Skip to main content
×
Home

Secrecy and Openness in Donor Insemination

  • Ken R. Daniels (a1) and Karyn Taylor (a1)
Abstract

This article explores the issues surrounding the notions of secrecy and openness in donor insemination (DI). Secrecy in DI is first placed in historical context, with an outline of some of the main reasons that secrecy has been advocated. The concept of openness is then introduced, and some of the arguments for a more open approach to DI are presented. On this basis, the responses of various governments to calls for more openness are outlined, and the social policy implications of these are discussed. It is concluded that more openness in DI would be advantageous to all of those involved. Couples, professionals, and policymakers are therefore urged to reexamine their views about the need for maintaining secrecy in the area.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Aitken J. (1983). “Donor Conceptions: A Conflict of Needs and Rights.” Monash Bioethics News 2:1216.
American Fertility Society (1990). “New Guidelines for the Use of Semen Donor Insemination.” Fertility and Sterility 53:1S13S.
Andrews L.B. (1984). “Yours, Mine and Theirs.” Psychology Today 18(December).
Annas G. (1980). “Fathers Anonymous: Beyond the Best Interests of the Sperm Donor.” Family Law Quarterly 14:113.
Asche A. (1985). Creating Children: Report of the Family Law Council of Australia. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.
Back K.W. and Snowden R. (1988). “The Anonymity of the Gamete Donor.” Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gynaecology 9:191–8.
Baran A. and Pannor R. (1989). Lethal Secrets. New York: Warner Books.
Barry N. (1984). “What Shall We Tell AID Babies?” Social Work Today (December):8.
Beck W.W. (1984). “Two Hundred Years of Artificial Insemination.” Fertility and Sterility 41:193–5.
Behrman S.J. (1959). “Artificial Insemination.” Fertility and Sterility 10:248–58.
Blank R.H. (1990). Regulating Reproduction. New York: Columbia University Press.
Blizzard J. (1977). Blizzard and the Holy Ghost. London: Peter Owen.
Brandon J. (1979). “Telling the AID Child.” Adoption and Fostering 95:1314.
Brandon J. and Warner J. (1977). “AID and Adoption: Some Comparisons.” British Journal of Social Work 7:338–40.
Braude P., Johnson M.H., and Aitken R.J. (1990). “Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill Goes to Report Stage.” British Medical Journal 300:1410–12.
Cary W.H. (1948). “Results of Artificial Insemination with an Extra-Marital Specimen (Semi-Adoption).” American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 56:727–32.
Daniels K.R. (1987). “Semen Donors in New Zealand: Their Characteristics and Attitudes.” Clinical Reproduction and Fertility 4:341–51.
Daniels K.R. (1988a). “Artificial Insemination Using Donor Semen and the Issue of Secrecy: The Views of Donors and Recipient Couples.” Social Science and Medicine 27:377–83.
Daniels K.R. (1988b). “Attitudes to Donor Insemination and In Vitro Fertilization: A Community Perspective.” New Zealand Social Work Review 1:410.
Daniels K.R. (1989). “Semen Donors: Their Motivations and Attitudes to their Offspring.” Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology 7:121–7.
Daniels K.R.(unpublished data). Work in progress on couples' experiences of DI.
Demack A.G. (1984). Report of the Special Committee Appointed by the Queensland Government to Enquire into the Laws Relating to Artificial Insemination, In Vitro Fertilization and Other Related Matters. Australia.
Edvinsson A., Forsman L., Milsom I. and Nordfors G. (1990). “Givarinsemination vid Manlig Infertilitet: Slut på en Epok?” [“Donor insemination for Male Infertility: The End of an Era?”] Läkartidningen 87:1871–2.
Elias S. and Annas G. (1986). “Social Policy Considerations in Non-Coital Reproduction.” Journal of the American Medical Association 255:67.
Committee Feversham (1960). Report of the Departmental Committee on Human Artificial Insemination. Cmnd 1105. London: HMSO.
Fletcher J. (1954). Morals and Medicine. Boston: Beacon Press.
Fopp P. (1982). “The Rights of the Child in Artificial Insemination.” Australian Association of Social Workers (SA Branch) Newsletter (August): 3.
Haderka J. (1987). “Artificial Reproduction in Czechoslovak Law with Special Reference to Other European Socialist Countries.” International Journal of Law and the Family 1:7291.
Hagenfeldt K. (1990). “Givarinsemination Behandlingsmetod: i Kris” [“Donor Insemination: A Treatment in Crisis”] Läkartidningen 87:18491850.
Haimes E. (1988). “Secrecy: What Can Artificial Reproduction Learn from Adoption?” International Journal of Law and the Family 2:4661.
Handelsman D.J., Dunn S.M., Conway A.J., Boylan L.M., and Jansen R.P.S. (1985). “Psychological and Attitudinal Profiles in Donors for Artificial Insemination.” Fertility and Sterility 43:95101.
Human Fertilization and Embryology Authority (1992). Annual Report, 1992. United Kingdom.
Humphrey M. and Humphrey H. (1986). “A Fresh Look at Genealogical Bewilderment.” British Journal of Medical Psychology 59:133–40.
Humphrey M. and Humphrey H. (1988). Families with a Difference: Varieties of Surrogate Parenthood. London: Routledge.
Infertility (Medical Procedures) Act (1984). Victoria, Australia.
Johnston I. (1980). “The Donor.” In Wood C., Leeton J., and Kovacs G. (eds.), Artificial Insemination by Donor. Melbourne: Brown Prior Andersen.
Joyce D.N. (1984). “The Implications of Greater Openness Concerning AID.” In AID and After: Papers from BAAF, BASW, and a Scottish Working Party. London: British Agencies for Adopting and Fostering.
Kirk H.D. (1981). Adoptive Kinship. Toronto: Butterworths.
Knoppers B.M. and LeBris S. (1991). “Recent Advances in Medically Assisted Conception: Legal, Ethical, and Social Issues.” American Journal of Law and Medicine 17:329–61.
Lasker J.N. and Borg S. (1989). “Secrecy and the New Reproductive Technologies.” In Whiteford L.M. and Poland M.L. (eds.), New Approaches to Human Reproduction: Social and Ethical Dimensions. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Lusk J. (1988). “The Importance of Children Having Knowledge about Their Parents.” In Bruce N., Mitchell A., and Priestley K., (eds.), Truth and the Child: A Contribution to the Debate on the Warnock Report. Edinburgh: Family Care.
Manuel C., Chevret M., and Czyba J. (1979). “Handling of Secrecy by AID Couples.” In David G. and Price W. (eds.), Human Artificial Insemination and Semen Preservation. Paris: International Symposium on Artificial Insemination and Semen Preservation.
McMichael A. (1980). “Social Aspects.” In Wood C., Leeton J., and Kovacs G. (eds.), Artificial Insemination by Donor. Melbourne: Brown Prior Andersen.
McWhinnie A.M. (1967). Adopted Children: How They Grow up. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
McWhinnie A.M. (1984). “Annex: The Case for Greater Openness Concerning AID.” In AID and After: Papers from BAAF, BASW and a Scottish Working Party. London: British Agencies for Adoption and Fostering.
McWhinnie A.M. (1985) Counselling and Telling in Infertility and AID. British Agencies for Adoption and Fostering Medical Group. Transcript of address to Annual General Meeting and Day Seminar, Liverpool, November 22.
McWhinnie A.M. (1988). “The Child, the Family and Society.” In Bruce N., Mitchell A., and Priestley K. (eds.), Truth and the Child: A Contribution to the Debate on the Warnock Report. Edinburgh: Family Care.
McWhinnie A.M.(unpublished manuscript). “A Developmental Chart for Adoptive Family Functioning.” Photocopy.
Menning B.E. (1981). “Donor Insemination: The Psychosocial Issues.” Contemporary Obstetrics and Gynecology 18:155–72.
Miall C. (1986). “The Stigma of Involuntary Childlessness.” Social Problems 33:268–82.
Mitchell G.D. (1982). “Family Making by AID.” International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 2:6974.
Mitchell G.D. (1984). “The Family and Society.” In AID and after: Papers from BAAF, BASW and a Scottish Working Party. London: British Agencies for Adoption and Fostering.
National Bioethics Consultative Committee (1988). Access to Information: An Analogy between Adoption and the Use of Gamete Donation. Background paper prepared for the Australian National Bioethics Consultative Committee, and Appendix to the Committee's Report (1991). Commonwealth of Australia.
New Zealand Infertility Society (1990). “Summary of Workshop on Donor Insemination and Artificial Insemination by Husband.” October. Typescript.
Nicholas M.K. and Tyler J.P.P. (1983). “Characteristics, Attitudes, and Personalities of AI Donors.” Clinical Reproduction and Fertility 2:4754.
N.S.W. Infertility Social Workers Group (1988). How I Began: The Story of Donor Insemination. Sydney: Fertility Society of Australia.
Paul J. and Durna E. (1987) “Attitudes of Sperm Donors.” Transcript of an oral presentation at the Fertility Society of Australia's annual conference, November 12.
Purdie A., Peek J.C., Irwin R., Ellis J., Graham F.M., and Fisher P.R. (1992). “Identifiable Semen Donors: Attitudes of Donors and Recipient Couples.” New Zealand Medical Journal 105:2728.
Rawson G. (1985). “Human Artificial Insemination by Donor and the Australian Community.” Clinical Reproduction and Fertility 3:119.
Report of a Commission Appointed by His Grace the Archbishop of Canterbury (1948). Artificial Human Insemination. London: Society for the Propagation of Christian Knowledge.
Rowland R. (1983). “Attitudes and Opinions of Donors on an Artificial Insemination by Donor (AID) Programme.” Clinical Reproduction and Fertility 2:249–59.
Rowland R. (1984). “Social and Psychological Consequences of Secrecy in Artificial Insemination by Donor.” In Adoption and AID: Access to Information? Melbourne: Monash University Centre for Human Bioethics.
Rowland R. (1985). “The Social and Psychological Consequences of Secrecy in Artificial Insemination by Donor (AID) Programmes.” Social Science and Medicine 21:391–6.
Rowland R.(unpublished manuscript). “The Complexity of Psychological Issues Involved in Artificial Insemination by Donor.” Typescript.
Rowland R. and Ruffin C. (1983). “Community Attitudes to Artificial Insemination by Husband or Donor, In Vitro Fertilization, and Adoption.” Clinical Reproduction and Fertility 2:195206.
Rubin S. (1983). “A Spermdonor Baby Grows Up.” In Zimmerman J. (ed.), The Technological Woman: Interfacing with Tomorrow. New York: Praeger.
Sants H.J. (1964). “Genealogical Bewilderment in Children with Substitute Parents.” British Journal of Medical Psychology 37:133–41.
Sauer M.V., Gorrill M.J., Zeffer K.B., and Bustillo M. (1989). “Attitudinal Survey of Sperm Donors to an Artificial Insemination Clinic.” Journal of Reproductive Medicine 34:362–4.
Schoysman R. (1975). “Problems of Selecting Donors for Artificial Insemination.” Journal of Medical Ethics 1:35.
Singer P. and Wells D. (1984). The Reproduction Revolution: New Ways of Making Babies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Snowden R. (1984). “AID and Artificial Reproduction.” In AID and After: Papers from BAAF, BASW and a Scottish Working Party. London: British Agencies for Adoption and Fostering.
Snowden R. and Mitchell G.D. (1981). The Artificial Family: A Consideration of Artificial Insemination by Donor. London: George Allen and Unwin.
Snowden R., Mitchell G.D., and Snowden E.M. (1983). Artificial Reproduction: A Social Investigation. London: George Allen and Unwin.
Snowden R. and Snowden E.M. (1984). The Gift of a Child. London: George Allen and Unwin.
Spiers J. (1988). “Children's Rights to Know Their Identity: Social Work Perspective.” In Bruce N., Mitchell A., and Priestley K (eds.), Truth and the Child: A Contribution to the Debate on the Warnock Report. Edinburgh: Family Care.
Swedish Law on Artificial Insemination, No. 1140/1984.
Triseliotis J. (1973). In Search of Origins: The Experiences of Adopted People. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Tyler J.P.P., Nicholas M.K., Crockett N.G., and Driscoll G.L. (1983). “Some Attitudes to Artificial Insemination by Donor.” Clinical Reproduction and Fertility 2:151–60.
United Nations (1948). Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Waller L. (1982). Interim Report. Committee to Consider the Social, Ethical and Legal Issues Arising from In Vitro Fertilization. Victoria, Australia.
Walters L. (1987). “Ethics and New Reproductive Technologies: An International Review of Committee Statements.” Hastings Center Report 17:39.
Warnock M. (1984). Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Human Fertilisation and Embryology. Department of Health and Social Security. London: HMSO.
Warnock M. (1987) “The Good of the Child.” Bioethics 1:141–55.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Politics and the Life Sciences
  • ISSN: 0730-9384
  • EISSN: 1471-5457
  • URL: /core/journals/politics-and-the-life-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 4 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 141 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 21st November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.