Skip to main content
×
Home

Godly Men and Mechanical Philosophers: Souls and Spirits in Restoration Natural Philosophy

  • Simon Schaffer (a1)
Abstract
The Argument

Recent historiography of the Scientific Revolution has challenged the assumption that the achievements of seventeenth-century natural philosophy can easily be described as the ‘mechanization of the world-picture.’ That assumption licensed a story which took mechanization as self-evidently progressive and so in no need of further historical analysis. The clock-work world was triumphant and inevitably so. However, a close examination of one key group of natural philosophers working in England during the 1670s shows that their program necessarily incorporated souls and spirits, attractions and congruities, within both their ontology and their epistemology. Any natural philosophical strategy which excluded spirits and sympathies from its world was condemned as tending to subversion and irreligion. This examination shows that the term ‘mechanical philosophy’ was a category given its meanings within local contexts and carries no universal sense separate from that accomplished by these natural philosophers. It also shows how the experimental praxis was compelled to treat souls and spirits, to produce them through experimental labor, and then to extend these experimentally developed entities throughout the cosmos, both social and natural. The development of mechanical philosophy cannot be used to explain the cognitive and social structure of this program, nor its success: instead, the historical setting of experimental work shows how a philosophy of matter and spirit was deliberately constructed by the end of the seventeenth century.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Alexander Peter, 1985. Ideas, Qualities and Corpuscules: Locke and Boyle on the External World, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Aubrey John, 1972. Three Prose Works: Miscellanies, Remaines of Gentilisme and Judaisme, Observations; ed. Buchanan-Brown J., Fontwell: Centaur Press.
Aylmer G. E., 1978. “Unbelief in Seventeenth Century England,” in Puritans and Revolutionaries, ed. Pennington D. and Thomas K., Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 121.
Bechler Zev, 1974. “Newton's 1672 Optical Controversies: A Study in the Grammar of Scientific Dissent,” in The Interaction Between Science and Philoposophy, ed. Elkana Y., Atlantic Highlands, N.J.: Humanities Press, pp. 115–42.
Bennett J. A., 1975. “Hooke, Wren and the System of the World,” British Journal for the History of Science 8: 3261.
Bennett J. A., 1981. “Cosmology and the Magnetical Philosophy, 1640–1680,” Journal for the History of Astronomy 12: 165–77.
Bennett J. A., 1986. “The Mechanics' Philosophy and the Mechanical Philosophy,” History of Science 24: 128.
Birch Thomas, 17561757. History of the Royal Society, 4 vols.
Bloch Marc, 1983. Les Rois Thaumaturges, new ed., Paris: Gallimard.
Boyle Robert, 1772. The Works, 2d ed., 6 vols.
Capp Bernard, 1984. “The Fifth Monarchists and Popular Millenarianism” in Radical Religion in the English Revolution, ed. McGregor J. F. and Reay B., Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 165–89.
Charleton Walter, 1654. Physiologia Epicuro-Gassendo-Charltoniana.
Cohen Edward H. and Ross John S., 1985. “The Commonplace Book of Edmond Halley,” Notes and Records of the Royal Society 40:140.
Crawfurd R., 1911. The King's Evil, Oxford.
Cudworth Ralph, 1678. The True Intellectual System of the Universe, Cambridge.
Curry Patrick, 1985. “Revisions of Science and MagicHistory of Science 23: 299325.
Davis A. B., 1973. Circulation Physiology and Medical Chemistry in England 1650–1680, Lawrence: Coronado Press.
Debus A. G., 1977. The Chemical Philosophy, New York: Science History Publications, 2 vols.
Debus A. G., 1980. “Thomas Sherley's Philosophical Essay (1672): Helmontian Mechanism as the Basis of a New PhilosophyAmbix 27:124135.
Dijksterhuis E. J., 1961. The Mechanization of the World Picture, Oèford: Clarendon Press.
Dobbs B. J. T., 1975. The Foundations of Newton's Alchemy: or, “The Hunting of the Greene Lyon” Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dobbs B. J. T., 1982. “Newton's Alchemy and his Theory of Matter,” Isis 73:511–25.
Duffy Eamonn, 1981. “Valentine Greatrakes, the Irish Stroker: Miracle, Science and Orthodoxy in Restoration England,” Studies in Church History 17:251–73.
Easlea Brian, 1980. Witch-hunting, Magic and the New Philosophy, Brighton: Harvester.
Figala Karin, 1977. “Newton as Alchemist,” History of Science 15: 102–37.
Fisch Harold, 1953. “The Scientist as Priest: A Note on Robert Boyle's Natural Philosophy,” Isis 44:252–65.
Forbes E. G., 1975. The Gresham Lectures of John Flamsteed, London: Mansell.
Foucault Michel, 1969. “Médecins, juges et sorciers au 17e siècle” Mèdecine en France 200: 121128.
Frank Robert, 1980. Harvey and the Oxford Physiologists, Berkeley: University of California Press.
Freudenthal Gad, 1983. “Theory of Matter and Cosmology in William Gilbert's De Magnete,” Isis 74:2237.
Gabbey Alan, 1982. “Philosophia Cartesiana Triumphata: Henry More, 1646–1671” in Problems of Cartesianism, ed. Lennon T. M., Nicholas J. M. and Davis J. W., Kingston and Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press.
Gabbey Alan, 1985. “The Mechanical Philosophy and its Problems: Mechanical Explanations, Impenetrability and Perpetual Motion,” in Change and Progress in Modern Science, ed. Pitt J. C., Dordrecht: D. Reidel, pp. 984.
Gascoigne John, 1985. “The Universities and the Scientific Revolution: the Case of Newton and Restoration Cambridge,” History of Science 23:391431.
Ginzburg Carlo, 1983. The Night Battles: Witchcraft and Agrarian Cults in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries, London: Routledge.
Glanvill Joseph, 1665. Scepsis Scientifica.
Glanvill Joseph, 1671. A Praefaratory Answer to Mr. Henry Stubbe.
Gouk P., 1980. “The Role of Acoustics and Music Theory in the Scientific Work of Robert Hooke,” Annals of Science 37:573605.
Guerlac H., 1977. Essays and Papers in History of Modern Science, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Gunther R. T., 1931. Early Science in Oxford, 14 vols., Oxford: privately printed.
Hale Matthew, 1677. Observations Touching the Principles of Natural Motion.
Hall M. B., 1952. “The Establishment of the Mechanical Philosophy,” Osiris 10:412541.
Hannaway Owen, 1975. The Chemists and the Word, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Heyd Michael, 1981. “The Reaction to Enthusiasm in the Seventeenth Century: Towards an Integrative Approach,” Journal of Modern History 53:258–80.
Hill Christopher, 1965. Intellectual Origins of the English Revolution, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hill Christopher, 1975. The World Turned Upside Down: Radical Ideas During the English Revolution, Harmondsworth: Penguin.
Hill Christopher, 1984. “Irreligion in the Puritan Revolution,” in Radical Religion in the English Revolution, ed. McGregor J. F. and Reay B., Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 191211.
Hirst P.Q., 1982. “Witchcraft Todayand Yesterday,” Economy and Society 11:428–48.
Hiscock W. G., 1937. David Gregory, Isaac Newton and their Circle, Oxford: privately printed.
Hobbes Thomas, 1651. Leviathan.
Hobbes Thomas, 1662. “Considerations upon the Reputation, Loyalty, Manners and Religion of Thomas Hobbes,” in The English Works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, ed. SirMolesworth W., 11 vols., London 1839–1845, Vol. 4, pp. 409–40.
Hooke Robert, 1661. An Attempt for the Explication of the Phenomena Observable in an Experiment Published by the Honourable Robert Boyle.
Hooke Robert, 1665. Micrographia.
Hooke Robert, 1705. Posthumous Works, ed. Waller Richard.
Hooke Robert, 1935. Diary, ed. Robinson H. W. and Adams W., London: Taylor and Francis.
Hunter Michael, 1975. John Aubrey and the Realm of Learning, London: Duckworth.
Hunter Michael, 1981. Science and Society in Restoration England, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hunter Michael and Wood P. B., 1986. “Towards Solomon's House: Rival Strategies for Reforming the Early Royal Society,” History of Science 24:49108.
Hutchison Keith, 1982. “What Happened to Occult Qualities in the Scientific Revolution?,” Isis 73: 233–53.
Ihde A. J., 1964. “Alchemy in Reverse: Boyle on the Degradation of Gold,” Chymia 9: 4757.
Jacob J. R., 1977. Robert Boyle and the English Revolution. Burt Franklin, New York.
Jacob J. R., 1983. Henry Stubbe, Radical Protestantism and the Early Enlightenment, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Jacob M. C., Jacob J. R., 1980. “The Anglican Origins of Modern Science,” Isis 71: 251–67.
Jobe T. H., 1981. “The Devil in Restoration Science: the Glanvill-Webster Debate,” Isis 72: 343–56.
Kaplan B. B., 1982. “Greatrakes the Stroker: the Interpretations of His Contemporaries,” Isis 72: 178–85.
Klaaren Eugene M., 1977. The Religious Origins of Modern Science, Grand Rapids, Mich.: William B. Eerdmans.
Koyré Alexandre, 1952. “An Unpublished Letter of Robert Hooke to Isaac Newton,” Isis 43: 312–37.
Koyré Alexandre, 1956. “The Origins of Modern Science,” Diogenes 16: 122.
Kubrin D. C., 1967. “Newton and the Cyclical Cosmos,” Journal of the History of Ideas 28: 325–46.
Lamont William, 1969. Godly Rule: Politics and Religion 1603–1660. London: Macmillan.
Larner Christina, 1984. Witchcraft and Religion: the Politics of Popular Belief. Oxford: Blackwell.
Leibniz G. W. von, 1956. The Leibniz-Clarke Correspondence, ed. Alexander H., Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Lennard R. V., 19321934. “English Agriculture under Charles II: Evidence of the Royal Society Enquiries,” Economic History Review 4:2345.
Macdonald Michael, 1982. “Religion, Social Change, and Psychological Healing in England,” Studies in Church History 19: 101–26.
Macfarlane Alan, 1977. “Witchcraft in Tudor and Stuart Essex,” in Crime in England, 1550–1800, ed. Cockburn J. S., London: Macmillan.
McGee J. S., 1976. The Godly Man in Stuart England, New Haven: Yale University Press.
McGuire J. E., 1968. “Force, Active Principles and Newton's Invisible Realm,” Ambix 15: 154208.
McKeon Michael, 1975. Politics and Poetry in Restoration England, Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
McKie Douglas, 1953. “Fire and the Flamma Vitalis: Boyle, Hooke and Mayow,” in Science, Medicine and History, ed. Underwood E. Ashworth, London: Oxford University Press, pp. 469–88.
Maddison R. E. W., 1969. The Life of the Honourable Robert Boyle, London: Taylor and Francis.
Mayow John, 1964. Tractatus quinque. Oxford.
Mayow John, 1957. Medico-physical Works, ed. Brown A. Crum and Dobbin L., Edinburgh: Livingstone.
Millen Ron, 1985. “The Manifestation of Occult Qualities in the Scientific Revolution,” in Religion, Science and World-View: Essays in Honor of Richard S. Westfall, ed. Osier M. J. and Farber P. L., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 185216.
More Henry, 1962. A Collection of Several Philosophical Writings.
Newton Isaac, 1687. Principia mathematica.
Newton Isaac, 1934. Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy, ed. Cajori F., Berkeley: California University Press.
Newton Isaac, 1958. Papers and Letters on Natural Philosophy, ed. Cohen I. B. and Schofield R. E., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Newton Isaac, 19591977. Correspondence, ed. Turnbull H. W., Scott J. D., Hall A. R., and Tilling L., 7 vols., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Newton Isaac, 1962. Unpublished Scientific Papers, ed. Hall A. R. and Hall M. B., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Nicolson M. H., 1930. The Conway Letters, New Haven: Yale University Press.
Pagel W., 1982. Joan Baptista van Helmont, Reformer of Science and Medicine, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Petty William, 1674. Discourse Concerning the Use of Duplicate Proportion.
