Skip to main content
×
×
Home

Empathy, Simulation, and Narrative

  • Shaun Gallagher (a1)
Argument

A number of theorists have proposed simulation theories of empathy. A review of these theories shows that, despite the fact that one version of the simulation theory can avoid a number of problems associated with such approaches, there are further reasons to doubt whether simulation actually explains empathy. A high-level simulation account of empathy, distinguished from the simulation theory of mindreading, can avoid problems associated with low-level (neural) simulationist accounts; but it fails to adequately address two other problems: the diversity problem and the starting problem. It is argued that a narrative approach to empathy obviates all these problems and offers a more parsimonious account.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Baillargeon, Renée, Scott, Rose M., and He, Zijing. 2010. “False-belief understanding in infants.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences 14 (3):110118.
Boltanski, Luc. 1999. Distant Suffering: Politics, Morality and the Media. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bretherton, Inge, Fritz, Janet, Zahn-Waxler, Carolyn, and Ridgeway, Doreen. 1986. “The acquisition and development of emotion language: A functionalist perspective.” Child Development 57:529548.
Bruner, Jerome and Kalmar, David A.. 1998. “Narrative and metanarrative in the construction of self.” In Self-Awareness: Its Nature and Development, edited by Ferrari, M. and Sternberg, R. J., 308331. New York: Guilford Press.
Carruthers, Peter. 2009. “Mindreading underlies metacognition.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 32:164176.
Carolyn, Catmur, Walsh, Vincent, and Heyes, Cecilia. 2007. “Sensorimotor Learning Configures the Human Mirror System.” Current Biology 17 (17):15271531.
Chouliaraki, Lilie. 2006. The spectatorship of suffering. London: Sage Publications.
Csibra, Gergely. 2005. “Mirror neurons and action observation. Is simulation involved?” ESF Interdisciplines. http://www.mendeley.com/research/mirror-neurons-action-observation-simulation-involved/ (last accessed 29 April 2012).
Decety, Jean. 2005. “Une anatomie de l'empathie.” Psychiatrie, Sciences Humaines, Neurosciences 3 (11):1624.
Decety, Jean. 2004. “Empathie et mentalisation à la lumière des neurosciences sociales.” Neuropsychiatrie: Tendances et Débats 23:2535.
Decety, Jean. 2003. “L'empathie ou l’émotion partagée” [Empathy: Sharing emotions]. Pour La Science 309:4651.
Decety, Jean. 2002. “Naturaliser l'empathie” [Empathy naturalized]. L'Encéphale 28:920.
Decety, Jean and Grèzes, Julie. 2006. “The power of simulation: Imagining one's own and other's behavior.” Brain Research 1079:414.
Decety, Jean and Jackson, Philip L.. 2004. “The functional architecture of human empathy.”Behavioral and Cognitive Neuroscience Reviews 3 (2):71100.
De Jaegher, Hanne, Di Paolo, Ezequiel, and Gallagher, Shaun. 2010. “Does social interaction constitute social cognition?Trends in Cognitive Sciences 14 (10):441447.
de Vignemont, Frédérique and Jacob, Pierre. (2012). “What is it like to feel another's pain?Philosophy of Science 79 (2):295316
de Vignemont, Frédérique and Singer, Tania. 2006. “The empathic brain: How, when and why?Trends in Cognitive Sciences 10:435441.
Dinstein, Illan, Thomas, Cibu, Behrmann, Marlene, and Heege, David J.. 2008. “A mirror up to nature.” Current Biology 8 (1):R13R18.
Fisher, Justin C. 2006. “Does simulation theory really involve simulation?Philosophical Psychology 19 (4):417432.
Gallagher, Shaun. 2001. “The practice of mind: Theory, simulation, or interaction?Journal of Consciousness Studies 8 (5–7):83107.
Gallagher, Shaun. 2004. “Understanding interpersonal problems in autism: Interaction theory as an alternative to theory of mind.” Philosophy, Psychiatry, and Psychology 11 (3):199217.
Gallagher, Shaun. 2005. How the Body Shapes the Mind. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Gallagher, Shaun. 2007. “Simulation trouble.” Social Neuroscience 2 (3–4):353–65.
Gallagher, Shaun. 2008. “Neural simulation and social cognition.” In Mirror Neuron Systems: The Role of Mirroring Processes in Social Cognition, edited by Pineda, Jaime A., 355–71. Totowa NJ: Humana Press.
Gallagher, Shaun. 2011a. “Narrative competency and the massive hermeneutical background.” In Hermeneutics in Education, edited by Fairfield, Paul, 2138. New York: Continuum.
Gallagher, Shaun. 2011b. “In defense of phenomenological approaches to social cognition: Interacting with the critics.” Review of Philosophy and Psychology. Published online first: DOI 10.1007/s13164-011-0080-1.
Gallagher, Shaun and Hutto, Daniel. 2008. “Primary interaction and narrative practice.” In The Shared Mind: Perspectives on Intersubjectivity, edited by Zlatev, Jordan, Racine, Timothy P., Sinha, Chris, and Itkonen, Esa, 1738. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Gallagher, Shaun and Cole, Jonathan. 2010. “Dissociation in self-narrative.” Consciousness and Cognition 20:149155.
Gallese, Vittorio. 2001. “The ‘shared manifold’ hypothesis: From mirror neurons to empathy.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 8:3350.
Gallese, Vittorio. 2003. “The roots of empathy: The shared manifold hypothesis and the neural basis of intersubjectivity.” Psychopathology 36:171180.
Gallese, Vittorio. 2005. “‘Being like me’: Self-other identity, mirror neurons and empathy.” In Perspectives on Imitation, edited by Hurley, Susan and Chater, Nick, 101118. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Gallese, Vittorio. 2009. “Motor abstraction: A neuroscientific account of how action goals and intentions are mapped and understood.” Psychological Research 73 (4):486–98.
Gallese, Vittorio and Goldman, Alvin. 1998. “Mirror neurons and the simulation theory of mind-reading.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences 12:493501.
Goldman, Alvin I. 1989. “Interpretation psychologized.” Mind and Language 4:161185.
Goldman, Alvin I. 2002. “Simulation theory and mental concepts.” In Simulation and Knowledge of Action, edited by Dokic, Jérôme and Proust, Joëlle, 119. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Goldman, Alvin. 2005a. “Mirror Systems, Social Understanding and Social Cognition.” Interdisciplines. http://www.interdisciplines.org/mirror/papers/3/6/1 (last accessed 30 May 2005).
Goldman, Alvin. 2005b. “Imitation, mind reading, and simulation.” In Perspectives on Imitation II, edited by Hurley, Susan and Chater, Nick, 7993. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Goldman, Alvin. 2006. Simulating minds: The philosophy, psychology and neuroscience of mindreading. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Goldman, Alvin. 2011. “Two routes to empathy: Insights from cognitive neuroscience.” In Empathy: Philosophical and Psychological Perspectives, edited by Coplan, Amy and Goldie, Peter. Oxford: Oxford University Press. DOI: 10.1093/ac prof: 050/9780199 5399 56.003.0004.
Goldman, Alvin I. and Sripada, Chandra S.. 2005. “Simulationist models of face-based emotion recognition.” Cognition 94:193213.
Gordon, Robert M. 1996. “‘Radical’ simulationism.” In Theories of Theories of Mind, edited by Carruthers, Peter and Smith, Peter K., 1121. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Grezes, Julie and Decety, Jean. 2001. “Functional anatomy of execution, mental simulation, observation, and verb generation of actions: A meta-analysis.” Human Brain Mapping 12:119.
Gutsell, Jennifer N. and Inzlich, Michael. 2010. “Empathy constrained: Prejudice predicts reduced mental simulation of actions during observation of outgroups.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 46 (5):841845
He, Zijing and Baillargeon, Renée. 2011. “False-belief understanding in 2.5-year-olds: Evidence from change-of-location and unexpected-contents violation-of-expectation tasks.” Developmental Science 14:292305.
Heal, Jane. 1996. “Simulation, theory and content.” In Theories of Theories of Mind, edited by Carruthers, Peter and Smith, Peter K., 7589. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Herschbach, Mitchell. 2007. “The phenomenological critics of folk psychology: The case of false belief.” Paper presented at the Berkeley-Stanford-Davis Graduate Student Conference, 14 April 2007.
Hogan, Robert. 1969. “Development of an empathy scale.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 33:307316.
Howe, Mark L. 2000. The Fate of Early Memories: Developmental Science and the Retention of Childhood Experiences. Washington: American Psychological Association.
Hurley, Susan. L. 2005. “Active perception and perceiving action: The shared circuits model.” In Perceptual Experience, edited by Gendler, Tamar and Hawthorne, John, 205259. New York: Oxford University Press.
Hurley, Susan L. 2008. “The shared circuits model. How control, mirroring, and simulation can enable imitation and mindreading.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 31 (1):122
Hutto, Daniel D. 2008: Folk Psychological Narratives: The Socio-Cultural Basis of Understanding Reasons. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Jacob, Pierre. 2008. “What do mirror neurons contribute to human social cognition?Mind and Language 23 (2):190223.
Jacob, Pierre. 2011. “The direct perception model of empathy: A critique.” Review of Philosophy and Psychology 2 (3):519540.
Jeannerod, Marc and Pacherie, Elizabeth. 2004. “Agency, simulation, and self-identification.” Mind and Language 19 (2):113–46.
Keysers, Christian and Gazzola, Valeria. 2006. “Towards a unifying neural theory of social cognition.” Progress in Brain Research 156:383406.
McIntyre, Alestair. 1981. After Virtue. South Bend: University of Notre Dame Press.
Merleau Ponty, Maurice. 1962. Phenomenology of Perception. Translated by Smith, Colin. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Nelson, Katherine. 1992. “Emergence of autobiographical memory at age 4.” Human Development 35:172177.
Nelson, Katherine. 2003. “Narrative and the emergence of a consciousness of self.” In Narrative and Consciousness: Literature, Psychology, and the Brain, edited by Fireman, Gary D., McVay, Ted E. Jr. and Flanagan, Owen J., 1736. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Nelson, Katherine. 2009. “Narrative Practices and Folk Psychology: A Perspective from Developmental Psychology.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 16 (6–8):6993.
Newman-Norlund, Roger D., Noordzij, Matthijs L., Meulenbroek, Rudd G.J., and Bekkering, Harold. 2007. “Exploring the brain basis of joint attention: Co-ordination of actions, goals and intentions.” Social Neuroscience 2 (1):4865.
Perner, Josef. 1992. “Grasping the concept of representation: Its impact on 4-year-olds’ theory of mind and beyond.” Human Development 35:146155.
Richner Elizabeth, S. and Nicolopoulou, Ageliki. 2001. “The narrative construction of differing conceptions of the person in the development of young children's social understanding.” Early Education and Development 12:393432.
Rizzolatti, Giacomo, Fogassi, Leonardo, and Gallese, Vittorio. 2001. “Neurophysiological mechanisms underlying the understanding and imitation of action.” Nature Review Neuroscience 2:661670.
Ruby, Perine and Decety, Jean. 2001. “Effect of subjective perspective taking during simulation of action: a PET investigation of agency.” Nature Neuroscience 4 (5):546–50.
Ruffman, Ted and Perner, Josef. 2005. “Do infants really understand false belief? Response to Leslie.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences 9 (10):462–63.
Shanton, Karen and Goldman, Alvin. 2010. “Simulation theory.” Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Cognitive Science. http://fas-philosophy.rutgers.edu/goldman/Simulation%20Theory.pdf (last accessed 21 February 2010).
Slovic, Paul. 2007. “If I look at the mass I will never act: Psychic numbing and genocide.” Judgment and Decision Making 2:7995.
Small, Deborah A., Loewenstein, George, and Slovic, Paul. 2007. “Sympathy and callousness: Affect and deliberations in donation decisions.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 102:143153.
Southgate, Victoria, Chevallier, Coralie, and Csibra, Gergely. 2010. “Seventeen-month-olds’ appeal to false beliefs to interpret others’ referential communication.” Developmental Science 13 (6):907912.
Stueber, Karsten R. 2006. Rediscovering Empathy: Agency, Folk-Psychology and the Human Sciences. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Stueber, Karsten R. 2008. “Reasons, generalizations, empathy, and narratives: The epistemic structure of action explanation.” History and Theory 47 (February):3143.
Stueber, Karsten R. 2012. “Varieties of empathy: Neuroscience and the narrativist challenge to the contemporary theory of mind debate.” Emotion Review 4 (1):5563.
Luca, Surian, Caldi, Stefania, and Sperber, Dan. 2007. “Attribution of beliefs by 13-month-old infants.” Psychol Science 18 (7):580586.
Dan, Zahavi. 2011. “Empathy and direct social perception: A Phenomenological Proposal.” Review of Philosophy and Psychology 2 (3):541558.
Zahavi, Dan and Overgaard, Søren. 2011. “Empathy without isomorphism: A phenomenological account.” In Empathy: From Bench to Bedside, edited by Decety, Jean, 320. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Zahn-Waxler, Carolyn and Radke-Yarrow, Marian. 1982. “The development of altruism: Alternative research strategies.” In The Development of Prosocial Behavior, edited by Eisenberg, Nancy and Berlin, Harry, 109138. New York: Academic Press.
Zahn-Waxler, Carolyn, Radke-Yarrow, Marian, Wagner, Elizabeth, and Chapman, Michael. 1992. “Development of concern for others.” Developmental Psychology 28:126136.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Science in Context
  • ISSN: 0269-8897
  • EISSN: 1474-0664
  • URL: /core/journals/science-in-context
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed