INTRODUCTION
The transition from the last interglacial to the last glacial period occurred between ~120 and 110 thousand years ago (ka, before AD 1950) and was characterized by progressive ice-sheet growth in response to the climatic amplification of astronomical forcing through the Earth's internal feedback (Landais et al., Reference Landais, Masson-Delmotte, Jouzel, Raynaud, Johnsen, Huber, Leuenberger, Schwander and Minster2006; Capron et al., Reference Capron, Landais, Chappellaz, Schilt, Buiron, Dahl-Jensen and Johnsen2010, Reference Capron, Landais, Chappellaz, Buiron, Fischer, Johnsen, Jouzel, Leuenberger, Masson-Delmotte and Stocker2012 and references therein). At least one-quarter of ice-sheet volume during full glacial conditions was reached during Marine Oxygen Isotope Stage (MIS) 5d. This transition is also associated with an abrupt millennial-scale warming event first identified in North Atlantic marine records (Chapman and Shackleton, Reference Chapman and Shackleton1999; Oppo et al., Reference Oppo, McManus and Cullen2006), identified as Dansgaard-Oeschger (DO) event 25 in the NGRIP δ18O record (NGRIP Project Members, 2004).
DO events are one of the classical features of the last glacial period (NGRIP Project Members, 2004). A DO event in Greenland is described as an abrupt warming of 8°C–16°C within a few decades (Kindler et al., Reference Kindler, Guillevic, Baumgartner, Schwander, Landais and Leuenberger2014 and references therein), leading to peak interstadial conditions, Greenland interstadial (GI), followed by a gradual cooling, and finally ending in rapid return to the cold stadial state, Greenland Stadial (GS). These abrupt climate changes have been recorded in numerous paleoclimatic archives worldwide (Porter and An, Reference Porter and An1995; Chapman and Shackleton, Reference Chapman and Shackleton1999; Leuschner and Sirocko, Reference Leuschner and Sirocko2000; Wang et al., Reference Wang, Cheng, Edwards, An, Wu, Shen and Dorale2001; Voelker, Reference Voelker2002; NGRIP Project Members, 2004; EPICA Community Members, 2006; Zhao et al., Reference Zhao, Wang, Edwards, Cheng and Liu2010; Baumgartner et al., Reference Baumgartner, Kindler, Eicher, Floch, Schilt, Schwander and Spahni2014; Zhang et al., Reference Zhang, Xiao, Chou, Cai, Lone, Shen and Jiang2020) and persisted through the entire last glacial period.
As an abrupt climate event during the MIS 5d, GI 25 is very similar in pattern and transition to those observed during MIS 3 in the Greenland ice-core δ18O record (NGRIP Project Members, 2004; Rasmussen et al., Reference Rasmussen, Bigler, Blockley, Blunier, Buchardt, Clausen and Cvijanovic2014). Climate excursions are also clearly registered in cave records from southern Europe, providing the first direct, independent, and radiometrically derived estimates for the timing of GI 25 and GI 24 (Drysdale et al., Reference Drysdale, Zanchetta, Hellstrom, Fallick, McDonald and Cartwright2007; Boch et al., Reference Boch, Cheng, Spötl, Edwards, Wang and Häuselmann2011; Columbu et al., Reference Columbu, Drysdale, Capron, Woodhead, Waele, Sanna, Hellstrom and Bajo2017; Moseley et al., Reference Moseley, Spötl, Brandstätter, Erhardt, Luetscher and Edwards2020). A detailed comparison of the NGRIP record with multiple indicators shows GI 25 does not match hydroclimate changes at low-latitude zones (Capron et al., Reference Capron, Landais, Chappellaz, Buiron, Fischer, Johnsen, Jouzel, Leuenberger, Masson-Delmotte and Stocker2012). Such an equivocal fingerprint raises the question of whether GI 25 is simply a rapid event. Interestingly, two high-resolution stalagmite δ18O records from Sanbao Cave in central China and Bittoo Cave in northern India provided unambiguous evidence of a strengthened GI 25 monsoon event at MIS 5d, concurring with the contemporaneous event in the Greenland δ18O record (Wang et al., Reference Wang, Cheng, Edwards, Kong, Shao, Chen, Wu, Jiang, Wang and An2008; Kathayat et al., Reference Kathayat, Cheng, Sinha, Spötl, Edwards, Zhang, Li, Yi, Ning, Cai, Liu and Breitenbach2016). But records from the caves of Suozi (Zhou et al., Reference Zhou, Zhao, Zhang, Shen, Chi, Feng, Lin, Guan and You2008) and Wanxiang (Johnson et al., Reference Johnson, Ingram, Sharp and Zhang2006) in monsoonal China show no clear evidence for this abrupt event (Fig. 1). Thus, there is still a debate whether the decoupling between low- and high-latitude climate conditions occurred during the last glacial inception (Zhou et al., Reference Zhou, Zhao, Zhang, Shen, Chi, Feng, Lin, Guan and You2008; Wu et al., Reference Wu, Li, Yu, Shen, Chen, Zhang, Li, Wang, Huang and Xiao2020).
