Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

On the limits of using combined U-series/ESR method to date fossil teeth from two Early Pleistocene archaeological sites of the Orce area (Guadix-Baza basin, Spain)

  • Mathieu Duval (a1) (a2), Christophe Falguères (a2), Jean-Jacques Bahain (a2), Rainer Grün (a3), Qingfeng Shao (a2), Maxime Aubert (a3), Jean-Michel Dolo (a4), Jordi Agustí (a5), Bienvenido Martínez-Navarro (a5), Paul Palmqvist (a6) and Isidro Toro-Moyano (a7)...

The combined U-series/electron spin resonance (ESR) dating method was applied to nine teeth from two Early Pleistocene archaeological sites located in the Orce area (Guadix-Baza Basin, Southern Spain): Fuente Nueva-3 (FN-3) and Barranco León (BL). The combination of biostratigraphy and magnetostratigraphy places both sites between the Olduvai and Jaramillo subchrons (1.78–1.07 Ma).

Our results highlight the difficulty of dating such old sites and point out the limits of the combined U-series/ESR dating method based on the US model. We identified several sources of uncertainties that may lead to inaccurate age estimates. Seven samples could not be dated because the dental tissues had (230Th/234U) activity ratios higher than equilibrium, indicating that uranium had probably leached from these tissues. It was however possible to calculate numerical estimates for two of the teeth, both from FN-3. One yielded a Middle Pleistocene age that seems to be strongly underestimated; the other provided an age of 1.19 ± 0.21 Ma, in agreement with data obtained from independent methods. The latter result gives encouragement that there are samples that can be used for routine dating of old sites.

Corresponding author
*Corresponding author at: Centro nacional de investigación sobre la evolución humana (CENIEH), Paseo de Atapuerca s/n, 09002-Burgos, Spain. E-mail address: (M. Duval).
Hide All
AdamiecG., AitkenM.J., (1998). Dose-rate conversion factors: update. Ancient TL. 16, 3750.
AgustiJ., (1986). Synthèse biostratigraphique du plio-pléistocène de Guadix–Baza (Province de Granada, Sud-Est de l'Espagne). Geobios. 19, 505510.
AgustíJ., MadurellJ., (2003). Los arvicólidos (Muroidea, Rodentia, Mammalia) del Pleistoceno inferior de Barranco León y Fuente Nueva 3 (Orce, Granada). Datos preliminares. ToroI., AgustíJ., Martínez-NavarroB., El Pleistoceno inferior de Barranco León y Fuente Nueva 3, Orce (Granada), Memoria científica campañas 1999–2002, Junta de Andalucía, Consejería de Cultura, 137146.
AgustíJ., OmsO., ParésJ.M., (2007). Biostratigraphy, paleomagnetism and geology of the Orce ravine (Southern Spain). Comment on the paper by Gibert et al. 2006. Quaternary Science Reviews. 26, 568572.
AgustíJ., BlainH.-A., FurióM., de MarfáR., Santos-CubedoA., (2010). The early Pleistocene small vertebrate succession from the Orce region (Guadix-Baza Basin, SE Spain) and its bearing on the first human occupation of Europe. Quaternary International. 223–224, 162169.
AnadónP., JuliaR., OmsO., (2003). Estratigrafía y estudio sedimentológico preliminar de diversos afloramientos en Barranco León y Fuente Nueva (Orce, Granada). ToroI., AgustíJ., Martínez-NavarroB., El Pleistoceno inferior de Barranco Le"n y Fuente Nueva 3, Orce (Granada), Memoria científica campañas 1999–2002, Junta de Andalucía, Consejería de Cultura 4772.
ArribasA., PalmqvistP., (1998). Taphonomy and palaeoecology of an assemblage of large mammals: hyaenid activity in the Lower Pleistocene site at Venta Micena (Orce, Guadix-Baza basin, Granada, Spain). Geobios. 31, 347.(suppl.).
ArribasA., PalmqvistP., (2002). The first human dispersal to Europe: remarks on the archaeological and palaeoanthropological record from Orce (Guadix-Baza basin, southeastern Spain). Human Evolution. 17, 5578.
BahainJ.-J., YokoyamaY., FalguèresC., SarciaM.N., (1992). ESR dating of tooth enamel: a comparison with K-Ar dating. Quaternary Science Reviews. 11, 245250.
BergerG.W., Pérez-GonzalezA., CarbonellE., ArsuagaJ.L., Bermúdez de CastroJ.M., KuT.L., (2008). Luminescence chronology of cave sediments at the Atapuerca paleoanthropological site, Spain. Journal of Human Evolution. 55, 300311.
BischoffJ.L., RosenbauerR.J., (1981). Uranium-series dating of human skeletal remains from the Del Mar and Sunnyvale sites, California. Science. 213, 10031005.
BischoffJ., RosenbauerR., TavosoA., de LumleyH., (1988). A test of uranium-series dating of fossil tooth enamel: results from Tournal cave, France. Applied Geochemistry. 3, 135141.
BlackwellB., PoratN., SchwarczH., DebenathA., (1992). ESR dating of tooth enamel — comparison with Th-230/U-234 speleothem dates at La-Chaise-de-Vouthon (Charente), France. Quaternary Science Reviews. 11, 231244.
BlankA., SuhovoyE., HalevyR., ShtirbergL., HarneitW., (2009). ESR imaging in solid phase down to sub-micron resolution: methodology and applications. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics. 11, 66896699.
BrennanB.J., RinkW.J., McGuirlE.L., SchwarczH.P., PrestwichW.V., (1997). Beta doses in tooth enamel by “one-group” theory and the ROSY ESR dating software. Radiation Measurements. 27, 307314.
BrikA.B., RosenfeldL.G., HaskellE.H., KennerG.H., BrikV.B., (2000). Formation mechanisms and localization places of CO2 radicals in tooth enamel. Mineralogical Journal (Ukraine). 22, 5767.
CallensF.J., MoensP., VerbeeckR., (1995). An EPR study of intact and powdered human tooth enamel dried at 400°C. Calcified Tissue International. 56, 543548.
CarbonellE., RodriguezX.P., (2006). The first human settlement of Mediterranean Europe. Comptes Rendus Palevol. 5, 291298.
CarbonellE., Bermúdez de CastroJ.M., ParésJ.M., Pérez-GonzalezA., Cuenca-BescosG., OlleA., MosqueraM., HuguetR., van der MadeJ., RosasA., SalaR., VallverduJ., GarciaN., GrangerD., Martinon-TorresM., RodriguezX., StockG., VergesJ., AllueE., BurjachsF., CaceresI., CanalsA., BenitoA., DiezC., LozanoM., MateosA., NavazoM., RodriguezJ., RosellJ., ArsuagaJ.L., (2008). The first hominin of Europe. Nature. 452, 465470.
ChenT.-M., YangQ., HuY.-Q., BaoW.-B., LiT.-Y., (1997). ESR dating of tooth enamel from Yunxian Homo erectus site, China. Quaternary Science Reviews (Quaternary Geochronology). 16, 455458.
CohenK.M., GibbardP., (2011). Global chronostratigraphical correlation table for the last 2.7 million years. Subcommission on Quaternary Stratigraphy (International Commission on Stratigraphy), Cambridge, England.
Cuenca-BescosG., RofesJ., López-GarcíaJ., BlainH.-A., de MarfáR., Galindo-PellicenaM., Bennásar-SerraM., Melero-RubioM., ArsuagaJ., Bermúdez de CastroJ., CarbonellE., (2010). Biochronology of Spanish Quaternary small vertebrate faunas. Quaternary International. 212, 109119.
de LumleyH., (1988). La stratigraphie du remplissage du Vallonnet. L'Anthropologie. 92, 407428.
DuvalM., (2008). Evaluation du potentiel de la méthode de datation par Résonance de Spin Electronique (ESR) appliquée aux gisements du Pléistocène inférieur: étude des gisements d'Orce (bassin de Guadix-Baza, Espagne) et contribution à la connaissance des premiers peuplements de l'Europe. Ph.D. thesis, Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle, Paris.
DuvalM., GrünR., FalguèresC., BahainJ.-J., DoloJ.-M., (2009). ESR dating of Lower Pleistocene fossil teeth: limits of the single saturating exponential (SSE) model for the equivalent dose determination. Radiation Measurements. 44, 477482.
DuvalM., Toro MoyanoI., FalguèresC., MestourB., PerrenoudC., Patrocinio EspigaresM., RosS., (2010). Estudio litoestratigráfico del yacimiento arqueologico de Fuente Nueva 3 (Orce, cuenca de Guadix-Baza, España). ToroI., Martínez-NavarroB., AgustíJ., Ocupaciones humanas en el Pleistoceno inferior y medio de la Cuenca de Guadix-Baza, Junta de Andalucia, Consejeria de Cultura, 5776.
DuvalM., AubertM., HellstromJ., GrünR., (2011a). High resolution, three dimensional mapping of U-concentrations and U-series isotopes in an Early Pleistocene equid tooth from Fuente Nueva-3 (Orce, Andalusia, Spain) using laser ablation ICP-MS. Quaternary Geochronology. 6, 5 458467.
DuvalM., FalguèresC., BahainJ.-J., GrünR., ShaoQ., AubertM., HellstromJ., DoloJ.-M., AgustiJ., Martínez-NavarroB., PalmqvistP., Toro-MoyanoI., (2011b). The challenge of dating Early Pleistocene fossil teeth by the combined uranium series-electron spin resonance method: the Venta Micena palaeontological site (Orce, Spain). Journal of Quaternary Science. 26, 6 603615.
DuvalM., MorenoD., ShaoQ., VoinchetP., FalguèresC., BahainJ.-J., GarciaT., GarcíaJ., MartínezK., (2011c). Datación por ESR del yacimiento arqueológico del Pleistoceno inferior de Vallparadís (Terrassa, Cataluña, España). Trabajos de Prehistoria. 68, 724.
EgginsS., GrünR., PikeA., ShelleyA., TaylorL., (2003). 238U, 232Th profiling and U-series isotope analysis of fossil teeth by laser ablation ICPMS. Quaternary Science Reviews. 22, 13731382.
EgginsS.M., GrünR., McCullochM.T., PikeA.W.G., ChappellJ., KinsleyL., MortimerG., ShelleyM., Murray-WallaceC.V., SpötlC., TaylorL., (2005). In situ U-series dating by laser-ablation multi-collector ICPMS: new prospects for Quaternary geochronology. Quaternary Science Reviews. 24, 25232538.
Espigares OrtizM.P., (2010). Análisis y modelización del contexto sedimentario y los atributos tafonómicos de los yacimientos pleistocénicos del borde nororiental de la cuenca de Guadix-Baza. PhD thesis, Universidad de Granada.
FajardoB., (2008). Les industries lithiques anciennes d'Orce : les sites de Barranco León et Fuente Nueva 3. Leur place dans le contexte des plus anciennes industries eurasiatiques. PhD thesis, Université Montpellier III-Paul Valery.
FalguèresC., BahainJ.-J., YokoyamaY., ArsuagaJ.L., Bermúdez de CastroJ.M., CarbonellE., BischoffJ.L., DoloJ.M., (1999). Earliest humans in Europe: the age of TD6 Gran Dolina, Atapuerca, Spain. Journal of Human Evolution. 37, 343352.
FalguèresC., BahainJ.-J., DuvalM., ShaoQ., HanF., LebonM., MercierN., Perez-GonzalezA., DoloJ.-M., GarciaT., (2010). A 300–600 ka ESR/Useries chronology of Acheulian sites in Western Europe. Quaternary International. 223–224, 293298.
GarciaT., FéraudG., FalguèresC., de LumleyH., PerrenoudC., LordkipanidzeD., (2010). Earliest human remains in Eurasia: new 40Ar/39Ar dating of the Dmanisi hominid-bearing levels, Georgia. Quaternary Geochronology. 5, 443451.
García-AguilarJ.M., PalmqvistP., (2011). A model of lacustrine sedimentation for the Early Pleistocene deposits of Guadix-Baza basin (southeast Spain). Quaternary International. 243, 315.
GradsteinF., OggJ., SmithA., (2004). A Geologic Time Scale. Cambridge University Press.
GrünR., (2000). Methods of dose determination using ESR spectra of tooth enamel. Radiation Measurements. 32, 767772.
GrünR., (2009a). The relevance of parametric U-uptake models in ESR age calculations. Radiation Measurements. 44, 472476.
GrünR., (2009b). The DATA program for the calculation of ESR age estimates on tooth enamel. Quaternary Geochronology. 4, 231232.
GrünR., Katzenberger-ApelO., (1994). An alpha-irradiator for ESR dating. Ancient TL. 12, 3538.
GrünR., McDermottF., (1994). Open system modelling for U-series and ESR dating of teeth. Quaternary Science Reviews (Quaternary Geochronology). 13, 121125.
GrünR., SchwarczH.P., ChadamJ., (1988). ESR dating of tooth enamel: coupled correction for U-uptake and U-series disequilibrium. Nuclear Tracks Radiation Measurements. 14, 237244.
GrünR., HuangP.H., HuangW., McDermottF., StringerC.B., ThorneA., YanG., (1998). ESR and U-series analyses of teeth from the palaeoanthropological site of Hexian, Anhui Province, China. Journal of Human Evolution. 34, 555564.
GrünR., Joannes-BoyauR., StringerC., (2008). Two types of CO2 radicals threaten the fundamentals of ESR dating of tooth enamel. Quaternary Geochronology. 3, 150172.
GrünR., AubertM., HellstromJ., DuvalM., (2010). The challenge of direct dating old human fossils. Quaternary International. 223–224, 8793.
HanF., (2011). The Chronology of Earliest Human Settlement in China — Contribution of ESR dating method on Longgupo and Donggutuo early Pleistocene archaeological sites. Ph.D. thesis, Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle, Paris.
HoffmannD., ManginiA., (2003). A method for coupled ESR/U-series dating of teeth showing post-depositional U-loss. Quaternary Science Reviews. 22, 13671372.
IkeyaM., (1982). A model of linear uranium accumulation for ESR age of Heidelberg (Mauer) and Tautavel bones. Japanese Journal of Applied Physics. 21, 690692.
Joannes-BoyauR., GrünR., (2009). Thermal behavior of orientated and non-orientated CO2 radicals in tooth enamel. Radiation Measurements. 44, 505511.
Joannes-BoyauR., GrünR., (2011). A comprehensive model for CO2 radicals in fossil tooth enamel: implications for ESR dating. Quaternary Geochronology. 6, 8297.
Joannes-BoyauR., BodinT., GrünR., (2010). Decomposition of the laboratory gamma irradiation component of angular ESR spectra of fossil tooth enamel fragments. Applied Radiation and Isotopes. 70, 17981808.
KaufmanA., BroeckerW.S., (1965). Comparison of 230Th and 14C ages for carbonate materials from lakes Lahontan and Bonneville. Journal of Geophysical Research. 70, 40394054.
LongerichH.P., JacksonS.E., GuntherD., (1996). Laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometric transient signal data acquisition and analyte concentration calculation. Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry. 11, 899904.
LordkipanidzeD., JashashviliT., VekuaA., Ponce de LeonM.S., ZollikoferC.P.E., RightmireG.P., PontzerH., FerringR., OmsO., TappenM., BukhsianidzeM., AgustiJ., KahlkeR., KiladzeG., Martinez-NavarroB., MouskhelishviliA., NioradzeM., RookL., (2007). Postcranial evidence from early Homo from Dmanisi, Georgia. Science. 449, 305310.
LudwigK., (2003). User's Manual for Isoplot 3.00, A Geochronological Toolkit for Microsoft Excel. Berkeley Geochronology Center Special Publication. v.4.
Martínez-NavarroB., TurqA., Agusti BallesterJ., OmsO., (1997). Fuente Nueva-3 (Orce, Granada, Spain) and the first human occupation of Europe. Journal of Human Evolution. 33, 611620.
MoulléP.-E., LacombatF., EchassouxA., (2006). Apport des grands mammifères de la grotte du Vallonnet (Roquebrune-Cap-Martin, Alpes-Maritimes, France) à la connaissance du cadre biochronologique de la seconde moitié du Pléistocène inférieur d'Europe. L'Anthropologie. 110, 837849.
OmsO., AgustiJ., GabasM., AnadonP., (2000a). Lithostratigraphical correlation of micromammal sites and biostratigraphy of the Upper Pliocene to Lower Pleistocene in the Northeast Guadix-Baza Basin (southern Spain). Journal of Quaternary Science. 15, 4350.
OmsO., ParésJ.M., Martinez-NavarroB., AgustiJ., ToroI., Martinez-FernandezG., TurqA., (2000b). Early human occupation of Western Europe: paleomagnetic dates for two paleolithic sites in Spain. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 97, 10,66610,670.
OmsO., AnadónP., AgustíJ., JuliàR., (2011). Geology and chronology of the continental Pleistocene archeological and paleontological sites of the Orce area (Baza basin, Spain). Quaternary International. 243, 3343.
PalmqvistP., Martínez-NavarroB., ToroI., EspigaresM.P., Ros-MontoyaS., TorregrosaV., Pérez-ClarosJ.A., (2005). Réévaluation de la pr"sence humaine au Pléistocène inférieur dans le Sud de l'Espagne. L'Anthropologie. 109, 411450.
PrescottJ.R., HuttonJ.T., (1988). Cosmic ray and gamma ray dosimetry for TL and ESR. Nuclear Tracks and Radiation Measurements. 14, 223227.
PrescottJ.R., HuttonJ.T., (1994). Cosmic ray contributions to dose rates for luminescence and ESR dating: large depths and long-term time variations. Radiation Measurements. 23, 497500.
RookL., Martinez-NavarroB., (2010). Villafranchian: the long story of a Plio-Pleistocene European large mammal biochronologic unit. Quaternary International. 219, 134144.
Sanz de GaldeanoC., VeraJ.A., (1992). Stratigraphic record and palaeogeographical context of the Neogene basins in the Betic Cordillera, Spain. Basin Research. 4, 2136.
SchwarczH.P., GrünR., TobiasP.V., (1994). ESR dating studies of the australopithecine site of Sterkfontein, South Africa. Journal of Human Evolution. 26, 175181.
ScherbinaO.I., BrikA.B., (2000). Temperature stability of carbonate groups in tooth enamel. Applied Radiation and Isotopes. 52, 10711075.
ShaoQ., (2011). Combined ESR/U-series Dating of Fossil Teeth from Middle Pleistocene Sites in Northern Europe and Mediterranean Area : Contributing to the Chronology of the Acheulian Settlement of Europe. Ph.D. thesis, Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle, Paris.
SoriaF., Lopez-GarridoJ., VeraJ., (1987). Analisis estratigráfico y sedimentológico de los depósitos neógeno-cuaternarios en el sector de Orce (depresión de Guadix-Baza). Paleontologia i Evolucio, Memoria especial. 1, 1134.
Toro-MoyanoI., de LumleyH., BarrierP., BarskyD., CaucheD., CelibertiV., GrégoireS., LebègueF., MestourB., MoncelM.-H., (2010). Les industries lithiques archaïques de Barranco León et de Fuente Nueva 3. CNRS éditions, Paris.
TurqA., Martinez-NavarroB., PalmqvistP., ArribasA., AgustiJ., Rodriguez VidalJ., (1996). Le Plio-Pléistocène de la région d'Orce, province de Grenade, Espagne: bilan et perspectives de recherche. Paléo. 8, 161204.
VoronaI.P., IshchenkoS.S., BaranN.P., PetrenkoT.L., RudkoV.V., (2006). Evidence of annealing-induced transformation of CO2 radicals in irradiated tooth enamel. Radiation Measurements. 41, 577581.
YokoyamaY., NguyenH.V., (1980). Direct and non destructive dating of marine sediments, manganese nodules and corals by high resolution gamma-ray spectrometry. GoldbergE.D., Isotope Marine Chemistry, Uchida Rokakuho, Tokyo, 259289.
YokoyamaY., BibronR., FalguèresC., (1988). Datation absolue des planchers stalagmitiques de la grotte du Vallonnet à Roquebrune-Cap-Martin (Alpes-Maritimes, France), par la résonance de spin électronique (ESR). L'Anthropologie. 92, 429436.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Quaternary Research
  • ISSN: 0033-5894
  • EISSN: 1096-0287
  • URL: /core/journals/quaternary-research
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Type Description Title
Supplementary Materials

Duval et al. Supplementary Material
Supplementary Material

 PDF (1.8 MB)
1.8 MB


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 1 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 51 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 20th January 2017 - 22nd October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.