labial harmony

  • Adam G. McCollum (a1)

This paper uses novel data showing gradient labial harmony in Kazakh to compare Kaun's (1995) feature-based analysis with a dispersion-based analysis in a Maximum Entropy Harmonic Grammar. The paper demonstrates that the dispersion-based analysis better fits the Kazakh data than Kaun's analysis, and then extends it to account for four languages with harmony patterns different from that in Kazakh. The paper also argues that the dispersion-based account provides a better analysis of the typology of labial harmony than Kaun's feature-based analysis.

Corresponding author
Hide All

I am particularly grateful to the Kazakh speakers who have shared so much of their time, language and culture with me. This work emerged from my master's thesis at the University of Florida, and has been greatly improved through discussions with Eric Baković, Marc Garellek, Brent Henderson, Jaye Padgett, Sharon Rose, Ratree Wayland and Caroline Wiltshire, as well as the careful comments from three anonymous reviewers and the editors. Additionally, I received many helpful comments from the audiences at the 2015 CUNY Phonology Forum, Tu+1, UC Santa Cruz's Phlunch and SCAMP 2016, where earlier versions of this work were presented. Any errors are my own.

Hide All
Abramson, Arthur S. & Ren, Nianqi (1990). Distinctive vowel length: duration vs. spectrum in Thai. JPh 18. 7992.
Abuov, Zhoumaghaly (1994). The phonetics of Kazakh and the theory of synharmonism. UCLA Working Papers in Phonetics 88. 3953.
Ainsworth, W. A. (1972). Duration as a cue in the recognition of synthetic vowels. JASA 51. 648651.
Andersen, Torben (1999). Vowel harmony and vowel alternation in Mayak (Western Nilotic). Studies in African Linguistics 28. 129.
Andersen, Torben (2007). Kurmuk phonology. Studies in African Linguistics 36. 2990.
Anttila, Arto (1997). Deriving variation from grammar. In Hinskens, Frans, van Hout, Roeland & Wetzels, W. Leo (eds.) Variation, change and phonological theory. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: Benjamins. 3568.
Archangeli, Diana & Pulleyblank, Douglas (2007). Harmony. In de Lacy, Paul (ed.) The Cambridge handbook of phonology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 353378.
Balakaev, M. B. (1962). Sovremennyj Kazakhskij jazyk: fonetika i morfologija. Alma-Ata: Akademii Nauk Kazakhskoj SSR.
Beckman, Jill N. (1997). Positional faithfulness, positional neutralisation and Shona vowel harmony. Phonology 14. 146.
Bennett, David C. (1968). Spectral form and duration as cues in the recognition of English and German vowels. Language and Speech 11. 6585.
Boer, Bart de (2000). Self-organization in vowel systems. JPh 28. 441465.
Boersma, Paul & Hamann, Silke (2008). The evolution of auditory dispersion in bidirectional constraint grammars. Phonology 25. 217270.
Boersma, Paul & Hayes, Bruce (2001). Empirical tests of the Gradual Learning Algorithm. LI 32. 4586.
Boersma, Paul & Pater, Joe (2016). Convergence properties of a Gradual Learning Algorithm for Harmonic Grammar. In McCarthy, John J. & Pater, Joe (eds.) Harmonic Grammar and Harmonic Serialism. London: Equinox. 389434.
Burnham, Kenneth P. & Anderson, David R. (2004). Multimodel inference: understanding AIC and BIC in model selection. Sociological Methods and Research 33. 261304.
Cho, Taehong (2001). Effects of morpheme boundaries on intergestural timing: evidence from Korean. Phonetica 58. 129162.
Clements, George N. & Sezer, Engin (1982). Vowel and consonant disharmony in Turkish. In van der Hulst, Harry & Smith, Norval (eds.) The structure of phonological representations. Part 2. Dordrecht: Foris. 213255.
Coetzee, Andries W. & Pater, Joe (2011). The place of variation in phonological theory. In Goldsmith et al. (2011). 401–434.
Cole, Jennifer & Kisseberth, Charles (1994). An optimal domains theory of harmony. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 24. 101114.
Cole, Jennifer & Trigo, Loren (1988). Parasitic harmony. In van der Hulst, Harry & Smith, Norval (eds.) Features, segmental structure and harmony processes. Part 2. Dordrecht: Foris. 1938.
Pietra, Della, Stephen, Vincent Della Pietra & Lafferty, John (1997). Inducing features of random fields. IEEE Transactions: Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence 19. 380393.
Dolphyne, Florence A. (1988). The Akan (Twi-Fante) language: its sound systems and tonal structure. Accra: Ghana Universities Press.
Dzhunisbekov, Alimkhan (1972). Glasnye kazakhskogo jazyka. Alma-Ata: Akademii Nauk Kazakhskoj SSR.
Dzhunisbekov, Alimkhan (1980). Singarmonizm v kazakhskom jazyke. Alma-Ata: Akademii Nauk Kazakhskoj SSR.
Essegbey, James & McCollum, Adam G. (2017). Purely progressive vowel harmony in Tutrugbu. Available (February 2018) at
Finley, Sara (2008a). The interaction of vowel harmony and epenthesis. CLS 44. 95109.
Finley, Sara (2008b). Formal and cognitive restrictions on vowel harmony. PhD dissertation, Johns Hopkins University.
Flanagan, James L. (1955). A difference limen for vowel formant frequency. JASA 27. 613617.
Flemming, Edward (2002). Auditory representations in phonology. London & New York: Routledge.
Flemming, Edward (2004). Contrast and perceptual distinctiveness. In Hayes et al. (2004). 232–276.
Flemming, Edward (2008). Asymmetries between assimilation and epenthesis. Paper presented at the 82nd Annual Meeting of the Linguistic Society of America, Chicago.
Fylstra, Daniel, Lasdon, Leon, Watson, John & Waren, Allan (1998). Design and use of the Microsoft Excel Solver. Interfaces 28:5. 2955.
Goldsmith, John A., Riggle, Jason & Yu, Alan C. L. (eds.) (2011). The handbook of phonological theory. 2nd edn. Malden, Mass.: Wiley-Blackwell.
Goldwater, Sharon & Johnson, Mark (2003). Learning OT constraint rankings using a Maximum Entropy model. In Spenader, Jennifer, Eriksson, Anders & Dahl, Östen (eds.) Proceedings of the Stockholm Workshop on Variation within Optimality Theory. Stockholm: Stockholm University. 111120.
Guion, Susan G., Post, Mark W. & Payne, Doris L. (2004). Phonetic correlates of tongue root vowel contrasts in Maa. JPh 32. 517542.
Hadding-Koch, Kerstin & Abramson, Arthur S. (1964). Duration versus spectrum in Swedish vowels: some perceptual experiments. Studia Linguistica 18. 94107.
Hahn, Reinhard F. (1991). Spoken Uyghur. Seattle: University of Washington Press.
Hall, Daniel Currie (2011). Phonological contrast and its phonetic enhancement: dispersedness without dispersion. Phonology 28. 154.
Harrison, K. David (2000). Topics in the phonology and morphology of Tuvan. PhD dissertation, Yale University.
Harrison, K. David & Kaun, Abigail (2000). Pattern-responsive lexicon optimization. NELS 30. 327339.
Hayes, Bruce, Kirchner, Robert & Steriade, Donca (eds.) (2004). Phonetically based phonology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hayes, Bruce & Wilson, Colin (2008). A maximum entropy model of phonotactics and phonotactic learning. LI 39. 379440.
Hillenbrand, James M., Clark, Michael J. & Houde, Robert A. (2000). Some effects of duration on vowel recognition. JASA 108. 30133022.
Hsu, Brian & Jesney, Karen (2016). Scalar positional markedness and faithfulness in Harmonic Grammar. CLS 51. 241255.
Hulst, Harry van der & Moskal, Beata (2013). Patterns of defective labial harmony in Turkic languages. Dilbilim Araştırmaları Dergisi 1. 1752.
Hulst, Harry van der & van de Weijer, Jeroen (1995). Vowel harmony. In Goldsmith, John A. (ed.) The handbook of phonological theory. Cambridge, Mass.: Blackwell. 495534.
Hulst, Harry van der & Smith, Norval (1988). Tungusic and Mongolian vowel harmony: a minimal pair. In Coopmans, Peter & Hulk, Aafke (eds.) Linguistics in the Netherlands 1988. Dordrecht: Foris. 7988.
Itô, Junko & Mester, Armin (1999). Realignment. In In Kager, René, van der Hulst, Harry & Zonneveld, Wim (eds.) The prosody–morphology interface. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 188217.
