Skip to main content

Nonverbal contention and contempt in U.K. parliamentary oversight hearings on fiscal and monetary policy

  • Cheryl Schonhardt-Bailey (a1)

In parliamentary committee oversight hearings on fiscal policy, monetary policy, and financial stability, where verbal deliberation is the focus, nonverbal communication may be crucial in the acceptance or rejection of arguments proffered by policymakers. Systematic qualitative coding of these hearings in the 2010–15 U.K. Parliament finds the following: (1) facial expressions, particularly in the form of anger and contempt, are more prevalent in fiscal policy hearings, where backbench parliamentarians hold frontbench parliamentarians to account, than in monetary policy or financial stability hearings, where the witnesses being held to account are unelected policy experts; (2) comparing committees across chambers, hearings in the House of Lords committee yield more reassuring facial expressions relative to hearings in the House of Commons committee, suggesting a more relaxed and less adversarial context in the former; and (3) central bank witnesses appearing before both the Lords and Commons committees tend toward expressions of appeasement, suggesting a willingness to defer to Parliament.

Corresponding author
Correspondence: Cheryl Schonhardt-Bailey, Government Department, London School of Economics and Political Science, Houghton Street, London WC2A 2AE. Email:
Hide All
1 Blinder, Alan, Central Banking in Theory and Practice (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1998).
2 U.K. Parliament, “Select committees in the House of Commons,” 2011,, accessed May 24, 2017.
3 Bovens, Mark, “Two concepts of accountability: Accountability as a virtue and as a mechanism,” West European Politics , 2010, 33(5): 946967, at p. 951.
4 Schonhardt-Bailey, Cheryl, Deliberating American Monetary Policy: A Textual Analysis (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2013).
5 Schonhardt-Bailey, Cheryl, “Explanations and accountability: Deliberation in U.K. select committees,” paper presented at the Conference on the Political Development of Parties and Legislatures in Canada, Britain, and the United States (Toronto: University of Toronto, 2015).
6 House of Commons, Revisiting Rebuilding the House: The Impact of the Wright Reforms, Third Report of Session 2013–14 (Political and Constitutional Reform Committee) (London: Stationery Office, 2013).
7 Chan, Szu Ping, “Charlotte Hogg resigns as Bank of England deputy governor,” The Telegraph, March 14, 2017.
8 Maurer, Marcus and Reinemann, Carsten, “Do uninvolved voters rely on visual message elements? A test of a central assumption of the ELM in the context of televised debates,” paper presented at the European Consortium for Political Research General Conference (Bordeaux, France, 2013).
9 Bucy, Erik P. and Gong, Zijian Harrison, “Image bite analysis of presidential debates,” in Exploring the C-SPAN Archives: Advancing the Research Agenda, Browning, Robert X., ed. (West Lafayette, IN: Purdue University Press, 2016), pp. 4575.
10 Gong, Zijian Harrison and Bucy, Erik P., “When style obscures substance: Visual attention to display appropriateness in the 2012 presidential debates,” Communication Monographs , 2016, 83(3): 349372.
11 Knapp, Mark L. and Hall, Judith A., Nonverbal Communication in Human Interaction 7th ed. (Boston: Wadsworth Cengage Learning, 2010).
12 Bucy, Erik P. and Grabe, Maria Elizabeth, “Taking television seriously: A sound and image bite analysis of presidential campaign coverage, 1992–2004,” Journal of Communication , 2007, 57(4): 652675.
13 Bucy, Erik P. and Grabe, Maria Elizabeth, “‘Happy warriors’ revisited: Hedonic and agonic display repertoires of presidential candidates on the evening news,” Politics and the Life Sciences , 2008, 27(1): 7898.
14 Stewart, Patrick A., Bucy, Eric P., and Mehu, Marc, “Strengthening bonds and connecting with followers: A biobehavioral inventory of political smiles,” Politics and the Life Sciences , 2015, 34(1): 7392.
15 Grabe, Maria Elizabeth and Bucy, Erik Page, Image Bite Politics: News and the Visual Framing of Elections (New York: Oxford University Press, 2009).
16 Grabe and Bucy, 2009, p. 12.
17 Knapp and Hall, 2010, pp. 11, 20.
18 Bucy, Erik P., “Nonverbal communication, emotion, and political evaluation,” in The Routledge Handbook of Emotions and Mass Media, Döveling, Katrin, von Scheve, Christian, and Konijn, Elly A., eds. (London: Routledge, 2011), pp. 195220, at p. 197.
19 Lowi, Theodore J., “American business, public policy, case studies, and political theory,” World Politics , 1964, 16: 677715.
