Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
×
Home

Why not believe in an evil God? Pragmatic encroachment and some implications for philosophy of religion

  • ANASTASIA PHILIPPA SCRUTTON (a1)

Abstract

Pointing to broad symmetries between the idea that God is omniscient, omnipotent, and all-good, and the idea that God is omniscient, omnipotent, but all-evil, the evil-God challenge raises the question of why theists should prefer one over the other. I respond to this challenge by drawing on a recent theory in epistemology, pragmatic encroachment, which asserts that practical considerations can alter the epistemic status of beliefs. I then explore some of the implications of my argument for how we do philosophy of religion, arguing that practical and contextual as well as alethic considerations are properly central to the discipline.

Copyright

References

Hide All
Abu-Raiya, Hisham, & Pargament, Kenneth (2012) ‘On the links between religion and health: what has empirical research taught us?’, in Cobb, M., Puchalski, C. M., and Rumbold, B. (eds) Oxford Textbook of Spirituality in Healthcare (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 333340.
Alston, William P. (1993) Perceiving God: The Epistemology of Religious Experience (Ithaca NY: Cornell University Press).
Cahn, Stephen (1976) ‘Cacodaemony’, Analysis, 37, 6973.
Clifford, William K. (1877) The Ethics of Beliefs, Reprinted in Lectures and Essays II (1879) (London: MacMillan Publishing Company).
Dein, Simon (2006) ‘Religion, spirituality and depression: implications for research and treatment’, Primary Care and Community Psychiatry, 11, 6772.
Derose, Keith (1992) ‘Contextualism and knowledge attributions’, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 52, 913929.
Dougherty, Trent, & Rysiew, Patrick (2011) ‘Clarity about concessive knowledge attributions’, Synthese, 181, 395403.
Fantl, Jeremy, & Mcgrath, Matthew (2007) ‘On Pragmatic encroachment in epistemology’, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 75, 558588.
Fantl, Jeremy, & Mcgrath, Matthew (2009a) ‘Advice for fallibilists: put knowledge to work’, Philosophical Studies, 142, 5566.
Fantl, Jeremy, & Mcgrath, Matthew (2009b) Knowledge in an Uncertain World (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Fulford, K. W. M., & Jackson, M. (1997) ‘Spiritual experience and psychopathology’, Philosophy, Psychiatry and Psychology, 4, 4165.
Hawthorne, John, & Stanley, Jason (2008) ‘Knowledge and Action’, Journal of Philosophy, 105, 571590.
Heriot-Maitland, Charles, Knight, Matthew, & Peters, Emmanuelle (2012) ‘A qualitative comparison of psychotic-like phenomena in clinical and non-clinical populations’, British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 51, 3753.
Hick, John (1992) ‘The rationality of religious beliefs’, in Geivett, Douglas & Sweetman, Brendan (eds) Contemporary Perspectives on Religious Epistemology (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 304319.
Jackson, Lana, Hayward, Mark, & Cooke, Anne (2010) ‘Developing positive relationships with voices: a preliminary grounded theory’, International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 57, 487495.
James, William (1896) The Will to Believe and Other Essays in Popular Philosophy (New York NY: Longmans, Green, and Co.).
Koenig, Harold, King, Dana, & Carson, Verna B. (2012) Handbook of Religion and Health (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Law, Stephen (2010) ‘The evil-god challenge’, Religious Studies, 46, 353373.
Loewenthal, Kate. 2007. Religion, Culture and Mental Health. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Madden, Edward, & Hare, Peter (1968) Evil and the Concept of God (Springfield IL: C. Thomas).
New, Christopher (1993) ‘Antitheism’, Ratio, 6, 3643.
Pargament, Kenneth, Koenig, Harold, & Perez, Lisa (2000) ‘The many methods of religious coping: development and initial validation of the RCOPE’, Journal of clinical psychology, 56, 519543.
Pargament, K., Feuille, M., & Burdzy, D. (2011) ‘The Brief RCOPE: Current psychometric status of a short measure of religious coping’, Religions, 2, 5176.
Plantinga, Alvin (1967) God and Other Minds: A Study of the Rational Justification of Belief in God (Ithaca NY: Cornell University Press).
Platvoet, Jan (2001) ‘Chasing off God: spirit possession in a sharing society’, in Harvey, Graham & MacLeod, Mary Ralls (eds) Indigenous Religious Musics (Aldershot: Ashgate), 122135.
Rizzieri, Aaron (2011) ‘Pragmatic encroachment, high stakes, and religious knowledge’, International Journal for the Philosophy of Religion, 70, 217229.
Rizzieri, Aaron (2013) Pragmatic Encroachment, Religious Belief, and Practice (New York NY: Palgrave Macmillan).
Scrutton, Anastasia (forthcoming) ‘Can being told you're ill make you ill? A discussion of religion, psychiatry, and out of the ordinary experiences’, Think: Philosophy for Everyone.
Stein, Edward (1990) ‘God, the demon, and the status of theodicies’, American Philosophical Quarterly, 27, 163167.
Williamson, Timothy (2005) ‘Contextualism, subject-sensitive invariantism, and knowledge of knowledge’, Philosophical Quarterly, 55, 213235.
Wonder. 2006. Counselling from Hell, <http://www.bipolar.about.com/cs/choosepdoc/a/9910_counshell.htm> (accessed 2 July 2015).
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Religious Studies
  • ISSN: 0034-4125
  • EISSN: 1469-901X
  • URL: /core/journals/religious-studies
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed