Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-5nwft Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-03T18:13:05.763Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Free trade, British hegemony and the international economic order in the nineteenth century

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 October 2010

Patrick K. O'Brien  and
Geoffrey Allen Pigman
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The theory (or rather the notion) that the international economy functioned more or less effectively for roughly a century down to 1914 because Great Britain provided the ‘public goods’ required for the smooth operation of the ‘liberal international order’ has become a textbook generalization. That notion emerged quite recently and can be traced to Kindleberger's attempt to explain the pronounced cyclical fluctuations experienced by the world economy during the interwar years 1919–39, as well as the severity and duration of the Great Depression from 1929–33 in terms of the American failure to sustain conditions necessary for the financial stability of an interdependent global economy. In Kindleberger's view, Britain, which had acted as a hegemonic power before 1914, lacked the resources to continue with its historic role after the Great War, while the United States (which by 1918 enjoyed a position in the world economy of arguably greater weight and significance than the United Kingdom had ever possessed during the long nineteenth century) commanded neither the knowledge nor the political will to replace Britain as the responsible hegemonic power until after the Second World War.

Type
Research Article
Information
Review of International Studies , Volume 18 , Issue 2 , April 1992 , pp. 89 - 113
Copyright
Copyright © British International Studies Association 1992

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Gilpin, R., The Economic Dimension of International Security (Princeton, 1989)Google Scholar; Kindleberger, C. P., The World in Depression, 1929–1939 (Berkeley, 1973)Google Scholar; Calleo, D. P., Beyond American Hegemony (New York, 1987)Google Scholar.

2 Kindleberger, The World in Depression, and Eichengreen, B., ‘Hegemonic Stability Theories of the International Monetary System’, in Cooper, R. N. et al. (eds.), Can Nations Agree? (Washington, 1989)Google Scholar.

3 Gilpin, R., War and Change in the International System (Cambridge, 1981)Google Scholar.

4 Krasner, S. D., ‘State Power and the Structure of the International System’, World Politics 28 (1976)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Krasner, ‘State Power’.

6 Gilpin, War and Change.

7 Gilpin, War and Change.

8 Snidal, D., ‘The Limits of Hegemonic Stability’, International Organization, 39 (1985)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Calleo, D., Beyond American Hegemony (New York, 1987)Google Scholar; Keohane, R. O., After Hegemony (Princeton, 1984)Google Scholar.

9 Strange, S., ‘The Persistent Myth of Lost Hegemony’, International Organization 41 (1987)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10 Nye, R., Bound To Lead (New York, 1990)Google Scholar.

11 Joll, J., Gramsci (Glasgow, 1977)Google Scholar.

12 Wallerstein, Immanuel, The Modern World-System (I) (New York/London, 1974)Google Scholar.

13 Krasner, ‘State Power’.

14 Keohane, After Hegemony.

15 Snidal, ‘The Limits of Hegemonic Stability’.

16 Russett, B., ‘The Mysterious Case of Vanishing Hegemony; or, Is Mark Twain Really Dead?’ in International Organization, 39 (1985)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 Calleo, Beyond American Hegemony.

18 Calleo, Beyond American Hegemony.

19 Calleo, Beyond American Hegemony.

20 Strange, ‘The Persistent Myth’, pp. 551–74.

21 Nau, H. R., The Myth of America's Decline (Oxford, 1990)Google Scholar.

22 McKeown, R., ‘Hegemonic Stability Theory and 19th Century Tariff Levels in Europe’, International Organization 37 (1983)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