A world map with summer (June–July–August) mean 850 hPa vector wind based on the National Centers for Environmental Prediction/National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCEP/NCAR) Reanalysis (1960–2020). The red triangles represent the Lianhau (LH), and Dragon Caves (LD) (this study). Black triangles represent the Sanbao (SB; Wang et al., Reference Wang, Cheng, Edwards, Kong, Shao, Chen, Wu, Jiang, Wang and An2008), Wanxiang (WX; Johnson et al., Reference Johnson, Ingram, Sharp and Zhang2006), Suozi (SZ; Zhou et al., Reference Zhou, Zhao, Zhang, Shen, Chi, Feng, Lin, Guan and You2008), Dongge (DG; Yuan et al., Reference Yuan, Cheng, Edwards, Dykoski, Kelly, Zhang and Qin2004; Kelly et al., Reference Kelly, Edwards, Cheng, Yuan, Zhang and An2006), Sanxing (SX; Jiang et al., Reference Jiang, Wang, He, Hu, Li, Spötl and Shen2016), and Bittoo (BT; Kathayat et al., Reference Kathayat, Cheng, Sinha, Spötl, Edwards, Zhang, Li, Yi, Ning, Cai, Liu and Breitenbach2016) Caves in the southeastern Asian monsoon region; Schneckthe loch (SL; Moseley et al., Reference Moseley, Spötl, Brandstätter, Erhardt, Luetscher and Edwards2020), Grete-Ruth shaft (GR; Boch et al., Reference Boch, Cheng, Spötl, Edwards, Wang and Häuselmann2011), Antrodrl-Corchia (AC; Drysdale et al., Reference Drysdale, Zanchetta, Hellstrom, Fallick, McDonald and Cartwright2007), and Bue Marino (BM; Columbu et al., Reference Columbu, Drysdale, Capron, Woodhead, Waele, Sanna, Hellstrom and Bajo2017) Caves in southern Europe nearby the Mediterranean Sea; and Caverna Botuverá Cave (CB; Cruz et al., Reference Cruz, Burns, Karmann, Sharp, Vuille, Cardoso, Ferrari, Dias and Viana2005) in Brazil, South America. The black dot represents the International Ocean Discovery Program sediment core (ODP) 985 (Oppo et al., Reference Oppo, McManus and Cullen2006); and the black square represents the North Greenland Ice Core Project (NGRIP; NGRIP Members, 2004). The Asian summer monsoon is a steady flow of warm, moist air from the tropical oceans, while the winter monsoon is a flow of cold, dry air associated with the Siberian–Mongolian High.
Recently, significant and rapid cold–warm climate oscillations within DO events have been documented in Greenland ice cores, especially during MIS 5 (Capron et al., Reference Capron, Landais, Chappellaz, Schilt, Buiron, Dahl-Jensen and Johnsen2010; Rasmussen et al., Reference Rasmussen, Bigler, Blockley, Blunier, Buchardt, Clausen and Cvijanovic2014). Such multicentennial-scale climate excursions were also reported in Alpine cave records (Boch et al., Reference Boch, Cheng, Spötl, Edwards, Wang and Häuselmann2011), southern Italian lacustrine sediments (Martin-Puertas et al., Reference Martin-Puertas, Brauer, Wulf, Lauterbach and Dulske2014), and Mediterranean cave deposits (Columbu et al., Reference Columbu, Drysdale, Capron, Woodhead, Waele, Sanna, Hellstrom and Bajo2017). For example, a high-resolution cave record from Sardinia first revealed a cool-dry to warm-wet oscillation independently associated with the first intra-GI/GS events GI 25a–c (Columbu et al., Reference Columbu, Drysdale, Capron, Woodhead, Waele, Sanna, Hellstrom and Bajo2017). However, no proxy record with detailed structure for DO 25 in the low-latitude Asian monsoon region is available. To fully understand the monsoonal climate variability on multicentennial-to-millennial scales, high-resolution and precisely dated cave records are required.
Here, we report a multidecadally resolved stalagmite δ18O record from the Lianhua and Dragon Caves in northern China, near the eastern boundary of the Chinese Loess Plateau (CLP), where very limited well-dated proxy records are currently available. High resolution sampling and more U-Th dates with uncertainties of ± 100s yr allows us to reconstruct the East Asian summer monsoon (EASM) evolution at multicentennial-to-millennial time scales during MIS 5d. Our new Lianhua–Dragon records show millennial-scale GI/GS 25 monsoon events occurring at 114.6–108.3 ka, substages of intra-interstadial oscillations of the GI 25 monsoon event, and the linkage to low- and high-latitude hydroclimates at MIS 5d.
STUDY SITE
Two caves, Lianhua (38°10′N, 113°43′E, 1200 m above sea level [m asl]) and Dragon (36°46′N, 113°13′E, 1600 m asl), 150 km apart in Shanxi Province, northern China, were selected for the present study (Fig. 1). Both caves had small entrances, 1 m in height and 2 m in width, and developed in the same carbonate bedrock, Ordovician limestone. Their narrow passages, 1–2 m in height, were 250 and 1000 m long, respectively. Relative humidity in the inner part, 170 m to the cave entrance, reaches 98%–100% in both caves. The overlying soil layer on the limestone above the caves is thin, only 0–1 m, favorable to rapidly communicate the external climate signal into the cave (Dong et al., Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Jiang2015, Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Duan2018a). The EASM strongly influences this area, and the hydroclimate is characterized by warm-wet summers and cool-dry winters. The region receives maximum precipitation (almost 75% of the annual rainfall) between June and September when the summer monsoon prevails (Dong et al., Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Jiang2015, Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Duan2018a, Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wu, Hu, Ren and Wang2018b).
Local ground air temperature for Lianhua Cave is 11.0°C, and annual precipitation is 515 mm (AD 1970–AD 2000; recorded in a meteorological station Yangquan, 20 km from the cave). For Dragon Cave, the local air temperature is 10.3°C, and the local annual precipitation is 530 mm (AD 1970–AD 2000; meteorological station Wuxiang, 18 km from the cave).
SAMPLES AND METHODS
One stalagmite, LH36, 206 mm in length and 80–110 mm in diameter, was collected in a chamber 200 m from the entrance of Lianhua Cave. Another stalagmite, L4, 126 mm in length and 55–70 mm in diameter, was collected in the gallery 600 m from the entrance of Dragon Cave. Both stalagmites were sectioned along the vertical growth axis using a water-cooled saw (Fig. 2). For LH36, alternating changes of the petrography are observed at 33–35 and 153–155 mm intervals from the top (Fig. 2a), indicating possible growth discontinuities. The lower part from 155–206 mm is characterized with milky-white layering. Stalagmite L4 is very clean and composed of transparent and compact calcite throughout the whole growing period. Only one white clay lamina is observed at 115 mm from the top, suggesting a possible hiatus (Fig. 2b).
Photographs of stalagmite samples (a) LH36 of Lianhua Cave and (b) L4 of Dragon Cave. Horizontal layers denote the subsamples drilled for U-Th dating. Black dashed lines represent the depositional hiatuses. Orange vertical dashed lines show the paths for carbon and oxygen isotopic measurement.
Twenty-eight subsamples, 19 from LH36 and 9 from L4 (Fig. 2, Table 1), with a weight range from 100 to 200 mg, were drilled parallel to the growth plane for U-Th chemistry (Shen et al., Reference Shen, Cheng, Edwards, Moran, Edmonds, Hoff and Thomas2003) and dating (Shen et al., Reference Shen, Lawrence Edwards, Cheng, Dorale, Thomas, Bradley Moran, Weinstein and Edmonds2002, Reference Shen, Wu, Cheng, Edwards, Hsieh, Gallet and Chang2012). U-Th isotopic measurement was performed on a multicollector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (MC-ICP-MS), Thermo Finnigan NEPTUNE, housed at the High-Precision Mass Spectrometry and Environment Change Laboratory (HISPEC), Department of Geosciences, National Taiwan University, and at the Nanjing Normal University Isotope Laboratory (Shen et al., Reference Shen, Wu, Cheng, Edwards, Hsieh, Gallet and Chang2012; Shao et al., Reference Shao, Li, Huang, Liao, Arps, Huang, Chou and Kong2019). A gravimetrically calibrated (Cheng et al., Reference Cheng, Edwards, Shen, Polyak, Asmerom, Woodhead and Hellstrom2013) triple-spike, 229Th-233U-236U, isotope-dilution method was applied to correct the mass bias and determine the U-Th contents and isotopic compositions (Shen et al., Reference Shen, Wu, Cheng, Edwards, Hsieh, Gallet and Chang2012). Uncertainties in isotopic data and dates relative to AD 1950, are given at the 2σ level or 2 standard deviations of the mean (2σm). Half-lives of nuclides used for age calculation are given in Cheng et al. (Reference Cheng, Edwards, Shen, Polyak, Asmerom, Woodhead and Hellstrom2013). StalAge algorithm techniques (Scholz and Hoffmann, Reference Scholz, Hoffmann, Hellstrom and Bamsey2012) were used to construct the age models.
Uranium and thorium isotopic compositions and 230Th ages for stalagmites L4 (Dragon Cave) and LH36 (Lianhua) using a multicollector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer MC-ICP-MS.
a An asterisk (*) indicates samples were measured by the Nanjing Normal University Isotope Laboratory.
b [238U] = [235U] × 137.818 (±0.65‰) (Hiess et al., Reference Hiess, Condon, McLean and Noble2012); δ234U = ([234U/238U]activity − 1) × 1000.
c [230Th/238U]activity = 1 − e−λ230T + (δ234Umeasured/1000)[λ230/(λ230 − λ234)](1 − e−(λ230 − λ234)T), where T is the age.
Decay constants are 9.1705 × 10−6/yr for 230Th, 2.8221 × 10−6/yr for 234U (Cheng et al., Reference Cheng, Edwards, Shen, Polyak, Asmerom, Woodhead and Hellstrom2013), and 1.55125 × 10−10/yr for 238U (Jaffey et al., Reference Jaffey, Flynn, Glendenin, Bentley and Essling1971).
d δ234Uinitial corrected was calculated based on 230Th age (T), i.e., δ234Uinitial = δ234Umeasured × eλ234*T, where T is corrected age.
e Age corrections, relative to before AD 1950, were calculated using an estimated atomic 230Th/232Th atomic ratio of 4 ± 2 × 10−6. Those are the values for material at secular equilibrium, with the crustal 232Th/238U value of 3.8. The errors are arbitrarily assumed to be 50%.
f Analytical errors are 2σ of the mean.
For stable isotope analysis, carbonate subsamples were drilled out with a 0.3-mm-diameter carbide dental bur at 1 mm intervals for the upper segment (30–153 mm) and at 0.5 mm intervals for the lower part (153–206 mm) of stalagmite LH36. Subsamples were retrieved at 1 mm intervals for the depth range of 0–116 mm for stalagmite L4 (Fig. 2). Stable isotope analysis was carried out on 340 powdered samples (Supplementary Table 1), each weighing 20–40 μg, using a Finnigan-MAT 253 mass spectrometer equipped with an automated Kiel Carbonate Device at the College of Geography Science, Nanjing Normal University. Carbonate δ18O (‰) values are expressed relative to the Vienna Pee Dee Belemnite (VPDB) reference standard. An international standard, NBS-19, was measured every 15–20 subsamples to confirm that a 6 month 1-sigma external error was better than ± 0.06‰ for δ18O.
RESULTS
Chronology
The U-Th isotopic composition, content, and 230Th dates we determined are listed in Table 1. Relatively low 238U content of 0.09–0.34 × 10−6 g/g and high 232Th of 10−1–102 × 10−9 g/g in LH36 layers result in age uncertainties of ± 0.1–2.2 ka. Most (16/19) of the corrected 230Th ages are in stratigraphic order. StalAge algorithm techniques (Scholz and Hoffmann, Reference Scholz, Hoffmann, Hellstrom and Bamsey2012) show an age model from 34.6 ± 0.1 to 110.7 ± 0.9 ka, with two growth hiatuses at depths of 33–35 and 153–155 mm from the top (Fig. 2), identified at 34.6–41.1 and 61.4–108.0 ka, respectively (Fig. 3). The calculated deposition rates are 6 μm/yr for the upper section at 40–150 mm and 21 μm/yr for the lower section at 155–206 mm for stalagmite LH36.
Plots of the age models constructed with the StalAge algorithm (Scholz and Hoffmann, Reference Scholz, Hoffmann, Hellstrom and Bamsey2012) for the two stalagmites, LH36 and L4. Age models for (a) the top 153 mm and (b) 153–206 mm of LH 36 and (c) L4. Black dots denote 230Th dates, and horizontal bars are their 2σ errors. Green and red dashed lines are the age models with 95% confidence intervals.
For stalagmite L4, high 238U levels are 1.0–2.4 × 10−6 g/g. For most layers (8/9), 232Th content is only 0.005–0.097 × 10−9 g/g to yield small errors of ± 0.4–0.7 ka. The exceptionally high 232Th content of 5.93 × 10−9 g/g on subsample L4-117 causes a large error of ± 1.0 ka (Table 1). The determined ages for the top eight layers at a depth interval of 10–114 mm range from 111.6 to 114.8 ka (Fig. 3c). At a depth of 117 mm from the top, the measured age of 197 ka, dramatically different from other ages, indicates a hiatus at a depth of 115 mm. The estimated deposition rate is 36 μm/yr for a depth interval of 0–114 mm for stalagmite L4.
LH36/L4 oxygen isotope records
We have compared the δ18O results obtained from the stalagmites investigated in the present study with the previously published Lianhua–Dragon stalagmite δ18O records at 60–0 ka (Dong et al., Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Jiang2015, Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Duan2018a; Zhang et al., Reference Zhang, Huang, Jiang, Chen, Shen and Dong2021a), as illustrated in Figure 4. This comparison also clearly shows an absence of significant offsets between δ18O records at the overlapping growth intervals. We argue that the spliced δ18O record at 115–108 ka (Fig. 5a) in the two stalagmites in this study, LH36 and L4, unambiguously reflects changes in monsoonal intensity over GI 25 and GS 25.
Comparison of the δ18O for the Lianhua–Dragon stalagmites and quantitatively reconstructed monsoon rainfall records. (a) Pollen-inferred annual precipitation in Bayanchagan Lake, Inner Mongolia, northern China (Jiang et al., Reference Jiang, Guo, Sun, Wu, Chu, Yuan, Hatté and Guiot2006). (b) Lianhua–Dragon δ18O records (Dong et al., Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Jiang2015, Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Duan2018a; Zhang et al., Reference Zhang, Huang, Jiang, Chen, Shen and Dong2021a). Numbers denote Dansgaard-Oeschger (DO) events. (c) Quantitative reconstruction of summer rainfall in western Chinese Loess Plateau (CLP), northern China (Rao et al., Reference Rao, Chen, Cheng, Liu, Wang, Lai and Bloemendal2013). Yellow bars represent weakened East Asian summer monsoon (EASM) periods at Heinrich (H) events and Younger Dryas (YD).
Stalagmite δ18O records from China and northern India. Stalagmite δ18O records are from (a) Lianhua–Dragon (this study) and (b)Wanxiang Caves (Johnson et al., Reference Johnson, Ingram, Sharp and Zhang2006) in northern China, (c) Sanbao and (d) Suozi Caves in central China (Wang et al., Reference Wang, Cheng, Edwards, Kong, Shao, Chen, Wu, Jiang, Wang and An2008; Zhou et al., Reference Zhou, Zhao, Zhang, Shen, Chi, Feng, Lin, Guan and You2008), (e) Sanxing and (f) Dongge Caves in southwestern China (Kelly et al., Reference Kelly, Edwards, Cheng, Yuan, Zhang and An2006; Jiang et al., Reference Jiang, Wang, He, Hu, Li, Spötl and Shen2016), and (g) Bittoo Cave in northern India (Kathayat et al., Reference Kathayat, Cheng, Sinha, Spötl, Edwards, Zhang, Li, Yi, Ning, Cai, Liu and Breitenbach2016). Yellow/gray bars denote increased/decreased Asian summer monsoon (ASM) periods during the Greenland interstadial (GI)/Greenland Stadial (GS) 25 event. The values denote the relative amplitude changes in δ18O during the GS 25 event. 230Th ages and errors are color coded by stalagmite.
The average temporal resolution of δ18O data points of stalagmites LH36 and L4 plotted in Figure 5a is 27–37 yr. The stalagmite δ18O record, ranging from −7.5 to −10.1‰, is characterized with a decreasing trend from −7.5‰ at 114.6 ka to −9.4‰ at 111.4 ka, followed by a 0.7 ka gap to 110.7 ka. The time window from 110.7 to 108.4 ka in the LH36 record is marked by two episodes of enrichment in terms of oxygen isotope ratios. The first one took place at 110.7–110.0 ka with an enrichment of 1.2‰ in δ18O, while the second at 109.5–108.4 ka recorded 2.5‰ enrichment. An abrupt decrease of 2.6‰ in the δ18O record at 108.4 ka marked the end of the GS 25.
DISCUSSION
The interpretation of stalagmite δ18O records
An essential prerequisite for using stalagmite δ18O to reconstruct paleoclimate change is that stalagmites are formed under isotopic equilibrium conditions. Good between-cave reproducibility of contemporaneous δ18O records at 115–108 ka for stalagmites LH36 of Lianhua Cave, L4 of Dragon Cave, and SB23 of Sanbao Cave is also expressed in Figure 5a and c. Moreover, seven stalagmite δ18O records of Lianhua and Dragon Caves over the past 60 ka also show high similarities in terms of event, trend, and amplitude during overlapping growth intervals (Fig. 4b). All lines of evidence indicate a solid replication test (Dorale and Liu, Reference Dorale and Liu2009) and a negligible kinetic effect on Lianhua–Dragon δ18O records, which are primarily of climatic origin.
