Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

A Meta-Analysis on the Effects of 2,4-D and Dicamba Drift on Soybean and Cotton

  • J. Franklin Egan (a1), Kathryn M. Barlow (a2) and David A. Mortensen (a2)

Commercial introduction of cultivars of soybean and cotton genetically modified with resistance to the synthetic auxin herbicides dicamba and 2,4-D will allow these compounds to be used with greater flexibility but may expose susceptible soybean and cotton cultivars to nontarget herbicide drift. From past experience, it is well known that soybean and cotton are both highly sensitive to low-dose exposures of dicamba and 2,4-D. In this study, a meta-analysis approach was used to synthesize data from over seven decades of simulated drift experiments in which investigators treated soybean and cotton with low doses of dicamba and 2,4-D and measured the resulting yields. These data were used to produce global dose–response curves for each crop and herbicide, with crop yield plotted against herbicide dose. The meta-analysis showed that soybean is more susceptible to dicamba in the flowering stage and relatively tolerant to 2,4-D at all growth stages. Conversely, cotton is tolerant to dicamba but extremely sensitive to 2,4-D, especially in the vegetative and preflowering squaring stages. Both crops are highly variable in their responses to synthetic auxin herbicide exposure, with soil moisture and air temperature at the time of exposure identified as key factors. Visual injury symptoms, especially during vegetative stages, are not predictive of final yield loss. Global dose–response curves generated by this meta-analysis can inform guidelines for herbicide applications and provide producers and agricultural professionals with a benchmark of the mean and range of crop yield loss that can be expected from drift or other nontarget exposures to 2,4-D or dicamba.

Corresponding author
Corresponding author's E-mail:
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

SM Andersen , SA Clay , LJ Wrage , D Matthees (2004) Soybean foliage residues of dicamba and 2,4-D and correlation to application rates and yield. Agron J. 96:750760

V Bagnardi , A Zambon , P Quatto , G Corrao (2004) Flexible meta-regression functions for modeling aggregate dose-response data, with an application to alcohol and mortality. Am J Epidemiol 159:10771086

PA Banks , J Schroeder (2002) Carrier volume affects herbicide activity in simulated spray drift studies. Weed Technol 16:833837

GL Barker , JL Hatfield , DF Wanjura (1985) Cotton phenology parameters as affected by wind. Field Crops Res 12:3347

CW Bednarz , RL Nichols (2005) Phenological and morphological components of cotton crop maturity. Crop Sci. 45:14971503

MR Behrens , N Mutlu , S Chakraborty , R Dumitru , WZ Jiang , BJ LaVallee , PL Herman , TE Clemente , DP Weeks (2007) Dicamba resistance: Enlarging and preserving biotechnology-based weed management strategies. Science 316:11851188

RB Brown , MH Carter , GR Stephenson (2004) Buffer zone and windbreak effects on spray drift deposition in a simulated wetland. Pest Manag Sci. 60:10851090

SCK Carlsen , NH Spliid , B Svensmark (2006) Drift of 10 herbicides after tractor spray application. 2. Primary drift (droplet drift). Chemosphere 64:778786

N Cedergreen , C Ritz , JC Streibig (2005) Improved empirical models describing hormesis. Environ Toxicol Chem. 24:31663172

GW Charles , GA Constable , DJ Llewellyn , MA Hickman (2007) Tolerance of cotton expressing a 2,4-D detoxification gene to 2,4-D applied in the field. Aust. J. Agric. Res 58:780787

J Constantin , RS de Oliveira Júnior, JR Fagliari , PH Pagliari , JGZ de Arantes , SD Cavalieri , VP Framesqui , DA Gonçalves (2007) Effect of sub-lethal dosages of 2,4-D on cotton yield and crop susceptibility as a function of its development stage. Engenharia Agrícola 27:2429

FMW de Jong , GR de Snoo , JC van de Zande (2008) Estimated nationwide effects of pesticide spray drift on terrestrial habitats in the Netherlands. J Environ Manage 86:721730

JF Egan , DA Mortensen (2012) Quantifying vapor drift of dicamba herbicides applied to soybean. Environ Toxicol Chem. 31:10231031

JM Ellis , JL Griffin , CA Jones (2002) Effect of carrier volume on corn (Zea mays) and soybean (Glycine max) response to simulated drift of glyphosate and glufosinate. Weed Technol 16:587592

EA Epps (1953) Growth regulators. Effect of 2,4-D on growth and yield of cotton. J Agric Food Chem. 1:10091010

LV Hedges , J Gurevitch , PS Curtis (1999) The meta-analysis of response ratios in experimental ecology. Ecology. 80:11501156

BD Hill , KN Harker , P Hasselback , JR Moyer , DJ Inaba , SD Byers (2002) Phenoxy herbicides in Alberta rainfall: Potential effects on sensitive crops. Can J Plant Sci. 82:481484

DL Kittock , HF Arle (1977) Termination of late season cotton fruiting with plant growth regulators. Crop Sci. 17:320324

DL Kittock , JR Mauney , HF Arle , LA Bariola (1973) Termination of late season cotton fruiting with growth regulators as an insect-control technique. J Environ Qual 2:405408

DA Mortensen , JF Egan , BD Maxwell , MR Ryan , RG Smith (2012) Navigating a critical juncture for sustainable weed management. BioScience 62:7585

PA Paul , PE Lipps , LV Madden (2006) Meta-analysis of regression coefficients for the relationship between fusarium head blight and deoxynivalenol content of wheat. Phytopathology 96:951961

C Ritz , JC Streibig (2005) Bioassay analysis using R. J Stat Softw 12:122

AP Robinson , VM Davis , DM Simpson , WG Johnson (2013) Response of soybean yield components to 2,4-D. Weed Sci. 61:6876

FW Slife (1956) The effect of 2,4-D and several other herbicides on weeds and soybeans when applied as post-emergence sprays. Weeds 4:6168

RJ Smith (1965) Effects of chlorophenoxy herbicides on soybeans. Weeds 13:168169

G Staten (1946) Contamination of cotton fields by 2,4-D or hormone-type weed sprays. Agron J. 38:536544

SG Thompson , JPT Higgins (2002) How should meta-regression analyses be undertaken and interpreted? Stat Med. 21:15591573

L Tuduri , T Harner , P Blanchard , YF Li , L Poissant , DT Waite , C Murphy , W Belzer (2006) A review of currently used pesticides (CUPS) in Canadian air and precipitation. Part 2: Regional information and perspectives. Atmos Environ. 40:15791589

NC Wagner , BD Maxwell , ML Taper , LJ Rew (2007) Developing an empirical yield-prediction model based on wheat and wild oat (Avena fatua) density, nitrogen and herbicide rate, and growing-season precipitation. Weed Sci. 55:652664

E Waltz (2010) Glyphosate resistance threatens Roundup hegemony. Nat Biotechnol 28:537538

M Wang , D Rautman (2008) A simple probabilistic estimation of spray drift -factors determining spray drift and development of a model. Environ Toxicol Chem. 27:26172626

JD Weidenhamer , GB Triplett , FE Sobotka (1989) Dicamba injury to soybean. Agron J. 81:637643

AF Wiese , AG Martin (1963) Toxicity of benzoic acid herbicide to cotton and soybeans. Weeds 11:710

TR Wright , GM Shan , TA Walsh , JM Lira , C Cui , P Song , MB Zhuang , NL Arnold , GF Lin , K Yau , SM Russell , RM Cicchillo , MA Peterson , DM Simpson , N Zhou , J Ponsamuel , ZY Zhang (2010) Robust crop resistance to broadleaf and grass herbicides provided by aryloxyalkanoate dioxygenase transgenes. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 107:2024020245

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Weed Science
  • ISSN: 0043-1745
  • EISSN: 1550-2759
  • URL: /core/journals/weed-science
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 28 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 209 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 20th January 2017 - 20th September 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.