Skip to main content

Strip-tillage reduces productivity in organically managed grain and forage cropping systems in the Upper Midwest, USA

  • Sharon L. Weyers (a1), David W. Archer (a2), Frank Forcella (a1), Russ Gesch (a1) and Jane M.F. Johnson (a1)...

Tillage is decreasing globally due to recognized benefits of fuel savings and improved soil health in the absence of disturbance. However, a perceived inability to control weeds effectively and economically hinders no-till adoption in organic production systems in the Upper Midwest, USA. A strip-tillage (ST) strategy was explored as an intermediate approach to reducing fuel use and soil disturbance, and still controlling weeds. An 8-year comparison was made between two tillage approaches, one primarily using ST the other using a combination of conventional plow, disk and chisel tillage [conventional tillage (CT)]. Additionally, two rotation schemes were explored within each tillage system: a 2-year rotation (2y) of corn (Zea mays L.), and soybean (Glycine max [L.] Merr.) with a winter rye (Secale cereale L.) cover crop; and a 4-year rotation (4y) of corn, soybean, spring wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) underseeded with alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.), and a second year of alfalfa. These treatments resulted in comparison of four main management systems CT-2y, CT-4y, ST-2y and ST-4y, which also were managed under fertilized and non-fertilized conditions. Yields, whole system productivity (evaluated with potential gross returns), and weed seed densities (first 4 years) were measured. Across years, yields of corn, soybean and wheat were greater by 34% or more under CT than ST but alfalfa yields were the same. Within tillage strategies, corn yields were the same in 2y and 4y rotations, but soybean yields, only under ST, were 29% lower in the fertilized 4y than 2 yr rotation. In the ST-4y system yields of corn and soybean were the same in fertilized and non-fertilized treatments. Over the entire rotation, system productivity was highest in the fertilized CT-2y system, but the same among fertilized ST-4y, and non-fertilized ST-2y, ST-4y, and CT-4y systems. Over the first 4 years, total weed seed density increased comparatively more under ST than CT, and was negatively correlated to corn yields in fertilized CT systems and soybean yields in the fertilized ST-2y system. These results indicated ST compromised productivity, in part due to insufficient weed control, but also due to reduced nutrient availability. ST and diverse rotations may yet be viable options given that overall productivity of fertilized ST-2y and CT-4y systems was within 70% of that in the fertilized CT-2y system. Closing the yield gap between ST and CT would benefit from future research focused on organic weed and nutrient management, particularly for corn.

Corresponding author
*Corresponding author:
Hide All
Al-Kaisi, M.M., Yin, X., and Licht, M.A. 2005. Soil carbon and nitrogen changes as influenced by tillage and cropping systems in some Iowa soils. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 105:635647.
Anderson, R.L. 2015. Integrating a complex rotation with no-till improves weed management in organic farming. A review. Agronomy for Sustainable Development 35:967974.
Arbuckle, J.G. and Roesch-McNally, G. 2015. Cover crop adoption in Iowa: The role of perceived practice characteristics. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 70:418429. doi:10.2489/jswc.70.6.418.
Archer, D.W., Jaradat, A.A., Johnson, J.M., Weyers, S.L., Gesch, R.W., Forcella, F., and Kludze, H.K. 2007. Crop productivity and economics during the transition to alternative cropping systems. Agronomy Journal 99:15381547.
Baskin, J.M. and Baskin, C.C. 1985. The annual dormancy cycle in buried weed seeds: A continuum. BioScience 35:492498.
Beckendorf, E.A., Catangui, M.A., and Riedell, W.E. 2008. Soybean aphid feeding injury and soybean yield, yield components, and seed composition. Agronomy Journal 100:237246.
Bietila, E., Silva, E.M., Pfeiffer, A.C., and Colquhoun, J.B. 2016. Fall-sown cover crops as mulches for weed suppression in organic small-scale diversified vegetable production. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 32:349357.
Bond, W. and Grundy, A.C. 2001. Non-chemical weed management in organic farming systems. Weed Research 41:383405. doi:10.1046/j.1365-3180.2001.00246.x
Carr, P.M., Gramig, G.G., and Liebig, M.A. 2013. Impacts of organic zero tillage systems on crops, weeds, and soil quality. Sustainability 5:31723201.
Corbin, A.T., Collins, D.P., Krebill-Prather, R.L., Benedict, C.A., and Moore, D.L. 2015. Adoption potential and perceptions of reduced tillage among organic farmers in the maritime Pacific Northwest. eOrganic, 9597. Available at Web site (verified 31 December 2016).
Dimitri, C. and Oberholtzer, L. 2009. Marketing U.S. organic foods: Recent trends from farmers to consumers. Economic Information Bulletin 58. USDA Economic Research Service, 36 pg. Available at Web site (verified 31 December 2016).
Donald, W.W. 2000. Timing and frequency of between-row mowing and band-applied herbicide for annual weed control in soybean. Agronomy Journal 92:10131019.
Drury, C.F., Tan, C.S., Reynolds, W.D., Welacky, T.W., Weaver, S.E., Hamill, A.S., and Vyn, T.J. 2003. Impacts of zone tillage and red clover on corn performance and soil physical quality. Soil Science Society of America Journal 67:867877.
Eghball, B. 2000. Nitrogen mineralization from field-applied beef cattle feedlot manure or compost. Soil Science Society of America Journal 64:20242030.
Erazo-Barradas, M. 2016. Corncob grit application as an alternative to control weeds in two crop production systems. PhD thesis, South Dakota State University. 165 p. (verified 31 December 2016).
Filipovic, D., Kosutic, S., Gospodaric, Z., Zimmer, R., and Banaj, D. 2006. The possibilities of fuel savings and the reduction of CO2 emissions in the soil tillage in Croatia. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 115:290294.
Forcella, F. 2012. Air-propelled abrasive grit for postemergence in-row weed control in field corn. Weed Technology 26:161164.
Forcella, F. 2013. Short- and full-season soybean in stale seedbeds versus rolled-crimped winter rye mulch. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 29:9299.
Ford, G.T. and Mt. Pleasant, J. 1994. Competitive abilities of six corn (Zea mays L.) hybrids with four weed control practices. Weed Technology 8:124128.
Friedrich, T. 2005. Does no-till farming require more herbicides? Outlooks on Pest Management, 16:188191.
Hanna, H.M. 2001. Fuel required for field operations. Iowa State University, University Extension. PM709. Available at Web site (verified 31 December 2016).
Johnson, J.M.F., Archer, D.W., Weyers, S.L., and Barbour, N.W. 2011. Do mitigation strategies reduce global warming potential in the northern U.S. corn belt? Journal of Environmental Quality 40:15511559.
Kladivko, E.J. 2001. Tillage systems and soil ecology. Soil and Tillage Research 61:6176.
Kladivko, E.J., Kaspar, T.C., Jaynes, D.B., Malone, R.W., Singer, J., Morin, X.K., and Searchinger, T. 2014. Cover crops in the upper Midwestern United States: Potential adoption and reduction of nitrate leaching in the Mississippi River Basin. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 69:279291.
Koga, N., Tsuruta, H., Tsuji, H., and Nakano, H. 2003. Fuel consumption-derived CO2 emissions under conventional and reduced tillage cropping systems in northern Japan. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 99:213219.
Kornecki, T.S., Price, A.J., and Raper, R.L. 2006. Performance of different roller designs in terminating rye cover crop and reducing vibration. Applied Engineering in Agriculture 22:633641.
Kurstjens, D.A. 2007. Precise tillage systems for enhanced non-chemical weed management. Soil and Tillage Research 97:293305.
Lal, R. 2004. Carbon emission from farm operations. Environment International 30:981990.
Licht, M.A. and Al-Kaisi, M. 2005. Strip-tillage effect on seedbed soil temperature and other soil physical properties. Soil and Tillage Research 80:233249.
Liebman, M. and Dyck, E. 1993. Crop rotation and intercropping strategies for weed management. Ecological Applications 3:92122.
Mäder, P. and Berner, A. 2012. Development of reduced tillage systems in organic farming in Europe. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 27:711.
McLaughlin, N.B., Drury, C.F., Reynolds, W.D., Yang, X.M., Li, Y.X., Welacky, T.W., and Stewart, G. 2008. Energy inputs for conservation and conventional primary tillage implements in a clay loam soil. Transactions of the ASABE 51:11531163.
Mirsky, S.B., Ryan, M.R., Teasdale, J.R., Curran, W.S., Reberg-Horton, C.S., Spargo, J.T., Wells, M.S., Keene, C.L., and Moyer, J.W. 2013. Overcoming weed management challenges in cover crop-based organic rotational no-till soybean production in the Eastern United States. Weed Technology 27:193203.
Morris, N.L., Miller, P.C.H., Orson, J.H., and Froud-Williams, R.J. 2010. The adoption of non-inversion tillage systems in the United Kingdom and the agronomic impact on soil, crops and the environment—A review. Soil and Tillage Research 108:115.
Nelson, R.G., Hellwinckel, C.M., Brandt, C.C., West, T.O., De La Torre Ugarte, D.G., and Marland, G. 2009. Energy use and carbon dioxide emissions from cropland production in the United States, 1990–2004. Journal of Environmental Quality 38:418425.
NOAA-NCDC. 2013. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Climate Database Center. Climate Data Online. (accessed: 27 September 2013).
Oriade, C.A. and Forcella, F. 1999. Maximizing efficacy and economics of mechanical weed control in row crops through forecasts of weed emergence. Journal of Crop Production 2:189205.
Peigné, J., Ball, B.C., Roger-Estrade, J., and David, C. 2007. Is conservation tillage suitable for organic farming? A review. Soil Use and Management 23:129144.
Reese, C.R. and Forcella, F. (1997). WeedCast: Forecasting weed emergence and growth in crop environments. Available at Web site (verified 31 December 2016).
SAS Institute Inc. 2014a. SAS/STAT® 13.2 User's Guide. SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC.
SAS Institute Inc. 2014b. JMP® 11 Basic Analysis. SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC.
SAS Institute Inc. 2014c. JMP® 11 Multivariate Methods. SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC.
Silva, E.M. 2014. Screening five fall-sown cover crops for use in organic no-till crop production in the Upper Midwest. Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems 38:748763.
Sindelar, A.J., Schmer, M.R., Gesch, R.W., Forcella, F., Eberle, C.A., Thom, M.D., and Archer, D.W. 2015. Winter oilseed production for biofuel in the US Corn Belt: Opportunities and limitations. GCB Bioenergy 117. doi:10.1111/gcbb.1229
Singh, S.N., Sah, A.K., Singh, R.K., Singh, V.K., and Hasan, S.S. 2010. Diversification of rice (Oryza sativa L.)-based crop sequences for higher production potentials and economic returns in India's central Uttar Pradesh. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture 34:141152.
Tautges, N.E., Burke, I.C., Borrelli, K., and Fuerst, E.P. 2017. Competitive ability of rotational crops with weeds in dryland organic wheat production systems. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 32:5768.
Teasdale, J.R., Mangum, R.W., Radhakrishnan, J., and Cavigelli, M.A. 2004. Weed seedbank dynamics in three organic farming crop rotations. Agronomy Journal 96:14291435.
USDA-AMS 2016. Bi-Weekly National Organic Comprehensive Report. Available at Web site (verified: 31 December 2016).
USDA ERS 2012. Prices for organic grains and feedstuffs, regional markets, monthly 2008–2011. Available at Web site (verified 31 December 2016).
USDA ERS 2014. Wholesale prices for organic grains and feedstuff, U.S., monthly, 2011–13. Available at Web site (Verified 31 December 2016).
USDA-NRCS 2016. Web Soil Survey. Soil Survey Staff, Natural Resources Conservation Service, United States Department of Agriculture. Available at Web site (accessed 27 September 2013).
Wayman, S., Cogger, C., Benedict, C., Collins, D., Burke, I., and Bary, A. 2015. Cover crop effects on light, nitrogen, and weeds in organic reduced tillage. Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems 39:647665.
West, T.O. and Marland, G. 2002. A synthesis of carbon sequestration, carbon emissions, and net carbon flux in agriculture: Comparing tillage practices in the United States. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 91:217232.
Weyers, S.L., Johnson, J.M., and Archer, D.W. 2013. Assessment of multiple management systems in the Upper Midwest. Agronomy Journal 105:16651675.
Weyers, S.L., Archer, D.W., Forcella, F., Gesch, R., and Johnson, J.M.F. 2017. Can reducing tillage and increasing crop diversity benefit grain and forage production? Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems. In press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems
  • ISSN: 1742-1705
  • EISSN: 1742-1713
  • URL: /core/journals/renewable-agriculture-and-food-systems
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *