Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

A Review of the Evidence of Third Sector Performance and Its Relevance for a Universal Comprehensive Health System

  • Elke Heins (a1), David Price (a2), Allyson M. Pollock (a2), Emma Miller (a3), John Mohan (a4) and Jean Shaoul (a5)...

UK policy promotes third sector organisations as providers of NHS funded health and social care. We examine the evidence for this policy through a systematic literature review. Our results highlight several problems of studies comparing non-profits with other provider forms, questioning their usefulness for drawing lessons outside the place of study. Most studies deem contextual factors and the regulatory framework in which providers operate as much more important than ownership form. We conclude that the literature does not support the policy of a larger role for the third sector in healthcare, let alone a switch to a market-based system.

Hide All
Alchian A. A. and Demsetz H. (1973), ‘The property right paradigm’, Journal of Economic History, 33, 1, 1627.
Arrow K. (1963), ‘Uncertainty and the welfare economics of medical care’, The American Economic Journal, 53, 5, 941–73.
Becker E. R. and Potter S. J. (2002), ‘Organisational rationality, performance, and social responsibility: Results from the hospital industry’, Journal of Health Care Finance, 29, 1, 2348.
Bennett J., Iossa E. and Legrenzi G. (2003), ‘The role of commercial non-profit organisations in the provision of public services’, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 19, 2, 335–47.
Berta W., Laporte A. and Valdmanis V. (2005), ‘Observations on institutional long-term care in Ontario: 1996–2002’, Canadian Journal on Aging, 24, 7184.
Castle N. G. (2005), ‘Facility charter and quality of care for board and care residents’, Journal of Health and Social Policy, 20, 1, 2342.
Chalkley M. and Malcomson J. M. (1998), ‘Contracting for health services when patient demand does not reflect quality’, Journal of Health Economics, 19, 119.
Currie G., Donaldson C. and Lu M. S. (2003), ‘What does Canada profit from the for-profit debate on health care?’, Canadian Public Policy-Analyse de Politiques, 29, 227–51.
Dellana S. A. and Glascoff D. W. (2001), ‘The impact of health plan profit status on consumer satisfaction with health care’, Journal of Nonprofit and Public Sector Marketing, 9, 3, 119.
Demsetz H. (1967), ‘Toward a theory of property rights’, The American Economic Review, 57, 2, 347–59.
Department of Health (2006), Our Health, Our Care, Our Say: A New Direction for Community Services, Cm 6737, London: HMSO.
Department of Health (2008), ‘The Social Enterprise Investment Fund’, available at, last modified date 12 May 2008; accessed on 25 May 2008.
Devereaux P. J., Choi P. T. L., Lacchetti C., Weaver B., Schünemann H. J., Haines T. et al. (2002), ‘A systematic review and meta-analysis of studies comparing mortality rates of private for-profit and private not-for-profit hospitals’, Canadian Medical Association Journal, 166, 1399–406.
Green A., Showstack J., Rennie D. and Goldman L. (2005), ‘The relationship of insurance status, hospital ownership, and teaching status with interhospital transfers in California in 2000’, Academic Medicine, 80, 8, 774–9.
Hansmann H. B. (1980), ‘The role of nonprofit enterprise’, Yale Law Journal, 89, 835901.
Hansmann H. B., Kessler D. and McChellan M. (2002), ‘Ownership form and trapped capital in the hospital industry’, NBER Working Paper No. 8989, 1–39.
Harrington C., Woolhandler S., Mullan J., Carillo H. and Himmelstein D. U. (2001), ‘Does investor ownership of nursing homes compromise the quality of care?’, American Journal of Public Health, 91, 1452–5.
Haugh H. and Kitson M. (2007), ‘The Third Way and the third sector: New Labour's economic policy and the social economy’, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 31, 6, 973–94.
HM Treasury (2002), The Role of the Voluntary and Community Sector in Service Delivery: A Cross Cutting Review, London: HM Treasury.
HM Treasury (2004), ‘Exploring the role of the third sector in public service delivery and reform: a discussion document’, available at, accessed 19 June 2007.
HM Treasury (2006), Improving Financial Relationships with the Third Sector: Guidance to Funders and Purchasers, London: HM Treasury.
Horwitz J. R. (2003), ‘Why we need the independent sector: the behavior, law, and ethics of nonprofit hospitals’, UCLA Law Review, 50, 6, 1345–411.
Horwitz J. R. (2005), ‘Making profits and providing care: comparing nonprofit, for-profit, and government hospitals’, Health Affairs, 24, 3, 790801.
Mohan J. (1984), ‘Geographical aspects of private hospital developments in Britain’, Area, 16, 191–9.
Mohan J. (1985), ‘Independent acute medical care in Britain: its organisation, location and prospects’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 9, 475–93.
Mohan J. (2002), Planning, Markets and Hospitals, London: Routledge.
Monitor (2008), ‘Foundation Trust sector continues to grow’, press release from 1 May 2008, available at, accessed on 11 July 2008.
Mossialos E. and Le Grand J. (1999), ‘Cost containment in the European Union: an overview’, in Mossialos E. and Le Grand J. (eds.), Health Care and Cost Containment in the European Union, Aldershot: Ashgate, pp. 1154.
New York Academy of Medicine, Division of Health and Science Policy (1999), ‘The empirical literature comparing for-profit and nonprofit hospitals, managed care organisations and nursing homes: updating the Institute of Medicine Study’, The Academy of Medicine, New York.
NHS (2000), The NHS Plan: A Plan for Investment, A Plan for Reform, Cm 4181–I, London: NHS.
NHS (2006), ‘Consultation on core principles for everyone providing care to NHS patients’, available at, accessed 4 April 2007.
NHS Primary Care Contracting (2006), Primary Medical Services Contracts: A Guide for Potential Contractors, London: NHS Primary Care Contracting.
Rathgeb Smith S. and Lipsky M. (1993), Nonprofits for Hire: The Welfare State in the Age of Contracting, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Saltman R., Busse R. and Mossialos E. (eds.) (2002), Regulating Entrepreneurial Behaviour in European Health Care Systems, Buckingham: Open University Press.
Sikorska-Simmons E. (2005), ‘Facility ownership and resident satisfaction with assisted living’, Journal of Housing for the Elderly, 19, 1, 2340.
Third Sector Commissioning Task Force (2006), ‘No excuses: embrace partnership now – step towards change!’, Report of the Third Sector Commissioning Task Force, Department of Health, London.
US Census Bureau (2007), Income, Poverty and Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2006, Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
Watson M. and Hay C. (2003), ‘The discourse of globalisation and the logic of no alternative: rendering the contingent necessary in the political economy of new labour’, Policy and Politics, 31, 3, 289305.
Williamson O. (1985), The Economic Institutions of Capitalism, New York: Free Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Social Policy and Society
  • ISSN: 1474-7464
  • EISSN: 1475-3073
  • URL: /core/journals/social-policy-and-society
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 1
Total number of PDF views: 24 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 212 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 21st October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.