Severe wasting, defined as very low weight-for-height or as very small arm circumference for age, is frequent among under-fives in developing countries, and is an indication for urgent medical attention and intensive nutritional rehabilitation. Severe wasting has drawn the attention of nutritionists for a long time and, despite overall improvements in nutritional status, has become again a subject of research because treatment for severe wasting has improved dramatically and become increasingly efficient in recent years(Reference Fauveau, Briend, Chakraborty and Sarder1–Reference Bhutta, Ahmed and Black4).
Severe wasting is often seen as a nutritional risk factor for mortality from other causes of death. Indeed, numerous studies have shown that children with severe wasting have much higher risks of death than children with anthropometric indicators above the median(Reference Gomez, Ramos-Galvan, Frenk, Cravioto-Munoz, Chavez and Vasquez5–Reference Garenne, Maire, Fontaine and Briend17). However, severe wasting can also be seen as a disease per se, for which classic epidemiological indicators can be computed, such as prevalence, incidence, duration of episodes and case fatality. Calculation of such indicators requires a longitudinal study, where children can be monitored over time and episodes of malnutrition identified. Owing to the long process leading to severe wasting and the long time for recovery, only few such studies have been conducted in developing countries. A review of the literature conducted recently by one of the authors (A.B.) did not reveal any publication with proper estimates of incidence and duration of episodes of severe wasting.
In the current paper we present two contrasted situations – one in West Africa, the other in Central Africa – with different patterns of malnutrition and different profiles of causes of death. We have developed a way of calculating epidemiological indicators from longitudinal studies conducted several years ago, which were not full-scale cohort studies from birth to age 5 years, but which provided data enabling incidence and duration to be calculated from transition rates. This information still appears valuable, since it has policy implications for treatment of severe child malnutrition. Although we note that the average nutritional situation has somewhat improved worldwide since the 1980s, severe malnutrition still remains a problem in many rural areas in developing countries, as is well documented by numerous surveys, such as the Demographic and Health Surveys(Reference Mukuria, Cushing and Sangha18), and by a recent series of articles published in The Lancet (Reference Black, Allen, Bhutta, Caulfield, de Onis, Ezzati, Mathers and Rivera19).
Data and methods
The first site, Niakhar, is located in rural Senegal, some 150 km east of Dakar, the country’s capital city. The study site and the study design are described elsewhere(Reference Garenne, Maire, Fontaine, Dieng and Briend16, Reference Garenne and Cantrelle20). In brief, we followed an open cohort of about 5000 children, covering all under-fives living in thirty villages. We visited the children four times at 6-month intervals in May and November of 1983 and 1984. At each visit comprehensive anthropometric measurements were taken (weight, height, head circumference, arm circumference, triceps skinfold and subscapular skinfold). All measures were taken by the researchers themselves (B.M. and O.F.) after careful standardization and using state-of-the-art equipment: Seca® scales with a precision of 10 g and Holtain® length/height boards with a precision of 1 mm(Reference Garenne, Maire, Fontaine, Dieng and Briend16). Survival within 6 months was monitored for all children, and long-term survival was also known for virtually all children from the demographic surveillance system, with detailed causes of death obtained by verbal autopsy(Reference Garenne and Fontaine21).
The second site, Bwamanda, is located in the Democratic Republic of Congo (Zaire at that time), in the north-western province of Equateur. The study site and the study design are also described elsewhere(Reference Van den Broeck, Eeckels and Vuylsteke22). In brief, an open cohort of about 5000 under-fives was followed for about two years. Children were seen six times at 3-month intervals, from October 1989 to February 1991. Each visit included anthropometric measurements (weight, height, arm circumference, triceps skinfold). Weight was measured in the nude with spring scales to the nearest 100 g and length or height with a locally designed measuring board to the nearest millimetre; field workers were trained extensively in anthropometric standardization, including use of the Frankfort plane for length and height. Child survival was monitored up to 15 April 1992, i.e. at least 12 months after the last visit, also with detailed causes of death. The two studies are therefore comparable in size and methods, with the frequency of visits being the main difference.
Both sites are located in the African savannah, with the Niakhar area being somewhat drier and the Bwamanda area having forest galleries along rivers. Both areas have a dry and a rainy season at about the same time, although the rainy season in shorter in Niakhar (July to October) than in Bwamanda (June to November). In both areas malaria is holoendemic, with major peaks of transmission during the rainy season. Staple diet in Niakhar is millet or sorghum, occasionally rice or maize, supplemented with local vegetables, peanut sauce and dried fish, prepared as a kind of couscous (steamed millet), and served two to three times daily. Staple diet in Bwamanda is maize and cassava, also supplemented with vegetables, peanuts and fish, prepared as a kind of sticky porridge, and served once or twice daily. In theory both diets are balanced, assuming the family is wealthy enough, and the main difference is the staple food (millet/sorghum v. maize/cassava). The main sources of water in Niakhar are shallow wells, although some deep wells were recently built in the largest villages; water is kept in clay tanks at home, a major source of contamination with water-borne germs because of poor hygienic practices. Water in Bwamanda comes primarily from deep tube wells. Also worth noticing is the difference in body shapes between the two populations: the Niakhar population belongs almost exclusively to the Sereer ethnic group, a Sahelian group with rather long legs compared with the trunk, whereas the Bwamanda population belongs primarily to the Ngbaka ethnic group, stocky Bantu people with rather short legs compared with the trunk.
We defined severe wasting in two ways, from the two indicators routinely used in screening programmes: mid upper-arm circumference (MUAC) <110 mm and weight-for-height Z-score (WHZ) ≤−3.0. The Z-score was calculated using the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2000 child growth charts (CDC-2000), because it was found the most robust system and the one with the best screening power for mortality in Niakhar(Reference Kuczmarski, Ogden, Guo, Grummer-Strawn, Flegal, Mei, Wei, Curtin, Roche and Johnson23). We also provide equivalent calculations using the National Center for Health Statistics 1977 child growth references (NCHS-1977) and the WHO Multicentre Growth Reference Study 2006 child growth standards (MGRS-2006) for comparison(Reference Hamill, Drizd, Johnson, Reed, Rocher and Moore24, Reference De Onis, Garza, Onyango and Borghi25). In both cases, the interval used for the comparative analysis was 6 months (each second visit in the case of Bwamanda), the common denominator for the two surveys. We defined incident cases as children being above the threshold at previous visit and below the threshold at next visit. Recovery cases were the opposite: below the threshold at previous visit and above the threshold at next visit. Mortality was defined as death within 6 months after a visit.
In both studies, we constructed a multi-state life table using standard formulae(Reference Manton and Stallard26). In brief, a synthetic cohort is built from transition rates measured in the population and describes the population in each state and in each 6-month age group. The states were: ‘alive above threshold’, ‘alive below threshold’, ‘deceased while above threshold’ and ‘deceased while below threshold’. The transitions were ‘incident case’, ‘recovery case’ and ‘mortality’. This multi-state life table provided therefore all basic epidemiological indicators of the morbidity process: the incidence, duration of episodes and case fatality for the under-fives.
Results
Basic population characteristics
The samples were of comparable size, 5751 children in Niakhar and 5167 children in Bwamanda, and there were more measurements taken in the six visits in Bwamanda than in the four visits in Niakhar (Table 1). Mortality, calculated as the probability of dying between 1 and 60 months (post-neonatal under-five mortality), was higher in Niakhar in 1983–4 (227 per 1000, based on 356 deaths) than in Bwamanda in 1989–92 (131 per 1000, based on 215 deaths), the difference being highly significant (relative risk = 1·73, 95 % CI 1·46, 2·05; P = 2 × 10−10).
Demographic characteristics and nutritional status in the two sites
ALRI, acute lower respiratory infection; WAZ, weight-for-age Z-score; HAZ, height-for-age Z-score; WHZ, weight-for-height Z-score; MUAC, mid upper-arm circumference.
The causes of death were also different. In Niakhar, mortality from diarrheal diseases was 5·9 times higher than in Bwamanda, and mortality from vaccine-preventable diseases (primarily measles and whooping cough) was 4·8 times higher. In contrast, mortality from malaria and severe anaemia was 2·3 times higher in Bwamanda than in Niakhar, and mortality from severe malnutrition (kwashiorkor and marasmus) was 2·7 times higher, all these differences being statistically significant (P < 0·05). In addition, the profile of mortality from malnutrition was different, with similar numbers of kwashiorkor and marasmus deaths in Bwamanda, whereas in Niakhar kwashiorkor accounted for about a third of deaths coded as severe malnutrition and typical clinical marasmus for about a sixth, others being cases of severe wasting.
Stunting was less prevalent in Niakhar than in Bwamanda (average height-for-age Z-score (HAZ): −1·09 v. −2.00) and wasting was somewhat more prevalent (average WHZ: −0·77 v. −0·58). However, MUAC was on average higher in Niakhar (142 mm v. 130 mm). Standard deviations of the distributions of the four indicators were similar, with somewhat higher values for WAZ (weight-for-age Z-score) in Bwamanda (associated with a lower mean) and somewhat smaller values for MUAC (also associated with a lower mean). These observations had serious implications for the distribution of severe malnutrition, and especially for the proportions of children below a given threshold.
Among children aged 1–59 months, the prevalence of severe malnutrition (WAZ < −3·0) was similar in the two sites (10·3 % in Niakhar, 11·8 % in Bwamanda). However, due to the large difference in stunting, severe wasting defined by WHZ ≤ −3·0 was somewhat more prevalent in Niakhar (3·2 % v. 2·9 %), whereas it was less prevalent when defined by MUAC < 110 mm (1·7 % v. 4·6 %). This shows that the patterns of malnutrition were different in the two sites, even though the overall prevalence was similar, and that different indicators could lead to different conclusions (Fig. 1).
Prevalence of moderate malnutrition in children aged 6–59 months, Niakhar (Senegal; ░) and Bwamanda (Democratic Republic of Congo; ▒). WAZ, weight-for-age Z-score; HAZ, height-for-age Z-score; WHZ, weight-for-height Z-score; MUAC, mid upper-arm circumference
Prevalence of severe wasting in the cohorts
The age profiles of severe wasting were somewhat different in the two sites (Fig. 2, Tables 2a and 2b). In Niakhar, the proportion with WHZ ≤ −3·0 increased rapidly with age in the first year, became very high between 12 and 30 months and lower thereafter, whereas severe wasting was more uniform in Bwamanda, with a smaller rise in infancy and a slower decline after 30 months. With respect to low MUAC, prevalence was much higher in Bwamanda and the decline was rapid with age. For children aged 1–59 months, MUAC prevalence of severe wasting was 2·7 times higher in Bwamanda (P < 10−10). Even ignoring children below 6 months of age, for whom MUAC should not be used without adjusting for age, MUAC < 110 mm appeared to be overestimating the prevalence of severe wasting in the very young in Bwamanda, but underestimating the prevalence at 12–35 months in Niakhar.
Prevalence of severe wasting by age (population estimates) according to weight-for-height Z-score (WHZ) and mid upper-arm circumference (MUAC): Niakhar (Senegal; —▴—, WHZ; – –▴– –, MUAC) and Bwamanda (Democratic Republic of Congo; —○—, WHZ; – –○– –, MUAC). Thresholds: WHZ ≤ −3·0 and MUAC < 110 mm
Multi-state life table of competing risks of severe wasting and mortality among under-fives in Niakhar (Senegal) and Bwamanda (Democratic Republic of Congo), based on weight-for-height Z-score ≤−3·0
Multi-state life table of competing risks of severe wasting and mortality among under-fives in Niakhar (Senegal) and Bwamanda (Democratic Republic of Congo), based on mid upper-arm circumference <110 mm
Incidence of severe wasting in the cohorts
Incidence of severe wasting reflected the differences in prevalence (Fig. 3, Tables 2a and 2b). Using WHZ, the incidence was of the same magnitude in the two sites (2·6 % per child-semester in Niakhar, 2·1 % in Bwamanda), whereas it was much lower in Niakhar for MUAC. In Niakhar, the peak incidence was at 6–11 months, with very high values (6·3 %), almost 50 % more than in Bwamanda at the same age (4·3 %). The age profile was again somewhat different, with a faster decline in Niakhar from 18 to 36 months to reach low values, whereas in Bwamanda incidence declined more slowly from 6–11 months to 42–47 months. Incidence measured by MUAC < 110 mm tended to be much lower than that obtained with WHZ ≤ –3·0 in Niakhar, but quite close in Bwamanda.
Incidence of severe wasting (life table estimates) according to weight-for-height Z-score (WHZ) and mid upper-arm circumference (MUAC): Niakhar (Senegal; —▴—, WHZ; – –▴– –, MUAC) and Bwamanda (Democratic Republic of Congo; —○—, WHZ; – –○– –, MUAC)
Frequency and duration of episodes
In Niakhar, 22 % of newborn children were likely to encounter an episode of severe wasting defined by WHZ and only 6 % when defined by MUAC. In Bwamanda, these proportions were 19 % for WHZ and 20 % for MUAC (Table 3). Virtually all surviving children had recovered from severe wasting by age 5 years.
Synthetic indicators from multi-state life tables among under-fives in Niakhar (Senegal) and Bwamanda (Democratic Republic of Congo)
WHZ, weight-for-height Z-score; MUAC, mid upper-arm circumference.
Reference norms: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2000 child growth charts (CDC-2000).
Despite the differences in prevalence and in age profiles of incidence in the two studies, the episodes of severe wasting had a similar duration whatever the anthropometric indicator used: 7·4 and 7·8 months for WHZ, and 7·6 and 8·4 months for MUAC, Niakhar and Bwamanda respectively (Table 3). This duration explains the age pattern of prevalence. Most new cases occur in the first two years of life, and episodes last on average less than a year, so that by the age of 3 years most of them have ended.
Mortality and case fatality
For all episodes combined, mortality in the severe wasting group represented 6 % (based on WHZ) to 12 % (based on MUAC) of the total mortality in Niakhar, and 9 % to 12 % respectively in Bwamanda (Table 3). These values are close to the attributable risks obtained by directly calculating the relative risk of death and the prevalence (respectively 13 % and 10 % in Niakhar, 11 % and 14 % in Bwamanda). This makes severe wasting one of the leading causes of death, of the same order of magnitude as measles or malaria in Niakhar or as diarrhoeal diseases in Bwamanda. Of course, the attributable risk depended on the threshold chosen (WHZ ≤ −3·0 or MUAC < 110 mm). Note that MUAC identified children with higher risks of death than WHZ in Niakhar, whereas mortality was the same for both indicators in Bwamanda, reflecting the differences in stunting, in body composition and in body shape.
Case fatality can also be derived from the life tables (Tables 2 and 3). Its value was dependent on the definition chosen, and ranged from 12 % (WHZ) to 22 % (MUAC) in Niakhar, and from 6 % (WHZ) to 7 % (MUAC) in Bwamanda, making severe wasting one of the most lethal conditions in these populations. The high value of case fatality for MUAC in Niakhar is due in part to the relatively lower bound of the threshold compared with the mean in the population, selecting a smaller group of high-risk children, and in part to the higher mortality level.
Impact of standards
The impact of the standard can be evaluated by comparing the results of multi-state life tables produced with the NCHS-1977 and the MGRS-2006 standards with those obtained with the CDC-2000 standard. Overall, the standard did not much influence the estimates of mean duration of episodes, which fluctuated around 7·5 months (Table 4). However, the standard had a large effect on prevalence in the population, and as a result on incidence in a cohort. These differences, which are due to different values of the −3·0 Z-score threshold, have been documented elsewhere(Reference De Onis, Garza, Onyango and Borghi25). To give an example, the −3·0 threshold for a height of 80 cm for males is 8·840 kg in the CDC-2000 system, but only 8·290 kg in NCHS-1977 and 8·300 kg in MGRS-2006, which explains why prevalence is higher with CDC-2000.
Comparison of effect of norm system on life table estimates among under-fives in Niakhar (Senegal) and Bwamanda (Democratic Republic of Congo)
MGRS-2006, WHO Multicentre Growth Reference Study 2006 child growth standards; NCHS-1977, National Center for Health Statistics 1977 child growth references; CDC-2000, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2000 child growth charts.
Discussion
The present study revealed a common pattern of episodes of severe wasting, with similar duration in the two areas investigated (7·5 months), despite differences in environment, in diet, in causes of death profiles and in prevalence of malnutrition. Here, we considered severe wasting as a disease, with the usual epidemiological characteristics, such as prevalence, incidence, duration and case fatality rate. The disease parameters were estimated from longitudinal studies, which, however, were not full-scale cohort studies from birth to age 5 years. Proper clinical investigations in cohorts could provide further evidence, in particular on the distribution of the duration of episodes, which may be quite wide. Some episodes appear to be of short duration for children who recover quickly or who are properly treated, whereas others last a long time and lead to severely retarded growth.
A 6-month reference period was used in the comparative study because the Niakhar data imposed this interval. Similar computations were conducted in Bwamanda with 3-month intervals and revealed somewhat shorter episodes of, on average, 4·5 months for WHZ and 5·3 months for MUAC, as well as a higher incidence. Finding more episodes of short duration with smaller intervals was expected, and this could be further pursued with even smaller intervals. The clinical significance of these shorter episodes could be further analysed. However, one could also consider that measurement errors around the threshold could lead to false positive cases of severe malnutrition, and a more rigorous case definition associated with formal growth monitoring might be necessary to sort out this issue. Furthermore, the attributable risk obtained using a 3-month interval was higher than the attributable risk calculated directly from relative risk of death and prevalence (20 % v. 14 % for MUAC, 15 % v. 11 % for WHZ), which suggests that this method tended to overestimate incidence.
The differences between the two sites deserve further investigation. Many factors could be evoked. Diet was different in the two sites, with millet and sorghum being the staple foods in Niakhar compared with maize and cassava in Bwamanda. Among infectious diseases of childhood, the pattern of malaria transmission differed between the two sites, with more intense and more seasonal transmission in Niakhar inducing very high mortality during the four months of the rainy season but not during the rest of the year. In Bwamanda, malaria transmission was more steady, leading to mortality all year round and to more cases of severe anaemia. Access to treatment probably also differed, with an advantage to people living near the well-staffed Bwamanda hospital, whereas Niakhar in the 1980s was poorly served. The time period was also different. In Niakhar the study was conducted before the mass vaccination campaigns of 1986–7, and by 1988 mortality rates from measles, whooping cough and tetanus had been reduced to very low numbers, and overall mortality was strongly reduced. It was also conducted before the oral rehydration therapy programme really took off, which could explain the high mortality from diarrhoea. A comparison done in 1989–91 in Niakhar would have led to different conclusions.
Genetic factors seemed also to play a role in the comparison. Sahelians of West Africa are usually taller than Congolese Bantus, and in particular tend to have a low ‘sitting-height to standing-height ratio’ (Cormic index). Their body shape therefore tends to underestimate stunting (measured by HAZ) and to overestimate wasting measured by WHZ when compared with other indicators of the muscular mass. This has been documented already for populations in Eastern Africa(Reference Myatt and Duffield27). In our comparison, it was striking to note that the differences in estimates of severe wasting changed depending on the indicator selected. Arm circumference remains the closest indicator of the lean body mass, and has been found repeatedly to be the best predictor of child survival(Reference Briend and Zimicki12, Reference Brambilla, Rolland-Cachera, Testolin, Briend, Salvatoni, Testolin and Chiumello28). How the genetic components of body shape and body composition affect arm circumference and its interpretation remains to be explored.
These studies were conducted some 20 to 25 years ago and meanwhile HIV/AIDS has emerged, leading to an increase in the prevalence of severe wasting in many African countries. This new disease is likely to change some of the parameters used in the present study. The availability of highly active antiretroviral therapy for HIV-infected under-fives is also likely to have an impact on HIV-related severe wasting. These new facts should be taken into account for recent estimates of the causes of death and the burden of severe wasting.
Acknowledgements
The Niakhar study was supported by the European Union, DG-XII, Grant # TDR-36 (M.G., B.M., A.B. and O.F.). The Bwamanda study was supported by the Nutricia Research Foundation (J.V.d.B., R.E. and D.W.). All authors declare no conflict of interest of any type. The Niakhar study was initiated by M.G., B.M. and A.B.; the field work was conducted by M.B., B.M. and O.F. All four authors contributed to the data analysis and the writing of the paper. The Bwamanda study was initiated by J.V.d.B. and R.E., who also conducted the field work; both contributed to the data analysis and the writing of the paper together with D.W. The authors thank all those who participated in the field work, in particular the technical assistants, the mothers and children, and the community leaders, who welcomed the study.
