Introduction
During winter dormancy, hybrid bermudagrass putting greens are susceptible to invasion from annual bluegrass because hybrid bermudagrass is not actively growing (Johnson Reference Johnson1980). Few herbicide options exist to control annual bluegrass in hybrid bermudagrass putting greens. Currently, pendimethalin, pronamide, and sulfonylurea herbicides such as trifloxysulfuron and foramsulfuron may be used to control annual bluegrass. However, herbicide resistance is widespread among annual bluegrass populations, especially in the southern and transitional zones of the United States (Brosnan et al. Reference Brosnan, Elmore and Bagavathiannan2020). During the winter dormancy of hybrid bermudagrass is the best time to control annual bluegrass, both to preserve the aesthetics and playability of the turf surface (Callahan and McDonald Reference Callahan and McDonald1992). However, many annual bluegrass populations have evolved resistance to mitotic-inhibiting herbicides such as pendimethalin and pronamide (Breeden et al. Reference Breeden, Brosnan, Mueller, Breeden, Horvath and Senseman2017; Brosnan et al. Reference Brosnan, Reasor, Vargas, Breeden, Kopsell, Cutulle and Mueller2014; Isgrigg et al. Reference Isgrigg, Yelverton, Brownie and Warren2002; McCullough et al. Reference McCullough, Yu and Czarnota2017). Additionally, it has been well documented that annual bluegrass has become resistant to acetolactate synthase inhibitors in areas where hybrid bermudagrass is grown (Brosnan et al. Reference Brosnan, Breeden, Vargas and Grier2015, Reference Brosnan, Vargas, Breeden, Grier, Aponte, Tresch and LaForest2016; McElroy et al. Reference McElroy, Flessner, Wang, Dane, Walker and Wehtje2013). Therefore, new herbicidal options are needed for annual bluegrass control in hybrid bermudagrass putting greens.
Methiozolin (categorized by the Weed Science Society of America [WSSA] as a Group 30 herbicide) was registered in 2019 for preemergence (PRE) and postemergence (POST) control of annual bluegrass in hybrid bermudagrass putting greens. The novel mode of action of methiozolin is via inhibition of fatty acid thioesterase (FAT; Brabham et al. Reference Brabham, Johnen, Hendriks, Betz, Zimmerman, Gollihue, Serson, Kempinski and Barrett2021). Annual bluegrass control with PRE and POST applications of methiozolin is commercially acceptable and is well documented in peer-reviewed literature (Askew and McNulty Reference Askew and McNulty2014; Brosnan et al. Reference Brosnan, Henry, Breeden, Cooper and Serensits2013, Reference Brosnan, Vargas, Breeden, Boggess, Staton, Wadl and Trigiano2017; Hoisington et al. Reference Hoisington, Flessner, Schiavon, McElroy and Baird2014; McCullough et al. Reference McCullough, Gomez de Barreda and Jialin2013).
Cumyluron is also a FAT-inhibiting herbicide (Johnen et al. Reference Johnen, Zimmermann, Betz, Hendriks, Zimmermann, Marnet, De, Zimmermann, Kibat, Cornaciu, Mariaule, Pica, Clavel, Márqueze and Witschelc2022) that controls annual bluegrass before it emerges (Askew and McNulty Reference Askew and McNulty2014; Reicher et al. Reference Reicher, Sousek, Patton, Weisenberger, Hathaway and Calhoun2015). Limited peer-reviewed information exists regarding cumyluron usage; however, the patent indicates that it inhibits annual bluegrass germination at rates of 500 to 30,000 g ai ha−1 (Tomita and Tonaka Reference Tomita and Tonaka2003). Although the safety of creeping bentgrass putting greens has been well documented with methiozolin and cumyluron use (Askew and McNulty Reference Askew and McNulty2014; McCullough et al. Reference McCullough, Gomez de Barreda and Jialin2013), peer-reviewed literature does not include information on hybrid bermudagrass putting green tolerance to these herbicides.
Endothall is a herbicide currently used in the United States to control a variety of aquatic weed species (Skogerboe and Getsinger Reference Skogerboe and Getsinger2002). Endothall has historically been used on turfgrass in the United States to control annual bluegrass in cool-season turfgrasses (Engel and Aldrich Reference Engel and Aldrich1960; Turgeon et al. Reference Turgeon, Meggitt and Penner1972a, Reference Turgeon, Penner and Meggitt1972b), but herbicide products have not been marketed for use on turfgrass in the United States for several decades. Endothall is currently registered in Australia for annual bluegrass control in turf systems with no restrictions against its use on hybrid bermudagrass golf greens (Anonymous 2020). Endothall’s effectiveness to control annual bluegrass has been limited by cool-season turfgrass phytotoxicity (Peppers et al. Reference Peppers, Brewer and Askew2021). Although peer-reviewed studies have not reported endothall effects on bermudagrass turf in managed turf systems, bermudagrass (Cynodon dactylon L. Pers.) was 60 times more tolerant to endothall in irrigation water compared to that of annual bluegrass (Koschnick et al. Reference Koschnick, Haller and Fox2005). Endothall is a serine/threonine protein phosphatase inhibitor (WSSA Group 31), which is a novel mode of action in warm-season turfgrass systems (Bajsa et al. Reference Bajsa, Pan, Dayan, Owens and Duke2012; Tresch et al. Reference Tresch, Schmotz and Grossman2011). This, coupled with previous literature evaluating annual bluegrass control with endothall in cool-season turf (Engel and Aldrich Reference Engel and Aldrich1960; Turgeon et al. Reference Turgeon, Meggitt and Penner1972a, Reference Turgeon, Penner and Meggitt1972b), indicates that endothall may effectively control herbicide-resistant annual bluegrass populations. Barua et al. (Reference Barua, Bousalis, Malone, Gill and Preston2020) found that all annual bluegrass populations screened in Australia were resistant to endothall. However, in the study by Barua et al., the susceptible comparison was controlled by 50% with a single application of endothall at less than half of the rate that was applied thrice to sublethally suppress annual bluegrass seedheads in other studies (Peppers et al. Reference Peppers, Brewer and Askew2021). Therefore, higher dosages of endothall may acceptably control annual bluegrass with lower risks for resistance development. The now-lapsed U.S. federal label for uses of endothall (US EPA 2005) indicates a maximum terrestrial use rate of 2.24 kg ai ha−1, which is approximately 10 times higher than the currently labeled rate in Australia (Anonymous 2020). Although lower label rates may be necessary for cool-season turfgrass tolerance, higher rates appear plausible for use in bermudagrass systems (Koschnick et al. Reference Koschnick, Haller and Fox2005).
The objective of this study was to evaluate the safety of hybrid bermudagrass to cumyluron, endothall, and methiozolin applied in late winter or spring as is typical for targeting emerged annual bluegrass on golf greens. A secondary objective was to evaluate those herbicides applied during full dormancy and during spring transition. Hybrid bermudagrass is generally more susceptible to injury when herbicides are applied during spring transition (Johnson Reference Johnson1976; Reed and McCullough Reference Reed and McCullough2014; Reed et al. Reference Reed, McCullough, Grey, Czarnota, Vencill and Waltz2015). We hypothesized that bermudagrass greens will not suffer a delay in spring transition due to applications of cumyluron, methiozolin, and endothall when applied during full dormancy. Additionally, we hypothesize these herbicides will transiently injure hybrid bermudagrass when applied during spring transition.
Materials and Methods
A total of 16 field studies were established on six golf putting greens to evaluate impact of spring-applied herbicides on bermudagrass spring transition. All trials were conducted at the Independence Golf Club Short Course in Midlothian, VA (37.54°N, 77.69°W). The 16 studies were equally split between initial herbicide treatments to full-dormancy versus mid-transition turf. In 2021, the full-dormancy study was established on two greens and the mid-transition study was established on all six greens. In 2022, this trend was reversed yielding eight site-years for each study. Full-dormancy studies were initiated on February 24, 2021, and February 18, 2022. Mid-transition studies were initiated when hybrid bermudagrass green coverage was approximately 50%. These studies were initiated April 7, 2021, and March 17, 2022. A full description of each site-year can be found in Table 1. Site-years D1 through D8 were established during full dormancy, and site-years MT1 through MT8 were established during mid-transition.
Putting green information for each site-year.
a Soil organic matter was measured via loss on ignition from the top 6 cm of soil excluding the verdure, and is presented as a percentage of soil dry weight.
Treatments are listed in Table 2, and included three biweekly applications of methiozolin (Poacure®; Moghu Research Center Ltd, Daejeon, South Korea) or pronamide (Kerb®; Corteva Agriscience, Indianapolis, IN) and single treatments of cumyluron (HM-0814; Helena Agri-Enterprises LLC, Collierville, TN), endothall (KFD-211-01; UPL Limited, Mumbai, India), or trifloxysulfuron (Monument®; Syngenta, Basel, Switzerland). A nonionic surfactant (Induce®; Helena Agri-Enterprises LLC) was included with trifloxysulfuron at 0.25% v/v. Treatments were applied to 1.67-m2 plots using a CO2-pressurized sprayer calibrated to deliver 374 L ha−1 at 289 kPa using TeeJet 11006 TTI nozzles (Spraying Systems Co., Glendale Heights, IL). Following applications of methiozolin, pronamide, and cumyluron, approximately 6.4 mm of postapplication irrigation was applied to wash herbicide from the foliage and to the soil according to the respective herbicide labels. Application timings are listed in Table 2.
Herbicide rate and application timings for each study.
a Methiozolin and pronamide were applied three times at 2-wk intervals, all others were applied once. A nonionic surfactant was included with trifloxysulfuron at 0.25% v v−1. Cumyluron, methiozolin, and pronamide were incorporated with 6.4 mm of irrigation immediately after treatment.
b All rates are expressed as g ae ha−1.
In full-dormancy studies, data included visually assessed percent green coverage of hybrid bermudagrass and normalized difference vegetative index (NDVI) assessed via a multispectral analyzer (Crop Circle™ Model ACS-210; Holland Scientific Inc.). The center 0.84 m2 of each plot was scanned and collected approximately 35 NDVI readings per experimental unit, which were averaged. These data were collected biweekly until >90% bermudagrass green coverage was observed in each plot. Percent green coverage was converted to thermal time required to reach 90% green coverage via nonlinear regressions using the NLIN procedure with SAS software (version 9.4; SAS Institute Inc., Cary NC). Thermal time was based on growing degree days with a base temperature of 15 C (GDD15) (Fluornoy Reference Flournoy2017). Daily growing degree days were calculated using Equation 1:
$${{Daily}}\,{{GD}}{{\rm{D}}_{15}} = {{Temp{\rm{\;}}\left( {high} \right) + Temp{\rm{\;}}\left( {low} \right)} \over 2} - 15{\rm{\;C\;}}$$
Total GDD15 accumulation is the sum of daily GDD15, excluding negative values, beginning on the initial application date. Nonlinear regressions to relate thermal time to hybrid bermudagrass green cover were fitted to a two-parameter rectangular hyperbolic model using Equation 2:
$${{Y}} = {{iGDD/[(1}} + {{iGDD)}}/{{a]}}$$
where Y is the predicted percent hybrid bermudagrass green coverage, GDD is the accumulated GDD15, i is the percent green coverage per unit GDD as GDD approaches zero, and a is the asymptote for maximum green coverage. Estimated i and a values were used to calculate thermal time required for turf to reach 90% green cover (T 90) in each experimental unit using Equation 3:
$${T_{90}} = \left( {90a} \right)/\left( {i\left( {[a - 90} \right)} \right]$$
where T90 is thermal units in GDD15, and a and i are the estimated parameters from Equation 2. Minimum observed NDVI measurements were recorded for each experimental unit excluding any measurements taken before nontreated turf reached 50% green coverage. Minimum-observed NDVI and T90 values were subjected to ANOVA using the GLM procedure (with SAS software) with sums of squares partitioned to reflect site-year, treatment, and site-year by treatment. Treatment mean squares were tested with the mean square associated with site-year by treatment. Treatment means, with the nontreated control excluded, were separated via Fisher’s protected LSD at α = 0.05. To compare treatment effects to the nontreated control, T90 and minimum observed NDVI values of each treatment were subjected to Dunnett’s procedure (Dunnett Reference Dunnett1955). To determine clusters of site-years that may be pooled, iterative analyses were conducted by systematically excluding different site-years from the ANOVA, and any group of site-years that did not have a significant site-year by treatment interaction were pooled and presented separately alongside other groups or individual site-years.
In mid-transition studies, NDVI readings were collected in a manner similar to that of the full-dormancy study, but percent visually assessed, hybrid bermudagrass injury was recorded rather than green turf cover. In this study, turf was already predominately green at initiation and assessed injury represents stunting, discoloration, and stand reduction caused by treatments. In the dormancy study, by contrast, the rate of hybrid bermudagrass green cover accumulation was a more direct assessment of herbicidal impacts to turf. Percent visible injury data were evaluated as 0% equals no injury, 100% equals complete visible necrosis of hybrid bermudagrass, and 30% equals maximum commercially acceptable injury (Johnson Reference Johnson1995). All data were collected biweekly until injury was no longer present in any plot (approximately 12 wk). Hybrid bermudagrass injury data were converted to number of days above the maximum acceptable injury threshold of 30% (DOT30). These DOT30 data were calculated in a manner similar to that by Brewer et al. (Reference Brewer, Craft and Askew2022) in which linear trends in changes to bermudagrass injury between assessment dates were assumed. The DOT30 values reflect the duration of unacceptable turfgrass injury that is important for turfgrass managers to understand when choosing a herbicide program. Additionally, maximum hybrid bermudagrass injury was calculated by recording maximum observed injury values from each experimental unit over the span of assessment dates and consist of an assessment of injury severity. Minimum observed NDVI measurements were also recorded for each experimental unit similarly to studies initiated during full dormancy. Minimum observed NDVI, maximum observed injury, and DOT30 values were subjected to ANOVA and means were separated as described for the full-dormancy study.
Results and Discussion
Hybrid Bermudagrass Tolerance to Herbicides Applied During Full Dormancy
Data were pooled over any group of site-years that exhibited insignificant trial by treatment interaction (P > 0.05). Hybrid bermudagrass T90 and minimum NDVI data were separated into three site-year groups including the pooled effect of sites D1 and D2; sites D3, D4, and D8; and sites D5, D6, and D7. Nontreated plots transitioned to green turf consistently across the eight site-years and required 42 to 60 GDD15 or 64 to 68 d to achieve 90% green cover depending on site-year (Table 3). Methiozolin was the only herbicide that resulted in increased hybrid bermudagrass T90 relative to the nontreated control. The site-year dependence was likely caused by a variable magnitude of bermudagrass response to methiozolin between the three site-year groups. For example, bermudagrass T90 following methiozolin at the lower rate was similar to nontreated turf at all sites except the group that contains D1 and D2, which are the two sites from 2021 (Table 3). Temperatures were colder in 2021 during study initiation (data not shown) and may have slowed hybrid bermudagrass development compared with the other sites in 2022. In addition, D1 was recently sprigged less than 1 yr before study initiation. Previous research indicates that recently established hybrid bermudagrass is more susceptible to root damage from root-absorbed herbicides such as methiozolin (Sharpe et al. Reference Sharpe, Dickens and Turner1989).
Influence of herbicides applied to fully dormant hybrid bermudagrass on thermal time to obtain 90% green coverage. a – e
a Abbreviations: GDD15, number of growing degree days with a base temperature of 15 C; T90, thermal time required for green bermudagrass turf to reach 90% green cover.
b Data are pooled over site-year groups when the trial by treatment interaction was insignificant (P > 0.05).
c Sites D1 through D8 were located on eight golf greens comprising six randomly chosen hybrid-bermudagrass cultivars at Independence Golf Club in Midlothian, VA. Hybrid bermudagrass cultivars included ‘Mach 1’ (D1, D7), ‘Experimental JK110521’ (D2, D8), ‘Experimental FAES1302’ (D3), ‘Miniverde’ (D4), ‘G12’ (D5), and ‘Tifeagle’ (D6).
d Means separation between treatments, excluding the nontreated control, were determined with Fishers protected LSD (P < 0.05).
e Treatment means followed by an asterisk (*) indicate significant difference compared to the nontreated check (P < 0.05) within a given site-year group based on Dunnett’s test.
f Methiozolin and pronamide were applied three times at 2-wk intervals, all others were applied once. A nonionic surfactant was included with trifloxysulfuron at 0.25% v v−1. Cumyluron, methiozolin, and pronamide were incorporated with 6.4 mm of irrigation immediately after treatment.
At site D2, however, the reason for the severe delay in T90 from methiozolin at the low rate is not apparent other than the aforementioned differences in early-season temperatures between 2021 and 2022. The same green where D2 was located in 2021 provided an adjacent site for D8 in 2022 where methiozolin at either rate caused minimal delay in green cover. Methiozolin applied at a high rate on sites D1 and D2, and sites D5, D6, and D7 caused hybrid bermudagrass to require five to six times more thermal time to reach 90% green cover than at the other three sites. Sites D5 and D6 received approximately 30% and 15% less daily sunlight, respectively, than the other dormant-initiated locations during the trial period based on total number of hours that these locations received direct sunlight, and D7 was less than 2 yr postestablishment at the time the trial initiated. The increased shade stress may have contributed to increased methiozolin injury because many studies have evaluated reduction of hybrid bermudagrass vigor grown in shade (Baldwin et al. Reference Baldwin, Liu and McCarty2008; Gaussoin et al. Reference Gaussoin, Baltensperger and Coffey1988; Trappe et al. Reference Trappe, Karcher, Richardson and Patton2011). Increased shade has also been attributed to increased methiozolin efficacy in preliminary experiments (Henry et al. Reference Henry, Begitschke and Tucker2023).
Additionally, hybrid bermudagrass cultivars may exhibit differential herbicidal susceptibility. McElroy et al. (Reference McElroy, Breeden, Yelverton, Gannon, Askew and Derr2005) observed differential bermudagrass cultivar susceptibility to broadleaf herbicides during turfgrass establishment. The PRE herbicide butralin also differentially damages some cultivars of hybrid bermudagrass relative to others (Johnson Reference Johnson1976). However, in those studies, hybrid bermudagrass cultivar and environmental conditions were randomly selected, and conclusions cannot be drawn regarding how these factors influence response to the herbicides that were evaluated. In addition, experimental cultivar ‘JK110521’ was represented at sites D2 and D8, which statistically separated into different site groups and exhibited differential response to either rate of methiozolin applied to dormant turf (Table 3). Cumyluron and endothall applied to dormant hybrid bermudagrass did not increase hybrid bermudagrass T90 relative to nontreated turf at any site-year.
Trends in hybrid bermudagrass T90 were corroborated by similar trends in minimum observed NDVI. The minimum observed NDVI in nontreated plots ranged from 0.506 to 0.579 (Table 4). Methiozolin applied at 1,000 g ai ha−1 reduced hybrid bermudagrass NDVI relative to the nontreated in all site-years. Methiozolin applied at 500 g ai ha−1 significantly reduced hybrid bermudagrass NDVI relative to the nontreated only in site-years D1 and D2. Similar to T90 data, no other treatment significantly reduced hybrid bermudagrass minimum NDVI relative to the nontreated control.
Influence of herbicides applied to fully dormant hybrid bermudagrass on hybrid bermudagrass minimum observed normalized vegetative difference index following the first instance of 50% green coverage in nontreated turf. a – d
a Data are pooled over site-years groups when the trial by treatment interaction was insignificant (P > 0.05).
b Sites D1 through D8 were located on eight golf greens consisting of six randomly chosen hybrid-bermudagrass cultivars at Independence Golf Club in Midlothian, VA. Hybrid bermudagrass cultivars included ‘Mach 1’ (D1, D7), ‘Experimental JK110521’ (D2, D8), ‘Experimental FAES1302’ (D3), ‘Miniverde’ (D4), ‘G12’ (D5), and ‘Tifeagle’ (D6).
c Means separation between treatments, excluding the nontreated control, were determined with Fishers protected LSD (P < 0.05).
d Treatment means followed by an asterisk (*) indicate significant difference compared to the nontreated check (P < 0.05) within a given site-year group based on Dunnett’s test.
e Methiozolin and pronamide were applied three times at 2-wk intervals, all others were applied once. A nonionic surfactant was included with trifloxysulfuron at 0.25% v/v. Cumyluron, methiozolin, and pronamide were incorporated with 6.4 mm of irrigation immediately after treatment.
Hybrid Bermudagrass Tolerance to Herbicides Applied During Mid-Transition
Data are pooled between site-years when the trial by treatment interaction was insignificant (P > 0.05). Hybrid bermudagrass DOT30, maximum observed injury, and minimum NDVI data separated into three groups representing the pooled effect of sites MT1, MT2, MT4, and MT6; MT3 and MT5; and MT7 and MT8. In general, hybrid bermudagrass injury metrics appeared to be more severe at sites MT3 and MT5 (Table 5). Sites MT3 and MT5 may have separated from the other site-years due to higher levels of abiotic stress relative to other site-years. Site-year MT5 was characterized as having relatively immature hybrid bermudagrass (Table 1) and MT3 had approximately 30% less direct sunlight relative to other site-years. For example, MT3 and MT5 were the only site-years where methiozolin at 500 g ai ha−1 caused more than 30% injury and produced a significant DOT30 (Table 5). Likewise, trifloxysulfuron and pronamide injured bermudagrass by more than 30% for 1.7 d to 6.8 d at MT3 and MT5, and no days at other locations. However, at site-years MT3 and MT5, only endothall and methiozolin applied at 1,680 and 1,000 g ai ha−1, respectively, increased hybrid bermudagrass DOT30 relative to the nontreated check. In all site-years, except MT7 and MT8, endothall applied at 1,680 g ai ha−1 had significant DOT30 values relative to the nontreated control. At site-years MT1, MT2, MT4, and MT6, endothall applied at 840 g ai ha−1 injured hybrid bermudagrass by at least 30% for 5.5 d to 8.5 d. Methiozolin applied at 500 g ai ha−1 never significantly increased hybrid bermudagrass DOT30 relative to the nontreated.
Influence of herbicides applied to mid-transition hybrid bermudagrass, on hybrid bermudagrass d over 30% injury threshold. a – d
a Data are pooled over site-years groups when the trial by treatment interaction was insignificant (P > 0.05).
b Sites D1 through D8 were located on eight golf greens comprising six randomly chosen hybrid-bermudagrass cultivars at Independence Golf Club in Midlothian, VA. Hybrid bermudagrass cultivars included ‘Experimental FAES1302’ (MT1), ‘Miniverde’ (MT2), ‘G12’ (MT3), ‘Tifeagle’ (MT4), ‘Mach 1’ (MT5, MT7), and ‘Experimental JK110521’ (MT6, MT8).
c Means separation between treatments, excluding the nontreated control, were determined with Fishers protected LSD (P < 0.05).
d Treatment means followed by an asterisk (*) indicate significant difference compared to the nontreated check (P < 0.05) within a given site-year based on Dunnett’s test.
e Methiozolin and pronamide were applied three times at 2-wk intervals, all others were applied once. A nonionic surfactant was included with trifloxysulfuron at 0.25% v/v. Cumyluron, methiozolin, and pronamide were incorporated with 6.4 mm of irrigation immediately after treatment.
The maximum observed injury caused by herbicides exhibited trends that were similar to that of injury DOT30. For example, endothall at either rate, and methiozolin at 1,000 g ai ha−1, had generally higher maximum injury (Table 6) compared to injury from the other products. Although most of the herbicides caused significant injury to hybrid bermudagrass, relative to the nontreated only endothall at either rate, and methiozolin applied at 1,000 g ai ha−1 resulted in unacceptable injury to hybrid bermudagrass. Some trends, however, indicate that when methiozolin injured hybrid bermudagrass by more than 30% the injury was persistent, which is reflected by 13 to 44 DOT30 at site-years MT3 and MT5, and MT7 and MT8 (Table 5). Cumyluron never significantly injured hybrid bermudagrass across all site-years.
Influence of herbicides applied to mid-transition hybrid bermudagrass on maximum observed hybrid bermudagrass injury. a – d
a Data are pooled over site-years groups when the trial by treatment interaction was insignificant (P > 0.05).
b Sites D1through D8 were located on eight golf greens comprising six randomly chosen hybrid-bermudagrass cultivars at Independence Golf Club in Midlothian, VA. Hybrid bermudagrass cultivars included ‘Experimental FAES1302’ (MT1), ‘Miniverde’ (MT2), ‘G12’ (MT3), ‘Tifeagle’ (MT4), ‘Mach 1’ (MT5, MT7), and ‘Experimental JK110521’ (MT6, MT8).
c Means separation between treatments, excluding the nontreated control, were determined with Fishers protected LSD (P < 0.05).
d Treatment means followed by an asterisk (*) indicate significant difference compared to the nontreated check (P < 0.05) within a given site-year group based on Dunnett’s test.
e Methiozolin and pronamide were applied three times at 2-wk intervals, all others were applied once. A nonionic surfactant was included with trifloxysulfuron at 0.25% v v−1. Cumyluron, methiozolin, and pronamide were incorporated with 6.4 mm of irrigation immediately after treatment.
Endothall applied at 840 and 1,680 g ai ha−1 reduced the minimum observed NDVI of hybrid bermudagrass relative to the nontreated in all but 1 site-year along a positive rate-dependent trend (Table 7). Endothall applied at 1,680 g ai ha−1 reduced hybrid bermudagrass NDVI greater than any other herbicide in all site-years. Although endothall applied at 840 g ai ha−1 resulted in unacceptable injury to hybrid bermudagrass (Table 6), the injury was transient, with hybrid bermudagrass DOT30 values never exceeding 9 d (Table 5). These results are consistent with those observed after flumioxazin and oxadiazon were applied during mid-bermudagrass-transition on non–putting green, hybrid bermudagrass (Johnson Reference Johnson1976; Reed and McCullough Reference Reed and McCullough2014; Reed et al. Reference Reed, McCullough, Grey, Czarnota, Vencill and Waltz2015). Additionally, these results align with preliminary reports of endothall activity on fairway-height hybrid bermudagrass, in which endothall applications were more injurious to hybrid bermudagrass when applied at higher rates to actively growing hybrid bermudagrass (Peppers and Askew Reference Peppers and Askew2022). Methiozolin applied at 1,000 g ai ha−1 at site-years MT3 and MT5 was the only treatment outside of endothall to significantly reduce hybrid bermudagrass NDVI relative to the nontreated control. Neither pronamide nor trifloxysulfuron produced significantly reduced minimum observed NDVI relative to the nontreated. Cumyluron did not unacceptably injure hybrid bermudagrass (Table 6) or reduce NDVI (Table 7) at any site-year.
Influence of herbicides applied to mid-transition hybrid bermudagrass on minimum observed hybrid bermudagrass normalized difference vegetative index. a – d
a Data are pooled over site-year groups when the trial by treatment interaction was insignificant (P > 0.05).
b Sites D1 through D8 were located on eight golf greens comprising six randomly chosen hybrid-bermudagrass cultivars at Independence Golf Club in Midlothian, VA. Hybrid bermudagrass cultivars included ‘Experimental FAES1302’ (MT1), ‘Miniverde’ (MT2), ‘G12’ (MT3), ‘Tifeagle’ (MT4), ‘Mach 1’ (MT5, MT7), and ‘Experimental JK110521’ (MT6, MT8).
c Means separation between treatments, excluding the nontreated control, were determined with Fishers protected LSD (P < 0.05).
d Treatment means followed by an asterisk (*) indicate significant difference compared to the nontreated check (P < 0.05) within a given site-year group based on Dunnett’s test.
e Methiozolin and pronamide were applied three times at 2-wk intervals, all others were applied once. A nonionic surfactant was included with trifloxysulfuron at 0.25% v v−1. Cumyluron, methiozolin, and pronamide were incorporated with 6.4 mm of irrigation immediately after treatment.
These are the first studies submitted to peer-review that evaluated hybrid bermudagrass putting green tolerance to methiozolin, endothall, or cumyluron. Results from these studies indicate that methiozolin is consistently detrimental to hybrid bermudagrass putting greens when applied at twice the label-recommended rate during full dormancy. Trends in the data suggest that abiotic stressors may negatively affect hybrid bermudagrass tolerance to elevated rates of methiozolin; however, no specific conclusions in this regard may be drawn from this study. Endothall injures hybrid bermudagrass when applied at higher rates or during postdormancy transition. Cumyluron can safely be used on hybrid bermudagrass before or during postdormancy transition. These trials were conducted in the northernmost portion of the transition zone where hybrid bermudagrass experiences more extreme cold stress than in the majority of locations in which hybrid bermudagrass is grown. A reduction in hybrid bermudagrass green coverage during spring transition is commonly observed with root-inhibiting herbicides in the northern transition zone (Bingham Reference Bingham1967; Bingham and Shaver Reference Bingham and Shaver1979; Breuninger and Schmidt Reference Breuninger and Schmidt1981). This is primarily due to the increased susceptibility of meristematic root tissue to root-inhibiting herbicides (Bingham Reference Bingham1967). Additionally, bermudagrass roots are mostly lost on fully dormant turf and must be regrown following the initiation of postdormancy growth (DiPaola and Beard Reference DiPaola and Beard1978). Abiotic stressors also exacerbate herbicide injury on turfgrasses (Bhowmik and Bingham Reference Bhowmik and Bingham1990; Hart et al. Reference Hart, Lycan and Murphy2004; Venner et al. Reference Venner, Ervin, Koo, Peppers and Askew2023), which may explain why hybrid bermudagrass appeared to be more susceptible to endothall, methiozolin, and pronamide at certain site-years. The maximum labeled use rate of methiozolin on putting greens is 500 g ai ha−1 (Anonymous 2021), which did not unacceptably injure hybrid bermudagrass at any site-year when applied during mid-transition. These data suggest that methiozolin should be applied only within labeled rates to actively growing hybrid bermudagrass putting greens, cumyluron can be applied anytime during late winter or spring, and endothall applications should be limited to dormant turf treatment unless transient phytotoxicity is acceptable.
Practical Implications
The proliferation of herbicide-resistant annual bluegrass on hybrid bermudagrass greens and associated areas has increased the need for multiproduct admixtures or novel herbicide modes of action. Methiozolin, endothall, and cumyluron control annual bluegrass and some other grassy weeds endemic to hybrid bermudagrass greens, but limited information exists regarding their safety for use in this unique turf system. Endothall and cumyluron are not currently labeled for use on any turfgrass site in the United States. The methiozolin product label indicates that hybrid bermudagrass should be actively growing when the herbicide is applied and use rates should not exceed 500 g ai ha−1 on turf managed at greens height (Anonymous 2021). Results of these studies suggest that cumyluron is safe to use on hybrid bermudagrass, regardless of application timing, when applied at 6,450 g ai ha−1. Endothall can be safely applied to hybrid bermudagrass during full dormancy, but high levels (approximately 20% to 80%) of injury may transiently occur when applied to hybrid bermudagrass during mid-transition. These data may have use in driving labeling decisions for endothall and cumyluron, and lead to warnings for methiozolin use on fully dormant hybrid bermudagrass putting greens.
Acknowledgments
We thank Dan Taylor, superintendent of Independence Golf Club, for allowing research to be conducted on putting greens under his care. This research received no specific grant from any funding agency, commercial or not-for-profit sectors. No conflicts of interest are declared.
Open access
