HISTORY OF THE SCIENTIFIC WORK UNCOVERING THE EVOLUTION AND ESTABLISHMENT OF SCHISTOSOMA HYBRIDS

From some of the earliest scientific literature on schistosomes, evidence of potential crosses and hybridizations between different species of schistosomes have been reported. These first identifications were mainly based on phenotypic eggs observations. For example, Alves in 1948 reported potential S. haematobium–S. mattheei hybrids amongst cases of human urogenital schistosomiasis in Southern Rhodesia, Zimbabwe (Alves, Reference Alves1948). This observation was followed by several others proposing the existence of the same hybrids occurring in both Zimbabwe and South Africa (Le Roux, Reference Le Roux1954b ; Pitchford, Reference Pitchford1959, Reference Pitchford1961; Kruger et al. Reference Kruger, Hamilton-Attwell and Schutte1986a , Reference Kruger, Schutte, Visser and Evans b ; Kruger and Hamilton-Attwell, Reference Kruger and Hamilton-Attwell1988), as well as other potential hybridized pairings, predominantly between S. haematobium with S. guineensis in Cameroon (Wright et al. Reference Wright, Southgate, Vanwijk and Moore1974; Southgate et al. Reference Southgate, Vanwijk and Wright1976; Rollinson and Southgate, Reference Rollinson, Southgate, Rollinson and Anderson1985; Ratard et al. Reference Ratard, Kouemeni, Bessala, Ndamkou, Greer, Spilsbury and Cline1990; Ratard and Greer, Reference Ratard and Greer1991; Tchuem Tchuenté et al. Reference Tchuem Tchuenté, Southgate, Njiokou, Njine, Kouemeni and Jourdane1997b ) and Gabon (Burchard and Kern, Reference Burchard and Kern1985; Zwingenberger et al. Reference Zwingenberger, Feldmeier, Bienzle and Steiner1990) (see Table 1). However, the viability of these eggs was rarely, if ever, assessed and these early phenotypic observations have often been considered, or even dismissed, as misleading identifications (Teesdale, Reference Teesdale1976; Kinoti and Mumo, Reference Kinoti and Mumo1988). Likewise, early reports of apparent human infections with pure animal Schistosoma spp., such as S. bovis, S. curassoni or S. mattheei (Raper, Reference Raper1951; Grétillat, Reference Grétillat1962; Albaret et al. Reference Albaret, Picot, Diaw, Bayssadedufour, Vassiliades, Adamson, Luffau and Chabaud1985; Chunge et al. Reference Chunge, Katsivo, Kok, Wamwea and Kinoti1986; Mouchet et al. Reference Mouchet, Develoux and Magasa1988), as were based primarily on egg morphologies, were again subsequently dismissed as misdiagnoses (Capron et al. Reference Capron, Deblock, Biguet, Clay, Adenis and Vernes1965; Vercruysse et al. Reference Vercruysse, Southgate and Rollinson1984; Rollinson et al. Reference Rollinson, Vercruysse, Southgate, Mooreo, Ross, Walker, Knowles, Geerts, Kumar and Brandt1987; Kruger and Evans, Reference Kruger and Evans1990; Brémond et al. Reference Brémond, Sellin, Sellin, Naméoua, Labbo, Theron and Combes1993). The use of biochemical markers confirmed, however, some of the earlier phenotypic observations made on schistosome hybrids, albeit not of any apparent cases of pure animal schistosome species infecting humans, and furthermore revealed new hybridization between different species. The first study on hybrid schistosomes using isoelectric-focusing of enzymes was made by Wright and Ross (Reference Wright and Ross1980), which confirmed hybridization between S. haematobium with S. mattheei in Eastern Transvaal, South Africa. By the 1990s, studies reported hybridization between S. bovis with S. curassoni in cattle, sheep and goats through the identification of gene flow using biochemical markers (Brémond, Reference Brémond1990; Brémond et al. Reference Brémond, Mouchet, Chevallier, Sellin, Vera and Sellin1990; Rollinson et al. Reference Rollinson, Southgate, Vercruysse and Moore1990a ). Likewise, by 1993, Brémond et al. (Reference Brémond, Sellin, Sellin, Naméoua, Labbo, Theron and Combes1993) used both morphological and biochemical markers to assess, for the first time, natural introgression of S. haematobium by genes from S. bovis in Niger.

Table 1.

Reports of potential natural hybridizations

The increasing use of molecular techniques available for parasitological research resulted in a growing number of reports on hybridization and introgression in schistosomes. Furthermore, these are providing new insights for understanding the evolution and epidemiology of the disease. For instance, new methods have been developed which can discriminate between different schistosomes species and their hybrids, in particular multi-locus approaches, combining both nuclear and mitochondrial DNA markers, as single-locus approaches are not appropriate to detect hybridization or introgression events (Norton et al. Reference Norton, Webster, Kane and Rollinson2008b ; Huyse et al. Reference Huyse, Webster, Geldof, Stothard, Diaw, Polman and Rollinson2009; Webster et al. Reference Webster, Rollinson, Stothard and Huyse2010a ). The internal transcribed spacer (ITS) is a particularly powerful marker to detect introgression. This region can retain both parental copies for several generations before they are homogenized by concerted evolution, the nuclear DNA profiles resulting in double chromatogram peaks at the species-specific mutation sites (Dover Reference Dover1986; Sang et al. Reference Sang, Crawford and Stuessy1995; Aguilar et al. Reference Aguilar, Rossello and Feliner1999; Kane et al. Reference Kane, Bartley, Stothard, Vercruysse, Rollinson and Southgate2002; Huyse et al. Reference Huyse, Webster, Geldof, Stothard, Diaw, Polman and Rollinson2009, Reference Huyse, Van Den Broeck, Hellemans, Volckaert and Polman2013; Webster et al. Reference Webster, Diaw, Seye, Webster and Rollinson2013b ; Moné et al. Reference Moné, Holtfreter, Allienne, Mintsa-NguéMa, Ibikounlé, Boissier, Berry, Mitta, Richter and Mouahid2015). The ITS marker has therefore repeatedly been used to detect hybridization events across the Schistosoma genera. Webster et al. (Reference Webster, Tchuem Tchuenté and Southgate2007) used a single-strand conformation polymorphism analysis of the second internal transcribed spacer (ITS2) of nuclear ribosomal DNA for the identification of S. haematobium, S. guineensis and their hybrids in Loum, Cameroon. This analysis revealed that some individuals previously considered to be S. haematobium, based on egg morphology and sequence data alone, were actually hybrids and this would not have been detected without employing such high-resolution analysis. Recent studies in Senegal, using sequence data of nuclear (ITS1+2) and mitochondrial (cox1) loci, reported the bidirectional hybridization between S. haematobium with S. bovis and S. haematobium with S. curassoni in school children and also in both Bulinus snails and between S. bovis with S. curassoni in cattle (Huyse et al. Reference Huyse, Webster, Geldof, Stothard, Diaw, Polman and Rollinson2009; Webster et al. Reference Webster, Diaw, Seye, Webster and Rollinson2013b ). Molecular analyses on cercariae from infected snails in Kenya and Tanzania have also observed hybrids between the human schistosome S. mansoni and its sister species, S. rodhaini, from rodents (Morgan et al. Reference Morgan, Dejong, Lwambo, Mungai, Mkoji and Loker2003; Steinauer et al. Reference Steinauer, Hanelt, Mwangi, Maina, Agola, Kinuthia, Mutuku, Mungai, Wilson, Mkoji and Loker2008). Furthermore, these authors, using microsatellite markers, demonstrated that the hybrids produce viable offspring through first or successive generation backcrosses with S. mansoni (Steinauer et al. Reference Steinauer, Hanelt, Mwangi, Maina, Agola, Kinuthia, Mutuku, Mungai, Wilson, Mkoji and Loker2008). More recently, studies combining epidemiological molecular and nuclear data have also revealed potential rare introgressions between the two major human schistosome species in Africa, S. haematobium with S. mansoni (Meurs et al. Reference Meurs, Mbow, Vereecken, Menten, Mboup and Polman2012; Huyse et al. Reference Huyse, Van Den Broeck, Hellemans, Volckaert and Polman2013), a phylogenetically distant pairing previously believed to result in unviable eggs exclusively through parthenogenesis (Khalil and Mansour, Reference Khalil and Mansour1995; Webster et al. Reference Webster, Southgate and Tchuem Tchuenté1999; Cunin et al. Reference Cunin, Tchuem Tchuenté, Poste, Djibrilla and Martin2003; Koukounari et al. Reference Koukounari, Donnelly, Sacko, Keita, Landoure, Dembele, Bosque-Oliva, Gabrielli, Gouvras, Traore, Fenwick and Webster2010). The use of molecular tools also allows identification of the direction of introgression. For example, Steinauer et al. (Reference Steinauer, Hanelt, Mwangi, Maina, Agola, Kinuthia, Mutuku, Mungai, Wilson, Mkoji and Loker2008) observed unidirectional gene flow from the rodent schistosome S. rodhaini to the human S. mansoni, whereas there appears to be bidirectional hybridization between the S. haematobium with S. bovis or S. curassoni hybrids described above.

There is, to date, no evidences of hybrids in Asia where S. japonicum and S. mekongi overlap, although experimental crossing of these two species has been achieved (Kruatrachue et al. Reference Kruatrachue, Upatham, Sahaphong, Tongthong and Khunborivan1987). Reports of potential schistosome hybrids are distributed across much of Africa, but it appears with predominance within West Africa (Table 1). This is a region both with multiple species of schistosomes, of humans and animals, naturally circulating, and of profound poverty.

Thus, through the use of either molecular or biochemical tools or phenotypic analyses, various combinations of Schistosoma spp. hybrids have been documented repeatedly within snails, livestock, wildlife and within humans. Moreover, these heterospecific crosses are between animal schistosome species (e.g. S. bovis with S. curassoni); human schistosome species (e.g. S. guineensis with S. haematobium); and perhaps most importantly and interestingly epidemiologically and clinically, between human schistosome species with animal schistosome species (e.g. S. mansoni with S. rodhaini or S. haematobium with S. bovis or S. curassoni or S. mattheei). However, to date, zoonotic hybrids between S. haematobium with S. bovis or S. curassoni have been reported in humans and snails but never from livestock, although past attempts at research therein have been rare and sporadic and bladder and urine from livestock have never been inspected (e.g. Vercruysse et al. Reference Vercruysse, Southgate and Rollinson1984; Webster et al. Reference Webster, Diaw, Seye, Faye, Stothard, Sousa-Figueiredo and Rollinson2013b ). This is particularly important as S. haematobium males have been shown to be dominant over other species such as S. mansoni, S. mattheei or S. guineensis, and to take females to the urogenital tract (Southgate et al. Reference Southgate, Vanwijk and Wright1976, Reference Southgate, Rollinson, Ross and Knowles1982, Reference Southgate, Tchuem Tchuenté, Vercruysse and Jourdane1995; Webster et al. Reference Webster, Southgate and Tchuem Tchuenté1999; Cunin et al. Reference Cunin, Tchuem Tchuenté, Poste, Djibrilla and Martin2003; Cosgrove and Southgate, Reference Cosgrove and Southgate2003a ; Webster and Southgate, Reference Webster and Southgate2003b ; Koukounari et al. Reference Koukounari, Donnelly, Sacko, Keita, Landoure, Dembele, Bosque-Oliva, Gabrielli, Gouvras, Traore, Fenwick and Webster2010; Gouvras et al. Reference Gouvras, Kariuki, Koukounari, Norton, Lange, Ireri, Fenwick, Mkoji and Webster2013).

Concurrent with research under field conditions, hybridization experiments in the laboratory began in the 1940s. Some were conducted between schistosome species that are unlikely to hybridize in the wild, because they have not shared the same geographical range [e.g. S. mansoni with S. japonicum (Vogel, Reference Vogel1941, Reference Vogel1942; Imbert-Establet et al. Reference Imbert-Establet, Xia and Jourdane1994; Fan and Lin, Reference Fan and Lin2005)]. These distant pairings were reported to result in the production of non-viable or apparently parthenogenetic eggs. Likewise, the experimental crosses conducted between the two phylogenetically distant species S. mansoni and S. haematobium, S. guineensis or S. mattheei also resulted in non-viable or parthenogenetic eggs (Taylor et al. Reference Taylor, Amin and Mbnelson1969; Tchuem Tchuenté et al. Reference Tchuem Tchuenté, Imbertestablet, Southgate and Jourdane1994; Khalil and Mansour, Reference Khalil and Mansour1995; Webster et al. Reference Webster, Southgate and Tchuem Tchuenté1999). Several experimental studies in laboratory have, however, confirmed that certain closely related schistosome species can successfully hybridize for several generations. Most of experimental research on interspecies crosses has been conducted within the S. haematobium group species (see the list of all crossings in Table 2). In the S. mansoni group, successful experimental crossings have been repeatedly performed only between S. mansoni with S. rodhaini (Le Roux, Reference Le Roux1954a ; Taylor, Reference Taylor1970; Brémond et al. Reference Brémond, Théron and Rollinson1989; Théron, Reference Théron1989; Norton et al. Reference Norton, Webster, Kane and Rollinson2008b ). It appears that the successfully hybridization, or not, of these pairings will vary in part with the geographical origin as well as the strain of the parasite. For example, Taylor (Reference Taylor1970) observed that the cross between a S. haematobium from Nigeria and S. bovis from Iran was viable, while the cross between S. haematobium and S. bovis both from Iran was of very low viability. Also, Wright and Ross (Reference Wright and Ross1980) showed that F1 hybrids issued from the cross between S. haematobium from Durban and female S. mattheei from Transvaal presented heterosis (i.e. hybrid vigour), whereas the same crossing with S. mattheei from Zambia with S. haematobium from the Ivory Coast did not (Tchuem Tchuenté et al. Reference Tchuem Tchuenté, Southgate, Jourdane, Kaukas and Vercruysse1997a ). More importantly, even viable crosses of the same species are not always reciprocal. For example, crossing only produces viable and fertile hybrid descendants between male S. haematobium and female S. guineensis or female S. mattheei (Wright et al. Reference Wright, Southgate, Vanwijk and Moore1974; Wright and Ross, Reference Wright and Ross1980; Tchuem Tchuenté et al. Reference Tchuem Tchuenté, Southgate, Jourdane, Kaukas and Vercruysse1997a ; Southgate et al. Reference Southgate, Jourdane and Tchuem Tchuenté1998). However, crossings between S. haematobium and S. bovis or S. curassoni appear bidirectional and involve both male and female of each species (Huyse et al. Reference Huyse, Webster, Geldof, Stothard, Diaw, Polman and Rollinson2009; Webster et al. Reference Webster, Diaw, Seye, Webster and Rollinson2013b ). One hypothesis could be that laboratory studies will mainly be on F₁ crosses, whereas molecular analyses on parasites from natural population in the field will detect repeated backcrossing and hence more evidences of bidirectional introgression.

Table 2.

Reports of experimental hybridizations

Unless stated, offspring viability has not been determined after the generation indicated.

Further experimental infections and crossings are required to study the mating behaviour of different schistosome species and to study the biological characteristics of the hybrid lines such as fecundity, infectivity, longevity, cercariae production and response to praziquantel, the drug routinely used to control human schistosomiasis, and, in some parts of the world, in Asia for example, animal schistosomiasis too. However, we must keep in mind that the laboratory system might bias studies on hybridization due to selection and genetic bottleneck events because of less compatible rodent or snail hosts in experimental infections. Most of the crossings performed to date have been obtained in rodents and we do not know yet how hybrids would develop in other mammalian hosts, in particular domestic livestock other than sheep, which may be predicted to be potentially more relevant to ongoing natural transmission cycles.

There also remains a great deal to elucidate concerning the genetics and genomics of hybridization and introgression across the Schistosoma genus and in parasites in general, such as, for example, how hybridization may affect spread and pathogenicity. Genetic introgression could occur in areas of the genome affecting the evolution of virulence, transmission and host specificity, among others characteristics. Modern molecular techniques can expose the signature of hybridization in the genome more rapidly and accurately and the recent whole genome sequencing of the three main human schistosome species S. japonicum, S. mansoni and S. haematobium (Berriman et al. Reference Berriman, Haas, Loverde, Wilson, Dillon, Cerqueira, Mashiyama, Al-Lazikani, Andrade, Ashton, Aslett, Bartholomeu, Blandin, Caffrey, Coghlan, Coulson, Day, Delcher, Demarco, Djikeng, Eyre, Gamble, Ghedin, Gu, Hertz-Fowler, Hirai, Hirai, Houston, Ivens, Johnston, Lacerda, Macedo, Mcveigh, Ning, Oliveira, Overington, Parkhill, Pertea, Pierce, Protasio, Quail, Rajandream, Rogers, Sajid, Salzberg, Stanke, Tivey, White, Williams, Wortman, Wu, Zamanian, Zerlotini, Fraser-Liggett, Barrell and El-Sayed2009; Schistosoma japonicum Genome Sequencing and Functional Analysis Consortium 2009; Young et al. Reference Young, Jex, Li, Liu, Yang, Xiong, Li, Cantacessi, Hall, Xu, Chen, Wu, Zerlotini, Oliveira, Hofmann, Zhang, Fang, Kang, Campbell, Loukas, Ranganathan, Rollinson, Rinaldi, Brindley, Yang, Wang, Wang and Gasser2012) will undoubtedly provide new insights into the study of schistosomes’ hybridization and Neglected Tropical Diseases research in general (Webster et al. Reference Webster, Oliviera, Rollinson and Gower2010b ).

EFFECT OF HYBRIDIZATION ON CERCARIAL EMERGENCE FROM SNAIL INTERMEDIATE HOST

Cercarial emergence is a heritable trait shaped by the definitive hosts’ behaviour and this can vary within species, as Lu et al. (Reference Lu, Wang, Rudge, Donnelly, Fang and Webster2009) observed within S. japonicum with two different emergence peaks, one in late afternoon emergence compatible with a nocturnal rodent reservoir, and one early emergence consistent with a diurnal cattle reservoir. Norton et al. (Reference Norton, Rollinson, Richards and Webster2008a ) also showed that co-infection and therefore competition between S. mansoni and S. rodhaini was influencing cercarial chronobiology resulting in a slight shift in the S. mansoni shedding pattern and a reduction of the S. rodhaini shedding period. In hybrids with different definitive host species, one could predict different chronobiology of cercariae shedding emergence depending on their relative parental species. Evidence in support of this has been provided by Théron (Reference Théron1989) with hybrids between S. mansoni with S. rodhaini showing two unequal emergence peaks, one diurnal (characteristic of S. mansoni for human infection) and the other nocturnal (characteristic of S. rodhaini for rodents’ infection). Depending on the chronobiological strain of S. mansoni used in the cross-breeding it was either the diurnal peak (when the early strain of S. mansoni was used), or the nocturnal peak (when the late strain of S. mansoni was used), that is preponderant. This could also explain some patterns of excretion observed by Norton et al. (Reference Norton, Rollinson, Richards and Webster2008a ) as some of the S. rodhaini and S. mansoni are likely to have hybridized. Finally, experimental crosses conducted between S. haematobium, S. guineensis and S. bovis, revealed a cercarial emission pattern amongst F₁ hybrids with only one emergence peak, but with a mean shedding time always in advance (from 1 to 5 h depending on the crossing) of those of the respective parental species, except for S. bovis from which no difference was observed (Pages and Theron, Reference Pages and Theron1990). The authors explained this modification by a greater sensibility of the hybrids to synchronization with photoperiod. Also, as cercariae can survive in the environment for several hours, one could proposed that an earlier shedding time would allow them to infect all the potential definitive host of their parental species, and hence give them a selective transmission advantage relative to their later shedding counterparts. These studies to date were, however, all performed using experimental laboratory infections and crossings. The only monitoring of hybrids cercarial emergence from natural infections to date was performed by Steinauer et al. (Reference Steinauer, Hanelt, Mwangi, Maina, Agola, Kinuthia, Mutuku, Mungai, Wilson, Mkoji and Loker2008) on S. mansoni with S. rodhaini hybrids collected from B. sudanica and B. pfeifferi in Western Kenya. Species were subsequentally identified using microsatellites, rDNA and mtDNA markers. They observed that most of the hybrids showed an emergence pattern similar to that of S. mansoni, except for one individual, that presented a bimodal emergence pattern that was characteristic of both parental species.

FACTORS POTENTIALLY FAVOURING HYBRID EVOLUTION AND ESTABLISHMENT

Environmental and/or anthropogenic changes, through natural phenomena (e.g. climate change) or human activities, such as dam constructions, changes in agricultural practices or drug treatments, can substantially impact the dynamics and distribution of schistosomiasis and infectious diseases in general, with potential positive and negative effects upon human and animal health (King et al. Reference King, Stelkens, Webster, Smith and Brockhurst2015). These environmental and anthropogenic changes place selective pressures on human and animal schistosomes and increase the opportunities for mixing of different species. This mixing within the human or animal hosts may be predicted to further influence the potential for novel zoonotic hybrid parasites, which may impact their potential for disease transmission and morbidity (Fig. 2). For example, it has been suggested that local deforestation may have altered the environment in Loum area (Cameroon) and allowed Bulinus truncatus (previously named B. rohfsi), the intermediate host for S. haematobium, to become established, and, the increase of human exchanges through the introductions of the railways created areas of sympatry between S. guineensis and S. haematobium, leading to the formation of hybrids (Southgate et al. Reference Southgate, Vanwijk and Wright1976; Southgate, Reference Southgate1978).

Fig. 2.

Schematic of causes and consequences of schistosome hybridization. The circumstances producing increased opportunity for hybridization are intensification of drug administration, agricultural practices and land use and modifications of environment due to human activities. This will then modify the ecology of both schistosomes’ intermediate and definitive host but also biology of the parasites. We outline what we think would be the most important and/or potentially dangerous effects of hybridization: an increase in transmission potential and morbidity and an altered response to drug therapy.

In the north of Senegal, the rehabilitation of the Lac de Guiers area (Mbaye, Reference Mbaye2013) provided new accesses to freshwater. These new contact areas are used both by people and livestock and are important sites where mixing of animals and humans schistosome species can happen. Likewise in Senegal, the construction of Diama dam on the Senegal river, for the creation of irrigation canals and development and extension of rice culture in the Senegal River basin, resulted in a reduction in salinity and more stable water flow, with a subsequent occurrence of new outbreaks of schistosomiasis, as well as other trematodiases, in humans and livestock in this region (Vercruysse et al. Reference Vercruysse, Southgate, Rollinson, Declercq, Sacko, Debont and Mungomba1994; Diaw et al. Reference Diaw, Vassiliades, Thiongane, Seye, Sarr and Diouf1998). N'Goran et al. (Reference N'goran, Diabate, Utzinger and Sellin1997) also observed a strong increase in human urogenital schistosomiasis prevalence around the Kossou and Taabo Lakes in Côte d'Ivoire between 1970 and 1992 after the construction of the two Dams of Kossou and Taabo.

The recent deliberate crossing/hybridization of local cattle breeds with European cattle, in an effort to increase milk and meat yield (Nicolas Diouf, personal communications), in Senegal may also be predicted to have consequences on the spreading of zoonotic hybrid schistosomes These new hybrid cattle may be predicted to have different susceptibilities for schistosome establishments and infection. The introduction of exotic cattle has already proved to accelerate the spread of several parasitic organisms. For example, the southern cattle tick Rhipicephalus (Boophilus) microplus, initially a parasite of Asian bovid species, has spread over the tropical and subtropical belts to become a major invasive pest in many agrosystems (Barré and Uilenberg, Reference Barré and Uilenberg2010). Its current geographic distribution and its dramatic expansion over the last century can primarily be explained by the introduction of highly susceptible European cattle (Bos taurus) breeds to tropical areas (Chevillon et al. Reference Chevillon, De Garine-Wichatitsky, Barre, Ducornez and De Meeus2013; Léger et al. Reference Léger, Vourc'h, Vial, Chevillon and Mccoy2013). In contrast to both wild and domestic tropical Bovidae, these introduced hosts of European origin are almost incapable of mounting efficient immune responses to R. microplus infestations (Frisch, Reference Frisch1999).

Temperature, among other factors, can also have a significant effect on the schistosome life cycle and the survival of its intermediate snail host (Mas-Coma et al. Reference Mas-Coma, Adela Valero and Dolores Bargues2009). Climate change (e.g. desertification) taking place in West Africa has also been argued to be responsible for important changes in the movement of domestic livestock, where animals may have to move long distance for food and water and may be in contact with multiple potential transmission sites. Indeed such livestock movement changes have been proposed to have brought S. bovis and S. curassoni into contact and may have led to hybridization between them (Rollinson et al. Reference Rollinson, Southgate, Vercruysse and Moore1990a ). In addition to human and animal movements, the current climate of global warming may also offer the potential to novel zoonotic hybrids to be a global disease. Many schistosome species infecting livestock could have a broader geographical range beyond Asia and Africa if compatible snail intermediate hosts are present. This appears now the case in parts of Europe, where novel introgressed hybrids between human S. haematobium with the livestock S. bovis have recently been identified in Corsica (France), and sporadically in Spain and Portugal, with substantial ongoing transmission amongst both local Corsican residents and tourists (De Laval et al. Reference De Laval, Savini, Biance-Valero and Simon2014; Boissier et al. Reference Boissier, Moné, Mitta, Dolores Bargues, Molyneux and Mas-Coma2015; Moné et al. Reference Moné, Holtfreter, Allienne, Mintsa-NguéMa, Ibikounlé, Boissier, Berry, Mitta, Richter and Mouahid2015; Berry et al. Reference Berry, Fillaux, Martin-Blondel, Boissier, Iriart, Marchou, Magnaval and Delobel2016; Webster et al. Reference Webster, Gower, Knowles, Molyneux and Fenton2016).

IMPLICATIONS FOR CONTROL

The recurrent hybridization between schistosome species in nature may have major implications in light of the current global push and shift from controlling morbidity to interrupting transmission (Webster et al. Reference Webster, Molyneux, Hotez and Fenwick2014). How such introgression may alter host range and transmission dynamic is perhaps the most pressing area for future research (King et al. Reference King, Stelkens, Webster, Smith and Brockhurst2015) (Fig. 2).

Since the first observations of hybridization of animal and human schistosomes, the main concern has been the possible complication of control measures occasioned by the existence of an animal reservoir infection (Wright and Southgate, Reference Wright, Southgate, Taylor and Muller1976; Wright and Ross, Reference Wright and Ross1980). Indeed, schistosomiasis control has focused almost exclusively on treatment of humans with mass drug administration using praziquantel. However, the extent to which hybridization may increase the role of wild mammals and livestock as reservoir hosts for infection, due to hybrid vigour for example, is poorly understood, although it is widely accepted that zoonotic diseases may be harder to eliminate due to the presence of animal reservoirs driving ongoing transmission (Webster et al. Reference Webster, Gower, Knowles, Molyneux and Fenton2016). It has been shown that S. haematobium alone is incapable of developing in sheep (Vercruysse et al. Reference Vercruysse, Southgate and Rollinson1984), but S. haematobium with S. mattheei hybrids have that ability (Tchuem Tchuenté et al. Reference Tchuem Tchuenté, Southgate, Jourdane, Kaukas and Vercruysse1997a ). Similarly, Taylor et al. (Reference Taylor, Nelson, Smith and Andrews1973) and Vercruysse et al. (Reference Vercruysse, Southgate and Rollinson1984) showed experimentally that S. bovis or S. curassoni cannot infect baboons as a single species, but they can when hybridized with S. haematobium. Hybrids between S. mansoni with S. rodhaini in Kenya may also be predicted to prove problematic, particularly in the elimination era. Rodents are reservoirs for several schistosome single species (S. mansoni, S. bovis, S. rodhaini, S. kisumuensis. S. mansoni and S. rodhaini), and co-infections in a single host individual has been observed, suggesting that this host species could be responsible for the production of hybrid schistosomes found in the area (Hanelt et al. Reference Hanelt, Mwangi, Kinuthia, Maina, Agola, Mutuku, Steinauer, Agwanda, Kigo, Mungai, Loker and Mkoji2010). In a worst-case scenario, one could predict that this could lead to a comparable situation as observed in China today, where after over 50 years of concerted and multi-faceted interventions (including chemotherapy, snail control, health education, sanitation and environmental improvement), S. japonicum remains endemic among humans and transmission has even re-emerged in some areas where schistosomiasis was thought to have been eliminated. It has been demonstrated, by combining field data with novel mathematical modelling, that spillover from animal zoonotic transmission is maintaining such human schistosomiasis in China (Lu et al. Reference Lu, Wang, Rudge, Donnelly, Fang and Webster2009, Reference Lu, Rudge, Wang, Donnelly, Fang and Webster2010a , Reference Lu, Wang, Rudge, Donnelly, Fang and Webster b , Reference Lu, Wang, Rudge, Donnelly, Fang and Webster2011; Rudge et al. Reference Rudge, Lu, Fang, Wang, Basanez and Webster2009, Reference Rudge, Webster, Lu, Wang, Fang and Basanez2013).

There are also other potential serious implications of wide-scale hybridization events in nature. For instance, introgressive hybridization may lead to phenotypic changes that can dramatically influence disease dynamics and evolution of the parasites. Hybridization between different Schistosoma species have already been suggested to affect the success of drug treatment; Pitchford and Lewis (Reference Pitchford and Lewis1978) have suggested that the poor response of S. mattheei to oxamniquine treatment in children, in a trial they conducted in Eastern Transvaal, may be due to hybridization with S. haematobium, which is not susceptible to the drug. Although the efficacy of praziquantel, which is currently the only anti-schistosome drug in wide-scale use, is not well documented in terms of livestock, as distinct from human, Schistososoma species, changes in mass drug administration (MDA) pressures could be predicted to play an important role in the evolution of hybrid schistosomes. Drug resistance or decreased sensitivity of S. mansoni to praziquantel has been documented under both field and laboratory conditions (Cioli et al. Reference Cioli, Pica-Mattoccia and Archer1993; Fallon and Doenhoff, Reference Fallon and Doenhoff1994; Bonesso-Sabadini and de Souza Dias, Reference Bonesso-Sabadini and De Souza Dias2002; Botros et al. Reference Botros, Sayed, Amer, El-Ghannam, Bennett and Day2005; Alonso et al. Reference Alonso, Munoz, Gascon, Valls and Corachan2006; Melman et al. Reference Melman, Steinauer, Cunningham, Kubatko, Mwangi, Wynn, Mutuku, Karanja, Colley, Black, Secor, Mkoji and Loker2009; Pica-Mattoccia et al. Reference Pica-Mattoccia, Doenhoff, Valle, Basso, Troiani, Liberti, Festucci, Guidi and Cioli2009; Lamberton et al. Reference Lamberton, Hogan, Kabatereine, Fenwick and Webster2010; Valentim et al. Reference Valentim, Cioli, Chevalier, Cao, Taylor, Holloway, Pica-Mattoccia, Guidi, Basso, Tsai, Berriman, Carvalho-Queiroz, Almeida, Aguilar, Frantz, Hart, Loverde and Anderson2013; Webster et al. Reference Webster, Diaw, Seye, Faye, Stothard, Sousa-Figueiredo and Rollinson2013a ). To which extent hybrid schistosomes may differ in terms of praziquantel efficacy, and how MDA could differentially select for hybrids, is not known but should be considered in the control of schistosomiasis (Fenwick and Webster, Reference Fenwick and Webster2006; Webster et al. Reference Webster, Gower and Norton2008, Reference Webster, Molyneux, Hotez and Fenwick2014). Hybridization and the occurrence of large animal reservoirs may, however, also have a positive role in the context of reducing the risk of drug resistance emergence or establishment by increasing the proportion of untreated worms, and hence Refugia, through the untreated animal host populations. Human infection could also be reduced as selection imposed by drug treatment in humans may be predicted to lead to a shift in host preference, favouring strains that prefer nonhuman hosts. Conversely, if livestock, particularly in Africa, were to also be intensively treated with praziquantel in the future, then the risk of drug resistance emerging would be exacerbated. This could be due both to the relative loss of Refugia, but also the increased risk of resistance developing in the veterinary field through treatment mismanagement, as has been the case with all the current veterinary anthelmintics to date, and its subsequent impact for human treatment, particularly critical for zoonotic hybrids (Webster et al. Reference Webster, Gower, Knowles, Molyneux and Fenton2016).

Hybrid infections may also be predicted to result in a differential morbidity profile in both humans and livestock, relative to their single-species infection counterparts. Schistosomiasis morbidity is caused primarily by parasite eggs being trapped within the host tissues. Previous studies have reported higher bladder morbidity in mixed S. haematobium–S. mansoni mixed infections compared with single S. haematobium infections. They suggested that S. haematobium males were mating with S. mansoni females and deviating the eggs to the urinogenital tract, thereby reducing the amount of egg granulomas in liver tissues whilst increasing the egg output at the vesicle venous plexus and therefore aggravating urogenital schistosomiasis in co-infected individuals (Koukounari et al. Reference Koukounari, Donnelly, Sacko, Keita, Landoure, Dembele, Bosque-Oliva, Gabrielli, Gouvras, Traore, Fenwick and Webster2010; Gouvras et al. Reference Gouvras, Kariuki, Koukounari, Norton, Lange, Ireri, Fenwick, Mkoji and Webster2013). To date there has been no such morbidity surveys performed related to introgressed schistosomes within the S. haematobium group. Any Such differential morbidity in hybrid infections may have major implications for current methods of monitoring and evaluation of human morbidity levels and control programme efficacy.

Hybrid vigour is also a potential issue for successful disease control. As it has already been observed for hybrids between Leishmania major and Leishmania infantum, with hybrids having enhanced transmission potential and fitness (Volf et al. Reference Volf, Benkova, Myskova, Sadlova, Campino and Ravel2007), schistosome hybrids may exhibit heterosis. Laboratory experiments have shown that F₁ and F₂ hybrids between S. haematobium and S. guineensis exhibited greater infectivity for snail intermediate hosts and for hamsters, as well as an increased longevity, growth rate and reproductive potential (i.e. females produced more eggs and larger numbers of eggs were passed in hamster feces relative to single-species infections) (Southgate et al. Reference Southgate, Vanwijk and Wright1976; Wright and Southgate, Reference Wright, Southgate, Taylor and Muller1976; Webster and Southgate, Reference Webster and Southgate2003a ). Similar results were observed by Wright and Ross (Reference Wright and Ross1980) and Taylor (Reference Taylor1970) on F₁ hybrids between S. haematobium males with S. mattheei females showing increased infectivity for snails and hamsters infected experimentally. Work has also been done on hybrid vigour in term of extended intermediate host range. Due to the potential inheritance of a snail infectivity factor by hybrid schistosomes, Schistosoma hybrids might be predicted to be able to break down the host specificity barrier and develop in both the intermediate snail hosts of the parental species, as it has already been observed. For example, Huyse et al. (Reference Huyse, Van Den Broeck, Hellemans, Volckaert and Polman2013) identified S. haematobium with S. bovis hybrids within both B. globosus and B. truncatus which are the intermediate snail hosts of S. haematobium and S. bovis respectively. In other experimental studies, hybrids of S. haematobium and S. guineensis were found to be able to infect both B. forskalii and B. truncatus (Southgate et al. Reference Southgate, Vanwijk and Wright1976; Wright and Southgate, Reference Wright, Southgate, Taylor and Muller1976; Wright and Ross, Reference Wright and Ross1980; Webster and Southgate, Reference Webster and Southgate2003a ), but also B. globosus and B. wrighti (Mutani et al. Reference Mutani, Christensen and Frandsen1985). And finally, hybrids of S. haematobium and S. mattheei have been shown to be able to develop in both B. globosus and B. forskalii (Wright, Reference Wright1974).

The excretory route of certain Schistosoma hybrids may also have substantial implications for their control. Hybrids between S. haematobium and S. guineensis are, for instance, predominantly passed with the host urine and not the feces, akin to pure S. haematobium. In humans, prevention of environmental contamination from urine might be harder to achieve relative to that from stool, and least in terms of human behavioural practices, and this could be of some importance in term of transmission where some level of local sanitation has been achieved (Southgate et al. Reference Southgate, Vanwijk and Wright1976).

Finally, in Cameroon it has been suggested that hybridization between S. haematobium and S. guineensis has caused disease outbreaks and that, rapidly after the establishment of S. haematobium, S. guineensis had been replaced by the hybrid and S. haematobium; S. haematobium and the hybrids offspring being more competitive than S. guineensis (Wright et al. Reference Wright, Southgate, Vanwijk and Moore1974; Southgate et al. Reference Southgate, Vanwijk and Wright1976, Reference Southgate, Rollinson, Ross and Knowles1982; Southgate, Reference Southgate1978; Tchuem Tchuenté et al. Reference Tchuem Tchuenté, Southgate, Njiokou, Njine, Kouemeni and Jourdane1997b ; Morand et al. Reference Morand, Southgate and Jourdane2002; Cosgrove and Southgate, Reference Cosgrove and Southgate2003a ; Webster and Southgate, Reference Webster and Southgate2003b ). Other studies have also observed competitive exclusion of one species by the other, S. mansoni males being more competitive than S. intercalatum and S. guineensis males at pairing with their respective females (Tchuem Tchuenté et al. Reference Tchuem Tchuenté, Imbertestablet, Delay and Jourdane1993, Reference Tchuem Tchuenté, Southgate, Imbertestablet and Jourdane1995, Reference Tchuem Tchuenté, Morand, Imbert-Establet, Delay and Jourdane1996; Cosgrove and Southgate, Reference Cosgrove and Southgate2003b ), S. haematobium being more competitive than S. mansoni males (Webster et al. Reference Webster, Southgate and Tchuem Tchuenté1999; Cunin et al. Reference Cunin, Tchuem Tchuenté, Poste, Djibrilla and Martin2003; Koukounari et al. Reference Koukounari, Donnelly, Sacko, Keita, Landoure, Dembele, Bosque-Oliva, Gabrielli, Gouvras, Traore, Fenwick and Webster2010; Gouvras et al. Reference Gouvras, Kariuki, Koukounari, Norton, Lange, Ireri, Fenwick, Mkoji and Webster2013) or than S. mattheei males (Southgate et al. Reference Southgate, Tchuem Tchuenté, Vercruysse and Jourdane1995), and S. rodhaini males over S. mansoni counterparts (Norton et al. Reference Norton, Webster, Kane and Rollinson2008b ). Hybrids may therefore be predicted to outcompete current single species as these inter-specific interactions would affect parasite establishment, growth, maturation, reproductive success and drug sensitivity (Norton et al. Reference Norton, Webster, Kane and Rollinson2008b ; Webster et al. Reference Webster, Gower and Norton2008).

CONCLUSIONS AND PERSPECTIVES

There is a gathering and convincing body of evidence for the natural hybridization between human and animal schistosome species. These raise a number of critical questions regarding evolution, epidemiology, health impact and ultimate control of schistosomiasis. The implications of hybrids in terms of human health remains unclear, but the emergence and spread of hybrid schistosomes, and in particular zoonotic hybrids, could prove problematic in terms of maintaining transmission in our current era of control/elimination, particularly if they can replace existing species and parasite strains, extend intermediate and definitive host ranges or present an increased infectivity and virulence. In term of future work, it is necessary to accurately identify these species. In particular, are the evolution and expansion of these hybrids a recent phenomenon, in response to new anthropogenic changes and pressures, or are they simply better detected now due to improvements in molecular diagnostics? This will allow us to understand the populations at risk and the transmission dynamics of infection with novel zoonotic hybrid schistosomes and will help to elucidate their role on host range, praziquantel efficacy, host morbidity and hence ultimately transmission potential, with a view to informing control programmes. This is especially important in today's era of ‘elimination of schistosomiasis as a public health problem’ implemented in the WHO roadmap (WHO, Reference World Health Organization2012) whereas schistosome zoonotic hybrids have the potential to become a global disease (De Laval et al. Reference De Laval, Savini, Biance-Valero and Simon2014; Boissier et al. Reference Boissier, Moné, Mitta, Dolores Bargues, Molyneux and Mas-Coma2015; Moné et al. Reference Moné, Holtfreter, Allienne, Mintsa-NguéMa, Ibikounlé, Boissier, Berry, Mitta, Richter and Mouahid2015; Berry et al. Reference Berry, Fillaux, Martin-Blondel, Boissier, Iriart, Marchou, Magnaval and Delobel2016). More generally, these research these questions could enhance our understanding of a wide spectrum of multi-host parasitic diseases of humans and animals, and in particular the role of hybridizations within major taxonomic groups in our rapidly changing world.