Skip to main content
×
Home

Shifting Expert Configurations and the Public Credibility of Science: Boundary Work and Identity Work of Hydraulic Engineers (1980–2009)

  • Erwin van Rijswoud (a1)
Argument
Argument

In the Netherlands, a country of water, dikes, and dams, the role of civil engineering in policy making and public debates over flood safety have changed over the last four decades. This had not just implied that new directions in flood safety policy were considered by politics, but also that engineering experts traditionally working in this area found their credibility challenged by competing expertises. I will argue that in responding to those challenges, experts combined boundary work (upholding boundaries between science and non-science, or between different fields of expertise) with identity work, in which the planning of actions and learning from experience are informed by the identity of oneself as an expert. The views of experts on the boundary zone of science, policy, and public debate, and the role and skills one attributes to oneself, are regarded as important aspects of that identity work. On the basis of biographical-narrative research, this will show that although the four experts studied here belong to a specific generation of engineers, experiencing common challenges and developments in their field of work, the combination of identity work and boundary work results in specific roles and responses for each individual expert.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Abbott Andrew. 1988. The System of Professions: An Essay on the Division of Expert Labour. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.
Anon. 2005. “Maak gebruik van onze kennis!” [Please Use Our Knowledge!]. Telegraaf, 9 April, 11.
Berkers Eric, and Nispen Marie Louise Ten Horn-van. 1998. “Het dynamische waterstaatsdomein” [The Dynamic Water Policy System]. In Techniek in Nederland in de twintigste eeuw [Technology in the Netherlands in the Twentieth Century], edited by Schot Johann W., Rip Arie and Albert de la Bruheze A. A., 176180. Zutphen: Walburg Pers.
Bijker Wiebe. 2002. “The Oosterschelde Storm Surge Barrier: a Test Case for Dutch Water Technology, Management, and Politics.” Technology and Culture 43 (3):569584.
Birkland Thomas A. 1997. After Disaster: Agenda Setting, Public Policy and Focusing Events. Washington DC: Georgetown University Press.
Blumer Herbert. 1969. Symbolic Interactionism: Perspective and Method. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.
Bogardi I, Saeijs H.L.F., and Vrijling Han J.K.. 1991. “Involvement of Ecology in the Decision Process.” Journal of Hydraulic Research 29:1, 20–23
Bohannon John, and Enserink Martin. 2005. “Scientists Weigh Options for Rebuilding New Orleans.” Science 309:18081809.
Buitenhof, (Dutch news and debate programm). 2008. Accessible at http://www.uitzendinggemist.nl/afleveringen/1193636, (last accessed February 10, 2008).
Collins Harry M., and Evans Rob. 2007. Rethinking Expertise. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
De Graaf Thomas C. 2003. “Modernisering van de overhead” [Modernization of the Government]. 29 362/1. Ministry of Administrative Renewal and Kingdom Relations.
De Vriend Huib J. 1981. “Steady Flow in Shallow Channel Bends.” Ph.D. diss. Delft University of Technology, Delft.
De Vriend Huib J. 2009. Interview by author, tape recorded, July 6.
Deltacommittee. 2008. Working Together with Water: A Living Land Builds for Its Future. The Hague: Delta Committee 2008.
Dewulf Art, Gray Barbara, Putnam Linda, Lewicki Roy, Aarts Noelle, Bouwen Rene, and Van Woerkum Cees. 2009. “Disentangling Approaches to Framing in Conflict and Negotiation Research: A Meta-paradigmatic Perspective.” Human Relations 62 (2):155193.
Disco Cornelis. 1998. “Uitwaterings- en Schutsluizen 1900–1940” [Discharge Sluices and Locks 1900–1940]. In Techniek in Nederland in de twintigste eeuw [Technology in the Netherlands in the Twentieth Century], edited by Schot Johann W., Rip Arie, and de la Bruheze Adri Albert, 131154. Zutphen: Walburg Pers.
Disco Cornelis. 2002. “Remaking ‘Nature’: The Ecological Turn in Dutch Water Management.” Science, Technology and Human Values 27 (2):206235.
Expertise Netwerk Waterkeringen. 5 March 2008. “Letter to Annemieke G. Nijhof” (Director-General Water Management).
Fresco Louise O., and Cees Veerman. 2008. “De Delta kan zelfs zwartste scenario aan” [The Delta Can Cope with the Worst-case Scenario]. Volkskrant, 24 September 2008, 11.
Gieryn Thomas F. 1983. “Boundary Work and the Demarcation of Science from Non-Science: Strains and Interests in Professional Ideologies of Scientists.” American Sociological Review 48(December):781795.
Gieryn Thomas F. 1995. “Boundaries of Science.” In Handbook of Science and Technology Studies, edited by Gerald E. Markle James C. Petersen, and Pinch Trevor, 393–343. Thousand Oaks CA: Sage.
Gieryn Thomas F. 1999. Cultural Boundaries of Science: Credibility on the Line. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Hagendijk Robert P. 1996. “Wetenschap, Constructivisme en Cultuur” [Science, Constructivism, and Culture] Ph.D. diss., University of Amsterdam.
Havinga Hendrick, and Smits Antoine J.M.. 2000. “River Management along the Rhine: A Retrospective View.” In New Approaches to River Management, edited by Smits Antoine J. M., Nienhuis Piet H. and Leuven Rob S. E. W., 1532. Leiden: Backhuys Publishers.
Hoppe Robert. 2009. “Scientific Advice and Public Policy: Expert Advisers’ and Policymakers’ Discourses on Boundary Work.” Poiesis & Praxis 6 (3–4):235263.
Huitema Dave, and Turnhout Esther. 2009. “Working at the Science-Policy Interface: A Discursive Analysis of Boundary Work at the Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency.” Environmental Politics 18 (4):576594.
Huizinga-Heringa Johanna Catharina. 2007. “Regulation for Appointment of a Committee on Sustainable Coastal Development (HDJZ/WAT/2007–1020).” Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management.
Janssen Pieter, and de Haan Tjalle. 2005. “Vorm en functie van het Expertise Netwerk Waterkeren” [Form and Function of the Expertise Network for Flood Protection]. Ministry of Transport, Public Works, and Water Management.
Jonkman Sebastian N., Stive Marcel J.F., and Vrijling Johannes K.. 2005. “New Orleans Is a Lesson to the Dutch.” Journal of Coastal Research 21 (6):1112.
Jonkman Sebastian N., and Vrijling Johannes K.. 2005. “Nederland kan leren van New Orleans” [Netherlands Can Draw Lessons from New Orleans]. NRC Handelsblad, 1 September, 9.
Jongejan Ruben, Vrijling Johannes K., and Jonkman Sebastian N.. 2008. “Bestuurders geboeid door de veiligheidsketen” [Administrators Tied by the Safety Chain]. Openbaar Bestuur 2–3.
Jongejan Ruben B., Vrijling Johannes K., Stive Marcel J.F. and Jonkman Sebastian N.. 2008. “A Comment on Changing Estuaries, Changing Views.” Hydrobiologia 605:1115.
Kabat Pavel, Van Vierssen Wim, Veraart Jeroen, Vellinga Pier, and Aerts Jeroen. 2005. “Climate Proofing the Netherlands.” Nature 438:283284.
Kingdon John W. 1995. Agendas, Alternatives and Public Policies. New York: Harper Collins.
Korevaar Gijs. 2007. “Niet bij dijkverhogingen alleen” [Not Just Higher Dikes]. Algemeen Dagblad, 17 September, 8.
Lintsen Harry W., and Nispen Marie-Louise Ten Horn-van. 1998. “De Waterstaat rond 1900” [Water Management around 1900]. In Techniek in Nederland in de twintigste eeuw [Technology in the Netherlands in the Twentieth Century], edited by Schot Johann W., Rip Arie, and Albert de la Bruheze Adri, 6570. Zutphen: Walburg Pers.
Littig Beate. 2008. “Interviews mit Eliten - Interviews mit ExpertInnen: Gibt es Unterschiede?Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung 9 (3):37.
Moore Molly. 2005. “Rethinking Defenses Against Sea's Power: Flood Experts See Lessons in New Orleans.” Washington Post, 8 September, 22.
Penders Bart, and Annemiek P. Nelis. 2011. “Credibility Engineering in the Food Industry: Linking Science, Regulation, and Marketing in a Corporate Context.” Science in Context 24 (4):487515.
Polkinghorne Donald E. 2005. “Narrative Configuration in Qualitative Analysis.” In Biographical Research Methods Vol. 2, edited by Miller Robert, 6998. London: Sage.
Reuss Martin. 2002. “Learning from the Dutch: Technology, Management, and Water Resource Development.” Technology and Culture 43(3):465472.
Rip Arie. 2006. “Folk Theories of Nanotechnologists.” Science as Culture 15 (4):349365.
Rosenthal Gabriela. 2005. “Biographical Research.” In Biographical Research Methods Vol. 3, edited by Miller Robert, 2558. London: Sage.
Schmit Hans. 1995. “De weersverwachting: meer regen” [The Weather Forecast: More Showers to Come]. Trouw, 4 February.
Schreuder Arjen. 2008. “Heel brede dijken waar alles op mag” [Very Broad Dikes Where Everything is Possible]. NRC Handelsblad, 6 February, 3.
Schultz van Haegen Melanie. 2003a. “Voortgang rivierdijkversterkingen” [Progress in the Strengthening of River Dikes]. Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management.
Schultz van Haegen Melanie. 2003b. “Research Programme Flyland.” Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management.
Schultz van Haegen Melanie. 2004. “Waterbeleid” [Water Policy]. 27 625/35. Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management.
Smits Antoine J.M., Nienhuis Piet H., and Leuven Rob S.E.W., eds. 2000. New Approaches to River Management. Leiden: Backhuys Publishers.