20 Lowi, Theodore J., “Four systems of policy, politics, and choice,” Public Administration Review , 1972, 32(4): 298310.
21 Cobb, Michael D. and Kuklinski, James H., “Changing minds: Political arguments and political persuasion,” American Journal of Political Science , 1997, 41(1): 88121.
22 Druckman, James N., “On the limits of framing effects: Who can frame?,” Journal of Politics , 2001, 63(4): 10411066.
23 Druckman, James N., “Political preference formation: Competition, deliberation, and the (ir)relevance of framing effects,” American Political Science Review , 2004, 98(4): 671686.
24 Kahneman, Daniel, Thinking, Fast and Slow (London: Penguin, 2011), pp. 2021.
25 Olivola, Christopher Y. and Todorov, Alexander, “Elected in 100 milliseconds: Appearance-based trait inferences and voting,” Journal of Nonverbal Behavior , 2010, 34(2): 83110.
26 Grabe and Bucy, 2009, pp. 12–13.
27 Matsumoto, David, Frank, Mark G., and Hwang, Hyi Sung, “Reading people: Introduction to the world of nonverbal behavior,” in Nonverbal Communication: Science and Applications, Matsumoto, David, Frank, Mark G., and Hwang, Hyi Sung, eds. (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2013), pp. 314, at p. 8.
28 Izard, Carroll E., “Emotions and facial expressions: A perspective from differential emotions theory,” in The Psychology of Facial Expression, Russell, James A. and Fernández-Dols, Jose Miguel, eds. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997), pp. 5777.
29 Matsumoto, David and Hwang, Hyi Sung, “Facial expressions,” in Nonverbal Communication: Science and Applications, Matsumoto, David, Frank, Mark G., and Hwang, Hyi Sung, eds. (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2013), pp. 1552, at p. 25.
30 Ekman, Paul, Emotions Revealed: Understanding Faces and Feelings (London: Orion Books, 2004).
31 Rendall, Drew, Owren, Michael J., and Ryan, Michael J., “What do animal signals mean?,” Animal Behaviour , 2009, 78: 233240.
32 Yik, Michelle S. M. and Russell, James A., “Interpretation of faces: A cross-cultural study of a prediction from Fridlund’s theory,” Cognition and Emotion , 1999, 13(1): 93104.
33 Fridlund, Alan J., Human Facial Expression: An Evolutionary View (San Diego, CA: Academic Press, 1994).
34 Fridlund, 1994.
35 Stewart, Bucy, and Mehu, 2015.
36 Stewart, Bucy, and Mehu, 2015.
37 McHugo, Gregory J., Lanzetta, John T., Sullivan, Dennis G., and Englis, Basil, “Emotional reactions to a political leader’s expressive displays,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 1985, 49(6): 15131529.
38 Bucy and Grabe, 2008.
39 Stewart, Bucy, and Mehu, 2015.
40 Masters, Roger D. and Sullivan, Denis G., “Nonverbal displays and political leadership in France and the United States,” Political Behavior , 1989, 11(2): 123156.
41 Bull, Peter E., Posture and Gesture (Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1987).
42 Knapp and Hall, 2010.
43 Bucy and Grabe, 2008.
44 Reed, Lawrence Ian, Zeglen, Katherine N., and Schmidt, Karen L., “Facial expressions as honest signals of cooperative intent in a one-shot anonymous prisoner’s dilemma game,” Evolution and Human Behavior , 2012, 33(3): 200209.
45 Bucy and Grabe, 2008.
46 Beattie, Geoffrey, Rethinking Body Language: How Hand Movements Reveal Hidden Thoughts (London: Routledge, 2016).
47 Izard, 1997, p. 71.
48 Darwin, Charles, The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals: Definitive Edition (New York: Harper Perennial, 2009), [1872].
49 Izard, 1997.
50 Knapp and Hall, 2010.
51 Grabe and Bucy, 2009.
52 Stewart, Bucy, and Mehu, 2015, p. 48.
53 Blinder, 1998.
54 Stewart, Patrick A., Méhu, Marc, and Salter, Frank K., “Sex and leadership: Interpreting competitive and affiliative facial displays based on workplace status,” International Public Management Journal , 2015, 18(2): 190208.
55 Stewart, Méhu, and Salter, 2015, p. 192.
56 Masters and Sullivan, 1989.
57 Frank, Mark G., Maroulis, Andreas, and Griffin, Darrin J., “The voice,” in Nonverbal Communication: Science and Applications, Matsumoto, David, Frank, Mark G., and Hwang, Hyi Sung, eds. (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2013), pp. 5374, at p. 63.
58 Dumitrescu, Delia, “Nonverbal communication in politics: A review of research developments, 2005–2015,” American Behavioral Scientist , 2016, 60(14): 16561675.
59 Frank, Maroulis, and Griffin, 2013, pp. 58–59.
60 Frank, Maroulis, and Griffin, 2013, p. 67.
61 Stewart, Patrick A., Eubanks, Austin D., and Miller, Jason, ““Please clap”: Applause, laughter, and booing during the 2016 GOP presidential primary debates,” PS: Political Science & Politics , 2016, 49(4): 696700.
62 Stewart, Patrick A., “Presidential laugh lines: Candidate display behavior and audience laughter in the 2008 primary debates,” Politics and the Life Sciences , 2010, 29(2): 5572.
