Stroke mortality is decreasing in Western European countries,Reference Kunst, Amiri and Janssen 1 - Reference Benatru, Rouaud and Durier 4 the United States of America (USA)Reference Benatru, Rouaud and Durier 4 and globally.Reference Kunst, Amiri and Janssen 1 The incidence of stroke is also declining or stable in the USA,Reference Broderick 6 China,Reference Cheng, Ziegler and Lai 8 Japan,Reference Kubo, Kiyohara and Ninomiya 9 , Reference Morikawa, Nakagawa and Naruse 10 Denmark,Reference Thorvaldsen, Davidsen, Brønnum-Hansen and Schroll 11 Finland,Reference Sivenius, Tuomilehto and Immonen-Räihä 3 France,Reference Benatru, Rouaud and Durier 4 EnglandReference Rothwell, Coull and Giles 12 and New Zealand.Reference Anderson, Carter and Hackett 13 Conversely, stroke mortality is increasing in Eastern European and Central Asian countries.Reference Redon, Olsen and Cooper 14 Stroke demographics are changing with the aging of western populations.Reference Niessen, Barendregt, Bonneux and Koudstaal 15 , Reference Börsch-Supan and Chiappori 16 Yet, stroke continues to be a significant burden, as the second leading cause of death worldwide.Reference Lozano, Naghavi and Foreman 17 Not all stroke mortality data from these studies are equivalent, as some used all-cause mortality per 100,000,Reference Kunst, Amiri and Janssen 1 , Reference Carandang, Seshadri and Beiser 5 , Reference Broderick 6 others 28-day mortality after first stroke,Reference Sivenius, Tuomilehto and Immonen-Räihä 3 , Reference Benatru, Rouaud and Durier 4 and others used 30-day, 1-year and 5-year mortality for first stroke hospitalization.Reference Schmidt, Jacobsen, Johnsen, Bøtker and Sørensen 2 Where trends in mortality were reviewed by stroke types, reductions in both ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke mortality were observed.
Reduced rates of stroke in-hospital mortality may have an effect on discharge destination, and consequently the need for support services. For example, more patients may require inpatient rehabilitation or long-term care as more stroke patients are surviving. Factors such as hospital type, patient demographics, and stroke type have been shown to affect discharge destination.Reference Mayo, Hendlisz, Goldberg, Korner-Bitensky, Becker and Coopersmith 18 , Reference Fonarow, Reeves and Smith 19 Trends in discharge destination reflect improvement in acute stroke care but suggest that rehabilitative services and long-term care will require ongoing improvement to respond to an increase in demand.
We reviewed 10-year trends in stroke occurrence and mortality for Canada. Specifically, we looked at stroke admissions across Canada by province and age group and stroke admission rates for all stroke types. We also separately reviewed 30-day in-hospital mortality for all strokes, ischemic strokes, intracerebral hemorrhagic strokes, and subarachnoid hemorrhagic strokes. We reviewed discharge destination for all strokes, ischemic strokes and hemorrhagic strokes discharged alive from acute care.
Methods
We conducted an analysis of all stroke patients admitted to a hospital for acute care in Canada. Data are from the Canadian Institutes for Health Information (CIHI). The population of Canada in 2013 was 35,158,304 compared to 31,641,630 in 2003. 20 Canada has a universal healthcare system, where all Canadian citizens and permanent residents have access to hospital and physician care. Health services are administered by each of its ten provinces and three territories. The CIHI’s Discharge Abstract Database (DAD) contains demographic, administrative and clinical data (including deaths, sign-outs and transfers) on all inpatient hospital discharges. All hospitals in Canada (with the exception of Quebec) are required to report to the DAD; Quebec reports their data through a different process. 21 Analysis of hospital chart coding in teaching and community hospitals in Canada showed excellent positive predictive value (85% for ischemic stroke, 98% for intracerebral hemorrhagic stroke, and 91% for subarachnoid hemorrhagic stroke) with a Kappa statistic (as a measure of agreement between coder and researcher) of 0.89 for International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, 10th Revision (ICD-10) coding.Reference Kokotailo and Hill 22
We used hospital administrative data from April 1st 2003 to March 31st 2013 from the DAD. All acute care facilities in all Canadian provinces contributed to the DAD with the exception of Manitoba (began in April 1st 2004) and Quebec (began in fiscal year 2008/09, ended in 2011/12). Therefore, all stroke patients admitted to hospital for acute care in Canada from April 1st 2003 to March 31st 2013 were included except for Manitoba and Quebec, who contributed only partially based on the above participation periods. Stroke patients were identified in our analysis using standardized case definitions based on ICD-10 codes for acute stroke, acute stroke plus transient ischemic attach (TIA), ischemic stroke, aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage, and intracerebral hemorrhage. [Table 1]
ICD-10 Codes Used
+ Includes all patients where there is a Prefix Q for query or suspected diagnosis
a Excludes I63.6, cerebral infarction due to cerebral venous thrombosis, nonpyogenic
b Excludes I60.8, other subarachnoid hemorrhage (Meningeal hemorrhage and rupture of cerebral arteriovenous malformation)
Stroke admission rates were calculated and standardized using the direct method to the Canadian census. Ten-year trends were assessed using standardized rates. We used the Canadian census data (2001, 2006 and 2011) to estimate the population of 2003-2005, 2007-2010, and 2012; and adjusted 2011 data as the standard population. Stroke in-hospital mortality was defined as the risk-adjusted rate of all-cause in-hospital death occurring within 30 days of first admission to an acute care hospital with a diagnosis of stroke. Specifically, the numerator is the number of deaths from all causes occurring in hospital within 30 days of admission for stroke and the denominator is the total number of stroke episodes. 23 We included stroke that occurred during hospitalization as a complication of hospital admission for another reason. Risk-adjusted rates were adjusted for age, sex, stroke type (ischemic vs. hemorrhagic) and comorbid illness defined by the Charlson-Deyo index (0-1 vs. 2+). Discharge location categories are: home without services; home with services; inpatient rehabilitation or other acute care facility; complex continuing care; long term care; and other. All statistical comparisons were done using Cochran-Armitage Trend Test via SAS 9.3 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA).
Results
Stroke Admissions
We identified 323 230 stroke hospital admissions in Canada from April 2003 to March 2013. Table 2 shows the absolute stroke (all), ischemic stroke, intracerebral hemorrhage, and subarachnoid hemorrhage admissions in Canada over 10 years for each province. We note that absolute numbers of stroke admissions were stable or declining in most provinces except Alberta (AB) and British Columbia (BC), where an increase in stroke numbers was observed. In relative terms, there was an increase in stroke admissions in those provinces of 21.7% (AB) and 16.2% (BC). Similar trends were observed for ischemic stroke admissions with an increase of 23.3% in AB and 15.4% in BC. For intracerebral hemorrhage, increases over the 10-year period were present for all provinces with increases ranging from 50% (New Brunswick) to 4% (Ontario). For subarachnoid hemorrhage, increases were present in Ontario (20.2%), Saskatchewan (10.7%), AB (12.6%), and BC (7.1%).
Absolute hospital admissions for stroke for Canada by Province
Figure 1 shows the standardized risk-adjusted rates of stroke admissions over the 10-year period. The standardized rate of ischemic stroke admissions has dropped by 17.7%. However, the rate of intracerebral hemorrhage and subarachnoid hemorrhage has dropped much less dramatically (10.0% and 7.9% respectively).
10-year trends stroke admission risk adjusted rates (incidence per 100,000 population) for all stroke, ischemic stroke, intracerebral hemorrhagic stroke, and subarachnoid hemorrhagic stroke
A higher proportion of admitted stroke patients were in younger age groups in 2012 compared to 2003 (Table 3). Stroke (all) and ischemic stroke in patients aged less than 40 years old has been stable. For patients aged between 40 and 69, the absolute increase for all strokes was 4.8% (p<0.0001) and for ischemic strokes, 5.4% (p<0.0001). For patients 70 years old and older, the absolute decrease for all strokes was 4.9% (p<0.0001) and for ischemic strokes, 5.6% (p<0.0001). The changes for intracerebral hemorrhage and subarachnoid hemorrhage were less dramatic.
Number (Percent) of Stroke Admissions per Age Group
In-hospital Mortality
We observed a decline for in-hospital 30-day mortality for all stroke patients (Figure 2). For all stroke patients, mortality fell between 2003 to 2012 from 18.5% (95% CI: 18.1%-18.9%) to 14.9% (95% CI: 14.4%-15.2%). For ischemic stroke, it went down from 15.2% (95% CI: 14.8%-15.7%) to 12.1% (95% CI: 11.7%-12.5%). For intracerebral hemorrhage, mortality fell from 35.6% (95% CI: 34.1%-37.1%) to 29.7% (95% CI: 28.3%-31.1%). For subarachnoid hemorrhage, mortality dropped from 25.1% (95% CI: 23.0%-27.2%) to 18.0% (95% CI: 16.1%-19.8%).
10-year trends for 30-day in-hospital risk adjusted mortality rate (death per 100 admitted stroke patients) for all stroke, ischemic stroke, intracerebral hemorrhage, and subarachnoid hemorrhage. Error bars represent 95% Confidence Interval.
Discharge Destination
The discharge destination for all stroke patients discharged alive from acute care is shown in Table 4. For ischemic stroke patients, the following changes were observed: an absolute decrease in the percent of patients discharged home without services by 3.2% (p=0.0463); an absolute increase in the percent discharged home with services by 2.6% (p<0.0001); an absolute increase in the percent of patients discharged to another inpatient acute care facility including inpatient rehabilitation by 5.6% (both p<0.0001), an absolute decrease in the percent being discharged to complex continuing care by 0.9% (p<0.0001) and long term care by 1.9% (p<0.0001). For hemorrhagic strokes, the following changes were observed: an absolute decrease in the percent discharged home without services by 1.7% (p=0.0249), and an absolute increase in the percent discharged home with services of 1.6% (p=0.0214).
Number (percent) of Stroke patients discharged alive to a specific destination from an acute care hospital
Contin.=Continuing
Discussion
Ten-year trends for hospitalized stroke patients in Canada show that absolute stroke admissions are not equal across provinces. When looking at absolute numbers, those provinces that have had large increases in population are shouldering a stark increase in ischemic stroke admissions; this has implications if funding for stroke services does not match the demands of population increases. When taking population increases into account, standardized risk adjusted admission rates have been decreasing for ischemic stroke but the decrease is much less dramatic for intracerebral and subarachnoid hemorrhage. This finding is somewhat similar to an earlier Quebec study (trends from 1990-2005) where ischemic stroke admissions in Quebec were declining but hemorrhagic stroke admissions were increasingReference Mayo, Nadeau, Daskalapoulou and Côté 24 - in contrast we saw a very slight decline in hemorrhagic stroke admissions. This decrease in stroke admission rates may be due to better hypertension control,Reference Campbell and McKay 25 improved stroke prevention strategies, more proactive secondary prevention through the implementation of stroke prevention clinics across Canada or other unmeasured factors. The decline in stroke rates and case fatality and the relative increase in younger strokes can be explained in part by Ontario data on trends in risk factors and stroke subtypes,Reference Bogiatzi, Hackam, McLeod and Spence 26 which showed a relative increase in cardioembolic stroke due to a decrease in large artery stroke and small vessel disease.
The distribution of age groups of stroke admissions is changing and is likely associated with the increasing age of the baby boomer cohort. The proportion of ischemic stroke patients aged 40-69 years old is increasing, and the proportion aged 70 and older is decreasing. A shift to a younger age group was also observed for intracerebral hemorrhagic stroke, where the proportion of patients in age groups under 40 and between 40 and 69 years old is increasing. An increase in the younger stroke victims, who are at the peak of their career and active role in society, will have greater indirect socioeconomic consequences in lost wages and increased costs of caring for younger disabled adults, despite a declining age-adjusted rate overall.
Similar to the findings from the USA and Western European countries,Reference Kunst, Amiri and Janssen 1 - Reference Benatru, Rouaud and Durier 4 stroke mortality was lower in Canada in 2012 compared to 2003. This holds true for ischemic stroke, intracerebral hemorrhage, and subarachnoid hemorrhage. The decrease in mortality can be attributed to better specialized medical care, prevention of secondary complications, and the implementation of in-hospital stroke units. However, the decline in mortality may translate into an overall increase in the number of patients with substantial functional deficits. When we reviewed trends in discharge destinations for stroke patients discharged alive from acute care, we observed a decrease in the percentage of ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke patients going home without services. There is an increase in ischemic stroke patients going to inpatient rehabilitation or other acute facilities, and ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke patients going home with services. However, there is a slight decrease observed in ischemic stroke patients going to complex continuing care and long-term care. The increase in patients going home with services (outpatient) and to inpatient rehabilitation or another acute care institutions is proportionate to the drop in in-hospital mortality, possibly suggesting that a decline in in-hospital mortality is contributing to the increased need for post-acute stroke services. Therefore, although more patients are surviving their stroke, the need for rehabilitation services is increasing.
Limitations
Our data uses only hospital administrative data, so it excludes patients who were never admitted to hospital, (mostly patients with milder strokes), as the number of stroke patients that die before they reach the hospital is small.Reference Morgenstern, Smith and Lisabeth 27 Hospital administrative data is subject to differences in reporting, and despite rigorous abstraction processes, variation in reporting may still be present. Data from Quebec and Manitoba do not include the entire 10-year study period, so we are not reporting the entire 10-year period occurrence across Canada. The use of hospital administrative data requires that we include strokes that were coded as Stroke, not specified as hemorrhage or infarction with acute ischemic strokes. We acknowledge that this does present some error; however, over 80% of all strokes are ischemic strokes and, typically, an ischemic stroke is most often referred to as stroke generally for the small fraction that were coded as not specified.
Conclusions
Ten-year stroke trends in Canada show that admission rates and in-hospital mortality are declining. However, those provinces that are experiencing the largest population growths are shouldering a greater proportion of stroke admissions. This is observed for the two western provinces: Alberta and British Columbia. Furthermore, the proportion of stroke admissions by age groups is showing a significant increase for those patients aged 40-69 and a significant decrease for those patients aged over 70. The decrease in mortality may also be contributing to more patients requiring inpatient and outpatient services.
Acknowledgements and Funding
The authors acknowledge HSF Stroke Quality Advisory Committee members 2013–2015. Funding for this study was received from Heart and Stroke Foundation and the Canadian Stroke Network. Moira Kapral is supported by a Career Investigator Award from the Heart and Stroke Foundation, Ontario Provincial Office.
Disclosures
RC has the following disclosures: Pfizer, Consultant, Honoraria; Bayer, Consultant, Honoraria; BMS, Speaker, Honoraria; Sanofi, Speaker, Honoraria. MH, JF, PL, MK, AND NK do not have anything to disclose.
