Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-wq484 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-29T13:01:52.868Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

CLARE DE GRAFFENREID AND THE ART OF CONTROVERSY: A PRIZEWINNING WOMAN ECONOMIST IN THE FIRST DECADE OF THE AMERICAN ECONOMIC ASSOCIATION

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 August 2012

ROBERT W. DIMAND  and
GEOFFREY BLACK
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The outspoken social reformer Mary Clare de Graffenreid (born 1849, died 1921) stood out among the handful of early women members of the American Economic Association (founded 1885) as the winner of two essay competitions. In 1889, Clare de Graffrenreid’s essay shared the $100 first prize in an AEA essay competition on child labor, and appeared the following year in the Publications of the American Economic Association (1st series, 5, 2, March 1890, pp. 194–271). In 1891 her essay “The Condition of Wage-Earning Women” (published in Forum 15, March 1893, pp. 68–82) won the $300 first prize in an AEA essay competition on women workers (the $200 second prize went to Helen Campbell’s “Women Wage Earners,” 1893). Her valedictory address at Wesleyan Female College in Macon, Georgia, in 1865 provided her first taste of public controversy, as the general commanding Union troops in the area responded by placing the college under guard and threatening to close it, but by far the most controversial of her twenty-seven publications was “The Georgia Cracker in the Cotton Mill” (Century Magazine, February 1891). This paper examines de Graffenreid’s career and contributions, and what her career reveals about the paths for women to participate in the AEA and the American economics profession in the late nineteenth century. After teaching Latin, literature, and mathematics for a decade at Georgetown Female Seminary, de Graffenreid had a non-academic career as an investigator with the Bureau of Labor (from 1888, Department of Labor) from 1886 until she retired in 1906. Despite her AEA prizes, her published lectures to other conferences (YWCA, National Conference of Charities and Correction), and her published testimony to the Industrial Commission on the Relations of Capital and Labor, she was never on the program of an AEA meeting. Like other women economists of her time, de Graffenreid crossed boundaries between scholarly research and social reform, and between different scholarly disciplines (e.g., publishing “Some Social Economic Problems” in American Journal of Sociology, 1896). The paper examines how essay competitions provided women such as de Graffenreid and Campbell (and Julie-Victoire Daubié and Clémence Royer in France) with a voice in the predominately male economics profession of the late nineteenth century.

Type
Research Articles
Information
Journal of the History of Economic Thought , Volume 34 , Issue 3 , September 2012 , pp. 339 - 353
Copyright
Copyright © The History of Economics Society 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Abbott, Edith. 1913a. “Public Pensions to Widows with Children.” American Economic Review 3 (June): 473–478.Google Scholar
Abbott, Edith. 1913b. “Massachusetts Report on Widows’ Pensions.” American Economic Review 3 (September): 739–745.Google Scholar
Balch, Emily Greene. 1893. “Public Assistance of the Poor in France.” Publications of the American Economic Association, First Series, VIII, 4–5: 3–179.Google Scholar
Balch, Emily Greene. 1972. Beyond Nationalism: The Social Thought of Emily Greene Balch. Edited by Randall, Mercedes M.. New York: Twayne Publishers.Google Scholar
Baumol, William J. 1985. “On Method in U.S. Economics a Century Earlier.” American Economic Review 75, 6 (December): 1–12.Google Scholar
Bemis, Edward W. 1891. “Review of Child Labor by William F. Willoughby and Clare De Graffenreid.” Political Science Quarterly 6, 1 (March): 188–189.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berendt, Emil B. 2007. “A Mathematical Note on Msgr. John A. Ryan’s Thought on the Minimum Wage.” Review of Social Economy 64, 4 (December): 459–473.Google Scholar
Bernstein, Michael A. 2008. “A Brief History of the American Economic Association.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology 67, 5 (November): 1007–1023.Google Scholar
Campbell, Helen Stuart. 1887. Prisoners of Poverty: Women Wage-Earners, Their Trades and Their Lives. Boston: Roberts Brothers. Also published as a series of articles in the New York Tribune; reprinted Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1970.Google Scholar
Campbell, Helen Stuart. 1889. Prisoners of Poverty Abroad. Boston: Roberts Brothers.Google Scholar
Campbell, Helen Stuart. 1893. Women Wage-Earners: Their Past, Their Present, and Their Future. Introduction by Ely, Richard T.. Boston: Roberts Brothers. Also published as six articles in Arena 7, January to July (excepting April), 1893; reprinted New York: Arno Press, 1972.Google Scholar
Campbell, Helen Stuart. 1896. Household Economics: A Course of Lectures in the School of Economics at the University of Wisconsin. New York: G.P. Putnam’s Sons.Google Scholar
Clark, John Bates, Wright, Carroll D., Dewey, Davis R., Hadley, Arthur T., and Brooks, J.G.. 1894. “Papers on Labor Problems.” Publications of the American Economic Association, First Series, IX, 5–6: 1–94.Google Scholar
Clary, Betsy Jane. 2008. “The Evolution of the Allied Social Science Associations.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology 67, 5 (November): 985–1005.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coats, A. W. 1960. “The First Two Decades of the American Economic Association.” American Economic Review L (4): 555–574.Google Scholar
Coman, Katharine. 1891. “The Tailoring Trade and the Sweating System.” Publications of the American Economic Association, First Series VI, 1–2 (Fourth Annual Meeting: Reports, Papers, Discussions): 144–147.Google Scholar
Coman, Katharine. 1893. “Wages and Prices in England, 1261–1701.” Journal of Political Economy II, 1 (December): 92–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coman, Katharine. 1903a. “History of Contract Labor in the Hawaiian Islands.” Publications of the American Economic Association, Third Series, IV (3): 1–74. Reprinted New York: Arno Press, 1978.Google Scholar
Coman, Katharine. [1903b] 1917. The Industrial History of the United States. Fourth edition. New York: Macmillan. Reprinted New York: Arno Press, 1975.Google Scholar
Coman, Katharine. 1911a. “Some Unsettled Problems of Irrigation.” American Economic Review I, 1 (March): 1–19.Google Scholar
Coman, Katharine. 1911b. “Government Factories: An Attempt to Control Competition in the Fur Trade.” American Economic Review: Supplement I, 2 (April): 368–388.Google Scholar
Coman, Katharine. 1912. Economic Beginnings of the Far West: How We Won the Land beyond the Mississippi. Two volumes. New York: Macmillan. Reprinted New York: Augustus M. Kelley, Reprints of Economic Classics, 1969.Google Scholar
Coman, Katharine. 1915. Unemployment Insurance: A Summary of European Systems. New York: Progressive National Service. Also published as a series of articles in Survey, American Association for Labor Legislation, 1914–1915.Google Scholar
Cooper, Anna Julia. 1892. A Voice of the South, By a Black Woman from the South. Xenia, Ohio: Aldine Printing House. Reprinted New York: Negro Universities Press, 1969, and in Cooper (1998).Google Scholar
Cooper, Anna Julia. 1899. “Colored Women as Wage-earners.” Southern Workman and Hampton School Record (August 28), pp. 295–298, as reprinted in Shirley Wilson Logan, ed., We Are Coming: The Persuasive Discourse of Nineteenth-Century Black Women. Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press, 1999.Google Scholar
Cooper, Anna Julia. 1925. L’Attitude de la France à l’égard de l’égalité des Races. PhD thesis, Paris: Sorbonne. Translated by. Frances Richardson Keller as Slavery and the French Revolutionists: 1788–1805. Lewiston, NY, and Queenston, ON: Mellen Press, 1988.Google Scholar
Cooper, Anna Julia. 1998. The Voice of Anna Julia Cooper. Edited by Lemert, Charles and Bhan, Esme. New York and Oxford: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
Creighton, Louise von Glehn. 1907. The Economics of the Household: Six Lectures Given at the London School of Economics. London: Longmans, Green & Co.Google Scholar
Dall, Caroline H. 1914. The College, the Market, and the Court, or Women’s Relation to Education, Labor, and Law. Concord, NH: The Rumford Press.Google Scholar
Daubié, Julie-Victoire. 1866. La femme pauvre au XIXe siècle. Paris: Guillaumin.Google Scholar
Dimand, Robert W. 2000. “Nineteenth Century American Feminist Economics: From Caroline Dall to Charlotte Perkins Gilman.” American Economic Review: AEA Papers and Proceedings 90, 2 (May): 480–484.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dimand, Robert W., Dimand, Mary Ann, and Forget, Evelyn L., eds. 2000. A Biographical Dictionary of Women Economists. Cheltenham, UK, and Brookfield, VT: Edward Elgar Publishing.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dimand, Robert W., Black, Geoffrey, and Forget, Evelyn L.. 2011. “Women's Participation in the ASSA Meetings.” Economies et Sociétés: Oikonomia 1, 1 (March): 33–50.Google Scholar
Douglas, Dorothy Wolff, and Douglas, Paul H.. 1921. “Karelsen Prize Essay: What Can a Man Afford?” American Economic Review XI, Supplement No. 2 (December): 1–95.Google Scholar
Eastman, Crystal. 1909. “The American Way of Distributing Industrial Accident Losses.” Publications of the American Economic Association, Third Series, 10, 1 (April): 119–134.Google Scholar
Folbre, Nancy. 1998. “The Sphere of Women in Early Twentieth-Century Economics.” In Silverberg, Helene, ed., Gender and American Social Science. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp. 35–60.Google Scholar
Folbre, Nancy. 2009. Greed, Lust & Gender: A History of Economic Ideas. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Forget, Evelyn L. 1995. “American Women Economists, 1900–1940: Doctoral Dissertations and Research Specializations.” In Dimand, Mary Ann, Dimand, Robert W., and Forget, Evelyn L., eds., Women of Value: Feminist Essays on the History of Women in Economics. Cheltenham, UK, and Brookfield, VT: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 25–38.Google Scholar
Fraisse, Geneviève. 1985. Clémence Royer: Philosophe et femme de sciences. Paris: La Découverte.Google Scholar
Gilman, Charlotte Perkins. 1907. “The Extent of Child Labor in the United States: Discussion.” Publications of the American Economic Association, Third Series, 8, 1 (February): 260.Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1877. “Is George Elliot Irreligious?” Frank Leslie’s Sunday Magazine, Volume II (July), pp. 10–11.Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1890a. “The Needs of Self-Supporting Women.” Johns Hopkins University Studies in Historical and Political Science 8, 1 (January): 79–88.Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1890b. “Child Labor.” Publications of the American Economic Association, First Series, V, 2 (March): 195–271.Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1890c. “A Voice from the Workroom.” The Christian Union XLI (April 3): 497–498.Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1890d. “What Do Working Girls Owe One Another?” Association of Working Girls’ Societies: 75–77.Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1891a. “School and College. London Schools.” The Independent XLIII (January 22).Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1891b. “The Georgia Cracker in the Cotton Mills.” The Century XLI (February):483–493.Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1891c. “`The Georgia Cracker in the Cotton Mills’: Miss de Graffenreid Explains the Motive of Her Much Discussed Article.” Manufacturers’ Record XIX (June 13).Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1891d. “Women in the London County Council.” The Chautauquan XIII (June): 357–360.Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1892. “Working Mothers and Uncared-For Children.” The Congregationalist LXXVII (May 12).Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1893a. “Trade Unions for Women.” Lend a hand, a Record of Progress, Volume X. Also in Near and Far (New York: National League of Women Workers), III, 27 (January 1893).Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1893b. “The Condition of Wage-Earning Women.” The Forum XV (March): 68–82.Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1895a. “Industrial Education.” American Federationist II (May).Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1895b. “The Permanent Improvement of Neighborhoods.” Lend a Hand, a Record of Progress, Volume XV (August).Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1896a. “Problems of Poverty and Pauperism: Need of Better Homes for Wage-Earners.” The Forum XV (May).Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1896b. “Compulsory Education.” Lend a Hand, a Record of Progress, Volume XVI (June).Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1896c. “The New Woman and Her Debts.” Appleton’s Popular Science Monthly XLIX (September).Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1896d. “Some Social Economic Problems.” American Journal of Sociology II, 2 (September): 190–201.Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1897a. “From Home to Throne in Belgium.” Harper’s New Monthly Magazine XCIV (April).Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1897b. “Typical Alley Houses in Washington.” Senate Report, No. 1297, 54 Cong. 2 Sess., 3–7.Google Scholar
de Graffenreid, (Mary) Clare. 1901. “Testimony of Miss Clare de Graffenreid, April 7, 1899.” In Report of Industrial Commission on the Relations and Conditions of Capital and Labor Employed in Manufacturing and General Business. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, pp. 218–233.Google Scholar
Dorfman, Joseph. 1936. “The Founding and Early History of the American Economic Association.” American Economic Review XXVI: 141–150.Google Scholar
Dorfman, Joseph. 1946–59. The Economic Mind in American Civilization. Five volumes. New York: Viking.Google Scholar
Ely, Richard T. 1893. “Prizes.” Handbook of the American Economic Association, pp. 8–9.Google Scholar
Furner, Mary O. 1975. Advocacy and Objectivity: A Crisis in the Professionalization of American Social Science, 1865–1905. Lexington: University Press of Kentucky.Google Scholar
Haskell, Thomas L. (1977) The Emergence of Professional Social Science: The American Social Science Association and the Nineteenth-Century Crisis of Authority. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.Google Scholar
Kyrk, Hazel. 1923. A Theory of Consumption. New York and Boston: Houghton Mifflin.Google Scholar
Leiby, James. 1960. Carroll Wright and Labor Reform: The Origins of Labor Statistics. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Madden, Kirsten K., Seiz, Janet A., and Pujol, Michèle. 2004. A Bibliography of Female Economic Thought to 1940. London and New York: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rader, Benjamin G. 1966. The Academic Mind and Reform: The Influence of Richard T. Ely in American Life. Kentucky: University of Kentucky Press.Google Scholar
Ross, Dorothy. 1991. The Origins of American Social Science. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Royer, Clémence-Auguste (pseudonym of Opportune Fervent). 1862. Théorie de l’impôt, ou la Dîme sociale. Two volumes. Paris: Guillaumin.Google Scholar
Ryan, John A. [1906] 1920. A Living Wage. Introduction by Ely, Richard T.. New York: Macmillan. Reprinted New York: Arno Press, 1971.Google Scholar
Sandmo, Agnar. 2007. “Retrospectives: Léon Walras and the Nobel Peace Prize.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 21, 4 (Fall): 217–228.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Scheftel, Yetta. 1916. The Taxation of Land Value: A Study of Certain Discriminatory Taxes on Land. Boston: Houghton Mifflin (Hart, Schaffner & Marx Prize Essays, No. 22).Google Scholar
Sewall, Hannah Robie. 1901. “Theory of Value before Adam Smith.” Publications of the American Economic Association, Third Series, II, 3: 1–132. Reprinted New York: Augustus M. Kelley, Reprints of Economic Classics, 1968, 1971.Google Scholar
Sewall, Hannah Robie. 1904. Child Labor in the U.S. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, U.S. Bureau of Labor Bulletin No. 52 (May): 485–637.Google Scholar
Starr, Martha A. 2008. “Consumption, Hours of Work, and Values in the Writings of John A. Ryan: Is it Possible to Return to the Road Not Taken?” Review of Social Economy 66, 1 (March): 7–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Steelman, Lala Carr. 1966. “Mary Clare de Graffenreid: The Saga of a Crusader for Social Reform.” In Steelman, John, ed., Studies in the History of the South, 1875–1922. Greenville, NC: Department of History, East Carolina College, Publications in History, Volume 3, pp. 53–83.Google Scholar
Steelman, Lala Carr. 1971. “De Graffenreid, Mary Clare.” In James, Edward T., ed., Notable American Women: A Biographical Dictionary. Volume I. Three volumes. Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, pp. 452–454.Google Scholar
Whites, LeeAnn. 1988. “The De Graffenreid Controversy: Class, Race, and Gender in the New South.” Journal of Southern History LIV, 3 (August): 449–478.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Willoughby, William F. 1890. “Child Labor.” Publications of the American Economic Association, First Series, V, 2 (March), pp. 123–194.Google Scholar
Wright, Carroll D. 1886. Industrial Depressions: First Annual Report of the Commissioner of Labor. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. Reprinted New York: Augustus M. Kelley, Reprints of Economic Classics, 1968.Google Scholar
Wright, Carroll D. 1888. “Statistics in College,” Publications of the American Economic Association, First Series, Volume III, No. 1, pp. 5–28.Google Scholar