63 Kimmel, Christopher M., Stewart, Patrick A., and Schreckhise, William D., “Of closed minds and open mouths: Indicators of Supreme Court justice votes during the 2009 and 2010 sessions,” The Forum , 2012, 10(2): Article 3.
64 Schubert, James N., Peterson, Steven A., Schubert, Glendon, and Wasby, Stephen, “Observing Supreme Court oral argument: A biosocial approach,” Politics and the Life Sciences , 1992, 11(1): 3551.
65 Beňuš, Štefan, Levitan, Rivka, and Hirschberg, Julia, “Entrainment in spontaneous speech: The case of filled pauses in Supreme Court hearings,” paper presented at the 3rd IEEE Conference on Cognitive Infocommunications (Kosice, Slovakia, 2012).
66 Matsumoto, David and Hwang, Hyi Sung, “Body and gestures,” in Nonverbal Communication: Science and Applications, Matsumoto, David, Frank, Mark G., and Hwang, Hyi Sung, eds. (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2013), pp. 7596, at pp. 76–79.
67 Bull, 1987, p. 33.
68 Rogers, William T., “The contribution of kinesic illustrators toward the comprehension of verbal behaviour within utterances,” Human Communication Research , 1978, 5(1): 5462.
69 Bull, 1987.
70 Everitt, Joanna, Best, Lisa A., and Gaudet, Derek, “Candidate gender, behavioral style, and willingness to vote: Support for female candidates depends on conformity to gender norms,” American Behavioral Scientist , 2016, 60(14): 17371755.
71 Beattie, 2016.
72 Beattie, 2015, p. 150.
73 Stewart, Eubanks, and Miller, 2016, pp. 48–50.
74 Schonhardt-Bailey, 2015.
75 Borg, James, Body Language: How to Know What’s REALLY Being Said (Harlow, UK: Pearson Education, 2011).
76 Bull, Peter, The Microanalysis of Political Communication: Claptrap and Ambiguity (London: Routledge, 2003), p. 86.
77 Hayes, Andrew F. and Krippendorff, Klaus, “Answering the call for a standard reliability measure for coding data,” Communication Methods and Measures , 2007, 1(1): 7789.
78 Schubert et al. 1992, p. 49.
79 Bucy and Gong, 2016, pp. 55–58.
80 Stewart, Patrick A., Salter, Frank K., and Mehu, Marc, “Taking leaders at face value: Ethology and the analysis of televised leader displays,” Politics and the Life Sciences , 2009, 28(1): 4874, at pp. 57–58.
81 Stewart, Salter, and Mehu, 2009.
82 Lang, Annie, Newhagen, John, and Reeves, Byron, “Negative video as structure: Emotion, attention, capacity, and memory,” Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media , 1996, 40(4): 460477.
83 Lang, Annie, Sanders-Jackson, Ashley, Wang, Zheng, and Rubenking, Bridget, “Motivated message processing: How motivational activation influences resource allocation, encoding, and storage of TV messages,” Motivation and Emotion , 2013, 37(9): 508517.
84 Bull, 2003.
85 Lewinski, Peter, “Automated facial coding software outperforms people in recognizing neutral faces as neutral from standardized datasets,” Frontiers in Psychology , 2015, 6: 16.
86 Pedrini, Seraina, Bächtiger, André, and Steenbergen, Marco R., “Deliberative inclusion of minorities: Patterns of reciprocity among linguistic groups in Switzerland,” European Political Science Review , 2013, 5(3): 483512, at 488.
87 Pedrini, Bachtiger, and Steenbergen, 2013, p. 488.
88 Keohane, Nigel and Broughton, Nida, The Politics of Housing (London: Social Market Foundation for National Housing Federation, 2013).
89 Norton, Philip, “Legislative scrutiny in the House of Lords,” in Parliament: Legislation and Accountability, Horne, Alexander and Le Sueur, Andrew, eds. (London: Bloomsbury, 2016), pp. 117136.
90 Norton, 2016, p. 129.
91 Broom, Mark, Koenig, Andreas, and Borries, Carola, “Variation in dominance hierarchies among group-living animals: Modeling stability and the likelihood of coalitions,” Behavioral Ecology , 2009, 20(4): 844855.
92 Dominiczak, Peter, “David Cameron praises George Osborne for his weight loss,” The Telegraph , 2015, January 26.
93 Fenton, Siobhan, “George Osborne failed to suppress a smirk at the mention of more austerity cuts during PMQs,” The Independent , 2016, March 6.
94 Ekman, Paul, Davidson, Richard J., and Friesen, Wallace V., “The Duchenne smile: Emotional expression and brain physiology II,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 1990, 58(2): 342353.
95 Stewart, Bucy, and Mehu, 2015.
96 Bucy, 2011.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Politics and the Life Sciences
  • ISSN: 0730-9384
  • EISSN: 1471-5457
  • URL: /core/journals/politics-and-the-life-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Type Description Title
Supplementary materials

Schonhardt-Bailey supplementary material

 Unknown (56 KB)
56 KB


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed