Introduction
Peltigera Willd. section Peltigera (Fig. 1A & B) includes a high number of undescribed species delimited by Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018). Among the large clades recognized within section Peltigera, the P. ponojensis/monticola clade (Clade 5 in Fig. 1B) has been the most challenging taxonomically. Morphological characters that distinguish putative species are often indistinct, and there is a high level of intraspecific morphological variability. Phylogenetic boundaries between species are in many cases ambiguous, and sampling of specimens is frequently scattered across broad geographic ranges (Magain et al. Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018).
Phylogenetic placement of Peltigera globulata sp. nov. within the genus Peltigera (A), section Peltigera (B), and P. ponojensis/monticola clade (C). For all trees, bootstrap support values (BS) > 50% are shown for each internode when space permits. Thickened branches represent bootstrap support (BS) values ≥ 70%, except for thick branches without support values in A and B, which indicate BS = 100%. Scales represent nucleotide substitutions per site. A, phylogeny of the genus Peltigera adapted from fig. 2 of Chagnon et al. (Reference Chagnon, Magain, Miadlikowska and Lutzoni2019) depicting the relationships among the eight recognized sections of Peltigera established by Miadlikowska & Lutzoni (Reference Miadlikowska and Lutzoni2000) based on maximum likelihood (ML) analysis of seven loci (ITS, nrLSU, β-tubulin, RPB1, COR1b, COR3, COR16). Each section is represented by a single terminal branch. B, phylogeny of sections Retifoveatae and Peltigera adapted from fig. 1 of Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018) depicting relationships within these sections based on ML analysis of five loci (ITS, β-tubulin, COR1b, COR3, COR16). Clades were collapsed using FigTree v. 1.4.3 (Rambaut Reference Rambaut2012). Monophyletic groups that include more than two species are labelled ‘clade’ (e.g. P. rufescens clade) and the names of all included species are not listed. The top arrow indicates where the most similar ITS sequences based on BLASTn were found for the type specimen of P. aubertii. The other arrow, pointing to the P. rufescens clade, shows where the sequences with the highest similarity to sequences of the type material of P. soredians and P. antarctica were found based on BLASTn of ITS sequences. C, phylogenetic relationships within the P. ponojensis/monticola clade (Clade 5 of Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018)) as inferred in the present study. The tree was generated with RAxML using a 5-locus dataset (COR16, COR1b, COR3, ITS, β-tubulin; 3970 characters) for 68 taxa including eight representatives of P. globulata. The tree was rooted according to the phylogeny shown on fig. 1 of Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018). The number of loci included in the data matrix for each specimen is shown in parentheses. Asterisks indicate newly added specimens for which sequences were available in GenBank but were not included in the phylogenetic analyses of Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018). Species designation within the P. ponojensis/monticola clade follows fig. 1 of Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018). Peltigera monticola s. str. corresponds to P. ponojensis/monticola 7 of Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018) based on the high similarity (BLASTn) of the ITS sequence of the holotype (Austria) to the ITS sequence of a specimen of P. monticola P0073 (also from Austria) indicated by an arrow. Peltigera ponojensis/monticola 11 corresponds to Peltigera antarctica in Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018). However, based on the ITS sequence of the lectotype material, P. antarctica belongs to the P. rufescens clade (arrow in panel B). Peltigera ponojensis/monticola 10a corresponds to P. ‘scotteri’ 1 in Miadlikowska et al. (Reference Miadlikowska, Lutzoni, Goward, Zoller and Posada2003). The holotype specimen of P. globulata (P2165) is indicated by an arrow. Further information about the sequences used in these analyses can be found in Supplementary Material Table S1 (available online).
The P. ponojensis/monticola clade, which was labelled ‘A – P. ponojensis group’ in fig. 2 of Miadlikowska et al. (Reference Miadlikowska, Lutzoni, Goward, Zoller and Posada2003), was initially represented by two European species that were relatively easy to recognize: P. ponojensis Gyeln. and P. monticola Vitik. (Vitikainen Reference Vitikainen1994a). Peltigera monticola, a southern European species with curled, and often phyllidiate, margins ‘resembles in its habit and size P. rufescens and P. ponojensis, but the tomentum is less pronounced, the thallus is thinner, and the rhizines and veining patterns differ’ according to the original description by Vitikainen (Reference Miadlikowska, Lutzoni, Goward, Zoller and Posada1994a); ‘it has slightly pruinose lobe tips with a very sparse tomentum and becomes etomentose and glabrose or somewhat scabrose towards the center of the thallus’ (Vitikainen Reference Vitikainen1994a). Peltigera ponojensis, most commonly found in boreal and temperate parts of Europe, resembles P. rufescens (Weiss) Humb. but ‘differs in the paler, often persistently whitish color of its veins and rhizines (when young), which tend to be simple and solitary’ (Vitikainen Reference Vitikainen1994a). In the same article, Vitikainen indicated that both species needed further investigation, especially in light of some atypical phenotypes of P. ponojensis found in Iceland.
Nearly ten years later, Miadlikowska et al. (Reference Miadlikowska, Lutzoni, Goward, Zoller and Posada2003) demonstrated that both species are monophyletic on the basis of data from ten individuals collected in Europe (mostly Poland). This study also included the closely affiliated P. ‘scotteri’ 1, a putative, undescribed species from Canada with a P. degenii-like, etomentose morphology. Peltigera ‘scotteri’ 1 was shown to be part of the P. monticola + P. ponojensis clade by Miadlikowska & Lutzoni (Reference Miadlikowska and Lutzoni2000) using the nrLSU + ITS locus combined with morphological characters. Miadlikowska et al. (Reference Miadlikowska, Lutzoni, Goward, Zoller and Posada2003) demonstrated the diagnostic utility of the hypervariable region within ITS1 (ITS1-HR) for species recognition within section Peltigera, including the P. ponojensis group. ITS1-HR sequences showed that P. monticola and P. ponojensis were commonly found outside of Europe (Magain et al. Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018).
With an expanded sampling of 46 specimens mostly from North and South America, and China, Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018) reported that the P. ponojensis group was a large species complex (Clade 5/P. ponojensis/monticola s. lat. in fig. 1 of Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018)) containing 15 putative species recognized and validated by multiple analytical methods. Since most of the lineages were morphologically heterogenous and included morphotypes also identified as P. rufescens or P. degenii Gyeln., no formal taxonomic changes were proposed, and the putative species were left as numbered clades. Peltigera sp. 17 stood out because of its unusual globulate margins somewhat resembling P. soredians Vitik. when seen in the field. Another monophyletic group that included specimens mostly from Chile was identified as Peltigera antarctica C. W. Dodge based on available descriptions and comparisons with identified herbarium collections. One consequence of this expanded sampling was that Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018) could no longer confidently identify P. monticola s. str. and P. ponojensis s. str. based solely on morphology and geography, because typical morphotypes collected in Europe were spread across multiple clades within the P. ponojensis/monticola complex. This also raised questions about the identity of the type specimens for these two species, but DNA sequences from their type material were not available at the time.
In order to resolve some of the taxonomic issues within the P. ponojensis/monticola species complex, we inferred a phylogeny for this clade based on DNA sequences used by Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018) and additional data available in GenBank, for a total of 68 terminal branches (Supplementary Material Table S1, available online). We re-examined the morphology of Peltigera sp. 17 to provide a description and a formal name: P. globulata. To further validate the presence of multiple species within the P. ponojensis/monticola species complex and justify the formal recognition of P. globulata as a species new to science, we reassessed species boundaries by estimating levels of gene flow among putative species within the species complex. In order to more confidently link existing species names to putative species-level clades, we sequenced the ITS locus from type specimens of P. monticola and P. antarctica, two species within the species complex, as well as P. soredians and P. aubertii C. W. Dodge, two other species from section Peltigera but outside of the P. ponojensis/monticola clade.
Materials and Methods
Specimen examination
Specimens of Peltigera globulata were examined using a Leica MZ6 dissecting microscope and a Leica DMLB compound microscope (×400 magnification). Three individuals of P. globulata (P2165 and P2164 from Peru, and P2195 from Ecuador; Supplementary Material Table S1, available online) and two representatives of P. soredians (P2152: Ecuador, Kalb & Jonitz 39785, DUKE; and P14480: Costa Rica, Clerc & Rojas PC 2013/487, G 00111756) were subjected to thin-layer chromatography (LaGreca, TLC plate #199; 1/27/2021; DUKE) as described in Culberson & Kristinsson (Reference Culberson and Kristinsson1970), Culberson (Reference Culberson1972) and Culberson & Johnson (Reference Culberson and Johnson1982). Small thallus fragments were extracted in hexane, spotted on the pre-coated Merck silica gel 60 F254 glass plates and eluted in solvent systems C (TA in Holtan-Hartwig (Reference Holtan-Hartwig1993)) and G (Culberson et al. Reference Culberson, Culberson and Johnson1981). The chromatograms were developed by spraying with 10% sulphuric acid and heating them at 110 °C for 1 h. Plates were examined under white (normal) light and UV light (350 nm).
Phylogenetic analyses
To assemble the data matrix for this study, we started with the 5-locus dataset (COR16, COR1b, COR3, ITS and β-tubulin) for 48 individuals that Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018) used to infer the phylogeny and delimit species in the P. ponojensis/monticola species complex (i.e. Clade 5; fig. 2B in Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018)). We added 20 ITS sequences that were not included in the phylogenetic analyses of Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018) (Supplementary Material Table S1). We adjusted the alignments manually with Mesquite v. 3.51 (Maddison & Maddison Reference Maddison and Maddison2018). The final data matrix consisted of 68 individuals and 3970 characters (available on FigShare: 10.6084/m9.figshare.c.6636131). We divided the dataset into eight subsets (COR16, COR1b, COR3, ITS, β-tubulin 1st, 2nd and 3rd codon positions and introns) to determine the best partition scheme using PartitionFinder2 v. 2.1.1 (Lanfear et al. Reference Lanfear, Frandsen, Wright, Senfeld and Calcott2017). We applied the corrected Akaike information criterion (AICc) and the greedy algorithm (Lanfear et al. Reference Lanfear, Calcott, Ho and Guindon2012). Maximum likelihood (ML) phylogenetic searches were implemented with RAxML v. 8.2.12 (Stamatakis Reference Stamatakis2006; Stamatakis et al. Reference Stamatakis, Hoover and Rougemont2008) using the CIPRES Science Gateway v. 3.3 (Miller et al. Reference Miller, Schwartz, Pickett, He, Klem, Scheuermann, Passarotti, Kaufman and O'Leary2015), with the GTRGAMMA model applied to each of the eight initially specified partitions. Bootstrap support values were obtained from 1000 pseudoreplicates.
Gene flow analyses
We investigated gene flow among populations representing putative species within a well-supported clade (85% bootstrap support; see small box for this specific internode in Fig. 1C) that encompassed eight lineages, including P. globulata, based on the same five loci mentioned above and using an Isolation with Migration (IM) model implemented in IMa3 v. 1.11 (Hey et al. Reference Hey, Chung, Sethuraman, Lachance, Tishkoff, Sousa and Wang2018). Population summary statistics and neutrality tests were performed on full-length sequence alignments using SITES v. 1.1 (Hey & Wakeley Reference Hey and Wakeley1997). The eight predefined populations (Fig. 1C) corresponded to species delimited by Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018). The two specimens of P. ponojensis from Poland were assigned to a single population. Pairwise F ST values > 0.5 supporting the strong genetic differentiation between predefined populations and the results from Tajima's D, Fu and Li's D, and Fu and Li's D* neutrality tests demonstrating that all five loci did not deviate significantly from neutrality and are therefore suitable for coalescent analysis are included in Supplementary Material Table S2 (available online). We first estimated the best rooted population phylogeny by calculating the posterior probability distributions of topologies and hyperprior distributions for population rate parameters under a finite sites model. To ensure proper Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) mixing, we used a burn-in of 1 000 000 iterations prior to sampling and 256 heated chains with geometric heating (-ha0.97 and -hb0.80), according to the IMa3 documentation (Hey Reference Hey2019). Estimates of effective population sizes (Ne), migration rates (2Nem) and population splitting times (t) were based on MCMC simulations of 50 000 sampled genealogies per locus using a fixed population topology. Population parameter estimation on demographic scales was based on a mutation rate of 1 × 10−9 per base per generation (Edwards & Rhodes Reference Edwards and Rhodes2021) and a generation time of 17 years (Richardson et al. Reference Richardson, Anderson and Cameron2013). Final parameter estimation was based on convergence of parameter distributions from at least two runs each with high swapping rates (> 0.9) between successive chains and high effective sample sizes (ESS > 10 000). Visualization of the population phylogeny showing the direction of statistically significant migration events and confidence intervals for effective population sizes and splitting times was generated using the IMfig program (https://github.com/jodyhey/IMa3). All runs were performed on CIPRES using program calls from the IMa3 and IMfig workflow (https://tools.cifr.ncsu.edu/ima3) implemented in the DeCIFR toolkit (https://decifr.cifr.ncsu.edu/).
Sequencing type specimens
We extracted DNA and used PCR and Sanger sequencing to obtain the ITS region from the holotype of P. monticola (Vitikainen Reference Vitikainen1994a) following Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018). A similar attempt on the type of Peltigera ponojensis was unsuccessful. For the holotype of P. soredians, we were unable to amplify the entire ITS region, and instead separately amplified and sequenced the two spacers with primer pairs ITS1F-ITS2 and ITS3-ITS4 (Gardes & Bruns Reference Gardes and Bruns1993; White et al. Reference White, Bruns, Lee, Taylor, Innis, Gelfand, Sninsky and White1990). For lectotypes of P. antarctica and P. aubertii, DNA was extracted using the ClearYieldTM kit from BioLink Laboratories (Washington, DC, USA) following the manufacturer's instructions. Libraries (150 bp paired end) were prepared with the KAPA HyperPrep kit (Roche Sequencing Solutions, Pleasanton, CA, USA) following the manufacturer's instructions and sequenced on an Illumina NovaSeq 6000 S Prime flow cell. The library preparation and sequencing were completed at the Duke Sequencing and Genomic Technologies core facility. We trimmed low-quality read ends (< Q20) using Trimmomatic v. 0.39 (Bolger et al. Reference Bolger, Lohse and Usadel2014) and assembled the metagenomes using the –meta option in SPAdes v. 3.14.1 (Bankevich et al. Reference Bankevich, Nurk, Antipov, Gurevich, Dvorkin, Kulikov, Lesi, Nikolenko, Pham and Prjibelski2012; Nurk et al. Reference Nurk, Meleshko, Korobeynikov and Pevzner2017) with kmer sizes 45, 65 and 85 bp. We then conducted a BLASTn search on the assembled metagenomic contigs using a 5.8S sequence from Peltigera pulverulenta (Taylor) Nyl. (GenBank OM349079). Finally, from each metagenome assembly, we extracted the contig that contained the BLAST hit to the 5.8S region and ran ITSx (Bengtsson-Palme et al. Reference Bengtsson-Palme, Ryberg, Hartmann, Branco, Wang, Godhe, De Wit, Sánchez-García, Ebersberger and de Sousa2013) to delimit and assemble the ITS1, 5.8S and ITS2 regions. The species-level identity of the ITS sequences of the type specimens was established using BLASTn with the NCBI nucleotide database.
Type specimens sequenced other than for P. globulata
Peltigera antarctica C. W. Dodge. Antarctica: Melchior Archipelago: Omega (Lystad) Island, 1941, Siple, Frazier & Bailey 330 (FH 00979245—lectotype, designated by Vitikainen (Reference Vitikainen2002)). GB: OQ955290.
Peltigera aubertii C. W. Dodge. Kerguelen: Grande Terre: near Molloy point, on basalt escarpments, Butte aux Fougères, muscicola, 1952, Aubert de la Rue 55 (FH 00979244—lectotype, designated by Vitikainen (Reference Vitikainen2002)). GB: OQ955289.
Peltigera monticola Vitik. Austria: Tirol: Stubaier Alpen, Mt Hammerspitze, 2600 m, on calcareous slates, 1973, Vitikainen 8884 (H 9500157—holotype). GB: OQ972013.
Peltigera soredians Vitik. Peru: Cuzco: Paucartambo, Paucartambo-Pillcopata road, just SW of Paso de Tres Cruces, 13°8ʹS, 71°38ʹW, 3450 m, 1981, R. Santesson, A. Tehler & G. Thor P96:25 (S L63027—holotype). GB: OQ972014.
Results and Discussion
Our phylogeny of the P. ponojensis/monticola clade (Fig. 1C) largely agrees with the phylogenetic trees presented by Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018). Eighteen newly added ITS sequences cluster with the species delimited previously by Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018), whereas two individuals of P. ponojensis from Poland might represent a new lineage within the species complex. Peltigera globulata (Peltigera sp. 17 in Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018)) forms a monophyletic group (BS = 100%) within a broader well-supported clade (BS = 85%). However, its precise phylogenetic placement within that clade remains uncertain (sister relationship with P. ponojensis/monticola 4 received bootstrap support of 48%; Fig. 1C). With a few exceptions, the relationships among lineages within the large clade where P. globulata is placed (BS = 85% in Fig. 1C) are not well supported (see also Veas-Mattheos et al. Reference Veas-Mattheos, Almendras, Pezoa, Muster and Orlando2023).
The multiple IMa3 runs converged on the same topology (Fig. 2), which differs from the ML tree (Fig. 1C). However, the relationships among the lineages where P. globulata is placed are in general poorly supported and therefore unsettled. Overall, no significant gene flow was detected among the eight putative species. Low levels of gene flow were detected for the P. ponojensis clade from Poland and P. ponojensis/monticola 2 (Fig. 2). Among the eight populations (i.e. putative species) considered, the ancestral population of P. ponojensis/monticola 4 and P. globulata was inferred to be the oldest within this clade (Fig. 2). Based on the IMa3 results, the putative species delimited by Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018) across the entire P. ponojensis/monticola clade probably represent genetically isolated populations, and therefore could be recognized at the species level. However, many of these phylogenetic lineages were not well sampled and are in need of further investigation to better understand phenotypic and molecular variation across their geographical ranges. Peltigera globulata is an exception because of its unique and easily recognizable morphology (i.e. globulated margins) and narrow geographical distribution (i.e. currently reported only from Peru and Ecuador).
Results of the IMa3 analyses generated using the IMfig program (Hey Reference Hey2019) showing no evidence of significant gene flow between the eight populations representing putative species within the clade containing Peltigera globulata (85% bootstrap support in Fig. 1) (P. pon/mon = P. ponojensis/monticola). The phylogeny is drawn as a hierarchical series of boxes, with ancestor boxes connecting descendent populations and the width of boxes proportional to the estimated effective population size (Ne). The vertical dashed lines to the right and left side of each population box are the 95% confidence intervals for each Ne value. Population splitting time (t) values in units of million years ago (MYR) are represented as solid horizontal lines and 95% confidence intervals for splitting times are shown as vertical grey arrows on the left, and parallel dashed lines. Migration arrows (in green) are the estimated migration rate (2Nem) values from one population into another over a shared time interval. The two green arrows indicate very low migration rates that are not statistically significant into the clades of P. ponojensis/monticola from Poland and P. ponojensis/monticola 2.
Most of the c. 50 delimited species in section Peltigera (Magain et al. Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018), even if morphologically cryptic, can be recognized using ITS1-HR (Miadlikowska et al. Reference Miadlikowska, Lutzoni, Goward, Zoller and Posada2003; Magain et al. Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018). Unfortunately, this hypervariable region has low diagnostic value within the P. ponojensis/monticola species complex. Two main ITS1-HR patterns were detected within this species complex, characterized by a 13-base pair indel (Fig. 3). However, taxa with one or the other main sequence type do not form monophyletic groups, which could be the result of incomplete lineage sorting. Moreover, within the two main sequence types, similar or identical ITS1-HR sequences were detected across multiple taxa (see also Veas-Mattheos et al. Reference Veas-Mattheos, Almendras, Pezoa, Muster and Orlando2023). For example, the same ITS1-HR sequence (44 nucleotides long) is shared between P. globulata and P. ponojensis/monticola 10a (Fig. 3; see also supplementary figure S2 of Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018)).
ITS1 hypervariable region (ITS1-HR; positions 182–335 of the ITS1 alignment) from Peltigera globulata in comparison to the other phylogenetic lineages (i.e. putative species) within the P. ponojensis/monticola species complex. Also included are the ITS1-HR sequence from the lectotype specimen of P. antarctica and sequences for P. soredians, a morphologically similar, co-occurring sorediate species from the P. rufescens group. The number of individuals represented by each ITS1-HR sequence type within each species or putative species is shown in parentheses, whereas the numbers in square brackets represent the length of each ITS1-HR sequence type.
Based on BLAST results (100% query cover; 99.66% similarity with P0073 from Austria, see Fig. 1C) of the ITS sequence from the Austrian holotype of P. monticola, we confirm that P. ponojensis/monticola 7 represents P. monticola s. str. as hypothesized by Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018). Note that Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018) inadvertently swapped the labels for P. ponojensis/monticola 7 and 9 in their fig. 2B, but here we follow the nomenclature of their fig. 1, the primary mycobiont phylogeny. As such, P. monticola s. str. has a broad geographical range, with scattered verified records (i.e. sequence data) from southern Europe (Austria and Switzerland), China (Ningxia Province), and Russia (Republic of Dagestan) (Fig. 1C), and possibly North America (Utah; GenBank Accession number MZ243915, with 99% similarity). However, the species is perhaps more common but overlooked (e.g. Miadlikowska (Reference Miadlikowska1999) reported it from several localities in Poland based on morphology).
It remains uncertain which clade within the P. ponojensis/monticola complex represents P. ponojensis s. str. because our attempt to sequence the holotype (collected in Murmansk, Russia, in 1889, Kihlman 258, H!) was unsuccessful. There are four potential candidate clades with the P. ponojensis morphotype that have been collected in Europe (P. ponojensis/monticola 9, 6, 2, and the new lineage from Poland). Peltigera ponojensis/monticola 2 was suggested by Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018). The phylogenetic identity of P. plittii Gyeln. (described from Colorado, USA), which might be conspecific with P. ponojensis (Vitikainen Reference Vitikainen1994a), also remains unresolved because we did not sequence the type specimen. North American specimens corresponding to P. plittii (P. ponojensis morphotype according to Vitikainen (Reference Vitikainen1994a)) were found to be affiliated with multiple putative species (see North American specimens in Fig. 1C).
Based on morphological description and the placement of specimens identified as P. antarctica (Dodge Reference Dodge1968; described from mosses in Antarctica), Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018) erroneously applied this name to a Neantarctic clade containing individuals predominantly from Chile corresponding to Peltigera sp. 23 in Veas-Mattheos et al. (Reference Veas-Mattheos, Almendras, Pezoa, Muster and Orlando2023) and P. ponojensis/monticola 11 in Fig. 1C. The ITS sequence of the lectotype specimen of P. antarctica blasts with 100% cover and 99% similarity to two accessions (OP602838 and OP602833) collected in the high Andean steppes of the Región de Aysén, Reserva Nacional Coyhaique in Chile, which were considered to potentially represent a new species (Peltigera sp. 24 in Veas-Mattheos et al. (Reference Veas-Mattheos, Almendras, Pezoa, Muster and Orlando2023)) sister to P. rufescentiformis in P. rufescens clade, part of section Peltigera, but outside of the P. ponojensis/monticola clade (Fig. 1B). Based on the ITS sequence from lectotype material of P. aubertii, with 100% cover and similarity to specimen P2037 (MH758230) from Chile, we confirm that the name was correctly applied in Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018), based on morphology, to a clade sister to the semi-aquatic P. hydrophila W. R. Buck et al. (Fig. 1B). Both species have Holantarctic distributions and represent a lineage sister to the rest of section Peltigera (Magain et al. Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018). The ITS1 and ITS2 sequences from the holotype of P. soredians with 99% coverage was found to be 99% similar to P2151, a specimen collected in Ecuador (MH758348), which confirms that Magain et al. (Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018) correctly applied this name to a lineage in the P. rufescens clade.
In addition to P. globulata, formal descriptions for P. ponojensis/monticola 10 (a and b) and 4 are in preparation. Specimens of P. ponojensis/monticola 10a and 10b have a unique P. degenii-like, glabrous morphology (they are often misidentified as P. degenii), and a distribution restricted to western North America (confirmed records from British Columbia, California and Utah). Molecular and morphological data support their formal recognition as one species using the name P. ‘scotteri’ as proposed by Trevor Goward (Miadlikowska & Lutzoni Reference Miadlikowska and Lutzoni2000; Miadlikowska et al. Reference Miadlikowska, Lutzoni, Goward, Zoller and Posada2003). Peltigera ponojensis/monticola 4 represents another well-defined morphotype with an etomentose thallus resembling P. degenii but with smaller and rather roundish and isolated lobes, growing on thick matts of mosses in the Ozark region of the USA (Arkansas, Kansas, Missouri).
The remaining putative species within the P. ponojensis/monticola species complex should be described later. Additional sampling is required to gain a better understanding of the variation in geographically widespread clades. For example, we still lack any sequence data from the P. ponojensis/monticola complex in Iceland, for which Vitikainen (Reference Vitikainen1994a) reported morphologically unusual specimens of P. ponojensis. Sequencing type material using a metagenomic approach has proved to be extremely helpful in resolving nomenclatural issues within the genus Peltigera (Magain et al. Reference Magain, Miadlikowska, Goffinet, Goward, la Hoz CJ, Jüriado, Simon, Mercado-Diaz, Barlow and Moncada2023), especially for old historical herbarium specimens that could not be sequenced using PCR and Sanger sequencing. Using this approach, existing species names can be applied with confidence to specific lineages (e.g. Leavitt et al. Reference Leavitt, Kueler, Newberry, Rosentreter and St Clair2019), and therefore phylogenetic lineages that lack conclusive phenotypic characteristics (including chemistry and distribution) can, when appropriate, be described as novel species.
Taxonomy
Peltigera globulata Miadl. & Magain sp. nov.
MycoBank No.: MB 848772
Thallus margins disintegrating into irregular globules that are often covered with erect tomentum and white, flaky pruina and therefore somewhat resembling the sorediate margins of P. soredians. Upper thallus surface pale to dark brown when dry, partly scabrid, partly tomentose and pruinose but never entirely grey in colour and thickly tomentose across the lobes as in P. soredians. Differs from P. soredians by the nucleotide sequence at positions 182–335 of the ITS1 hypervariable region (Fig. 3).
Type: Peru, Puno, Lampa, Santa Lucia, along Arequipa-Juliaca road, 12 km past Lagunillas, 15°38ʹ58ʺS, 70°43ʹ47ʺW, 4325 m, on thick layer of mosses along the road, 22 May 2012, F. Lutzoni s. n. [DNA extraction: P2165] (DUKE 0401811—holotype).
Peltigera globulata (P2165). A, thallus habit with globulate lobe margin, upper side. B, under side of the thallus. Peltigera soredians (P14480). C, thallus habit with sorediate lobe margin, upper side. D, under side of the thallus. Scales = 5 mm.
Peltigera globulata. A, lobes with patches of white pruina on the thallus surface and globulated margin (P2165–holotype). B, appressed tomentum resembling scabrose-like upper thallus surface, beige in colour when dry (P1477). C, Peltigera soredians (P14480), thickly tomentose upper thallus surface, pale grey to whitish when dry. D, Peltigera globulata (P2195) fertile lobes with saddle-shaped apothecia. Scales = 5 mm.
Thallus up to 7 cm diam., but often smaller, lobes narrow, elongated, 0.5–1.5 cm wide, with distinctly upturned, wavy (irregularly flexuose) margins. Margins uneven, partly split into globules, becoming flat or irregular in shape, often darker than thallus and brownish in colour, but covered with tomentum and whitish pruina. Upper thallus beige to pale brown when dry, the surface structure varies: partly tomentose (short and less appressed toward the lobe tips), partly scabrid, partly glabrous, and partly covered with irregular powdery or coarse granular and flaky white pruina, sometimes forming distinct white patches. Underside ochraceous pale with weakly defined, loosely angular and irregularly rigid venation; veins only slightly darker than interspaces, becoming brownish toward the thallus centre; interspaces in older parts of the thallus are often covered with whitish, loose and fluffy nets of hyphae; rhizines short, pale and almost simple and straight, or divided into multiple parallel hyphal bundles at the base in young marginal parts of the thallus, becoming pale brown or darker in colour, longer, fasciculate and fibrillose in shape, and more sparse towards thallus centre (difficult to separate from the substratum because often intermixed with thick mats of mosses). Photobiont Nostoc phylogroup XXVIb (the most common photobiont for P. globulata from Peru; shared with P. ponojensis/monticola 6 and P. laciniata), phylogroup XXXIX (found in a single collection from Ecuador; shared with other species from section Peltigera) and two unique haplotypes (Supplementary Material Table S1, available online; Magain et al. Reference Magain, Truong, Goward, Niu, Goffinet, Sérusiaux, Vitikainen, Lutzoni and Miadlikowska2018).
Apothecia saddle-shaped, on narrow, extended lobes (only two were present on a single specimen). Because spore shape and size have very limited diagnostic value for the identification of Peltigera species, the apothecia were not cross-sectioned.
Pycnidia immersed in marginal globules but too old to make detailed observations.
Chemistry
No lichen secondary products were detected by TLC.
Etymology
The name refers to the irregularly globulated margins of thalli, a signature morphological feature of this species.
Ecology
Found on thick layers of mosses and plants on the ground and boulders or directly on the ground; mostly along road banks in rocky, extremely xeric, exposed areas of the high Andes (elev. 3400–4325 m).
Distribution
Known from South America only; collected from three localities in Peru (Puno) and a single locality in Ecuador.
Notes
Peltigera globulata resembles the overall thallus size and habit of P. soredians. Its globulate and thickly pruinose margins can be mistaken for sorediate margins of P. soredians, when examined with the naked eye. However, P. soredians differs by the presence of granulose, coarse, whitish grey soredia, and a greyish thallus colour when dry because of the persistent, thick whitish appressed tomentum similar to P. laciniata (G. Merr.) Gyeln. (for a detailed description, see Vitikainen (Reference Vitikainen1994b)). Specimens of P. soredians were also observed that had a beige thallus colour when dry, and a less pronounced tomentum, which gives an areolate appearance to the thallus surface. In most specimens we examined, the overall underside of the thallus of P. soredians, in comparison with P. globulata, was paler in colour, the interspaces were more shallow and less defined, and the veins were covered with more dense rows of rhizines. Both species occur along road banks in the high Andes of Peru and Ecuador; however, currently P. soredians has a much broader ecology and distribution in Central and South America.
Additional specimens examined (paratypes)
Ecuador: Pichincha: Pasochoa, Reserva de Vida Silvestre Pasochoa, trail Palma de Cera, 0°25ʹ52ʺS, 78°30ʹ45ʺW, 3400 m, open secondary forest, along the trail on ground covered by mosses, 2013, C. Truong 3976 [with apothecia, DNA extraction: P2195, TLC] (DUKE 0401864).—Peru: Puno: Lampa, Santa Lucia, along Arequipa-Juliaca road, 12 km past Lagunillas, 15°38ʹ58ʺS, 70°43ʹ47ʺW, 4325 m, on a thick layer of mosses along the road, 22 v 2012, J. Miadlikowska s. n. [DNA extraction: P1472] (DUKE 0401811 p.p.); ibid., on a thick layer of mosses and plant debris along the road, 2012, F. Lutzoni 05.22.2012-1 [DNA extraction: P1473] (DUKE 0357994); ibid., on soil along the road, 2012, J. Miadlikowska 05.24.2012 [DNA extraction: P1476] (DUKE 0357964); ibid., 2012, on thick layer of mosses and plant debris along the road, J. Miadlikowska & E. Rivas Plata 22.05.2012 [DNA extraction: P1477] (DUKE 0357964); along Arequipa-Juliaca road, 12 km past Lagunillas, 15°38ʹ56ʺS, 70°43ʹ51ʺW, 4317 m, on thick layer of mosses along the road, 2012, F. Lutzoni 05.22.2012-8 [DNA extraction: P1728] (DUKE 0401804); Azángaro, Santiago de Pupuja, along Juliaca-Azángaro road, 3 km past el poblado Mataro Chico, 15°4ʹ37ʺS, 70°10ʹ51ʺW, 3865 m, S exposure, on soil and mosses on boulders, 2012, J. Miadlikowska 05.24.2012 [DNA extraction: P2164] (DUKE 0357990).
Acknowledgements
We thank Eimy Rivas Plata, Daniel Fernando Ramos Aranibar and Rafael Pérez Zorrilla for their generous help in organizing and executing the field trip in Peru, and Camille Truong for collecting the specimen of P. globulata in Ecuador. We are grateful to Prof. Arne Anderberg from the Swedish Museum of Natural History for sending us thallus fragments of the type specimen of Peltigera soredians for molecular work. We thank two anonymous reviewers for their comments and suggestions. This study was supported by the United States National Science Foundation (NSF) REVSYS award on the genus Peltigera DEB 1025930 and NSF BEE grant 1929994 to FL and JM. IDM was supported by an NSF Graduate Research Fellowship under grant DGE 1644868.
Author ORCIDs
Jolanta Miadlikowska, 0000-0002-5545-2130; Nicolas Magain, 0000-0001-5409-9518; Ian D. Medeiros, 0000-0003-2179-0745; Carlos J. Pardo-De la Hoz, 0000-0002-7898-0948; Ignazio Carbone, 0000-0003-2721-6656; Scott LaGreca, 0000-0002-1988-0437; Thomas Barlow, 0000-0002-3650-4580; Leena Myllys, 0000-0002-9566-9473; François Lutzoni, 0000-0003-4849-7143.
Competing Interests
The authors declare none.
Supplementary Material
The Supplementary Material for this article can be found at https://doi.org/10.1017/S0024282923000373.
Open access