23 Knorr, K. E., British Colonial Theories 1570–1850 (Toronto, 1944)Google Scholar.

24 Gomes, L., Foreign Trade and the National Economy (London, 1987)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

25 Viner, J., Studies in the Theory of International Trade (London, 1955)Google Scholar.

26 Smith, A., The Wealth of Nations (New York, 1937)Google Scholar.

27 Ehrman, J., The Younger Pitt: The Years of Acclaim (London, 1969)Google Scholar.

28 Ehrman, J., The British Government and Commercial Negotiations with Europe (Cambridge, 1962)Google Scholar.

29 Harlow, V. T., The Founding of the Second British Empire, 1763–93 (London, 1952)Google Scholar.

30 Horn, D. B., Great Britain and Europe in the Eighteenth Century (Oxford, 1967)Google Scholar.

31 Sheffield, Lord, Observations on the Commerce of the United States (London, 1784)Google Scholar.

32 O'Brien, P. K., ‘The Political Economy of British Taxation’, in Economic History Review, 41 (1988)Google Scholar.

33 Christie, I., Stress and Stability in Late Eighteenth Century Britain (Oxford, 1984)Google Scholar.

34 Crouzet, F., L'Economie Britannique el le Blocus Continental (Paris, 1987)Google Scholar, and O'Brien, P. K., ‘The Impact of the Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars on the Long-Run Growth of the British Economy 1798–1815’, Review 3 (1989)Google Scholar.

35 Webster, C. K., The Congress of Vienna, 1814–1815 (London, 1963)Google Scholar.

36 Webster, C. K., The Foreign Policy of Castlereagh 1812–15 (London, 1931)Google Scholar.

37 Hilton, B., Corn, Cash and Commerce. The Economic Policies of Tory Governments, 1815–1830 (Oxford, 1977)Google Scholar.

38 Williams, J. B., British Commercial Policy and Trade Expansion 1750–1850 (Oxford, 1972)Google Scholar.

39 Iliasu, A. A., ‘The Cobden-Chevalier Treaty of I860’, Historical Journal 14 (1971)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

40 Williams, British Commercial Policy.

41 Webster, C. K., The Foreign Policy of Palmerston 1830–41, 2 vols. (London, 1951)Google Scholar.

42 Puryear, J. V., International Economics and Diplomacy in the Near East (Stanford, 1935)Google Scholar.

43 Greenberg, M., British Trade and the Opening of China 1800–42 (Cambridge, 1951)Google Scholar.

44 Costin, W. C., Great Britain and China 1833–1860 (Oxford, 1968)Google Scholar.

45 Henderson, W. O., The Zollverein (London, 1959)Google Scholar; Redford, A., Manchester Merchants and Foreign Trade 1794–1858 (Manchester, 1934)Google Scholar.

46 Brown, L., The Board of Trade and the Free Trade Movement (Oxford, 1958)Google Scholar.

47 Henderson, The Zollverein.

48 Hilton, Corn, Cash and Commerce, and Semmel, B., The Rise of Free Trade Imperialism (Cambridge, 1970)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

49 Imlah, A., Economic Elements in the Pax Britannica (Cambridge, Mass., 1958)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

50 Gash, N., Aristocracy and People. Britain 1815–65 (London, 1979)Google Scholar.

51 Imlah, Economic Elements in the Pax Britannica.

52 Fay, C. R., The Corn Laws and Social England (Cambridge, 1932)Google Scholar, and McCord, N., The Anti-Corn Law league (London, 1958)Google Scholar.

53 Aydelotte, W. O. (ed.), The History of Parliamentary Behaviour (Princeton, 1977)Google Scholar, and Kitson-Clark, G., ‘The Repeal of the Corn Laws and the Politics of the Forties’, Economic History Review, 4 (1951)Google Scholar.

54 Semmel, The Rise of Free Trade Imperialism.

55 Aydelotte, W. O., ‘The House of Commons in the 1840's’, History, 39 (1954)Google Scholar; ‘Voting Patterns in the British House of Commons in the 1840's’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 5 (1963)Google Scholar; ‘Parties and Issues in Early Victorian England’, Journal of British Studies, 5 (1966)Google Scholar and ‘The Country Gentlemen and the Repeal of the Corn Laws’, English History Review 82 (1976)Google Scholar.

56 Kitson-Clark, G., The Making of Victorian England (London, 1962)Google Scholar, and Moore, D. C., The Politics of Deference (New York, 1976)Google Scholar.

57 Hopkins, A. G. and Cain, P. J., ‘The Political Economy of British Expansion Overseas, 1750–1914’, Economic History Review. 33 (1980)Google Scholar.

58 Williams, British Commercial Policy.

59 Brown, The Board of Trade and the Free Trade Movement.

60 Crouzet, F., The Victorian Economy (London, 1982)Google Scholar.

61 Dawson, W. H., Richard Cobden and Foreign Policy (London, 1926)Google Scholar.

62 Edsall, N. C., Richard Cobden, Independent Radical (Cambridge, Mass., 1986)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

63 Kindleberger, C. P., ‘The Rise of Free Trade in Western Europe, 1820–75’, Journal of Economic History, 35 (1975)Google Scholar, and Bairoch, P., Commerce extérieur et developpement économique de l'Europe au XIXe siècle (Paris, 1963)Google Scholar.

64 Clarke, J., British Diplomacy and Foreign Policy, 1782–1865 (London, 1989)Google Scholar.

65 Ashley, P., Modern Tariff History (London, 1920)Google Scholar.

66 Brown, The Board of Trade and the Free Trade Movement.

67 Dunham, A. L., The Anglo-French Treaty of Commerce of 1860 and the Progress of the Industrial Revolution in France (Ann Arbor, 1930)Google Scholar.

68 Bourne, K., The Foreign policy of Victorian England 1830–1902 (Oxford, 1970)Google Scholar.

69 Iliasu, ‘The Cobden-Chevalier Commercial Treaty’.

70 Dunham, The Anglo-French Treaty of Commerce.

71 Sherer, P., ‘British Reactions to the French Annexation of Nice and Savoy’, International Review of Historical and Political Science, 2 (1965)Google Scholar.

72 Kemp, T., ‘Tariff Policy and French Economic Growth, 1815–1914’, in Institute International d'Histoire de la Banque, 12 (1976)Google Scholar.

73 McCord, N., Free Trade: Theory and Practicefrom Adam Smith to Keynes (Newton Abbot, 1970)Google Scholar, and Levi, L., History of British Commerce and of the Economic Progress of the British Nation 1763–1878 (London, 1880)Google Scholar.

74 Iliasu, ‘The Cobden-Chevalier Commercial Treaty’.

75 Imlah, Economic Elements in the Pax Britannica.

76 Fuchs, C. J., The Trade Policy of Great Britain and Her Colonies since 1860 (London, 1905)Google Scholar.

77 Kindleberger, ‘Rise of Free Trade’.

78 McKeown, ‘Hegemonic Stability Theory’.

79 Baumont, M. and Naudin, P., Histoire du Commerce, Tome V. (Paris 1952)Google Scholar

80 Edsall, Richard Cobden.

81 , Henderson, Britain and Industrial Europe 1750–1870 (Leicester, 1972)Google Scholar.

82 Henderson, The Zollverein.

83 Helleiner, K. F., Free Trade and Frustration: Anglo-Austrian Negotiations 1860–1870 (Toronto, 1973)Google Scholar.

84 Pinter, W. M., Russian Economic Policy under Nicholas I (Ithaca, NY, 1967)Google Scholar.

85 Falkus, M. E., The Industrialisation of Russia 1700–1914 (London, 1972)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

86 Pincus, J. J., Pressure Groups and Politics in Antebellum Tariffs (New York, 1987)Google Scholar.

87 Veder, R. K., The American Economy in Historical Perspective (Belmont, 1976)Google Scholar.

88 Heringa, A., Free Trade and Protectionism in Holland (Haarlem, 1914)Google Scholar, and Toniolo, G., An Economic History of Liberal Italy (London, 1990)Google Scholar.

89 Kindleberger, ‘Rise of Free Trade’, and Pollard, S., Peaceful Conquest; The Industrialization of Europe 1760–1970 (Oxford, 1981)Google Scholar.

90 Costin, Great Britain and China 1838–1860.

91 Nish, I. H., The Anglo-Japanese Alliance (London, 1966)Google Scholar.

92 Bowring, L. B., ‘A Brief Recollection of Sir John Bowring’, Autobiographical Recollections (London, 1877)Google Scholar.

93 Stone, N., Europe Transformed 1878–1919 (London, 1983)Google Scholar, and Gourevitch, P. A., ‘International Trade, Domestic Coalitions and Liberty: Comparative Responses to the Crisis of 1873–1896’, Journal of Economic History 8 (1977)Google Scholar.

94 Fuchs, The Trade Policy of Great Britain and Her Colonies since 1860.

95 Coppa, F. J., ‘The Italian Tariff and the Conflict between Agriculture and Industry’, Journal of Economic History, 30 (1970)Google Scholar, and Ashley, Modern Tariff History.

96 Curtiss, G. B., The Industrial Development of Nations and History of the Tariff Policies of Britain, France, Russia and other European Powers, 3 vols. (London, 1912)Google Scholar.

97 Friedberg, The Weary Titan. By 1902 nominal tariff levels on manufactures were: Russia 131%; Spain 76%; United States 71%; France 32%; Italy 27%; Germany 25%; Sweden 23%; Denmark 18%; Canada 17%; Belgium 13%; Norway 12%. Cited in Little, I.et al. Industry and Trade in Some Developing Countries (Oxford, 1970)Google Scholar.

98 The League's bible was W. F. Ecroyd's The Policy of Self Help (1879).

99 Brown, B. H., The Tariff Reform Movement in Great Britain, 1881–1895 (New York, 1943)Google Scholar.

100 Royal Commission on the Depression of Trade and Industry 1884–86, Parliamentary Papers, 1886 (XXI and XXII).

101 Report of the Tariff Commission, vols. 1 and 2 (London, 1904)Google Scholar.

102 Fraser, P., ‘Unionism and Tariff Reform’, in Historical Journal, 5 (1962)Google Scholar.

103 Balfour, A. J., Economic Notes on Insular Free Trade (London, 1903)Google Scholar.

104 Egremont, M., Balfour (London, 1980)Google Scholar.

105 Cain, P. J., ‘Political Economy in Edwardian England: The Tariff Controversy’, in O'Day, A. (ed.), The Edwardian Age: Conflict and Stability (London, 1979)Google Scholar.

106 Wood, J. C., British Economists and the Empire (London, 1983)Google Scholar.

107 Semmel, Liberalism and Naval Strategy, and Beloff, M., Imperial Sunset, vol. I (New York, 1970)Google Scholar.

108 Sykes, A., Tariff Reform in British Politics, 1903–13 (Oxford, 1979)Google Scholar.

109 Balfour, M., Britain and Joseph Chamberlain (London, 1985)Google Scholar.

110 Porter, B., The Lion's Share: A Short History of British Imperialism 1850–1983 (London, 1984)Google Scholar, and Fay, C. R., Imperial Economy and its Place in the Formation of Economic Doctrine 1600–1932 (Oxford, 1934)Google Scholar.

111 Fielden, K., ‘The Rise and Fall of Free Trade’, in Bartlett, C. J. (ed.), Britain Pre-Eminent. Studies of British World Influence in the Nineteenth Century (London, 1936)Google Scholar.

112 Wood, British Economists and the Empire, and Hirst, F. W., From Adam Smith to Philip Snowden. A History of Free Trade in Great Britain (London, 1925)Google Scholar.

113 Free Trade Union, Handbook to the Tariff Question (London, 1908)Google Scholar; Cobden Club, A Decade of Tariff Fooling (London, 1913)Google Scholar; and Berard, M. V., British Imperialism and Commercial Supremacy (London, 1906)Google Scholar.

114 Hewins, W. A. S., The Apologia of an Imperialist. Forty Years of Empire Policy, 2 vols. (London, 1929)Google Scholar.

115 Semmel, B., ‘Imperialism and Social Reform’, in Social and Imperial Thought (London, 1960)Google Scholar.

116 Drummond, I., British Economic Policy and the Empire 1919–39 (London, 1973)Google Scholar.

117 Thornton, A. P., The Imperial Idea and Its Enemies (London, 1959)Google Scholar.

118 Kennedy, P. and Nicholls, A. J. (eds.), Nationalist and Radicalist Movements in Britain and Germany (Oxford, 1981)Google Scholar, and O'Day (ed.), The Edwardian Age.

119 Playne, C. E., The Pre-War Mind in Britain (London, 1928)Google Scholar, and Kennedy, P., The Rise of Anglo-German Antagonism 1860–1914 (London, 1980)Google Scholar.

120 None of the numerous pamphlets issued by the Cobden Club from 1900–13 makes this claim.

121 Asquith, H. H., Mr. Balfour's Position and Mine (A Speech) (London, 1904)Google Scholar. But see Lofft, R. E., The Great Experiment: Mock Free Trade (Bury St Edmunds, 1894)Google Scholar.