Johanson, Lars (1998). The history of Turkic. In Johanson & Csató (1998). 81–125.
Johanson, Lars & Csató, Éva Á. (eds.) (1998). The Turkic languages. London & New York: Routledge.
Jurgec, Peter (2011). Feature spreading 2.0: a unified theory of assimilation. PhD dissertation, University of Tromsø.
Kabak, Barıs & Weber, Silke (2013). Markedness, context, and directionality in Turkish harmony: a corpus study on vowel co-occurrence patterns. Dilbilim Araştırmaları Dergisi 1. 5385.
Kara, Dávid Somfai (2002). Kazak. Munich: Lincom.
Kaun, Abigail R. (1995). The typology of rounding harmony: an optimality theoretic approach. PhD dissertation, University of California, Los Angeles.
Kaun, Abigail (1999). Epenthesis-driven harmony in Turkish. BLS 25. 95106.
Kaun, Abigail R. (2004). The typology of rounding harmony. In Hayes et al. (2004). 87–116.
Kirchner, Mark (1998). Kazakh and Karakalpak. In Johanson & Csató (1998). 318–332.
Kirchner, Robert (1993). Turkish vowel harmony and disharmony: an Optimality Theoretic account. Paper presented at the Rutgers Optimality Workshop 1. Available as ROA-4 from the Rutgers Optimality Archive.
Ko, Seongyeon (2012). Tongue root harmony and vowel contrast in Northeast Asian languages. PhD dissertation, Cornell University.
Korn, David (1969). Types of labial harmony in the Turkic languages. Anthropological Linguistics 11. 98106.
Ladefoged, Peter (2001). Vowels and consonants: an introduction to the sounds of languages. Malden, Mass. & Oxford: Blackwell.
Legendre, Géraldine, Miyata, Yoshiro & Smolensky, Paul (1990). Harmonic Grammar: a formal multi-level connectionist theory of linguistic well-formedness: theoretical foundations. In Proceedings of the 12th Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society. Hillsdale: Erlbaum. 388–395.
Li, Bing (1996). Tungusic vowel harmony: description and analysis. The Hague: Holland Academic Graphics.
Liljencrants, Johan & Lindblom, Björn (1972). Numerical simulation of vowel quality systems: the role of perceptual contrast. Lg 48. 839862.
Linker, Wendy (1982). Articulatory and acoustic correlates of labial activity in vowels: a cross-linguistic study. PhD dissertation, University of California, Los Angeles.
Lindblom, Björn (1975). Experiments in sound structure. Revue de Phonétique Appliquée 51. 155189.
Lindblom, Björn (1986). Phonetic universals in vowel systems. In Ohala, John J. & Jaeger, Jeri J. (eds.) Experimental phonology. Orlando: Academic Press. 1344.
Lobanov, Boris M. (1971). Classification of Russian vowels spoken by different speakers. JASA 49. 606608.
McCarthy, John J. & Prince, Alan (1993). Generalized alignment. Yearbook of Morphology 1993. 79153.
McCarthy, John J. & Prince, Alan (1995). Faithfulness and reduplicative identity. In Beckman, Jill N., Dickey, Laura Walsh & Urbanczyk, Suzanne (eds.) Papers in Optimality Theory. Amherst: GLSA. 249384.
McCollum, Adam G. (2015). Labial harmonic shift in Kazakh: mapping the pathways and motivations for decay. BLS 41. 329352.
McCollum, Adam G. (2017). Mayak and the typology of labial harmony. In Jesney, Karen, O'Hara, Charlie, Smith, Caitlin & Walker, Rachel (eds.) Supplemental Proceedings of the 2016 Annual Meeting on Phonology.
McCollum, Adam G. & Chen, Si (2018). Illustration of the IPA: Kazakh. Available (February 2018) at
McPherson, Laura & Hayes, Bruce (2016). Relating application frequency to morphological structure: the case of Tommo So vowel harmony. Phonology 33. 125167.
Menges, Karl H. (1947). Qaraqalpaq grammar. Part 1: Phonology. New York: King's Crown.
Muhamedowa, Raihan (2015). Kazakh: a comprehensive grammar. Abingdon & New York: Routledge.
Nevins, Andrew (2010). Locality in vowel harmony. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
Ohala, John J. (1994). Towards a universal, phonetically-based theory of vowel harmony. Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Spoken Language Processing (ICSLP 94). Vol. 2. Yokohama: Acoustical Society of Japan. 491–494.
Padgett, Jaye (2004). Russian vowel reduction and Dispersion Theory. Phonological Studies 7. 8196.
Padgett, Jaye & Tabain, Marija (2005). Adaptive Dispersion Theory and phonological vowel reduction in Russian. Phonetica 62. 1454.
Pater, Joe (2009). Weighted constraints in generative linguistics. Cognitive Science 33. 9991035.
Peacock, Wesley (2007). Collected field reports on the phonology of Nkonya. Legon: Institute of African Studies, University of Ghana.
Prince, Alan & Smolensky, Paul (1993). Optimality Theory: constraint interaction in generative grammar. Ms, Rutgers University & University of Colorado, Boulder. Published 2004, Malden, Mass. & Oxford: Blackwell.
Przezdziecki, Marek A. (2005). Vowel harmony and coarticulation in three dialects of Yoruba: phonetics determining phonology. PhD dissertation, Cornell University.
Puech, Gilbert (1978). A cross-dialectal study of vowel harmony in Maltese. CLS 14. 377390.
Reetz, Henning & Jongman, Allard (2009). Phonetics: transcription, production, acoustics, and perception. Malden, Mass.: Wiley-Blackwell.
Rose, Sharon & Walker, Rachel (2011). Harmony systems. In Goldsmith et al. (2011). 240–290.
Schwartz, Jean-Luc, Boë, Louis-Jean, Vallée, Nathalie & Abry, Christian (1997). The Dispersion-Focalization Theory of vowel systems. JPh 25. 255286.
Seidel, Frank (2008). A grammar of Yeyi: a Bantu language of southern Africa. Cologne: Köppe.
Steriade, Donca (1981). Parameters of metrical harmony rules. Ms, MIT.
Steriade, Donca (2009). The phonology of perceptibility effects: the P-map and its consequences for constraint organization. In Hanson, Kristin & Inkelas, Sharon (eds.) The nature of the word: studies in honor of Paul Kiparsky. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press. 151179.
Suomi, Kari (1983). Palatal vowel harmony: a perceptually motivated phenomenon? Nordic Journal of Linguistics 6. 135.
Svantesson, Jan-Olof (1985). Vowel harmony shift in Mongolian. Lingua 67. 283327.
Terbeek, Dale (1977). A cross-language multidimensional scaling study of vowel perception. PhD dissertation, University of California, Los Angeles.
Tsumagari, Toshiro (2009). A sketch of Solon grammar. Journal of the Center for Northern Humanities 2. 121.
Ultan, Russell (1973). Some reflections on vowel harmony. Working Papers on Language Universals 12. 3767.
Vajda, Edward J. (1994). Kazakh phonology. In Kaplan, Edward H. & Whisenhunt, Donald W. (eds.) Opuscula Altaica: essays presented in honor of Henry Schwarz. Bellingham, Wash.: East Asian Studies Press. 603650.
Vaux, Bert (1993). The origins of Altaic labial attraction. Harvard Working Papers in Linguistics 2. 228237.
Vaux, Bert (1998). The phonology of Armenian. Oxford: Clarendon.
Vaux, Bert & Samuels, Bridget (2015). Explaining vowel systems: dispersion theory vs natural selection. The Linguistic Review 32. 573599.
Walker, Rachel (2001). Round licensing, harmony, and bisyllabic triggers in Altaic. NLLT 19. 827878.
Walker, Rachel (2011). Vowel patterns in language. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Washington, Jonathan North (2016). An investigation of vowel anteriority in three Turkic languages using ultrasound tongue imaging. PhD dissertation, Indiana University.
Wilson, Colin & George, Benjamin (2009). Maxent grammar tool. Software package. Available (February 2018) at
Xiāngrú, Zhào & Hahn, Reinhard F. (1989). The Ili Turk people and their language. Central Asiatic Journal 33. 260289.
Yavaş, Mehmet (1980). Some pilot experiments on Turkish vowel harmony. Research on Language and Social Interaction 13. 543562.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

  • ISSN: 0952-6757
  • EISSN: 1469-8188
  • URL: /core/journals/phonology
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
Type Description Title
Supplementary materials

McCollum supplementary material
McCollum supplementary material 1

 PDF (1.4 MB)
1.4 MB


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed