Introduction
Cerebral ischemia is one of the most serious neurological disorders and is the most common cause of permanent disability all over the world.Reference Knecht, Hesse and Oster 1 Its sequelae not only reduce the quality of survivor’s life, but also put a heavy burden on families and society. 2 Although a great deal of effort have been made in past decades, today we still lack effective strategies that can improve functional outcome in stroke survivors.Reference Pérez de la Ossa and Dávalos 3
The early phase postischemia is the critical time window for the functional recovery in which plenty of neuroprotective mechanisms were initiated, such as neurogenesis, functional plasticity, axonal sprouting and synaptogenesis, and attenuation of muscle atrophy in unaffected sides.Reference Jorgensen, Nakayama and Raaschou 4 - Reference Choe, An and Lee 6 This time window is sensitive to specific treatments that can trigger and promote neuroprotective mechanisms in spontaneous recovery.
In recent years, increasing clinic evidence has suggested that early locomotor exercise after stroke facilitated the functional recovery from stroke and had attracted a great deal of attention.Reference Bernhardt, Dewey, Thrift, Collier and Donnan 7 The benefits of early locomotor exercise after stroke included fewer deaths, fewer and less severe complications, less disability, and better quality of life.Reference Dragert and Zehr 8 - Reference Stoller, de Bruin and Knols 10 Moreover, early locomotor exercise poststroke has currently been recommended in a range of clinical guidelines, such as the Clinical Guidelines for Stroke Management 2010 document sponsored by the National Stroke Foundation in Australia. 11 Although early locomotor exercise poststroke was considered an important and potential treatment strategy for stroke, its clinical application is limited. Some clinicians have little confidence in its effectiveness because of the absence of high-quality randomized, double-blind, control clinical trials and an undefined molecular mechanism.Reference McCluskey, Vratsistas-Curto and Schurr 12 , Reference Stinear, Ackerley and Byblow 13
Although there are some differences between patient and animal models, the animal studies can help us explore underlying molecular mechanisms that is difficult to achieve in clinical trials. The unmasked mechanism may increase the willingness of clinicians to implement the early locomotor exercise poststroke in clinical settings. Here we review the mechanism of early locomotor exercise poststroke in animal stroke models in recent years. We hope that a comprehensive awareness of early locomotor exercise may help implement early locomotor exercise more appropriately in treatment for cerebral ischemic stroke.
Search Methodology and Results
We aimed to identify all rodent animal studies relating to cerebral ischemia, early locomotor exercise poststroke, behavioral recovery, and mechanism. We searched PubMed including all years up to January 2015 (English language only). We included animal studies that used global or focal ischemic stroke. Any intervention using early locomotor exercise, such as forced or voluntary locomotor exercise, was included.
Based on the keywords “cerebral ischemia” and “exercise,” we obtained 826 titles. Of these, 258 studies were animal models and their abstracts were identified for further review. Reference lists in these articles were hand-searched for further studies with potential relevance. Finally, 49 studies met the criteria (rodent model, cerebral ischemia, early-initiated [24-72 hours poststroke], and locomotor exercise intervention) and measured the effects of early locomotor exercise postcerebral ischemia on brain repair and so were included in this review (Table 1).
References of early exercise after stroke
NGF, nerve growth factors.
Definition of Early Locomotor Exercise
To implement early locomotor exercise appropriately, it is crucial to define the time window of the early phase after stroke. However, there is not a standard definition of early phase either in clinical applications or animal studies. In the clinical setting, 24 hours, the first 3 days, and the first week after stroke onset were considered as early phase.Reference Ada, Dean and Morris 14 , Reference Ada, Dean and Morris 15 The time window is one of the direct guides for clinical therapy. However, the optimal time point for early exercise depends on multiple factors including race, sex, age, lifestyle, complications, and individual differences. Thus the early phase after stroke cannot be defined only by time point in the clinical setting.
This issue becomes simple in animal model because we can control almost all conditions in experiments including the type of animal, sex, age, and severity of stroke. The middle cerebral artery occlusion is widely used in rodent stroke model. In most reports, early exercise was initiated during 24 to 72 hours after middle cerebral artery occlusion in rodents with 60 to 120 minutes of ischemiaReference Zhang, Zhang and Zhang 16 - Reference Lee, Kim and Park 20 (Table 1). Thus the exercise begun 24 to 72 hours after stroke was defined as early exercise in this review, with the training period lasting from 1 to 4 weeks.
The locomotor exercise program in this review included voluntary exercise and forced exercise (constant intensity during all training periods and gradually increased intensity during the first few days) (Table 1).
Histological and Functional Improvement
The death of neurons is the disastrous consequence of cerebral ischemia, which leads to serious histological damages and the formation of an infarct zone in brain parenchyma. The neurons in the ischemic core die via irreversible necrosis and apoptosis. Subsequently, most cells in the penumbra, region that surrounds the infarct zone, undergo apoptosis gradually after stroke.Reference Broughton, Reutens and Sobey 21 These cells can potentially be rescued in the early phase of cerebral ischemia by inhibiting the apoptotic pathway or by recovering the cerebral blood. Because decreased neuron death means reduced infarct volume and promoted functional recovery, the treatment strategies to date that could reduce infarct volume are potential protocols in stroke treatment.
Locomotor exercise at early phase is one kind of treatment in after-stroke recovery. However, early locomotor exercise did not reduce infarct volume consequentially; the infarct volume in ischemic rats may even be enlarged by conditioned overuse of the affected limb and high-intensity exercise at early phase after stroke.Reference Humm, Kozlowski and James 22 - Reference Bland, Pillai and Aronowski 24 Early locomotor exercise with a proper intensity reduced the infarct volume.Reference Yang, Wang, Wang and Yu 25 Although early locomotor exercise significantly promoted motor coordination and alleviated neurological deficits,Reference Yang, Wang, Wang and Yu 25 , Reference Shimada, Hamakawa and Ishida 26 the promoted functional recovery is not accompanied by reduced infarct volume.Reference Marin, Williams and Hale 27 Furthermore, the effect of early locomotor exercise on recovery is timing window–dependent. YangReference Yang, Wang and Wang 28 and Rasmus et alReference Nielsen, Samson, Simonsen and Jensen 29 demonstrated that rats with one week of mild treadmill training initiated 24 hours after operation had reduced infarct volume and better functional recovery than rats with equal training initiated one week after operation. Our group also demonstrated that early treadmill training with gradually increased intensity significantly reduced infarct volume and promoted functional recovery of motor and memory. Moreover, aging is often accompanied by stroke attack. Two weeks of early locomotor exercise decreased the infarct volume both in young and old rats compared with the control group, but the young rats had a smaller infarct volume than did the older rats.Reference Wang, Yu and Yang 30
In summary, these experimental studies indicate that locomotor exercise with mild to moderate intensity initiated early may decrease histological damage and enhance functional recovery from cerebral ischemia.
Neuroprotective Mechanism of Early Exercise
Early locomotor exercise initiates multiple neuroprotective responses in injured brains such as change of cerebral blood flow, gene expression, angiogenesis, neurogenesis, mitochondrial biogenesis, suppression of apoptosis, and neuroinflammation response. Their synergistic effect contributes to neuroprotection and subsequent functional recovery (Table 1).
Early Locomotor Exercise Attenuates Neuroinflammation Response
Cerebral ischemia is accompanied with the inflammatory responses, such as the production of proinflammatory cytokines, chemokines, and adhesion molecules and activation of the resident glial cells. These processes start within hours after ischemia and persist for months.Reference Barone and Feuerstein 31 , Reference Wang, Tang and Yenari 32 Although inflammatory responses exerted some beneficial effects in recovery from stroke,Reference Lucas, Rothwell and Gibson 33 - Reference Stoll and Jander 35 accumulating evidence showed that inflammatory response in the acute ischemic period was one of the main factors that led to brain damage and exacerbated ischemic injury in potentially viable tissues through secretion of deleterious molecules, such as glutamate, and production of reactive oxygen species and nitric oxide.Reference Dheen, Kaur and Ling 36 - Reference Eltzschig and Eckle 40 Some experimental evidence have demonstrated that inhibition of acute inflammatory responses with antagonists, neutralizing antibodies, or gene knockouts relieved the detrimental effects and markedly improved functional recovery.Reference Iadecola, Zhang and Casey 41 , Reference Hewlett and Corbett 42
Existing evidence shows that physical exercise diminishes inflammation in some chronic diseases and in aged mice.Reference Beavers, Brinkley and Nicklas 43 The molecular mechanism involves the reduction of macrophage infiltration, expression of inducible nitric oxide synthase and tumor necrosis factor-alpha in the heart and expression of chemokines and cytokines in the circulatory system.Reference Botta, Laher and Beam 44 - Reference Gomes, Simoes and Mortara 46 Interestingly, a recent article has indicated that preischemic physical exercise led to chronically increased expression of tumor necrosis factor-alpha during exercise, which conversely ameliorated inflammatory injury induced by ischemia/reperfusion.Reference Ding, Young and Luan 47 A possible explanation is that the chronically proinflammatory response during exercise led to ischemic tolerance, a phenomenon in which minor injury before ischemia led to a greater tolerance to subsequent serious injury. Recent research has focused on the effect of postischemic physical exercise on the acute inflammatory response. Our data indicated that early locomotor exercise after stroke significantly attenuated the acute neuroinflammation through decreasing proinflammatory cytokines and cell adhesion molecules, suppressing the activation of astrocytosis and microglia, and attenuating the detriment of over-released glutamate.Reference Zhang, Zhang and Pu 19 , Reference Zhang, Bai and Hu 48 Furthermore, we found that early locomotor exercise protects blood-brain barrier (BBB) integrity against ischemia/refusion injury.Reference Zhang, Zhang and Shen 49 The disrupted BBB is a critical early event that initiates the inflammatory cascade and exaggerates edema, which ultimately results in poor outcomes.Reference Spatz 50 Recent studies have indicated Toll-like receptor (TLR) signaling pathways are also involved the neuroprotective action of early locomotor exercise. TLRs are a group of important receptors in the brain’s innate immune system; they play a critical role in initiating and modulating the inflammatory cascade caused by cerebral ischemia through recruiting and linking to their endogenous ligands released from damaged neuronal cells.Reference Kaczorowski, Mollen and Edmonds 51 - Reference Winters, Winters and Gorup 53 Studies have shown that early locomotor exercise decreased TLR expression on cell-surface and inflammatory cytokine production in monocytes in ischemic brain tissue.Reference Gleeson, Mcfarlin and Flynn 54 - Reference Zwagerman, Plumlee and Guthikonda 56 The main downstream targets of TLR2/4, MyD88, and nuclear factor-κB were also reduced by early exercise following cerebral ischemia.Reference Ma, He and Qiang 57 In summary, early locomotor exercise after stroke may attenuate acute inflammatory responses via reduced expression of proinflammatory cytokines and inhibited BBB dysfunction so as to confer neuroprotective action.
Early Locomotor Exercise Suppresses Neural Apoptosis in Penumbra
Cerebral ischemia leads to irreversible death of neurons in the ischemic core. However, some neurons in penumbra survive with dysfunction and then undergo apoptosis if they do not receive effective therapeutic treatment.Reference Ribe, Serrano-Saiz and Akpan 58 - Reference Broughton, Reutens and Sobey 60 Thus, these injured neurons could be rescued in early-phase postischemia, and suppression of apoptosis may potentially be an opportunity to salvage these neurons and then alleviate brain injury.Reference Martinou, Dubois-Dauphin and Staple 61 , Reference Zhao, Yenari and Cheng 62 Increasing evidence shows that appropriate locomotor exercise could suppress apoptosis in many diseases,Reference Haack, Luu and Cho 63 , Reference Kavazis, Smuder and Min 64 particularly in ischemic myocardial infarctionReference Quindry, French and Hamilton 65 , Reference Kavazis, Mcclung and Hood 66 and Alzheimer diseaseReference Um, Kang and Leem 67 by reducing the expression of proapoptotic proteins and increasing the expression of antiapoptotic proteins.Reference French, Hamilton and Quindry 68 - Reference Kwak, Song and Lawler 70 Two-week early locomotor exercise started at 48 or 72 hours poststroke significantly reduces the number of TdT-mediated dUTP-biotin nick-end labeling–positive cells and suppressed autophagosomes.Reference Zhang, Hu and Luo 71 - Reference Lee, Kim and Kim 73 Even early locomotor exercise started at 24 hours after stroke also significantly improves neurological function by decreasing caspase-3 and cleaved caspase-3 expression and the number of apoptotic cells detected by Fluoro-Jade-B staining and TdT-mediated dUTP-biotin nick-end labeling concurrently by increasing Bcl-2 (a key antiapoptotic protein) expression detected by western blotting.Reference Zhang, Zhang and Zhang 16 , Reference Sim, Kim and Kim 74 , Reference Sim, Kim, Kim, Shin and Kim 75 These results indicate that suppressing neural apoptosis in the penumbra may be the potential underlying mechanism conferred to the neuroprotective mechanism induced by early locomotor exercise following cerebral ischemia.
Early Locomotor Exercise Increases Expression of Neurotrophic Factors
Neurotrophic factors play crucial roles in neuronal survival, repair, and recovery from stroke.Reference Ang and Gomez-Pinilla 76 However, their clinical application is limited because the recombinant neurotrophic factors cannot cross the BBB.Reference Poduslo and Curran 77 It is well-known that exercise can upregulate the expression of nerve growth factors in rats with both normal and diseased brains, such as brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF),Reference Quirie, Hervieu and Garnier 78 - Reference Sartori, Vieira and Ferrari 81 nerve growth factors, and neurotrophin, and so on.
Similarly, recent reports indicate that early locomotor exercise following stroke increases the expression of neurotrophic factors, such as BDNF and insulin-like growth factor (IGF), the possible mechanisms involved in the 5-HT, Trk, and AKT signaling pathways.Reference Liu, Huang and Lin 82 - Reference Sun, Ke, Yip, Hu, Zheng and Tong 87 The increased BDNF induced by early locomotor exercise is mainly distributed in the contralateral hemisphere and the penumbra in the ipsilateral hemisphere.Reference Kim, Bang and Han 88 The expression levels of nerve growth factors and Midkine are significantly upregulated in the cells around the infarct zone of the ischemic rats that received low-intensity early locomotor exercise compared with the ischemia-only sedentary rats.Reference Matsuda, Sakakima and Yoshida 17 Early locomotor exercise increases neurotrophin-4 protein level in the bilateral hemispheres compared with the ischemia-only sedentary rats, particularly in the contralateral hemisphere and the zone that adjacent to the ischemic region; this increase was detected as early as day 9 after ischemia.Reference Chung, Kim and Bang 89 The study by Chang et al found that early locomotor exercise increases the IGF-I concentration through promoted IGF-I entrance into the affected brain zone and increased its expression. Inhibiting IGF-I signaling eliminates such protective effects.Reference Chang, Yang and Wang 90 A study conducted by Ohwatashi et al found that early locomotor exercise induces increased expression of glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor in rats who underwent photochemical infarction.Reference Ohwatashi, Ikeda and Harada 91 It is noteworthy that Liu et alReference Liu, Huang and Lin 82 demonstrated that early locomotor exercise started at 24 hours significantly increased the expression of netrin-1 and its receptors, which regulate diverse recovery processes including neuron survival and migration,Reference Llambi, Causeret and Bloch-Gallego 92 , Reference Tang, Jang and Okada 93 axonal outgrowth and branching,Reference Dent, Barnes and Tang 94 and angiogenesis.Reference Wilson, Ii and Park 95
Early Locomotor Exercise Enhances the Angiogenesis and Improves Cerebral Blood Flow in the Ischemic Zone
Angiogenesis is a neuroprotective response induced by hypoxia within a few hours after the onset of stroke. The expression of a group of angiogenic factors including vascular endothelial growth factor, Ang1/2, and their receptor Tie2 in infarct hemisphere was gradually upregulated for weeks after stroke. These proteins trigger the proliferation of endothelial cells and neovascularization.Reference Sun, Jin and Xie 96 - Reference Beck, Acker and Wiessner 99 Krupinski et al found some vascular buds and connections in an ischemic rat by brain vascular cast method.Reference Krupinski, Stroemer and Slevin 100 Newly formatted blood vessels not only improve the exchange of oxygen and glucose through increased blood flow,Reference Jiang, Zhang and Ding 101 , Reference Hayashi, Deguchi and Nagotani 102 but also remove damaged tissues and ameliorate the microenvironment in hypoxic tissue.Reference Manoonkitiwongsa, Jackson-Friedman and Mcmillan 103 The improved microenvironment rescues the injured neurons and promotes the proliferation and migration of neural stem cells.Reference Petraglia, Marky and Walker 104 , Reference Li, Ford and Lavik 105 Indeed, clinical observation found that stroke patients with more newly formatted blood vessels survive a longer time.Reference Wei, Erinjeri and Rovainen 106 , Reference Krupinski, Kaluza and Kumar 107 Thus, improving angiogenesis after stroke plays a crucial role in recovery from stroke and is a potential strategy for treatment of ischemia.Reference Arenillas, Sobrino and Castillo 108 , Reference Ergul, Alhusban and Fagan 109
Early locomotor exercise after ischemia has been shown to augment angiogenesis through increasing the messenger RNA transcription and protein translation of angiopoietins, such as vascular endothelial growth factorReference Ma, Qiang and He 110 , PECAM-1Reference Sakakima, Khan and Dhammu 72 , CD31Reference Hu, Zheng and Yan 111 , Ang1, and their receptor Tie2.Reference Zhang, Yu and Zhou 112 , Reference Zheng, Zhu and Bai 113 Endothelial nitric oxide synthesis may be an underlying mechanism because the lack of endothelial nitric oxide synthase abolishes the beneficial effects of early locomotor exercise on angiogenesis.Reference Gertz, Priller and Kronenberg 114 Recently, we demonstrated that these newly formatted vessels increased by early locomotor exercise indeed give rise to new functional vessels and improve the cerebral blood flow in ischemic brain zone visualized by laser speckle flowmetry, a noninvasive imaging blood flow technique.Reference Zhang, Yu and Zhou 112 The similar result was achieved in Yang’s study, which reported increased CD31-positive blood vessel density in the affected striatum.Reference Yang, Chang, Wang and Wang 115 Furthermore, an in vitro study indicated that a modest flow induced by appropriate locomotor exercise decreases brain microvascular endothelial cells apoptosis in the ischemic condition.Reference Tian, Zhang and Tian 116 These results suggested that early locomotor exercise can improve cerebral blood flow through angiogenesis and increase blood flow rate in the ischemic brain zone.
Early Locomotor Exercise Promotes Neuroplasticity: Neurogenesis and Synaptic Reorganization
Neuroplasticity is a critical element in brain repair after stroke. Accumulative evidence has suggested that some newborn neurons after stroke were functionally recruited and formed appropriate synapses with the existing neurons in hippocampus.Reference Liu, Wang and Zhu 117 - Reference Nakatomi, Kuriu and Okabe 119 In addition to neurogenesis, synaptic reorganization is another key constituent in functional recovery following stroke.Reference Font, Arboix and Krupinski 120 The neurons in peri-infarct region of ipsilateral hemisphere and the contralateral hemisphere form some new synapses with survived neurons and newborn neurons.Reference Yiu and He 121
There is increasing evidence to show that locomotor exercise promoted neuroplasticity both in normal and ischemic animals.Reference Ang and Gomez-Pinilla 76 , Reference Rhodes, van Praag and Jeffrey 122 Several reports have shown that locomotor exercise initiated within 7 days after stroke enhances neurogenesis and functional recovery.Reference Luo, Jiang and Zhou 123 Some recent studies have detected the change of protein expression profile induced by early locomotor exercise in the cortex of rats with stroke. These results suggest that early locomotor exercise after stroke upregulate a group of proteins that promote synaptic plasticity, such as growth-associated protein 43 (GAP43, the key axon growth-associated protein), Syn1, synaptosomal-associated protein (SNAP-25), PSD95, and others.Reference Mizutani, Sonoda and Yamada 124 - Reference Mizutani, Sonoda and Hayashi 129 Accordingly, increased neurogenesis was detected in the hippocampus dentate gyrus and peri-infarct regions in rats who underwent early locomotor exercise.Reference Zheng, Zhang and Luo 130 During spontaneous recovery after ischemia, many of these newborn neurons undergo apoptosis,Reference Gould, Beylin and Tanapat 131 but early locomotor exercise significantly increases the neurogenesis and decreases the number of apoptotic cells.Reference Zhang, Hu and Luo 71 However, some reports show that early locomotor exercise poststroke reduces neurogenesis in the subventricular zone and dentate gyrus.Reference Komitova, Zhao and Gido 132 - Reference Lee, Kim, Kim and Yoon 134 These inconsistent results could be due to different models and exercise protocols used. Ameliorative neuroplasticity can be detected by electrophysiology. The results from Tang et alReference Tang, Yang and Hu 135 , Reference Tang, Tan and Yang 136 indicate that early locomotor exercise enhanced activity-dependent long-term depression through PICK1-dependent mechanisms and an increased expression level of AMPA receptor subunits that can increase synaptic transmission. Thus early locomotor exercise postischemia promotes neuroplasticity through neurogenesis and synaptogenesis and increases the functional synapse.
Early Locomotor Exercise Promotes Mitochondrial Biogenesis
Mitochondria is a critical organelle that supports the neuronal survival, metabolism, synthesis, and release of neurotransmitters and recovery from injury.Reference Cheng, Hou and Mattson 137 , Reference Garesse and Vallejo 138 However, mitochondrion play opposite roles during cerebral ischemic injury. On the one hand, injured mitochondria releases a great deal of reactive oxygen species that initiate detrimental cascade; on the other hand, biogenesis of functional mitochondria induced by stroke is helpful for neuroprotection and recovery.Reference Cheng, Hou and Mattson 137 , Reference Onyango, Lu and Rodova 139 Thus, the strategy to decrease mitochondria damage and increase mitochondrial biogenesis would be important to neuroprotective treatment after stroke.Reference Valerio, Bertolotti and Delbarba 140 Consistent evidence suggests that exercise increases mitochondrial biogenesis in healthy and ischemic brains.Reference Steiner, Murphy and Mcclellan 141 - Reference Bayod, Del and Canudas 143 Recent evidence from our laboratory shows that early locomotor exercise started 24 hours after stroke increases mitochondrial DNA content and significantly enhances the messenger RNA and protein expression of three transcription factors considered critical for mitochondrial gene transcription and DNA replication: PGC-1, NRF-1, and TFAM.Reference Zhang, Wu and Sha 144 , Reference Zhang, Wu and Zhang 145 These results indicate that early locomotor exercise after stroke could enhance mitochondrial biogenesis and may serve as a key component of early locomotor exercise–induced neuroprotective mechanisms in the ischemic brain.
Summary and Prospects
Locomotor exercise is an effective, inexpensive, home-based, and accessible intervention strategy. Early locomotor exercise poststroke has attracted a great deal of attention in rehabilitative centers and laboratories. Animal studies have increasingly revealed that early locomotor exercise induced neuroprotective mechanisms in the ischemic brain; randomized control trials with larger sample number are further exploring the optimal early locomotor exercise protocol. This evidence from clinical and animal studies indicates that early locomotor exercise poststroke was beneficial for recovery from cerebral ischemia and that it can be applied safely. However, to apply early locomotor exercise in clinical practice and maximize functional outcome, the choice of interventional protocol should be considered carefully. The first consideration is how to choose the type of locomotor exercise. Cumulative evidence indicates that different exercise protocols could lead to an entirely different outcome.Reference Ke, Yip, Li, Zheng and Tong 84 , Reference Ke, Yip, Li, Zheng, Tam and Tong 86 , Reference Yang, Chang, Wang and Wang 115 There are many locomotor exercise manipulations that could be used conveniently, but so far this is no unified standard to assist in choosing the optimum type. The second consideration is whether early locomotor exercise combined with other rehabilitative treatments or drugs is more reasonable than locomotor exercise only.Reference Wang, Feng, Du, Wang and Zhang 146 , Reference Gherardini, Gennaro and Pizzorusso 147 A related rehabilitative treatment may be functional electrical stimulation, acupuncture, music stimulus, light stimulus, skilled training, and so on. Drugs can include multiple agents that alleviate inflammatory response and neuronal apoptosis and promote angiogenesis and neurogenesis. Additionally, some locomotor exercise can be carried out under the help of body-weight support or a robot.Reference Li, Rong, Ke, Hu and Tong 148 The third consideration is how we can determine the amount and intensity of early locomotor exercise based on different levels of severity in a stroke patient. According to our knowledge from animal studies and clinic observations, low and gradually increased exercise intensity should be performed in the early phase after stroke.Reference Lee, Kim and Park 20 , Reference Shih, Yang and Wang 125 , Reference Austin, Ploughman, Glynn and Corbett 149
In summary, early exercise poststroke was safe, feasible, and effective (Table 1). But its implementation in a clinical setting should be cautiously introduced and based on each individual’s condition.
Acknowledgments and Funding
The present study is supported by the Foundation of Yunnan Educational Committee (KKJA201360028), Natural Science Foundation of Kunming University of Science and Technology (KKSY201360073), and Chinese National Natural Science Foundation (81460351, 81272169, 81201502, 81171856, and 81171855).
Disclosures
The authors have no disclosures.