122 Platt, D. C. M., Finance, Trade and Politics in British Foreign Policy 1815–1914 (Oxford, 1968)Google Scholar.

123 Hoffman, Great Britain and the German Trade Rivalry 1875–1914, and Kennedy, Rise of Anglo-German Antagonism.

124 Platt, Finance, Trade and Politics.

125 Hanson, J. R., Trade in Transition. Exports from the Third World 1840–1900 (New York, 1980)Google Scholar, and Fuchs, The Trade Policy of Great Britain and Her Colonies.

126 Hyam, R., Britain's Imperial Century 1815–1914 (London, 1976)Google Scholar, and Kennedy, P., The Realities Behind Diplomacy (London, 1981)Google Scholar.

127 Summaries of treaties can be found in Fuchs, Trade Policy of Great Britain and Her Colonies and Curtiss, The Industrial Development of Nations.

128 For contemporary definitions of treaties, see Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th edn (Cambridge, 1910–1911)Google Scholar.

129 Platt, Finance, Trade and Politics.

130 Platt, D. C. M., The Cinderella Service. British Consuls since 1825 (London, 1971)Google Scholar.

131 Despite the Foreign Office's aristocratic disdain for trade, it none the less assumed responsibility for commercial policy in an 1872 reform in which it took over the Board of Trade's Commercial Department for nearly a decade. In 1882 the Board of Trade, which recruited from a different cadre of people, resumed its formal advisory role in commercial policy. See Gaston, J., ‘Trade and the Late Victorian Foreign Office’, International History Review 4 (1982)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

132 Saul, B., Studies in Britain Overseas Trade 1870–1914 (Liverpool, 1960)Google Scholar.

133 , Gaston, ‘The Free Trade Diplomacy Debate and the Victorian European Common Market Initiative’, Canadian Journal of History, 22 (1987)Google Scholar.

134 Platt, Finance, Trade and Politics, and Wiener, M. J., English Culture and the Decline of the Industrial Spirit J850–1980 (Cambridge, 1981)Google Scholar.

135 Our survey of that debate found just the pamphlet which argued in such terms.

136 Kennedy, P., The Rise and Fall of British Naval Mastery (London, 1983)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

137 McCloskey, D., Enterprise and Trade in Victorian Britain (London, 1981)Google Scholar.

138 Pollard, Peaceful Conquest.

139 Gobert, A., Vers la Liberalisme du Commerce du XV Siecle au Milieu du XIX* Siecle (Paris, 1952)Google Scholar.

140 Louis, W. R. (ed.), Imperialism: The Robinson-Gallagher Controversy (London, 1976)Google Scholar, and Cain, P. J. and Hopkins, A. G., ‘Gentlemanly Capitalism and British Expansion Overseas—the Old Colonial System 1688–1850’ in Economic History Review, 39 (1986)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

141 Schmoller, G., The Mercantile System and its Historical Significance (London, 1896)Google Scholar.

142 Nye, Bound to Lead.

143 Hyam, Britain's Imperial Century.

144 O'Brien, P. K., ‘The Costs and Benefits of British Imperialism, 1846–1914’, in Past and Present, 120 (1988)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

145 These negotiations are detailed in several British Parliamentary Papers published between 1884 and 1913. See Pigman, G. A., ‘Hegemony and Free Trade Policy: Britain 1846–1914 and U.S.A. 1944–1990’, D. Phil thesis, Oxford (forthcoming 1992)Google Scholar.

146 Gaston, ‘Free Trade Diplomacy Debate’; Williams, E., Made in Germany (London, 1896)Google Scholar, and Hoffman, Great Britain and the German Trade Rivalry.

147 Kennedy, Origins of the Anglo-German Antagonism.

148 Lebovics, H., The Alliance of Iron and Wheat in the French Third Republic 1860–1914 (Baton Rouge, 1988)Google Scholar.

149 Gourevitch, ‘International Trade, Domestic Coalitions and Liberty’.

150 Stein, A. A., ‘The Hegemon's Dilemma: Great Britain, the United States and the International Economic Order’, International Organization 38 (1984)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.