Porter R. S., 1983. “The Rage of Party: a Glorious Revolution in English Psychiatry?,” Medical History 27: 3550.
Power Henry, 1664. Experimental Philosophy.
Ruffner J., 1966. The Background and Early Development of Newton's Theory of Comets, Ph.D. Thesis, Indiana University.
Schaffer Simon, 1987. “Newton's Comets and the Transformation of Astrology,” in Astrology, Science and Society: Historical Essays, ed. Curry P., London: Boydell and Brewer.
Schechner Genuth S., 1985. “Comets, Teleology and the Relationship of Chemistry to Cosmology in Newton's Thought,” Annali dell'Istituto e Museo di Storia della Scienza di Firenze 10: 3165.
Schuler Robert, 1980. “Some Spiritual Alchemies of Seventeenth Century England,” Journal of the History of Ideas 41: 293318.
Schuster J. A., 1984. “Methodologies as Mythic Structures,” Metascience 1: 1536.
Schwartz Hillel, 1980. The French Prophets, Berkeley: California University Press.
Shapin Steven, 1984. “Pump and Circumstance: Robert Boyle's Literary Technology,” Social Studies of Science 14: 481520.
Shapin S. and Schaffer S., 1985. Leviathan and the Air Pump: Hobbes, Boyleandthe Experimental Life, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Singer B. R., 1976. “Robert Hooke on Memory, Association, and Time Perception,” Notes and Records of the Royal Society 31: 115–31.
Sprat Thomas, 1667. History of the Royal Society.
Staudenbauer C., 1974. “Platonism, Theosophy and Immaterialism: Recent Views of the Cambridge Platonists,” Journal of the History of Ideas 35: 157–69.
Steneck N. H., 1982. “Greatrakes the Stroker: the Interpretations of Historians,” Isis 73: 161–77.
Swift Jonathan, 1975. A Tale of a Tub and Other Satires, ed. Williams Kathleen, London: J. M. Dent.
Tamny M., 1978. “Newton, Creation and Perception,” Isis 70: 4858.
Taylor F. Sherwood, 1949. “Alchemical Papers of Dr. Robert Plot,” Ambix 4: 6776.
Thomas K., 1973. Religion and the Decline of Magic, Harmondsworth: Penguin.
Tourney G., 1972. “The Physician and Witchcraft in Restoration England,” Medical History 14: 143–55.
Wagstaffe John, 1671. The Question of Witchcraft Debated, 2d edn.
Walker D. P., 1958. Spiritual and Demonic Magic from Ficino to Campanella, London: Warburg Institute Studies.
Webster C., 1967. “The Experimental Philosophy of Henry Power,” Ambix 14: 150–78.
Webster C., 1982. From Paracelsus to Newton: Magic and the Making of Modern Science, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Westfall R. S., 1971. Force in Newton's Physics, London: Macdonald.
Westfall R. S., 1972. “Newton and the Hermetic Tradition,” in Science, Medecine and Society in the Renaissance, ed. Debus A. G., New York: Science History Publications, pp. 183–93.
Westfall R. S., 1973. Science and Religion in Seventeenth Century England, Ann Arbor: Michigan University Press.
Westfall R. S., 1977. The Construction of Modern Science, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Westfall R. S., 1984. “Newton and Alchemy,” in Occult and Scientific Mentalities in the Renaissance, ed. Vickers Brian, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
White Thomas, 1663. An Exclusion of Scepticks from All Title to Dispute.
Whiteside D. T., 1970. “Before the Principia: the Maturing of Newton's Thoughts on Dynamical Astronomy,” Journal for the History of Astronomy 1: 519.
Wren C, 1750. Parentalia, or Memoirs of the Family of Wrens.
Wrightson Keith, 1982. English Society, 1580–1680. London: Hutchinson.
Zambelli P., ed., 1982. Scienze, Credenze Occulte, Livelli di Cultura, Florence: Olschki.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Science in Context
  • ISSN: 0269-8897
  • EISSN: 1474-0664
  • URL: /core/journals/science-in-context
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 79 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 895 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 18th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.