Chronic non-communicable diseases (NCD) account for approximately 60 % of all causes of death worldwide. It is estimated that 80 % of these deaths occur in low- and middle-income countries( 1 ). Among the major modifiable risk factors associated with these diseases are lifestyle-related behaviours such as smoking, physical inactivity, alcohol abuse and insufficient consumption of fruits and vegetables( 2 , 3 ).
In this context, knowing the occurrence of each risk behaviour provides a partial view of the problem, since these are highly interrelated( Reference Spring, Moller and Coons 4 ) and may present synergistic effects, potentiating the risk when occurring in an aggregate form( Reference Luoto, Pratala and Lutela 5 ), which makes relevant the knowledge about aggregation of such behaviours that are influenced by sociodemographic and economic factors as gender, age and socio-economic status( Reference Leech, McNaughton and Timperio 6 ). Studies with different population groups have evaluated the simultaneity or co-occurrence of risk behaviours and their association with NCD( Reference Fuglestad, Jeffery and Sherwood 7 – Reference Sena, Muraro and Rodrigues 11 ). However, most of them evaluated the co-occurrence of behaviours without considering the interrelationships between them( Reference McAloney, Graham and Law 12 ).
In Brazil, some studies also investigated the simultaneity of risk behaviours for NCD in adults( Reference Lessa, Araújo and Magalhães 13 – Reference Barros, Lima and Medina 18 ). However, only two studies found in the literature have identified risk behaviour patterns in a Brazilian national sample( Reference Steele, Claro and Monteiro 9 , Reference Azeredo, Levy and Peres 19 ). The first interviewed adults in a survey via telephone (VIGITEL) conducted annually in Brazilian capitals and in the Federal District; and the second with adolescents, based on data from the National School Health Survey (PeNSE), was conducted in 2012 with students from the 9th year of primary education in public and private schools. Therefore, none of the studies evaluated a probabilistic sample in the entire national territory of Brazil.
Thus, the present study aimed to identify risk behaviour patterns for NCD in the Brazilian population and associated socio-economic and demographic factors, using data from the most complete survey on the health of the Brazilian population, the National Health Survey (PNS).
Methods
The present study uses data from the PNS, a Brazilian home-based survey conducted in 2013 by the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics in partnership with the Health Surveillance Secretariat of the Ministry of Health and the Oswaldo Cruz Foundation.
The sample plan was defined by probabilistic sampling in three stages. In the first stage, there was a stratification of primary sampling units, constituted by sectors or groups of census sectors, the second stage consisted of homes, and residents aged 18 years or over corresponded to the third stage units. The selection of a sub-sample of the primary sampling units was made by simple random sampling( Reference Szwarcwald, Malta and Pereira 20 ).
The estimated sample size was based on 81357 homes and interview records were obtained in 64348 of them, and 60202 individuals aged 18 years or older were interviewed. Considering closed homes, the loss ratio was 20·8 % and the non-response ratio was 8·1 %. Details on the PNS methodological strategy design and the sampling process are available in other publications( Reference Souza Júnior, Freitas and Antonaci 21 , Reference Damacena, Szwarcwald and Malta 22 ).
Participants were interviewed and answered questions related to socio-economic, demographic and lifestyle information. The socio-economic and demographic variables evaluated in the present study were: gender (male/female); age categorized in age groups (18–24, 25–39, 40–59, 50–59 and ≥60 years); schooling level (none/incomplete primary education; complete primary education/incomplete secondary education; complete secondary education/incomplete higher education; complete higher education) and macro region of residence (Central-West, South, Southeast, North, Northeast).
Regarding food consumption information, the weekly intake frequency of soft drinks/artificial juice and sweet foods was obtained by a questionnaire, asking the following questions: ‘How many days in the week you usually drink artificial juice?’ and How many days in the week you usually eat sweet foods?’. Questionnaire answer was the number of days in the week. For fruits and vegetables, the number of days in the week was obtained by the questions: ‘How many days of the week do you usually eat lettuce and tomato salad or salad from any other raw vegetables or vegetables?’, ‘How many days of the week do you usually eat vegetables or boiled vegetables such as cabbage, carrots, chuchu, eggplant, zucchini? (not counting potatoes, manioc or yams)’ and ‘How many days in the week do you usually eat fruit?’.
For descriptive analyses, the lifestyle behaviours analysed were categorized as follows: (i) consumption of soft drinks/artificial juice (5 times/week or more); (ii) consumption of sweet foods (5 times/week or more); (iii) inadequate consumption of fruits, (iv) green or raw vegetable salad, (v) cooked vegetables (4 times/week or less for fruits and vegetables); (vi) consumption of red meat with apparent fat (yes or no); (vii) chicken skin consumption (yes or no); (viii) excessive consumption of alcoholic beverages (for men 5 doses or more and for women 4 doses or more of alcoholic beverages on a single occasion in the 30d prior to the interview); (ix) daily or sporadic use of tobacco; (x) absence of physical activity in leisure; and (xi) time spent watching television (3h/d or more) to characterize sedentary behaviour.
For the identification of risk behaviour patterns (dependent variable), we used exploratory factor analysis to reduce the initial number of variables into a smaller set of factors that represent, in a synthetic way, the information contained in the larger set of variables( Reference Marôco 23 ). The following behaviour factors were included in the model: (i) consumption of soft drinks/artificial juice (0 to 7 times/week); (ii) consumption of sweet foods (0 to 7 times/week); (iii) inadequate consumption of fruits, (vi) green or raw vegetable salad, (v) cooked vegetables (0 to 7 times/week); (vi) consumption of red meat with apparent fat; (vii) chicken skin consumption; (viii) excessive consumption of alcoholic beverages; (ix) daily or sporadic use of tobacco; (x) physical activity in leisure (0 to 7 times/week); and (xi) time spent watching television (categorical, from 1=‘do not watch television or watch for less than 1h/d’ to 7=watch television for 6h/d or more’) to characterize sedentary behaviour.
Data adequacy for the factor analysis was initially evaluated using the Bartlett sphericity test and the Kaiser–Meyer–Olkin sample adequacy measure( Reference Kaiser 24 ). Analysis of main components was used for factor extraction and varimax rotation was conducted to facilitate the interpretation of factors. Determination of the number of factors to retain was based on the Kaiser criterion, which proposes the retention of factors with eigenvalues ≥1( Reference Olinto 25 ).
Standardized factor scores (Z-scores) were assigned to each participant, for each of the retained patterns, calculated based on factor loading. The higher the Z-score value, the greater the participant’s adherence to that pattern( Reference Hofstetter, Dusseldorp and Empelen 26 ). Behaviours with a factor loading |≥0·30| remained in the patterns, with higher values indicating greater contribution of the behaviour to the specific pattern construction. Afterwards, identification of behaviour patterns stratified by the presence or absence of NCD (systemic arterial hypertension, diabetes, increased cholesterol and/or obesity) was carried out.
Blood pressure was measured using an automatic device following the same procedures used in the Longitudinal Study of Adult Health (ELSA) Project( Reference Souza Júnior, Freitas and Antonaci 21 ) and participants were classified as hypertensive if they had systolic blood pressure ≥140 mmHg and/or diastolic blood pressure ≥90 mmHg( 27 ). Participants who reported a medical diagnosis of systemic arterial hypertension and were taking antihypertension medication were also considered hypertensive.
To evaluate obesity, participants’ weight was obtained by means of a digital scale and height was measured by a portable stadiometer, for subsequent calculation of BMI. Weight was measured using a portable digital scale with capacity of 150 kg and gradation of 100 g. Before weighing, the scale was placed on a flat surface and properly calibrated. In addition, participants were asked to remove their shoes, heavy clothing and accessories. The weight was recorded in kilograms considering the first decimal place shown by the scale display. Height was measured by a portable stadiometer with a retractable treadmill, measuring to the nearest 0·1 cm. Participants were instructed to adopt the orthostatic position, parallel feet and barefoot; before measurement, the examiner ensured that five points (heels, calves, buttocks, scapulae and the back of the occiput) were against the wall. The height record was in centimetres considering the first decimal place( 28 ). In the identification of obesity, the cut-off point was BMI≥30·0 kg/m2. Information on diabetes and increased cholesterol was based on self-report according to previous medical diagnosis.
Statistical analyses were performed with the statistical software package SPSS Statistics version 17.0 and using the Complex Sample module, considering the study design and sample weights. The χ 2 test was used to compare the prevalence of behaviour patterns according to independent variables. Factor scores of retained patterns were categorized into tertiles.
The PNS was approved by the National Commission of Ethics for Research in Human Beings, of the Ministry of Health, under the opinion number 328,159 of 26 June 2013. Individuals invited and who accepted to participate in the research signed an Informed Consent Form.
Results
A total of 60202 Brazilians aged 18 years or over were analysed, of whom 52·9 % were female, 66·0 % were aged between 25 and 59 years and 54·5 % had low educational level (without education or incomplete secondary education). Regarding the risk behaviours evaluated, the highest prevalence was observed for physical inactivity at leisure time (68·5 %) followed by inadequate consumption of cooked vegetables (68·0 %), inadequate consumption of fruits (58·6 %), inadequate consumption of green or raw vegetable salad (53·5 %), and sedentary behaviour and consumption of meat with apparent fat, both with 28·9 % each (Table 1).
Distribution of the study population according to socio-economic and demographic characteristics, economic and risk behaviour characteristics for chronic non-communicable diseases. National Health Survey, Brazil, 2013 (n 60 202)
* Frequency of consumption: 4 times/week or less.
† Time spent watching television: 3 h/d or more.
‡ Daily or sporadic tobacco use.
§ Intake of alcoholic beverages on a single occasion in the last 30 d: intake of 5 doses or more for men and 4 doses or more for women.
║ Frequency of consumption: 5 times/week or more.
In the stratified analysis, no relevant differences were observed either in the identification of patterns or in the parameters evaluated between the population with and without self-report of some NCD (see online supplementary material, Supplemental Tables 1 and 2). Thus, the identification of patterns and conduction of analyses were done for the entire sample population.
Factor loads, commonalities (h 2) and estimated variances for the four patterns of risk behaviours for chronic non-communicable diseases identified among Brazilians. National Health Survey, Brazil, 2013 (n 60 202)
FV, fruits and vegetables.
Factors loading on each pattern are indicated in bold.
The Kaiser–Meyer–Olkin measure (= 0·64) and Bartlett’s sphericity test (P<0·01) indicated that the correlations between behaviours were sufficient and adequate for conducting the factor analysis. The identified patterns were named as follows: (i) ‘Physical inactivity in leisure time and Inadequate consumption of fruits and vegetables’ pattern, characterized by the absence of physical activity in leisure time and consumption below recommended levels for fruits and vegetables, explaining 18·43 % of the variance; (ii) ‘Saturated fat’ pattern, characterized by the consumption of chicken with skin and red meat with apparent fat, explaining 13·42 % of data variation; (iii) ‘Alcohol and Smoking’ pattern, with positive loadings for excessive consumption of alcoholic beverages and smoking, with a 10·41 % explanation of variance; and (iv) ‘Sedentary behaviour and Sugar’ pattern, characterized by ≥3h/d spent watching television, regular consumption of sweet foods and soft drinks/artificial juices, which explained 9·75 % of the variance. Together, the four risk behaviours explained 52·01 % of behaviour variability (Table 2).
It was observed that the pattern ‘Physical inactivity in leisure time and Inadequate consumption of fruits and vegetables’ showed a higher adherence among men, those who were younger, in the population with the lowest level of schooling, and those who resided in the North and Northeast regions. The ‘Saturated fat’ pattern was more frequent among men, in the population with lower educational level and residents in the South and Central-West regions of the country. For the ‘Alcohol and Smoking’ pattern, the highest adherence was also among men, people with lower educational levels, and residents in the Central-West and Northeast regions. In contrast, the ‘Sedentary behaviour and Sugar’ pattern had greater adherence among the younger participants (18–24 years old), with higher level of schooling, and residents in the South and Southern regions (Table 3).
Distribution (%) of Brazilians according to risk behaviour pattern scores for chronic non-communicable diseases categorized in tertiles and socio-economic and demographic characteristics. National Health Survey, Brazil, 2013 (n 60 202)
FV, fruits and vegetables.
* Values in parentheses are score ranges of participants in each tertile.
† P value from the χ 2 test.
Discussion
Four risk behaviour patterns for NCD were identified in the Brazilian population, denominated ‘Physical inactivity in leisure time and Inadequate consumption of fruits and vegetables’, ‘Saturated fat’, ‘Alcohol and Smoking’ and ‘Sedentary behaviour and Sugar’. These patterns showed heterogeneity regarding the socio-economic and demographic characteristics of the population, also varying according to regions of the country. Moreover, in general, our study revealed a trend of greater adherence to risk behaviours among men, younger individuals and those with lower schooling levels.
The risk behaviours analysed in the present study are characteristics of an unhealthy lifestyle and are known risk factors for the main NCD, responsible for a large share of the global burden of diseases( 2 , 3 ). The diversity of factors considered in studies evaluating the co-occurrence of risk behaviours for NCD and the criteria used in the classification of such factors make the comparison of results complex, and it should be noted that the patterns identified in the present study differ partially from those observed in other countries and even in Brazil( Reference Fuglestad, Jeffery and Sherwood 7 – Reference Sena, Muraro and Rodrigues 11 ), except for the pattern that associates smoking with the consumption of alcoholic beverages, which has been identified in several studies( Reference Ikeda, Inoue and Iso 29 – Reference Villiers, Copley and McGee 31 ). In a study with data from the PNS of 2013, Garcia and Freitas( Reference Ikeda, Inoue and Iso 29 ) observed a higher prevalence of alcohol abuse among occasional smokers (35·2 %) compared with daily smokers (27·4 %), and such categories had higher prevalence of alcohol abuse than among non-smokers (11·1 %).
In Brazil, among the nationally representative studies that used statistical procedures to identify behaviour patterns, Steele et al.( Reference Steele, Claro and Monteiro 9 ) verified the presence of two patterns from a list of twelve risk behaviours, with gender-stratified analysis. One pattern was characterized by healthy behaviours, called prudent, and the other one was represented by unhealthy behaviours, both with similar characteristics between men and women. Greater adherence to the prudent pattern was observed among women, from less developed regions (North and Northeast), with higher age groups and higher schooling level. On the other hand, the male population from more developed regions (South, Southeast and Central-West), those younger and with lower schooling level showed greater adherence to the second pattern. However, the authors emphasize as a limitation of the study the fact of reflecting only the reality of Brazilian capitals and the Federal District and not the entire national territory.
Since there are sociodemographic and economic differences in Brazil, it is important to consider that the level of poverty can affect behaviours related to health promotion and maintenance. Low purchasing power and low schooling level are clearly related to poorer health conditions( 3 ). The influence of schooling on risk behaviours reinforces the hypothesis of social determination of these behaviours.
Risk behaviour patterns reflect the inequalities and vulnerability of some social segments. These inequalities were well described in the study of Barros et al.( Reference Barros, Lima and Medina 18 ) with data from the PNS 2013, which detected differences in the prevalence of health risk behaviours (smoking, alcohol abuse, sedentary behaviour, below-recommended consumption of fruits and vegetables, among others) by gender and schooling level. The results of the present study reinforce the need to consider those differences in the development of public policies aiming at the promotion of healthy behaviours.
In the present study, ‘Physical inactivity in leisure time and Inadequate consumption of fruits and vegetables’ was the main pattern, explaining 18·43 % of the variance. A similar pattern was verified by Camões and Lopes( Reference Camões and Lopes 32 ) in Portuguese adults, who found an association between higher level of physical activity and consumption of a healthy diet. Also, in their study with French women, Estaquio et al.( Reference Estaquio, Pecollo and Latino 33 ) observed that the most active were those with higher consumption of fruits, vegetables and greens.
When assessing the low adherence to fruit and vegetable consumption, mainly in low economic groups( Reference Monsivais, Aggarwal and Drewnowski 34 ), access to these foods should be considered, mainly determined by the population’s purchasing power, given that greater monetary expenditure on food is associated with consumption of healthier foods, more specifically greater intake of fruits and vegetables( Reference Mackeback, Brage and Forouhl 35 ). This fact may explain, at least in part, the greater adherence to the ‘Physical inactivity in leisure time and Inadequate consumption of fruits and vegetables’ pattern verified in the present study for the population with lower schooling level and residing in less developed regions of the country (North and Northeast). Another possible explanation may be the issue of urban violence, since it inhibits the population to practise outdoor physical activities in leisure time, especially women. The North and Northeast regions include coincidentally the six states with the highest homicide rate in the country( 36 ).
In the present study, the ‘Saturated fat’ pattern, which explained 13·42 % of the variance, may be reflecting cultural aspects as well as greater access to sources of high-fat foods. Meat consumption contributes to the excessive intake of saturated fat, this habit being spread throughout the national territory and incorporated more strongly in the gastronomic culture of some regions, considering that Brazil is among the great powers in beef and chicken production( 37 ). In 2015, among the twenty municipalities with the largest beef production, thirteen were in the Central-West region, five in the North region and two in the South region( 38 ), a fact that may justify the greater adherence to the ‘Saturated fat’ pattern in Central-West and South regions. Such results also reflect the differentiated conditions of food intake according to the different economic and social scenarios of the country, since the economically more developed regions (South, Southeast and Central-West) presented high levels of fat intake, especially saturated fats, according to the 2008–2009 Household Budget Survey( 39 ).
The high intake of meat is a concern of health agencies and entities, such as the Brazilian Society of Cardiology, in developing the first guideline on the consumption of fats and cardiovascular health( Reference Santos, Gagliardi and Xavier 40 ). However, there has been an increase in the consumption of meat with excess fat in Brazil, which, according to data from VIGITEL 2016( 41 ), was 26·9 % in 2015 and 32·0 % in 2016, two times more frequent among men( Reference Santos, Gagliardi and Xavier 40 , 42 ), showing the need for action on food education.
Another intake behaviour pattern in the Brazilian adult population was the ‘Alcohol and Smoking’ one and both are responsible for millions of deaths each year( 43 ). The excessive consumption of alcoholic beverages is associated with other risk behaviours, especially smoking( 44 , Reference Anand and Roy 45 ), as was identified in a systematic review conducted in the UK( Reference Meader, King and Byrne 46 ). It is worth noting that the additive effects of those substances have harmful consequences on health and on society in general, especially in the economic sphere, since they have an impact on safety, the labour market and societal security( 44 , 47 , 48 ).
Excessive consumption of alcoholic beverages and tobacco use are risk behaviours that usually begin at an early age and last a lifetime( Reference Heron, Macleod and Munafo 49 ), especially among men and individuals with lower schooling level( Reference Anand and Roy 45 ). In Brazil, alcohol abuse is also more frequent among men and occasional smokers( Reference Garcia and Freitas 30 ) and smoking, in turn, is also associated with men and populations with lower levels of education( Reference Malta, Vieira and Szwarcwald 50 ). In the present study, greater adherence to the ‘Alcohol and Smoking’ pattern was observed among men and among individuals with lower schooling levels, in line with other studies( Reference Garcia and Freitas 30 , 44 , Reference Malta, Vieira and Szwarcwald 50 ).
Similar to that observed in the present study with regard to the ‘Sedentary behaviour and Sugar’ pattern, in a study carried out in the city of Minneapolis (USA), Fuglestad et al.( Reference Fuglestad, Jeffery and Sherwood 7 ) verified that the pattern denominated ‘Visualization and feeding related to television’ was characterized by high intake of sugar and fat.
Excessive time in front of the television and its influence on food behaviour have been investigated in the adult population( Reference Cleland, Schmidt and Dwyer 51 – Reference Heinonen, Helajärvi and Pahkala 53 ). The high prevalence of sedentary behaviour (28·9 %) in the Brazilian population( Reference Mielke, Hallal and Rodrigues 54 ) may favour the consumption of obesogenic foods, commonly linked to television advertisements, contributing to the replacement of fruit and vegetable consumption by unhealthy foods( Reference Cleland, Schmidt and Dwyer 51 – Reference Heinonen, Helajärvi and Pahkala 53 , Reference Rehm, Matte and Wye 55 ).
The pattern named ‘Sedentary behaviour and Sugar’ presented greater adherence among the population of lower age groups and higher schooling. Higher consumption of sweet foods among adults with higher schooling levels was previously described in Brazil( Reference Claro, Santos and Oliveira 56 ) and adolescents also have greater consumption of foods with a high amount of solid fats and with added sugar( Reference Pereira, Duffey and Sichieri 57 ).
Modifying risk behaviours for NCD can reduce all-cause mortality rates( 2 , 3 ) and thus identifying patterns of such behaviours is important to assist in controlling this group of diseases. However, knowing the patterns is not enough; it is necessary to adopt preventive actions aimed at reducing risk behaviours through public health policies that consider behaviour patterns present in the population. According to the WHO, for the effectiveness of policies aimed at the prevention of NCD, besides the issues related to legislation, mass education is critical, since behavioural changes are difficult to happen in the absence of environmental changes that reflect local characteristics and that respect the cultural component( 2 ).
Furthermore, the additional analysis in the current study showed that the behaviours do not seem to be modified in the presence of a chronic disease. Therefore, we should consider actions for the entire population, regardless of the diagnosis of some diseases.
Despite the innovative approach and representativeness of the evaluated population, the present study presents some limitations. Among them is the sedentary behaviour indicator evaluated, in which little active work (like remaining seated) and the time spent in front of other types of screen (computer monitor, tablet, smartphone) were not measured, considering that these behaviours can contribute to total sedentary time in adults. Another possible limitation was the measurement of physical activity or sport only in leisure time. However, this strategy was adopted by the study to prioritize personal choices, without considering involuntary or compulsory physical activities, such as those practised in routine work or in active transportation (walking from place to place). In addition, behaviour factors were defined based on a few questions about diet. Another limitation is related to the contextual variable regions of the country, which may be confounded by individual-level characteristics, age distribution and education. However, for public policies both levels of information is important.
One of the strengths of the present study is the use of a probabilistic sample of Brazilian adults, using an appropriate technique of statistical analysis to group risk factors, considering that most of the research carried out on this subject in the country is restricted to evaluating the occurrence of risk factors alone or only the co-occurrence of factors in populations limited to states or regions, being mostly studies in the South and Southeast regions.
Conclusion
The risk behaviour patterns for NCD reflected the socio-economic and demographic differences found in Brazil. This analysis, based on data from a nationally representative health survey, allowed the identification of Brazilian behavioural diversity in relation to lifestyle, considering several risk factors for NCD, in a holistic approach and integrated understanding of these behaviours. Our results indicate that public policies in a continental country such as Brazil should be tailored to better reach the less developed areas in the North and Northeast of the country. Also, gender and generational differences as observed in other countries should also be considered.
Acknowledgements
Acknowledgements: The authors are grateful to the Ministry of Health of Brazil and the Secretary of Health Surveillance for supporting and financing the health survey (NHS 2013). Financial support: A.P.P.D. received a PhD grant awarded by the National Scientific and Technological Development Council (CNPq). CNPq had no role in the design, analysis or writing of this article. Conflict of interest: None. Authorship: A.P.P.D. wrote this study, reviewed the literature and performed the analysis. P.R.M.R. and A.P.M. proposed the study analysis, performed the revision of the analysis and reviewed the literature. M.G.F. and D.B.C. performed the revision of the analysis, participated in the study design, reviewed the literature and helped with the discussion. N.F.M. and R.S. performed the critical review of the manuscript and helped with the discussion section. All authors contributed to multiple revisions of the article. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. Ethics of human subject participation: This study was conducted according to the guidelines laid down in the Declaration of Helsinki and all procedures involving human subjects were approved by the National Commission of Ethics for Research in Human Beings, of the Ministry of Health, under the opinion number 328,159. Written informed consent was obtained from all subjects.
Supplementary material
To view supplementary material for this article, please visit https://doi.org/10.1017/S136898001900034X
