Skip to main content
×
×
Home

The Social Brain and the Myth of Empathy

  • Allan Young (a1)
Argument

Neuroscience research has created multiple versions of the human brain. The “social brain” is one version and it is the subject of this paper. Most image-based research in the field of social neuroscience is task-driven: the brain is asked to respond to a cognitive (perceptual) stimulus. The tasks are derived from theories, operational models, and back-stories now circulating in social neuroscience. The social brain comes with a distinctive back-story, an evolutionary history organized around three, interconnected themes: mind-reading, empathy, and the emergence of self-consciousness. This paper focuses on how empathy has been incorporated into the social brain and redefined via parallel research streams, employing a shared, imaging technology. The concluding section describes how these developments can be understood as signaling the emergence of a new version of human nature and the unconscious. My argument is not that empathy in the social brain is a myth, but rather that it is served by a myth consonant with the canons of science.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Addis, Donna Rose, Wong, Alana, and Schacter, Daniel L.. 2007. “Remembering the past and imagining the future: common and distinct neural substrates during event construction.”Neuropsychologia 45 (7):13631377.
Bargh, John A. and Morsella, Ezequiel. 2008. “The unconscious mind.” Perspectives in Psychological Science 3:7379.
Barkow, Jerome H., Cosmides, Leda, and Tooby, John, eds. 1992. The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture. New York: Oxford University Press.
Baron-Cohen, Simon, Knickmeyer, Rebecca C., and Belmonte, Matthew K.. 2005. “Sex differences in the brain: implications for explaining autism.” Science 310:819823.
Baron-Cohen, Simon and Wheelwright, Sally. 2004. “The Empathy Quotient: an investigation of adults with asperger syndrome or high functioning autism, and normal sex differences.” Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 34:163175.
Barton, Robert A. and Dunbar, Robin I.M.. 1997. “Evolution of the social brain.” In Machiavellian Intelligence II, edited by Whiten, Andrew W. and Byrne, Richard W., 240263. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Berntsen, Dorthe and Hall, Nicolene M.. 2004. “The episodic nature of involuntary autobiographical memories.” Memory and Cognition 32:789803.
Blakeslee, Sandra. 2006. “Cells that read minds.” New York Times, 10 January.
Boden, Margaret A. 2006. Mind as Machine: A History of Cognitive Science, vol. 2. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Boyd, Robert, Gintis, Herbert, Bowles, Samuel, and Richerson, Peter J.. 2003. “The evolution of altruistic punishment.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 100:35313535.
Boyer, Pascal. 2010. “Evolutionary economics of mental time travel?Trends in Cognitive Sciences 12:219224.
Brass, Marcel, Schmitt, Ruth M., Spengler, Stephanie, and Gergely, György. 2007. “Investigating action understanding: inferential processes versus action simulation.” Current Biology 17:21172121.
Brooks, David. 2011a. “Social animal: How the new sciences of human nature can help make sense of a life.” New Yorker, 17 January.
Brooks, David. 2011b. The Social Animal: The Hidden Sources of Love, Character, and Achievement. New York: Random House.
Brothers, Leslie. 1989. “A biological perspective on empathy.” American Journal of Psychiatry 146:1019.
Busby, Janie and Suddendorf, Thomas. 2005. “Recalling yesterday and predicting tomorrow.” Cognitive Development 20:362372.
Byrne, Richard and Whiten, Andrew, eds. 1988. Machiavellian Intelligence. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Carr, Laurie, Iacoboni, Marco, Dubeau, Maria-Charlotte, Mazziotta, John C., and Lenzi, Gian Luigi. 2003. “Neural mechanisms of empathy in humans: a relay from neural systems for imitation to limbic areas.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 100:54975502.
Corballis, Michael C. 2009. “Mental time travel and the shaping of language.” Experimental Brain Research 192:553560.
Custers, Ruud and Aarts, Henk. 2010. “The unconscious will: how the pursuit of goals operates outside of conscious awareness.” Science 320:4750.
Decety, Jean and Grèze, Julie. 2006. “The power of simulation: Imagining one's own and other's behavior.” Brain Research 1079:414.
de Quervain, Dominique, Fischbacher, Urs, Treyer, Valerie, Schellhammer, Melanie, Schnyder, Ulrich, Buck, Alfred, and Fehr, Ernst. 2004. “The neural basis of altruistic punishment.” Science 305:12541258.
de Vignemont, Frederique and Singer, Tania. 2006. “The empathic brain: how, when and why?Trends in Cognitive Sciences 10:435441.
de Vignemont, Frederique and Haggard, Patrick. 2008. Action observation and execution: What is shared? Social Neuroscience 3:421433.
di Pellegrino, Giussepe, Luciano, Fadiga, Leonardo, Fogassi, Vittorio, Gallese, and Rizzolatti, Giacomo. 1992. “Understanding motor events: a neurophysiological study.” Experimental Brain Research 91:176180.
Dinstein, Ilan. 2008. “Human cortex: reflections of mirror neurons.” Current Biology 18:R956959.
Dinstein, Ilan, Uri Hasson, Nava Rubin, and Heeger, David J.. 2007. “Brain areas selective for both observed and executed movements.” Journal of Neurophysiology 98:14151427.
Dinstein, Ilan, Thomas, Cibu, Behrmann, Marlene, and Heeger, David J.. 2008. “A Mirror up to Nature.” Current Biology 18:R1318.
Dunbar, Robin I. M. 2003. “The social brain: mind, language, and society in evolutionary perspective.” Annual Review of Anthropology 32:163181.
Fadiga, Luciano and Craighero, Laila. 2004. “Electrophysiology of action representation.” Journal of Clinical Neurophysiology 21:57169.
Fadiga, Luciano, Pavesi, Giovanni, and Rizzolatti, Giacomo. 1996. “Motor facilitation during observation: a magnetic simulation study.” Journal of Neurophysiology 73:26082611.
Fehr, Ernst and Camerer, Colin F.. 2007. “Social neuroeconomics: the neural circuitry of social preferences.” Trends in Cognitive Science 11:419427.
Fliessbach, Klaus, Weber, Bernd, Trautner, P., Dohmen, T., Sunde, U., Elger, C.E., and Falk, A.. 2007. “Social comparison affects reward-related brain activity in the human ventral striatum.”Science 318:13051308.
Fodor, Jerry. 1983. Modularity of Mind: An Essay on Faculty Psychology. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Fodor, Jerry. 2000. The Mind Doesn't Work that Way: The Scope and Limits of Computational Psychology. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Fogassi, Leonardo, Gallese, Vittorio, and Rizzolatti, Giacomo. 2002. “Hearing sounds, understanding actions: action representation in mirror neurons.” Science 297:846848.
Fogassi, Leonardo, Ferrari, Piere F., Gesierich, Benno, Rozzi, Stefano, Chersi, Fabian, and Rizzolatti, Giacomo. 2005. “Parietal lobe: from action organization to intention understanding.” Science 308:662667.
Friston, Karl. 2002. Beyond phrenology: What can neuroimaging tell us about distributed circuitry? Annual Review of Neuroscience 25:2212250.
Gallese, Vittorio. 2001. “The “shared manifold” hypothesis: from mirror neurons to empathy.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 8:3350.
Gallese, Vittorio. 2003a. “The roots of empathy: the shared manifold hypothesis and the neural basis of intersubjectivity.” Psychopathology 36:171180.
Gallese, Vittorio. 2003b. “A neuroscientific grasp of concepts: from control to representation.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 358:12311240.
Gallese, Vittorio and Goldman, Alvin. 1998. “Mirror neurons and the simulation theory of mind reading.” Trends in Cognitive Science 2:493501.
Gallese, Vittoriao, Keysers, Christian, and Rizzolatti, Giacomo. 2004. “A unifying view of the basis of social cognition.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences 8:396403.
Gallese, Vittorio, Eagle, Morris, and Migone, Paolo. 2007. “Intentional attunement: mirror neurons and the neural underpinnings of interpersonal relations.” Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 55:151176.
Gergely, Csibra, and Gergely, György. 2007. “‘Obsessed with goals’: functions and mechanisms of teleological interpretation of actions in humans.” Acta Psychologica 124:6078.
Gergely, György, Bekkering, Harold, and Kiraly, Ildiko. 2002. “Rational imitation in preverbal infants.” Nature 415:755.
Hadjikhani, Nouchine, Joseph, Robert M., Snyder, Josh, and Tager-Flusberg, Helen. 2006. “Anatomical differences in the mirror neuron system and social cognition network in autism.” Cerebral Cortex 16:12761282.
Hamilton, William D. 1964. “The genetical evolution of social behaviour. I.” Journal of Theoretical Biology 7:116.
Hassin, Ran R., Uleman, James S., and Bargh, John A., eds. 2005. The New Unconscious. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
Heyes, Cecilia. 2010. “Mesmerizing mirror neurons.” Neuroimage 51:789791.
Hickcok, Gregory. 2009. “Eight problems for the mirror neuron theory of action understanding in monkeys and humans.” Journal of Cognitive Neurosciences 21:12291243.
Hrdy, Sandra B. 2009. Mothers and Others: the Evolutionary Origins of Mutual Understanding. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
Iacoboni, Marco. 2009. “Imitation, empathy, and mirror neurons.” Annual Review of Psychology 60:653670.
Iacoboni, Marco. 2008. Mirroring People: The New Science of How We Connect with Others. New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux.
Iacoboni, Marco and Dapretto, Mirella. 2006. “The mirror neuron system and the consequences of its dysfunction.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 7:942951.
Iacoboni, Marco, Molnar-Szakacs, Istvan, Gallese, Vittorio, Buccino, Giovanni, Mazziotta, John C., and Rizzolatti, Giacomo. 2005. “Grasping the intentions of others with one's own mirror neuron system.” PLoS (Public Library of Science) Biology 3:e79.
Jacob, Pierre. 2008. “What do mirror neurons contribute to human social cognition?Mind and Language 23:190223.
Jacob, Pierre and Jeannerod, Marc. 2005. “The motor theory of social cognition: a critique.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences 9:2125.
Jackson, Philip L., Meltzoff, Andrew N., and Decety, Jean. 2005. “How do we perceive the pain of others? A window into the neural processes involved in empathy.” NeuroImage 24:771779.
James, William. 1890. The Principles of Psychology. New York: Macmillan.
Jeannerod, Marc. 1994. “The representing brain: neural correlates of motor intention and imagery.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 17:187245.
Jones, Edward G. 2008. “Cortical maps and modern phrenology.” Brain 131:22272233.
Keysers, Christian and Gazzola, Valeria. 2010. “Mirror neurons reported in Humans.” Current Biology 20:R353354.
Keysers, Christian, Kaas, Jon H., and Gazzola, Valeria. 2010. “Somatosensation in social perception.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 11:417428.
Kilner, James M. and Frith, Chris D.. 2008. “Action observation: inferring intentions without mirror neurons.” Current Biology 18:R3233. 2008
Knoch, Daria, Pascual-Leone, Alvaro, Meyer, Kaspar, Treyer, Valerie, and Fehr, Ernst. 2006. “Diminishing reciprocal fairness by disrupting the right prefrontal cortex.” Science 314:829832.
Kohler, Evelyne, Keysers, Christian, Umlitá, M. Alessandra, Fogassi, Leonardo, Gallese, Vittorio, and Rizzolatti, Giacomo. 2002. “Hearing sounds, understanding actions: action representation in mirror neurons.” Science 297:846848.
Kosik, Kenneth S. 2003. “Beyond phrenology, at last.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 4:234239.
Kosslyn, Stephen M. 2005. “Mental images and the brain.” Cognitive Neuropsychology 22:333347.
Lanzetta, John T. and Englis, Basil G.. 1989. “Expectations of cooperation and competition and their effects on observers’ vicarious emotional responses.” Interpersonal Relations and Group Processes 56:543554.
Lawson, John, Baron-Cohen, Simon, and Wheelwright, Sally. 2004. “Empathising and systemising in adults with and without Asperger Syndrome.” Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 34:301310.
Lerner, Paul. 2003. Hysterical Men: War, Psychiatry, and the Politics of Trauma in Germany, 1890–1930. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Libet, Benjamin. 1986. “Unconscious cerebral initiative and the role of the unconscious will in voluntary action.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 8:529566.
Libet, Benjamin, Gleason, Curtis A., Wright, Elwood W., and Pearl, Dennis K.. 1983. “Time of conscious intention to act in relation to onset of cerebral activity (readiness potential): The unconscious initiation of a freely voluntary act.” Brain 102:623642.
Lindner, Isabel, Echterhoff, Gerald, Davidson, Patrick S.R., and Brand, Matthias. 2010. “Observation inflation: your actions become mine.” Psychological Science 21:12911299.
Maynard Smith, John. 1979. “Game theory and the evolution of behaviour.” Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences 205:475488.
Maynard Smith, John. 2001. “Reconciling Marx and Darwin.” Evolution 55:14961498.
Mukamel, Roy, Eckstrom, Arne D., Kaplan, Jonah, Iacoboni, Marco, and Fried, Iizhak. 2010. “Single-neuron responses in humans during execution and observation of actions.” Current Biology 20:17.
Nowak, Martin A. and Sigmund, Karl. 2005. “Evolution of indirect reciprocity.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 437:12911298.
Nummenmaa, Lauri, Hirvonen, Jussi, Parkkola, Ritta., and Hietanen, Jari K.. 2008. “Is emotional contagion special? An fMRI study on neural systems for affective and cognitive empathy.” Neuroimage 43:571580.
Oberman, Lindsay M., Hubbard, Edward M., McCleery, Joseph P., Altschuler, Eric L., Ramachandran, Vilayanur S., and Pineda, Jaime A.. 2005. “EEG evidence for mirror neuron dysfunction in autism spectrum disorders.” Cognitive Brain Research 24:190198.
Okuda, Jiro, Fujii, Toshikatsu, Ohtake, Hiroya, Tsukiura, Takashi, Tanji, Katsuyo, Suzuki, Kyoko, Kawashima, Ryuta, Fukuda, Hiroshi, Itoh, Matsatoshi, and Yamadori, Atsushi. 2003. “Thinking of the future and past: the roles of the frontal pole and the medial temporal lobes.” NeuroImage 19:13691380.
Rizzolatti, Giacamo and Arbib, Michael A.. 1998. “Language within our grasp.” Trends in Neuroscience 21:188194.
Rizzolatti, Giacamo and Corrado, Greg S.. 2010. “The functional role of the parieto-frontal mirror circuit: interpretations and misinterpretations.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 11:264274.
Rizzolatti, Giacomo and Craighero, Laila. 2004. “The mirror-neuron system.” Annual Review of Neuroscience 27:169192.
Rizzolatti, Giacamo and Fabbri-Destro, Maddlena. 2010. “Mirror neurons: from discovery to autism.” Experimental Brain Research 200:223237.
Rosas, Alejandro. 2008. “The return of reciprocity: a psychological approach to the evolution of cooperation.” Biology and Philosophy 23:555566.
Ryle, Gilbert. 1949. The Concept of Mind. London: Hutchinson.
Schacter, Daniel, Addis, Donna Rose, and Buckner, Randy L.. 2007. “Remembering the past to imagine the future: the prospective brain.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 8:657661.
Shamay-Tsoory, Simone G., Fischer, Meytal, Dvash, Jonathan, Harari, Hagai, Perach-Bloom, Nufar, and Levkovitz, Yechiel. 2009. “Intranasal administration of oxytocin increases envy and schadenfreude (gloating).” Biological Psychiatry 66:864870.
Schwartz, Daniel L. 1999. “Physical imagery: kinematic versus dynamic models.” Cognitive Psychology 38:433464.
Shmuelof, Lior and Zohary, Ehud. 2007. “Watching others’ actions: mirror representations in the parietal cortex.” Neuroscientist 13:667672.
Singer, Tania. 2006. “The neuronal basis and ontogeny of empathy and mind reading: review of literature and implications for future research.” Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 30:855863.
Singer, Tania, Seymour, Ben, O'Dougherty, John P., Kaube, Holger, Dolan, Raymond J., and Frith, Chris D.. 2004. “Empathy for pain involves the affective but not sensory components of pain.” Science 303:1157–62.
Singer, Tania, Seymour, Ben, O'Dougherty, John P., Stephan, Klaas E., Dolan, Raymond J., and Frith, Chris D.. 2006. “Empathic neural responses are modulated by the perceived fairness of others.” Nature 439:466469.
Smith, D. F. 2010. “Cognitive brain mapping for better or worse.” Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 53:321329.
Spence, Sean A. 2004. “The deceptive brain.” Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 97:69.
Spence, Sean A., Hunter, Mike D., and Harpin, Gemma. 2002. “Neuroscience and the will.” Current Opinion in Psychiatry 15:519526.
Strawson, Galen. 2008. Real Materialism and Other Essays. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Suddendorf, Thomas, Rose Addis, Donna, and Corballis, Michael C.. 2009. “Mental time travel and the shaping of the human mind.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 364:13171324.
Takahashi, Hidehiko, Kato, Motochiro, Matsuura, Masato, Mobbs, Dean, Suhara, Tetsuya, and Okubo, Yoshiro. 2009. “When your gain is my pain and your pain is my gain: neural correlates of envy and schadenfreude.” Science 323: 937939. Supporting Online Material, at www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/323/5916/937/DC1 (accessed 17 April 2012).
Tambiah, Stanley J. 1990. Magic, Science, Religion, and the Scope of Rationality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tettamanti, Marco, Buccino, Giovanni, Succaman, Maria C., Gallese, Vittorio, Danna, Massimo, Scifo, Paola, Fazio, Ferruccio, Rizzolatti, Giacomo, Cappa, Stefano E., and Perani, Daniela. 2005. “Listening to action-related sentences activates fronto-parietal motor circuits.” Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 17:2732781.
Trivers, Robert L. 1971. “The evolution of reciprocal altruism.” Quarterly Review of Biology 46:3557.
Turella, Luca, Pierno, Andrea C., Tubaldi, Frederico, and Castiello, Umberto. 2009. “Mirror neurons in humans: consisting or confounding evidence?Brain and Language 108:1021.
van der Gaag, Christiaan, Minderaa, Ruud B., and Keysers, Christian. 2007. “Facial expressions: What the mirror neuron system can and cannot tell us.” Social Neuroscience 2:179222.
Veyne, Paul. 1988. Did the Greeks Believe in their Myths? An Essay on the Constitutive Imagination. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Wegner, Daniel M. 2002. The Illusion of Conscious Will. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Wheelwright, S., Baron-Cohen, S., Goldenfeld, N., Delaney, J., Fine, D., Smith, R., and Wakabayashi, A.. 2006. “Predicting Autism Spectrum Quotient (AQ) from the Systemizing Quotient-Revised (SQ-R) and Empathy Quotient (EQ).” Brain Research 1079:4756.
Wicker, Bruno, Keysers, Christian, Plailly, Jane, Royet, Jean-Pierre, Gallese, Vittorio, and Rizzolatti, Giacamo. 2003. “Both of us disgusted in My insula: the common neural basis of seeing and feeling disgust.” Neuron 40:655664.
Williams, Justin H.G., Whitten, Andrew, Suddendorf, Thomas, and Perrett, David I.. 2001. “Imitation, mirror neurons and autism.” Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Review 25:287295.
Young, Allan. 1995. The Harmony of Illusions: Inventing Posttraumatic Stress Disorder. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Young, Allan. 2002. “The self-traumatized perpetrator as a ‘transient mental illness’.” Evolution Psychiatrique 67:2650.
Young, Allan. 2004. “When traumatic memory was a problem: On the antecedents of PTSD.” In Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: Issues and Controversies, edited by Rosen, G., 127146. Chichester UK: John Wiley.
Young, Allan. 2006. “Remembering the evolutionary Freud.” Science in Context 19:175189.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Science in Context
  • ISSN: 0269-8897
  • EISSN: 1474-0664
  • URL: /core/journals/science-in-context
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed