Skip to main content Accessibility help

Ethics and aesthetics: the social theory of barbershop harmony

  • Liz Garnett

Until recently, the world of the British barbershop singer was a self-enclosed community whose existence went largely unrecognised both by musicians involved in other genres and by the public at large. In the last few years this has started to change, chiefly due to the participation of barbershop choruses in the televised competition ‘Sainsbury's Choir of the Year’. Encouraged by the success of Shannon Express in 1994, many other choruses entered the 1996 competition, four of them reaching the televised semi-finals, and two the finals. During this increased exposure, it became apparent that television commentators had little idea of what to make of barbershoppers, indeed regarded them as a peculiar, and perhaps rather trivial, breed of performer. This bafflement is not surprising given the genre's relative paucity of exposure either in the mass media or in the musical and musicological press; the plentiful articles written by barbershoppers about their activity and its meanings are almost exclusively addressed to each other, to sustain the community rather than integrate it into wider musical life. The purpose of this paper, however, is not to follow the theme of these intra-community articles in arguing that barbershop harmony should actually be regarded as a serious and worthy art, or to explain to a bewildered world what this genre is actually about; rather, it aims to explore the way that barbershop singers theorise themselves and their activity to provide a case study in the relationship between social and musical values. That is, I am not writing as an apologist for a hitherto distinctly insular practice, but exploiting that very insularity as a means to pursue a potentially very broad question within a self-limited field of enquiry.

Hide All
Abbott, L. 1992. ‘Play that barbershop chord: a case for the African-Americans origin of barbershop harmony’, American Music, 10(3), pp. 289325
Amos, D. 1989. ‘Life president's message’, Harmony Express, 11, p. 1
Ayling, T. 1996. ‘Around the clubs: Portsmouth’, Singout, 07/08, p. 7
BABS Directory. 1996. BABS
Beck, J. 1982. The Napkin Method: Basic Barbershop Arranging Manual (Crawley)
Cox, W. 1997. Letter to the editor, Harmony Express, 04, p. 6
Denny, J. 1960. The Oxford School Harmony Course, Book I (London)
Francis, P. 1996. ‘Club news: Greater Manchester’, Harmony Express, 12, p. 10
Garnett, E.A. 1995. ‘Constructions of gender and musical style, 1790–1830’ Ph.D. dissertation, University of Southampton
Garnett, E.A. 1996. ‘Problems in the gendered analysis of instrumental music: drama, narrativity, personae’, presented at the Gender Theory Analysis Conference, Puy de Bost, France
Hagerman, B. and Sundberg, J. 1980. ‘Fundamental frequency adjustment in barbershop singing’, Journal of Research in Singing, 4, pp. 312
Hill, C.C. 1986. ‘Consonance and dissonance’, in The New Harvard Dictionary of Music, ed. Randall, Don (Cambridge, MA)
Holland, G. 1996. ‘What we have to offer the a cappella world is without precedent’, Harmony Express, 01/02, p. 7
‘Jenny Barbershopper writes …’ 1996. Singout, 05/06, p. 8
Jones, G.T. 1974. Music Theory (New York)
Kaplan, M. (ed.) 1993. Barbershopping: Musical and Social Harmony (London and Toronto)
Kavanagh, J.H. 1990. ‘Ideology’, in Critical Terms for Literary Study, eds. Lentricchia, F. and McLaughlin, T. (Chicago and London)
Kitson, C.H. 1920. Elementary Harmony, Part I (Oxford)
LABBS. 1996. Contest and Judging Handbook, LABBS Music & Judging Committee
Miles, S.A. 1995. ‘Critics of disenchantment’, Notes, 51(1), pp. 1138
Morris, R.O. 1958. Foundations of Practical Harmony and Counterpoint (London)
Obituaries: Reg Brooker, Guildford BHC and Reading BHC’. 1997. Harmony Express, 05, p. 5
Ottmann, R.W. 1970. Elementary Harmony: Theory and Practice (New Jersey)
Piston, W. 1941/1987. Harmony, revised by Mark Devoto (London)
Pooley, A. 1997. Letter to the editor, HE, 07, p.7
Schoenberg, A. 1941/1975. ‘Composition with twelve tones’, in Style and Idea: Selected Writings of Arnold Schoenberg, ed. Stein, L. (London) pp. 214–45
Searle, T. 1997. ‘From the Director of Music Services’. Harmony Express, 03, p. 10
Sessions, R. 1951. Harmonic Practice (New York)
SPEBSQSA, Inc. 1980. Barbershop Arranging Manual (Kenosha, WI)
Stebbins, R.A. 1996. The Barber Shop Singer: Inside the Social World of a Musical Hobby (Toronto)
Stevens, D. 1983. ‘What are we trying to preserve?’, Key-note address to SPEBSQSA Harmony College (issued on video 1983) (Kenosha, WI)
Szabo, B. 1976. Theory of Barbershop Harmony (Kenosha, WI)
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Popular Music
  • ISSN: 0261-1430
  • EISSN: 1474-0095
  • URL: /core/journals/popular-music
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed