Skip to main content
×
Home

A Staged Fright: Musical Hybridity and Religious Intolerance in Turkey, 1923–38

Abstract
Abstract

This article is concerned with the relationship between musical style and religious prejudice in Turkey during the early Republican period (1923–38). It focuses on a musical contest in 1932 between a Jewish cantor (hazan) and an Islamic vocalist (hafız) in the presence of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk (1881–1938), the president of the Turkish Republic who instigated revolutionary reforms that affected many aspects of Turkish culture, including music. Historical accounts of this musical contest not only suggest how religious discrimination manifested itself in a competitive setting but also serve to question the parameters of religious tolerance in Turkey, a country often admired for its favourable attitude towards Jews during the twentieth century. The discussion draws on Homi Bhabha's concept of a ‘third space’ to uncover the complex relations that existed in Turkey between Jews and Muslims on the one hand and among Jews on the other. It also invokes Bhabha to show how music can be viewed as a ‘supplementary discourse’ that serves both to unify cultural interests and to perpetuate cultural differences. By challenging the accepted narrative of religious tolerance in historical sources, the article explores through music the characteristics and consequences of racism in the country during a period of growing anti-Semitism both at home and abroad.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Aksoy Bülent, ed. İzak Algazi: Osmanlı-Türk ve Osmanlı-Yahudi Musıkisinin Büyük Sesi. Istanbul: Kalan Müzik CD 333, 2004.
Esim Janet, and Esim Jak. Antik bir Hüzün …: Judeo-Espanyol Şarkıları 1492–1992. Istanbul: Polin Bant Cassette 011, 1992.
Pal-Yarden Hadass. Yahudice: Ladino Şehir Müziği. Istanbul: Kalan Müzik CD 272, 2003.
Seroussi Edwin. An Early Twentieth-Century Sephardi Troubadour: the Historical Recordings of Haim Efendi from Turkey. Jerusalem: Anthology of Musical Traditions in Israel 21. 4 CDs, AMTI 0801, 2008.
Spottswood Dick, and Signell Karl, eds. Masters of Turkish Music, vol. 1. Cambridge, MA: Rounder CD 1051, 1990.
Spottswood Dick, and Signell Karl. Masters of Turkish Music, vol. 2. Cambridge, MA: Rounder, CD 1111, 1996.
Ünlü Cemal. Gazeller: 78 Devirli Taş Plak Kayıtları. Istanbul: Kalan Müzik CD 067, CD 072, 1997.
Ünlü Cemal. Gazeller 3. Istanbul: Kalan Müzik CD 360, 2006.
Yasak Aaron K., and Dilmen Lari, eds. Maftirim: Judeo-Sufi Connection. Istanbul: Kalan Müzik CD 234, 2001.
Aksoy Bülent. ‘Tanzimat'tan Cumhuriyete Musiki ve Batılılaşma’, in Tanzimat'tan Cumhuriyet'e Türkiye Ansiklopedisi. Istanbul: İletişim Yayınları, 1985. 12121248.
Aksoy Bülent. ‘Is the Question of the “Origin of Turkish Music” not Redundant?’. Turkish Musical Quarterly 2/4 (1989), 17.
Aksoy Bülent. ‘A Great Voice of Ottoman Turkish and Jewish Music’. 2010. <http://www.turkishmusicportal.org> (accessed 4 November 2010).
Algazi Isaac. Extrait du fassil husseini des chants juifs orientaux. Istanbul: Benjamin B. Joseph, 1924–5.
Aracı Emre. ‘Zor Yıllar (1935–46)’, in Adnan Saygun: Doğu Batı Arası Müzik Köprüsü. Istanbul: Yapı Kredi Yayınları, 2001. 81107.
Ataman Sadi Y.Atatürk ve Türk Musikisi. Atatürk Dizisi 31. Ankara: Kültür Bakanlığı, 1991.
Bali Rıfat N.Les relations entre turcs et juifs dans la Turquie moderne. Analecta Isisiana 53. Istanbul: Éditions Isis, 2001.
Bali Rıfat N.. ‘The Thrace Events: Continuity and Change within Turkish State Policies Regarding Non-Muslim Minorities: an Interview with Rıfat Bali’. European Journal of Turkish Studies 7 (2008), 121.
Bali Rıfat N.. ‘Confronting Turkish Anti-Semitism.’ 2009. FrontPage Magazine, 17 August 2009. <http://www.frontpagemag.com/readArticle.aspx?ARTID=35946> (accessed 21 August 2009).
Başgöz İlhan. ‘The Waqwaq Tree in the Turkish Shadow-Play Theatre Karagöz and the Story of Esther’, in The Jews of the Ottoman Empire, ed. Levy. 549558.
Behar Cem. Klasik Türk Mûsıkisi Üzerine Denemeler. Istanbul: Bağlam Yayınları, 1987.
Behar Cem. Zaman, Mekân, Müzik: Klâsik Türk Musıkisinde Eğitim (Meşk), İcra ve Aktarım. Istanbul: AFA Yayınları, 1993.
Behar Cem. Kantes relijyozos de Selihot, Roş-Aşana i Kipur en cudeo-espanyol. Istanbul: Güler Basımevi, 1947.
Ben-Naeh Yaron. Jews in the Realm of the Sultans: Ottoman Jewish Society in the Seventeenth Century. Texts and Studies in Medieval and Early Modern Judaism 22. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2008.
Bhabha Homi K.The Location of Culture. London: Routledge, 1994.
Bohlman Philip. Jewish Music and Modernity. New York and London: Oxford University Press, 2008.
Çakıroğlu Ekrem, ed. İstanbul Radyosu: Anılar, Yaşantılar. Istanbul: Yapı Kredi Kültür Sanat Yayıncılık, 2000.
Campos Michelle U.‘Between “Beloved Ottomania” and “The Land of Israel”: the Struggle over Ottomanism and Zionism among Palestine's Sephardi Jews, 1908–13’. International Journal of Middle East Studies 37/4 (2005), 461483.
Cengiz Halil E., ed. Yaşanmış Olaylarla Atatürk ve Müzik: Riyâset-i Cumhûr İnce Saz Hey'eti Şefi Binbaşı Hâfız Yaşar Okur'un Anıları (1924–1938). Ankara: Müzik Ansiklopedisi Yayınları, 1993.
Danielson Virginia. The Voice of Egypt: Umm Kulthum, Arabic Song, and Egyptian Society in the Twentieth Century. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1997.
Davis Ruth, ed. Musical Exodus: Al-Andalus and its Jewish Diasporas. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow Press, forthcoming.
Dorn[-Sezgin] Pamela J. ‘Change and Ideology: the Ethnomusicology of Turkish Jewry’. PhD diss., Indiana University, 1991.
Dorn[-Sezgin] Pamela J.. ‘Hakhamim, Dervishes, and Court Singers’, in The Jews of the Ottoman Empire, ed. Levy. 585632.
Erbay Fethiye, and Erbay Mutlu. Cumhuriyet Dönemi (1923–1938): Atatürk'ün Sanat Politikası. Istanbul: Boğaziçi Üniversitesi Güzel Sanatlar Bölümü, 2005.
Ergun Sadeddin N.Türk Musikisi Antolojisi. 2 vols. Istanbul: Rıza Koşkun Matbaası, 1942–3.
Faroqhi Suraiya, and Inalcık Halil, eds. The Ottoman Empire and its Heritage: Politics, Society and Economy. Leiden: Brill, 2003.
Feldman Walter. ‘Cultural Authority and Authenticity in the Turkish Repertoire’. Asian Music 22/3 (1991), 73113.
Feldman Walter. Music of the Ottoman Court: Makam, Composition and the Early Ottoman Instrumental Repertoire. Intercultural Music Studies 10. Berlin: Verlag für Wissenschaft und Bildung, 1996.
Franco Moïse. ‘L’alliance Israélite universelle et les Israélites de Turquie', in Essai sur l'histoire des Israélites de l'empire ottoman depuis les origins jusqu'à nos jours. Paris: El Mundo Djudeo-Espanyol, 2007 [1897]. 249265.
Galanté Avram. Türk ve Yahudiler. Istanbul: Tan Matbaası, 1928; expanded edn, 1947.
Galanté Avram. Documents officiels Turcs concernant les Juifs de Turquie. Istanbul: Haim Rozio, 1931.
Galanté Avram. Turcs et Juifs: étude historique, politique. Istanbul: Haim, Rozio & Co, 1932.
Galanté Avram. Histoire des Juifs d'Anatolie. 2 vols. Istanbul: M. Babok, 1937, 1939.
Galanté Avram. Türk Harsı ve Türk Yahudisi. Istanbul: Fakülteler Matbaası, 1953.
Gökalp Ziya. Türkçülüğün Esasları. Ankara: Matbuat ve Irtibarat Matbaası, 1923.
Greve Martin. Die Europäisierung orientalischer Kunstmusik in der Türkei. Berlin: Peter Lang / Europäischer Verlag der Wissenschaften, 1995.
Haker Erol. Edirne, its Jewish Community, and Alliance Schools 1867–1937. Istanbul: Isis Press, 2006.
Hood Mantle. ‘The Challenge of “Bi-Musicality”’. Ethnomusicology 4/2 (1960), 5559.
Idelsohn Abraham. Gesänge der orientalischen Sefardim. Jerusalem, Berlin, Vienna: Benjamin Hartz, 1923.
İnal İbnülemin M.Hoş Sadâ: Son Asır Türk Musikişinasları. Istanbul: Maarif Basımevi, 1958.
Juhasz Esther, ed. Sephardi Jews in the Ottoman Empire: Aspects of Material Culture. Jerusalem: Israel Museum, 1990.
Kalderon Albert E.Abraham Galante: a Biography. New York: Sepher-Hermon Press / Sephardic House at Congregation Shearith Israel, 1983.
Kandiyoti Deniz, and Saktanber Ayşe, eds. Fragments of Culture: the Everyday of Modern Turkey. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 2002.
Katz Ruth. ‘Singing of Baqqashōt by Aleppo Jews’. Acta Musicologica 40 (1968), 6585.
Kinross Lord Patrick. Atatürk: a Biography of Mustafa Kemal, Father of Modern Turkey. New York: William Morrow, 1965.
Kocatürk Utkan. Atatürk ve Türkiye Cumhuriyeti Tarihi Kronolojisi, 1918–1938. Ankara: Türk Tarihi Kurumu Basımevi, 1988.
Landau Jacob M. ‘Relations between Jews and Non-Jews in the Late Ottoman Empire: Some Characteristics’, in The Jews of the Ottoman Empire, ed. Levy. 539546.
Levy Avigdor. The Sephardim in the Ottoman Empire. Princeton, NJ: Darwin Press, 1992.
Levy Avigdor, ed. The Jews of the Ottoman Empire. Princeton, NJ: Darwin Press, 1994.
Lewis Bernard. The Emergence of Modern Turkey. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1968.
Lewis Bernard. The Jews of Islam. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1984.
Mango Andrew. Atatürk. London: John Murray, 1999.
Neumark Fritz. Zuflucht am Bosphorus: deutsche Gelehrte, Politiker und Künstler in der Emigration 1933–1953. Frankfurt: Knecht, 1995.
O'Connell John M. ‘An Alevi Musician in Berlin: an Artist's Individual View and the Assumptions of a General Musical Tradition’. MA thesis, University of California, Los Angeles, 1991.
O'Connell John M.. ‘Alaturka Revisited: Style as History in Turkish Vocal Performance’. PhD diss., University of California, Los Angeles, 1996.
O'Connell John M.. ‘The Arab in Arabesk: Style and Stereotype in Turkish Vocal Performance’, in The Limerick Anthology of Arab Affairs, ed. Adawy Nabil and Wharton Barrie. Limerick: Limerick University Press, 1998. 87103.
O'Connell John M.. ‘Fine Art, Fine Music: Controlling Turkish Taste at the Fine Arts Academy’. Yearbook for Traditional Music 33 (2000), 117142.
O'Connell John M.. ‘From Empire to Republic: Vocal Style in Twentieth-Century Turkey’, in Garland Encyclopedia of World Music, vol. 6, ed. Danielson Virginia, Marcus Scott, and Reynolds Dwight. New York: Garland, 2002. 781787.
O'Connell John M.. ‘Major Minorities: towards an Ethnomusicology of Irish Minority Musics’, in Music and Minorities, ed. Hemetek Ursula and Pettan Svanibor. Ljubljana: University of Slovenia Press, 2002. 165182
O'Connell John M.. ‘Song Cycle: the Life and Death of the Turkish Gazel: Review Essay’. Ethnomusicology 47/3 (2003), 399414.
O'Connell John M.. ‘A Resounding Issue: Greek Recordings of Turkish Music, 1923–1938’. Middle East Studies Bulletin 37/2 (2004), 324.
O'Connell John M.. ‘Sustaining Difference: Theorizing Minority Musics in Badakhshan’, in Music and Minorities, ed. Hemetek Ursula and Naroditskaya Inna. Cambridge: Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 2004. 116.
O'Connell John M.. ‘In the Time of Alaturka: Identifying Difference in Musical Discourse’. Ethnomusicology 49/2 (2005), 177205.
O'Connell John M.. ‘Sound Sense: Mediterranean Music from a Turkish Perspective’, in The Mediterranean in Music, ed. Cooper David and Dawe Kevin. Oxford: Scarecrow Press, 2005. 325.
O'Connell John M.. ‘The Mermaid of the Meyhane: the Legend of a Greek Singer in a Turkish Tavern’, in Music and the Sirens, ed. Austern Linda and Naroditskaya Inna. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2006. 273293.
O'Connell John M.. ‘War of the Waves: Cypriot Broadcasting in Great Britain’, in Echoes of Diversity: Music from Turkey in the Diaspora, ed. Hemetek Ursula and Sağlam Hande. Vienna: UNESCO, 2008. 119130.
O'Connell John M.. ‘Alabanda: Brass Bands and Musical Methods in Turkey’, in Giuseppe Donizetti Pascià: traiettorie musicali e storiche tra Italia e Turchia, ed. Spinetti Federico. Bergamo: Fondazione Donizetti, 2010. 1937.
O'Connell John M.. ‘Modal Trails, Model Trials: Musical Migrants and Mystical Critics in Turkey (1923–1938)’, in Musical Exodus: Al-Andalus and its Diasporas, ed. Davis .
Oransay Gültekin. Atatürk ile Kuğ. Izmir: Küğ Yayınları, 1985.
Ortyalı İlber. ‘Ottomanism and Zionism during the Second Constitutional Period, 1908–1915’, in The Jews of the Ottoman Empire, ed. Levy . 526537.
Özalp Nazimi. Türk Mûsikîsi Tarihi. 2 vols. Ankara: Müzik Dairesi Başkanlığı, 1986.
Özbek Meral. Popüler Kültür ve Orhan Gencebay Arabeski. Istanbul: İletişim Yayınları, 1991.
Öztuna Yılmaz. Büyük Türk Mûsikîsi Ansiklopedesi, 2 vols. Ankara: Kültür Bakanlığı, 1990.
Paçacı Gönul, ed. Cumhuriyet'in Sesleri. Istanbul: Türkiye İş Bankası, 1999.
Quataert Donald. The Ottoman Empire, 1700–1922. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.
Redhouse Sir James. Redhouse Türkçe/Osmanlıca–İngilizce Sözlük (Redhouse Turkish/Ottoman–English Dictionary). Istanbul: Redhouse Yayınevi, 1999.
Reisman Arnold. Turkey's Modernization: Refugees from Nazism and Atatürk's Vision. Washington, DC: New Academia Publishing, 2006.
Rodrigue Aron. ‘The Beginnings of Westernization and Community Reform among Istanbul's Jewry, 1854–65’, in The Jews of the Ottoman Empire, ed. Levy . 439456.
Rozen Minna. ‘Elite Culture and Popular Culture’, in A History of the Jewish Community in Istanbul: the Formative Years, 1453–1566. Leiden: Brill, 2002. 244277.
Rozen Minna. ‘Between the Two World Wars’, in The Last Ottoman Century and Beyond: the Jews in Turkey and the Balkans 1808–1945. Tel Aviv: School of Jewish Studies, 2005. 223255.
Sağman Ali R.Meşur Hafız Sami Merhum. Istanbul: Ahmet Sait Matbaası, 1947.
Saygun Adnan. Atatürk ve Musiki. Ankara: Ajans-Türk Matbaacılık Sanayii, 1965.
Seroussi Edwin.Mizimrat Qedem: the Life and Music of R. Isaac Algazi from Turkey. Jerusalem: Institute of Jewish Music, 1989.
Seroussi Edwin.. ‘The Turkish Makam in the Musical Culture of the Ottoman Jews: Sources and Examples’. Israel Studies in Musicology 5 (1990), 4368.
Seroussi Edwin.. ‘The Peşrev as a Vocal Genre in Ottoman Hebrew Sources’. Turkish Music Quarterly 4/3 (1991), 19.
Seroussi Edwin.. ‘La música sefardí en al Imperio Otomano: nuevas fuentes literias’, in Actes del Simposi Internacional sobre Cultura Sefardita, ed. Ribera Josep. Barcelona: Facultat de Filologia, 1993. 279294.
Seroussi Edwin.. ‘From Court and Tarikat to Synagogue: Ottoman Art Music and Hebrew Sacred Songs’, in Sufism, Music, and Society in the Middle East, ed. Hammarlund Anders, Olsson Tord, and Özdalga Elizabeth. Transactions 10. Istanbul: Curzon Press, 2001. 8196.
Seroussi Edwin.. ‘Maftirim Giriş / Introduction to Maftirim’, in Maftirim: Türk-Sefarad Sinagog Ilahileri / Turkish Sephardic Synagogue Hymns. Istanbul: Gözlem Gazetecilik, 2008.
Shapira Dan. Avraham Firkowicz in Istanbul (1830–1832): Paving the Way for a Turkic Nationalism. Ankara: Karam Yayıncılık, 2003.
Shaw Stanford. History of the Ottoman Empire and Modern Turkey, 2 vols. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1976–7.
Shaw Stanford. The Jews of the Ottoman Empire and the Turkish Republic. London: Macmillan, 1991.
Shaw Stanford. Turkey and the Holocaust: Turkey's Role in Rescuing Turkish and European Jewry from Nazi Persecution, 1933–1945. London: Macmillan, 1993.
Spivak Gayatri C. ‘Can the Subaltern Speak?’, in The Post-Colonial Studies Reader, ed. Ashcroft Bill, Griffiths Gareth, and Tiffin Helen. London: Routledge, 1995. 2428.
Stokes Martin. The Arabesk Debate: Music and Musicians in Modern Turkey. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press, 1992.
Tütüncü Mehmet, ed. Turkish–Jewish Encounters: Studies on Turkish–Jewish Relations through the Ages. Haarlem: SOTA, 2001.
Üngör Etem R.Türk Musikisi Güfteler Antolojisi. 2 vols. Istanbul: Eren Yayınları, 1980.
Ünlü Cemal. Git Zaman Gel Zaman: Fonograf – Gramofon – Taş Plak. Istanbul: Pan Yayıncılık, 2004.
Volkan Vamik, and Itzkowitz Norman. The Immortal Atatürk: a Psychobiography. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1984.
Zimmerman-Kalyoncu Cornelia. Deutsche Musiker in der Türkei im 20. Jahrhundert. Frankfurt: Peter Lang, 1985.
Zürcher Erik van. Turkey: a Modern History. New York: I. B. Tauris, 1993.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Twentieth-Century Music
  • ISSN: 1478-5722
  • EISSN: 1478-5730
  • URL: /core/journals/twentieth-century-music
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 2
Total number of PDF views: 12 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 122 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 17th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.