Sorgdrager Winnie. 1996. “Kaderwet Adviescolleges” [Framework Act for Advisory Councils]. Ministry of the Interior and Kingdom Relations.
Staatscourant. 2005a. “Wijziging Instellingsbesluit Adviescommissie Water en opheffing Technische Adviescommissie voor de Waterkeringen” [Amendment Appointment Decree Advisory Committee Water and Abolition Technical Advisory Council for Flood Protection]. Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management 122:13, 28 June.
Staatscourant. 2005b. “Instellingsbesluit Expertise Netwerk Waterkeren” [Appointment Decree Expertise Network Flood Protection]. Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management 245:40, 16 December.
Stehr Nico. 1994. Knowledge Societies. London. Thousand Oaks New Delhi: Sage.
Stive Marcel. 2009. Interview by author, tape recorded, June 23.
Stronkhorst Joost. 2008. Landaanwinning in de Noordzee: een verkenning van ervaringen [Land Reclamation in the North Sea: an Exploration of Experiences]. Delft: Deltares.
Van de Crommert Richard. 2005. “Duinen blijken te zwak” [Dunes are Too Weak]. Telegraaf, 1 March, 1.
Van den Brink Margot. 2009. “Rijkswaterstaat on the Horns of a Dilemma.” Ph.D. diss. Radboud University, Nijmegen.
Van der Ham Willem. 1999. Heersen en Beheersen: Rijkswaterstaat in de twintigste eeuw [Ruling and Controlling: the Corps of Engineers in the Twentieth Century]. Zaltbommel: Europese Bibliotheek.
Van der Vleuten Erik. 2010. “Networked Nation: Infrastructure Integration of the Netherlands.” In Technology and the Making of the Netherlands: The Age of Contested Modernization, 1890–1970, edited by Schot Johann W., Lintsen Harry, and Rip Arie, 47123. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Van Heezik Alex. 2008. Strijd om de Rivieren: 200 jaar rivierbeleid in Nederland [Battle for the Rivers: 200 Years of River Management in the Netherlands]. Haarlem/Den Haag: Van Heezik Beleidsresearch.
Van Hemert Mieke. 2008. “Making Rivers Modular. Emerging River Science 1980–2005.” Ph.D. diss., Twente University, Enschede.
Van Hemert Mieke, and Meulen Barend Van der. 2010. Kennis bundelen in onderzoeksprogramma's: Rivier- en kustonderzoek in Nederland [Merging Knowledge in Research Programs: Dutch Coast and River Research]. The Hague: Rathenau Institute.
Van Rijswoud Erwin. 2012. “Public Faces of Science: Experts and Identity Work in the Boundary Zone of Science, Policy and Public Debate.” Ph.D. diss., Radboud University, Nijmegen.
Vellinga Pier. 1986. “Beach and Dune Erosion during Storm Surges.” Ph.D diss., Delft University of Technology, Delft.
Vellinga Pier. 2003. “Klimaatverandering en de veiligheid van Nederland” [Climate Change and the Security of the Netherlands]. In Erasmuslecture 2003. van State Raad, The Hague: Erasmus Liga. Address given on May 28.
Vellinga Pier. 2009. Interview by author, tape recorded, May 26.
Vrijling Han. 2008a. “Verzekeren tegen grote overstroming” [Insuring Against Large Floods]. Expertise Netwerk Waterkeringen.
Vrijling Han. 2008b. “Het Deltaplan 2008 kritisch geanalyseerd. Een toekomstvast advies of een donderpreek?” [A Critical Analysis of the 2008 Deltaplan: Solid Advice or Sermon of Doom?]. Spil (5):15–18.
Vrijling Han. 2009. Interview by author, tape recorded, June 24.
Vrijling Han. 2010. Interview by author, tape recorded, June 28.
Weijers Ernest Paul, and Pier Vellinga. 1995. Climate Change and River Flooding: Changes in Rainfall Processes and Flooding Regimes Due to an Enhanced Greenhouse Effect. Amsterdam: Instituut voor Milieuvraagstukken.
Wengraf Tom. 2000. “Uncovering the General from Within the Particular: From Contingencies to Typologies in the Understanding of Cases.” In The Turn to Biographical Methods in Social Science: Comparative Issues and Examples, edited by Chamberlayne Prue, Bornat Joanna, and Wengraf Tom, 140164. London: Routledge.
Wesselink Anna J. 2007. “Flood Safety in the Netherlands: The Dutch Response to Hurricane Katrina.” Technology in Society 29:239247.
Wynne Brian. 1992. “Misunderstood Misunderstanding: Social Identities and the Public Uptake of Science.” Public Understanding of Science 1:281304.
Zembla [Dutch Public Broadcasting]. 2003. De nieuwe watersnood [The New Flood]. Accessible at http://zembla.incontxt.nl/seizoenen/2003/afleveringen/02-01-2003, last accessed, January 2, 2003.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Science in Context
  • ISSN: 0269-8897
  • EISSN: 1474-0664
  • URL: /core/journals/science-in-context
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 4
Total number of PDF views: 19 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 135 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 20th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.