Skip to main content

The Role of Social Housing in the ‘Care’ and ‘Control’ of Tenants with Mental Health Problems

  • Sadie Parr (a1)

Social housing is at the intersection of two policy agendas, namely anti-social behaviour and community care. This means that tenants with mental ill-health might at once be defined as vulnerable and in need of support to enable them to live independently, but simultaneously their behaviour may be viewed as a threat to the safety of others serving to legitimatise disciplinary and punitive forms of intervention on the grounds of ‘difference’. This paper focuses on the role of housing professionals in the management of cases of ASB involving people with mental ill-health. It argues that housing practitioners are not adequately equipped to make judgements on the culpability of ‘perpetrators’ who have mental ill-health and ensure their response is appropriate. This raises questions about the training housing officers recieve, and more broadly, whether the competing policy aims of community care and ASB can be reconciled.

Hide All
Allen C. (1997), ‘The Policy and Implementation of the housing role in community care – a constructionist theoretical perspective’, Housing Studies, 12, 1, 85110.
Audit Commission (1986), Making a Reality of Communnity Care, London: Audit Commission.
Audit Commission (1998), Home Alone: The Housing Aspects of Community Care, London.
BIBIC (2007), ‘BIBIC research on ASBOs and young people with learning difficulties and mental health problems’, on-line report, last accessed 25 February 2009,
Blunkett D. (2003), Tackling the Scourge of Anti-Social Behaviour, Statement to the House of Commons, London.
Bochel C. and Bochel H. (2001), ‘Housing: the foundation of community care?’, Health and Social Care in the Community, 7, 6, 492501.
Bostock L. (2004), ‘Contested housing landscapes? social inclusion, deinstitutionalisation and housing policy in Australia’, Australian Journal of Social Issues, 39, 1, 4162.
Burney E. (1999), Crime and Banishment: Nuisance and Exclusion in Social Housing, Winchester: Waterside Press.
Carr H. (2005), ‘Someone to watch over me: making supported housing work,’ Social and Legal Studies, 14, 3, 387408.
Cobb N. A. (2006), ‘Patronising the mentally disordered? Social landlords and the control of anti-social behaviour under the Disability Discrimination Act 1995’, Legal Studies 26, 2, 238–66.
Cresswell T. (1996), In Place/Out of Place: Geography, Ideology and Transgression, University of Minnesota Press, Minnesota.
Dillane J., Hill M., Bannister J. and Scott S. (2001), Evaluation of the Dundee Families Project – Final Report, Edinburgh: Scottish Executive.
Flint J. (2006), ‘Maintaining an arm's length? Housing, community governance and the management of problematic populations’, Housing Studies, 21, 2, 171–86.
Flint J., Casey R., Davidson E., Pawson H. and McCoulough E. (2007), Tackling Antisocial Behaviour in Glasgow: An Evaluation of Policy and Practice in the Glasgow Housing Association, Glasgow: Glasgow Housing Association.
Frankin B. (1989), ‘Forms and functions: assessing housing need in the community care context’, Health and Social Care in the Community, 6, 6, 420–28.
Franklin B. (2000), ‘Demands, expectations and responses: the shaping of housing management’, Housing Studies, 15, 6, 907–27.
Gleeson B. (1997), ‘Community care and disability: the limits to justice’, Progress in Human Geography, 21, 2, 199224.
Hewitt D. (2007), ‘Bovvered? A legal perspective on the ASBO’, Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, 14, 6, 355–63.
Home Office (2003), Respect and Responsibility – Taking a Stand Against Anti-social Behaviour, London: Home Office.
Home Office (2006), A Guide to Anti-social Behaviour Orders, London: Home Office.
Horton R. (2008), ‘The end of disability-related discrimination in employment?’, London Borough of Lewisham v. Malcolm [2008] UKHL 43, [2008] IRLR 700, Industrial Law Journal, 37, 4, 376–83.
Housing Corporation (2004), Anti-Social Behaviour Policy and Procedure: Guidance for Housing Associations, London: Housing Corporation.
Hunter C. (2006), ‘The changing legal framework: from landlords to agents of social control’, in Flint J. (ed.), Housing, Urban Governance and Anti-social Behaviour: Perspectives, Policy and Practice, Bristol: Policy Press.
Hunter C., Hodge N., Nixon J., Parr S. and Willis B. (2007a), Disabled People's Experiences of Antisocial Behaviour and Harassment in Social Housing: A Critical Review, London: Disability Rights Commission.
Hunter C., Hodge N., Nixon J. and Parr S. (2007b), ‘Anti-social behaviour and disability: the response of social landlords’, People, Place and Policy, 1, 3, 149–61.
Hunter C., Nixon J. and Shayer S. (2000), Neighbour Nuisance, Social Landlords and the Law, Coventry: Chartered Institute of Housing.
Hunter C., Hodge N., Nixon J. and Parr S. (2008), ‘Anti-Social Behaviour and Disability – the response of Social Landlords’, People, Place and Policy online, 2, 1.
Hunter C. and Nixon J. (2009), ‘Discipling women and the governance of conduct’, in Millie A. (ed.), Securing Respect: Behavioural Expectations and anti-social behaviour in the UK, Policy Press, Bristol.
Jones A., Pleace N. and Quilgars D. (2005), Shelter Inclusion Project: Two years on, London: Shelter.
Jones A., Pleace N. and Quilgars D. (2006), Addressing Antisocial Behaviour – An Independent Evaluation of Shelter Inclusion Project, London: Shelter.
Lewis J. and Glennerster H. (1996), Implementing the New Community Care, Buckingham: Open University Press.
Macdonald S. (2006), ‘A suicidal woman, roaming pigs and a noisy trampolinist: refining the ASBO's definition of “anti-social behaviour”’, Modern Law Review, 69, 2, 183213.
Means R. (1996), From ‘Special needs’ housing to Independent Living? Housing Studies, 11, 2, 207–25.
Mencap (1997), Barriers to Justice. Mencap: London.
Stephen D. and Squires P. (2003), Community Safety, Enforcement and Acceptable Behaviour Contracts, Brighton: Health and Social Policy Research Centre, University of Brighton.
Moon G. (2000), ‘Risk and protection: the discourse of confinement in contemporary mental health policy’, Health and Place, 6, 239–50.
Morris J. (1993), Independent Lives: Community Care and Disabled People, Macmillan Press.
Murie A. (1997), ‘Linking housing changes to crime’, Social Policy and Administration, 31, 5, 2236.
National Association of Probation Officers (2005), ASBOs: An Analysis of the First Six Years, London: NAPO.
Nixon J. and Parr S. (2006), ‘Anti-social behaviour: voices from the front Line’, in Flint J. (ed.), Housing, Urban Governance and Anti-Social Behaviour: Perspectives, Policy and Practice, Bristol: Policy Press.
Nixon J., Hunter C., Parr S., Myers S., Whittle S. and Sanderson D. (2006a), Anti-Social Behaviour Intensive Family Support Projects: An Evaluation of Six Pioneering Projects, London: ODPM.
Nixon J., Hunter C., Parr S., Myers S., Whittle S. and Sanderson D. (2006b), Interim Evaluation of Rehabilitation Projects for Families at Risk of Losing Their Homes as a Result of Anti-Social Behaviour, London: ODPM.
Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (2004), Anti-social Behaviour: Policy and Procedure Code of Guidance for Local Housing Authorities and Housing Action Trusts, London: ODPM.
Respect Task Force (2006), Respect Action Plan, London: Home Office.
Saugeres L. (2000), ‘Of tidy gardens and clean houses: housing officers as agents of social control’, Geoforum, 31, 4, 587–99.
Scottish Executive (2004), Guidance on Anti-Social Behaviour Orders. Edinburgh: Scottish Executive.
Social Exclusion Unit (2004), Mental Health and Social Exclusion, London: ODPM.
Stephen D. and Squires P. (2003), Community Safety, Enforcement and Acceptable Behaviour Contracts, Brighton: Health and Social Policy Research Centre, University of Brighton.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Social Policy and Society
  • ISSN: 1474-7464
  • EISSN: 1475-3073
  • URL: /core/journals/social-policy-and-society
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 8
Total number of PDF views: 55 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 251 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 23rd January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.