Modern instrumental observations (Zhang et al., Reference Zhang, Chen, Johnson, Chen, Ingram, Zhang, Zhang, Wang, Pang and Long2004; Li et al., Reference Li, Cheng, Tan, Ban, Sinha, Duan and Li2017; Wan et al., Reference Wan, Liu and Xing2018), proxy records (Zhang et al., Reference Zhang, Cheng, Edwards, Chen, Wang, Yang and Liu2008; Dong et al., Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Jiang2015, Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Duan2018a; Orland et al., Reference Orland, Edwards, Cheng, Kozdon, Cross and Valley2015; Tan et al., Reference Tan, Cai, Cheng, Lawrence Edwards, Shen, Gao and An2015), and model simulations (Liu et al., Reference Liu, Wen, Brady, Otto-Bliesner, Yu, Lu and Cheng2014; Cheng et al., Reference Cheng, Wu, Liu, Gu, Wang, Zhao and Li2021) over the past two decades showed that Chinese stalagmite δ18O variations under isotopic equilibrium conditions can generally reflect the change in monsoon intensity (Cheng et al., Reference Cheng, Zhang, Zhao, Li, Ning and Kathayat2019; Zhang et al., Reference Zhang, Zhang, Cai, Sinha, Spätl, Baker and Kathayat2021b). The regional precipitation δ18O signal, eventually recorded in speleothem, in the EASM region is governed by upstream and local moisture sources (Liu et al., Reference Liu, Wen, Brady, Otto-Bliesner, Yu, Lu and Cheng2014). Rainfall amounts in southern and central China may not completely reflect monsoonal intensity (Chen et al., Reference Chen, Xu, Chen, Birks, Liu, Zhang, Jin, An, Telford and Cao2015; Liu et al., Reference Liu, Chen, Zhang, Li, Rao and Chen2015). Lianhua and Dragon Caves are located in the northwest frontier of the EASM in northern China, and the regional precipitation change is very sensitive to variation in monsoon intensity, as demonstrated by instrumental data and simulated results (Liu et al., Reference Liu, Chen, Zhang, Li, Rao and Chen2015). Under strong EASM conditions, high rainfall with a negative δ18O value is delivered to this region (Orland et al., Reference Orland, Edwards, Cheng, Kozdon, Cross and Valley2015; Tan et al., Reference Tan, Cai, Cheng, Lawrence Edwards, Shen, Gao and An2015). The regional Holocene stalagmite δ18O records from the Lianhua (Dong et al., Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Jiang2015, Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wu, Hu, Ren and Wang2018b) and Zhenzhu Caves (Yin et al., Reference Yin, Li, Rao, Shen, Mii, Pillutla, Hu, Li and Feng2017) match a pollen-based rainfall reconstruction from Bayanchagan Lake in northern China (Jiang et al., Reference Jiang, Guo, Sun, Wu, Chu, Yuan, Hatté and Guiot2006; Fig. 4a) and a local dry–wet index over the past 1000 yr (CAMS, 1981), respectively. The δ18O record of stalagmite L30 from Dragon Cave covaries with a quantitatively proxy-inferred summer rainfall record in the western CLP during the last glacial period (Dong et al., Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Duan2018a; Fig. 4). The comparison in Figure 4 and the recent proxy, empirical, and modeling studies (Liu et al., Reference Liu, Wen, Brady, Otto-Bliesner, Yu, Lu and Cheng2014; Orland et al., Reference Orland, Edwards, Cheng, Kozdon, Cross and Valley2015; Cheng et al., Reference Cheng, Zhang, Zhao, Li, Ning and Kathayat2019; Zhang et al., Reference Zhang, Zhang, Cai, Sinha, Spätl, Baker and Kathayat2021b) support that the Lianhua–Dragon stalagmite δ18O records can reflect monsoonal precipitation in northern China and register EASM intensity, with low value expressing a strong summer monsoon condition, and vice versa.
EASM and ISM during the GI 25 event
To better understand the regional nature of the millennial-scale climate event GI 25 during the last glacial inception, we compared the Lianhua–Dragon record with absolute dated contemporaneous stalagmites records from other Chinese caves, including Sanbao (Wang et al., Reference Wang, Cheng, Edwards, Kong, Shao, Chen, Wu, Jiang, Wang and An2008), Wanxiang (Johnson et al., Reference Johnson, Ingram, Sharp and Zhang2006), Suozi (Zhou et al., Reference Zhou, Zhao, Zhang, Shen, Chi, Feng, Lin, Guan and You2008), Sanxing (Jiang et al., Reference Jiang, Wang, He, Hu, Li, Spötl and Shen2016), and Dongge (Yuan et al., Reference Yuan, Cheng, Edwards, Dykoski, Kelly, Zhang and Qin2004; Kelly et al., Reference Kelly, Edwards, Cheng, Yuan, Zhang and An2006), located in different climatic regions zones of the East Asian monsoon realm (Fig. 5). We also compared the Lianhua–Dragon δ18O record with the continuous high-resolution stalagmite BT5 record from Bittoo Cave in northern India (Kathayat et al., Reference Kathayat, Cheng, Sinha, Spötl, Edwards, Zhang, Li, Yi, Ning, Cai, Liu and Breitenbach2016 and references therein), where the local climate is solely influenced by the Indian summer monsoon (ISM) (Fig. 5g).
The Lianhua–Dragon δ18O record in northern China shows that the millennial-scale strong monsoonal event appears to be correlated with the warm GI 25, whereas the weak monsoonal event is related to the cold GS 25 (Fig. 5a). High-resolution loess and desert sections in the CLP, near the Lianhua–Dragon region, feature the same strong monsoon, characterized by a relatively high magnetic susceptibility and organic content at GI 25 (Guan et al., Reference Guan, Pan, Gao, Yuan, Wang and Huai2007; Du et al., Reference Du, Li, Chen, Zhang, Xiang, Niu, Wen and Ou2012). Similar results can also be expressed in other stalagmite records, including Tianmen Cave in the Tibetan Plateau, China (Cai et al., Reference Cai, Cheng, An, Edwards, Wang, Tan and Wang2010) and Bittoo Cave in northern India (Kathayat et al., Reference Kathayat, Cheng, Sinha, Spötl, Edwards, Zhang, Li, Yi, Ning, Cai, Liu and Breitenbach2016 and references therein; Fig. 5g). The evidence generally expresses an intensified Asian summer monsoon (ASM, including the EASM and ISM) circulation at GI 25, with more monsoon precipitation permeating the interior as far as the China–Mongolia border. Subsequently, the ASM intensity abruptly decreased during the transition to GS 25 (Fig. 5a, c, and g), although this signal appears to be muted in the Dongge record (Fig. 5f).
In northwestern China, the 50-yr-resolution WX-52 δ18O record with large dating uncertainty of ± 2–4 ka from Wanxiang Cave documents an 18O-depleted peak of 0.5‰–1.0‰ (Johnson et al., Reference Johnson, Ingram, Sharp and Zhang2006; Fig. 5b). Both the Sanbao δ18O record from central China (Fig. 5c) and the Sanxing δ18O record from southwestern China (Jiang et al., Reference Jiang, Wang, He, Hu, Li, Spötl and Shen2016) (Fig. 5e) show an obvious 18O-depleted peak of 1.0‰ after the cold GS 26 event. A continuously 60-yr-resolved stalagmite YYZ1 δ18O record from Yangzi Cave in southwestern China clearly captures the monsoon event with an 18O depletion of 1.0‰ (Shi et al., Reference Shi, Yang, Cheng, Zhao, Li, Lei, Liang, Feng and Edwards2022). All stalagmite records show that this relatively small GI 25 monsoon event occurred over the Asian monsoon realm. The amplitudes of the GI 25 monsoon event recorded in Chinese stalagmite δ18O records are 1.0‰–2.2‰ smaller than ones of subsequent rapid interstadial events (Wang et al., Reference Wang, Cheng, Edwards, Kong, Shao, Chen, Wu, Jiang, Wang and An2008; Jiang et al., Reference Jiang, Wang, He, Hu, Li, Spötl and Shen2016). Different from 1‰ depletion in the Sanbao record of central China (Fig. 5c), the obscure peak in the stalagmite SZ2 δ18O record from Suozi Cave in the same district (Zhou et al., Reference Zhou, Zhao, Zhang, Shen, Chi, Feng, Lin, Guan and You2008; Fig. 5d) could be attributed to the different regional responses of this small strong monsoon event in the Asian monsoon realm. Or the muted signal in Suozi Cave could be related to the complicated karst aquifer system.
The Lianhua–Dragon record (Fig. 5a) in northern China expresses an enrichment of 2‰ in 18O at GS 25, 1‰ higher than that in Sanbao record (Fig. 5c) in central China and 1.5‰–2‰ higher than those of the Yangzi (Shi et al., Reference Shi, Yang, Cheng, Zhao, Li, Lei, Liang, Feng and Edwards2022) and Dongge records (Fig. 5f) in southwestern China (Fig. 5). In northern India, the stalagmite BT5 δ18O record of Bittoo Cave shows an 18O enrichment of 1.8‰ at GS 25 (Fig. 5g). The different 18O enrichments among stalagmite records (Fig. 5) revealed the heterogeneity of the weak regional monsoon conditions, and conditions in the fringe regions were more severe. The difference in hydroclimatic changes may partly account for the phenomenon of the muted GS 25 monsoonal events as recorded in the southern Chinese stalagmites (Kelly et al., Reference Kelly, Edwards, Cheng, Yuan, Zhang and An2006; Wu et al., Reference Wu, Li, Yu, Shen, Chen, Zhang, Li, Wang, Huang and Xiao2020).
Comparison with the Greenland ice-core δ18O record
High northern latitudes witnessed significant millennial-scale fluctuations in temperature during MIS 5d (114.6–108.3 ka), characterized with a warm interstadial (GI 25) and two cold stadials (GS 25 and 26) in the NGRIP ice core (NGRIP Project Members, 2004; Fig. 6b). Those events were also clearly registered in the precisely dated stalagmite δ18O records from Corchia Cave, Italy (Drysdale et al., Reference Drysdale, Zanchetta, Hellstrom, Fallick, McDonald and Cartwright2007) and caves in the northern Alps (NALPS) of central Europe (Boch et al., Reference Boch, Cheng, Spötl, Edwards, Wang and Häuselmann2011; Fig. 6c). Similar millennial-scale abrupt climate events occurred along the ancient Silk Road at the beginning of the last glacial. For example, after the end of the cold GS 26 event, the Greenland air temperature rapidly increased by 5 °C in less than 100 yr at 115.3 ± 2.5 ka and maintained a warm stage until the next cold stage of GS 25 (Kindler et al., Reference Kindler, Guillevic, Baumgartner, Schwander, Landais and Leuenberger2014). Stalagmite L4 of Dragon Cave began to deposit at 114.8 ± 0.4 ka after a hiatus, and its δ18O values show a decreasing trend, suggesting an increasing EASM over the whole GI 25 event, confirmed by the Sanbao record (Wang et al., Reference Wang, Cheng, Edwards, Kong, Shao, Chen, Wu, Jiang, Wang and An2008; Fig. 5c). Moreover, a rapid transition into the cold GS 25 as recorded by the Lianhua–Dragon record at 109.5 ka concurred with its European counterpart in NALPS stalagmites at 110.3 ka (Boch et al., Reference Boch, Cheng, Spötl, Edwards, Wang and Häuselmann2011; Moseley et al., Reference Moseley, Spötl, Brandstätter, Erhardt, Luetscher and Edwards2020) and the NGRIP ice-core record at 110.6 ka within age errors (Fig. 6).
Comparison of stalagmites δ18O time series with the Greenland ice-core and marine records during MIS 5d. (a) Lithic abundance record of Ocean Discovery Program sediment core (ODP) 980 to infer ice-rafted detritus (IRD) events (Chapman and Shackleton, Reference Chapman and Shackleton1999). (b) δ18O record of NGRIP ice core based on GICC05modelext time scale (NGRIP Project Members, 2004; Wolff et al., Reference Wolff, Chappellaz, Blunier, Rasmussen and Svensson2010). (c) Northern Alps (NALPS) 19 stalagmite δ18O records from Austria (Boch et al., Reference Boch, Cheng, Spötl, Edwards, Wang and Häuselmann2011; Moseley et al., Reference Moseley, Spötl, Brandstätter, Erhardt, Luetscher and Edwards2020). Chinese stalagmite δ18O records from (d) Lianhua–Dragon Caves in northern China (this study), (e) Sanbao Cave in central China (Wang et al., Reference Wang, Cheng, Edwards, Kong, Shao, Chen, Wu, Jiang, Wang and An2008), and (f) Dongge Cave in southern China (Kelly et al., Reference Kelly, Edwards, Cheng, Yuan, Zhang and An2006). Stalagmite δ18O records of (g) Bittoo Cave in northern India (Kathayat et al., Reference Kathayat, Cheng, Sinha, Spötl, Edwards, Zhang, Li, Yi, Ning, Cai, Liu and Breitenbach2016) and (h) Botuverá Cave in southern Brazil (Cruz et al., Reference Cruz, Burns, Karmann, Sharp, Vuille, Cardoso, Ferrari, Dias and Viana2005). All records are given with their chronologies, with the exception of the marine Ocean Discovery Program sediment core (ODP) 980 record which has a shift of + 2.5 ka. GI 25 represents Greenland Interstadial 25 and GS 25 and 26 are Greenland Stadials 25 and 26 (NGRIP Members, 2004), corresponding to marine events C 24 and C 25, respectively (Chapman and Shackleton, Reference Chapman and Shackleton1999; Oppo et al., Reference Oppo, McManus and Cullen2006). Two vertical gray bars indicate two weak Asian summer monsoon (ASM) events (Wang et al., Reference Wang, Cheng, Edwards, Kong, Shao, Chen, Wu, Jiang, Wang and An2008), associated with GS 25 and GS 26. 230Th ages with 2σ uncertainties are color coded by stalagmite.
One prominent multicentennial-scale abrupt isotopic anomaly, with an amplitude of 1.2‰ that lasted for 700 yr from 110.7+0.6−0.5 to 110.0+0.8−0.4 ka, was first distinguished in the Lianhua–Dragon record during GI 25 (Fig. 7c). This weak-monsoon anomaly, GI 25b, separates the GI 25 event's two strong-monsoon substages, the 3.8-ka-long GI 25c and the 500-yr-long GI 25a. The multicentennial-to-millennial variations displayed in the Lianhua–Dragon record are more evident than those of the stalagmite δ18O records from central and southwestern China (Fig. 5c–f). We speculate that this difference could be attributable to our study site being closer to the northern boundary of the EASM and more sensitive than other regions (Dong et al., Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Jiang2015). The high-resolution δ18O record from Bittoo Cave in northern India, located at the edge of the ISM, also clearly expresses the similar short-lived climate events during GI 25 (Figs. 5 g and 7d).
A detailed comparison of the centennial-scale Asian summer monsoon (ASM) variability with the high-latitude North Atlantic temperature change during the Greenland interstadial (GI) 25 event. (a) NGRIP ice δ18O record with substages a, b, and c on GICC05 modelext time scale (NGRIP Project Members, 2004; Wolff et al., Reference Wolff, Chappellaz, Blunier, Rasmussen and Svensson2010). (b) Northern Alps (NALPS) 19 stalagmite δ18O record from Austria (Boch et al., Reference Boch, Cheng, Spötl, Edwards, Wang and Häuselmann2011; Moseley et al., Reference Moseley, Spötl, Brandstätter, Erhardt, Luetscher and Edwards2020). (c) Lianhua–Dragon stalagmite δ18O record from northern China. (d) Bittoo BT 5 stalagmite δ18O record from northern India (Kathayat et al., Reference Kathayat, Cheng, Sinha, Spötl, Edwards, Zhang, Li, Yi, Ning, Cai, Liu and Breitenbach2016). Gray vertical bar denotes substage GI 25b.
A detailed comparison with other high-resolution sequences along the south-north longitude transect in the Northern Hemisphere over GI 25 is given in Figure 7. These intra–GI 25 strong/weak monsoon events in Figure 7c and d show a striking similarity to the corresponding two warm periods and intervening cold interval in the NGRIP ice-core δ18O record (Fig. 7a). For example, a distinct weakening monsoon event lasting from 110.7 +0.6−0.5 to 110.0 +0.8−0.4 ka in the Lianhua–Dragon record (Fig. 7c) is linked to the 500 yr cold-dry excursion of GI 25b from 111.4 to 110.9 ka in the Greenland ice-core record (Fig. 7a). A short-lived aridity event occurred at 112.4–111.4 ka in northern India, revealed in the Bittoo stalagmite BT5 δ18O record (Kathayat et al., Reference Kathayat, Cheng, Sinha, Spötl, Edwards, Zhang, Li, Yi, Ning, Cai, Liu and Breitenbach2016; Fig. 7d), matches its counterparts in NALPS stalagmite and Greenland ice-core records within dating errors (Fig. 7).
The GI 25a marks the earliest glacial “rebound-type event,” depicted as a short-lived warm reversal during the gradual cooling limb of a large GI 25 event in the NGRIP record (Capron et al., Reference Capron, Landais, Chappellaz, Schilt, Buiron, Dahl-Jensen and Johnsen2010, Reference Capron, Landais, Chappellaz, Buiron, Fischer, Johnsen, Jouzel, Leuenberger, Masson-Delmotte and Stocker2012; Fig. 7a). A similar feature is also documented in the European stalagmite records, expressed as a temperature increase in Figure 7b. In the Asian monsoon region, records from the Lianhua–Dragon Caves of northern China and Bittoo Cave of north India (Fig. 7c and d) show an abrupt concurrent persistent monsoonal condition during GI 25a. The 400 yr duration of this warm GI 25a in NGRIP δ18O and CH4 records (Capron et al., Reference Capron, Landais, Chappellaz, Buiron, Fischer, Johnsen, Jouzel, Leuenberger, Masson-Delmotte and Stocker2012; Rasmussen et al., Reference Rasmussen, Bigler, Blockley, Blunier, Buchardt, Clausen and Cvijanovic2014) matches its counterpart in the ASM region: 500 yr in the Lianhua Cave record and 400 yr in the Bittoo Cave record (Fig. 7). This concurrency indicates a strong teleconnection between the ASM and temperature change in the North Atlantic on centennial-to-millennial time scales during MIS 5d.
Interhemispheric comparison
A regional insolation-governed interhemispheric antiphasing monsoonal pattern on millennial-to-orbital scales during the last glacial period was proposed by Wang et al. (Reference Wang, Auler, Edwards, Cheng, Ito, Wang, Kong and Solheid2007), who compared stalagmite δ18O records in Brazil and eastern China from 90 to 0 ka. Here we have further evaluated this relationship by using northern Chinese stalagmite δ18O records. Changes in Lianhua–Dragon δ18O records, concurrent with the Sanbao record, are opposite to those in the Botuverá Cave record from southern Brazil (Cruz et al., Reference Cruz, Burns, Karmann, Sharp, Vuille, Cardoso, Ferrari, Dias and Viana2005) on a millennial scale. During the MIS 5d, the South American summer monsoon became very weak during the warm GI 25 and was enhanced during the cold GS 25 (Fig. 6h). Although age uncertainties of stalagmite chronologies hinder a detailed comparison, an interhemispheric antiphasing similarity is sound even for hydroclimatic changes in northern China. These observations support the bipolar seesaw hypothesis that explains the time relationship between DO and Antarctic isotope maxima events (Broecker, Reference Broecker1998; Barker et al., Reference Barker, Diz, Vautravers, Pike, Knorr, Hall and Broecker2009).
Atlantic meridional overturning circulation (AMOC) has been proposed to explain the linkage of millennial-scale hydroclimate between the ASM and high-latitude Northern Hemisphere (Wang et al., Reference Wang, Cheng, Edwards, An, Wu, Shen and Dorale2001; Caballero-Gill et al., Reference Caballero-Gill, Clemens and Prell2012; Deplazes et al., Reference Deplazes, Lückge, Peterson, Timmermann, Hamann, Hughen and Röhl2013; Dong et al., Reference Dong, Shen, Kong, Wang and Duan2018a). The AMOC affects the oceanic transport of heat from low latitudes to the North Atlantic. In turn, it is strongly influenced by the extensive amounts of ice melt entering the North Atlantic, which attenuates the density-driven thermohaline circulation and leads to climate changes worldwide (Hemming, Reference Hemming2004). Such a mechanism was confirmed by a simulation that coupled the AMOC and ASM (Sun et al., Reference Sun, Clemens, Morrill, Lin, Wang and An2011). Results from the International Ocean Discovery Program sediment core (ODP) 1063 suggest that AMOC was relatively unstable on the millennial scale during the last glacial period (Böhm et al., Reference Böhm, Lippold, Gutjahr, Frank, Blaser, Antz, Fohlmeister, Frank, Andersen and Deininger2015). Two prominent weak EASM anomalies in the Lianhua–Dragon and Sanbao δ18O records correlate well with the North Atlantic ice-rafted detritus (IRD) events C 24 and C 25 (Chapman and Shackleton, Reference Chapman and Shackleton1999 and references therein; Fig. 6a) and their counterparts in the NGRIP record (Fig. 6b). This good alignment supports the previous hypothesis that the millennial-scale abrupt climate changes in the North Atlantic region may influence the Asian monsoonal climate through the reorganization of large-scale atmospheric circulation patterns (Porter and An, Reference Porter and An1995; An and Porter, Reference An and Porter1997; Wang et al., Reference Wang, Cheng, Edwards, An, Wu, Shen and Dorale2001). Changes in large-scale atmospheric circulations are linked to the displacement of the intertropical convergence zone, providing a potential association between the observed millennial-scale covariations in low and high latitudes (Y.J. Wang et al., Reference Wang, Cheng, Edwards, An, Wu, Shen and Dorale2001; Fleitmann et al., Reference Fleitmann, Burns, Mangini, Mudelsee, Kramers, Villa and Neff2007; X.F. Wang et al., Reference Wang, Auler, Edwards, Cheng, Ito, Wang, Kong and Solheid2007; Zhao et al., Reference Zhao, Wang, Edwards, Cheng and Liu2010).
CONCLUSIONS
Based on 28 precise 230Th dates, we provide a multidecadal-resolved stalagmite δ18O record from 114.6 to 108.3 ka from two neighboring caves, Lianhua and Dragon, in Shanxi Province, northern China. The δ18O records feature a strengthened monsoon interval associated with the corresponding GI 25 event and two weak monsoon events linked to cold episodes in Greenland and ice-rafting events in the North Atlantic, respectively. On the millennial time scale, our results are broadly consistent with previously published Chinese and Indian stalagmite δ18O records, but directly in opposition to the stalagmite δ18O record in southern Brazil. The Lianhua–Dragon record captures prominent multicentennial-to-millennial monsoon events, corresponding to the substages of intra-interstadial climate oscillations in GI 25. Our study shows the strong hydroclimate links between ASM and Northern Hemisphere high latitudes during MIS 5d.
Supplementary Material
The supplementary material for this article can be found at https://doi.org/10.1017/qua.2022.5
Acknowledgments
We thank two anonymous reviewers for critical and instructive comments and suggestions.
Financial Support
This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (awards 41877287, 41472317, and 41102216). U-Th dating in the HISPEC was supported by grants from the Science Vanguard Research Program of the Ministry of Science and Technology (MOST) (109-2123-M-002-001), the Higher Education Sprout Project of the Ministry of Education (109L901001), and National Taiwan University (110L8907).
Open access
