Eating at fast-food restaurants is common among adolescents. National data indicate that on any given day nearly 40 % of high-school-aged adolescents report consuming food from a fast-food restaurant(Reference Bowman, Gortmaker, Ebbeling, Pereira and Ludwig1). In the late 1970s, fast food comprised only 2 % of children and adolescents’ total energy intake, while in the mid-1990s it rose to 10 % of their total energy intake(Reference Guthrie, Lin and Frazao2). This trend of increased intake from fast-food restaurants shows little evidence of slowing down, with these restaurants commonly located within walking distance of schools(Reference Austin, Melly, Sanchez, Patel, Buka and Gortmaker3, Reference Zenk and Powell4), fast-food meals being served in school cafeterias(Reference Nestle5), open school campus policies that allow students to leave and purchase fast food for lunch(Reference Neumark-Sztainer, French, Hannan, Story and Fulkerson6), and excessive marketing of fast food to children and adolescents(Reference Outley and Taddese7, Reference Powell, Szczypka and Chaloupka8).
Frequently eating at fast-food restaurants may have adverse consequences for nutritional intake and weight-related health. Common adolescent food choices from fast-food restaurants, including hamburgers, pizza, French fries and sugar-sweetened beverages(Reference Subar, Krebs-Smith, Cook and Kahle9), which are frequently served in large portions(Reference Young and Nestle10), can contribute to poor nutritional intake. Among children, adolescents and adults, fast-food consumption has been associated with higher BMI(Reference Jeffery, Baxter, McGuire and Linde11), weight gain(Reference Pereira, Kartashov and Ebbeling12, Reference Taveras, Berkey and Rifas-Shiman13) and decreased insulin sensitivity(Reference Pereira, Kartashov and Ebbeling12). Additionally, those with high fast-food intake report higher intakes of total energy, total fat, saturated fat, carbohydrates, Na, added sugar and sugar-sweetened beverages, and lower intakes of milk, fruits and vegetables(Reference Bowman, Gortmaker, Ebbeling, Pereira and Ludwig1, Reference Jeffery, Baxter, McGuire and Linde11, Reference Taveras, Berkey and Rifas-Shiman13–Reference Wiecha, Finkelstein, Troped, Fragala and Peterson16).
In order to better understand and ultimately curb the consumption of fast food among adolescents, it is important to understand what factors contribute to fast-food intake. In particular, understanding the factors that predict fast-food intake during the transition from middle to high school, when adolescents become increasingly independent and have great access to unhealthy dietary choices, may be especially important. This knowledge can inform public health interventions aiming to improve adolescents’ dietary intake and help them achieve a healthy weight status.
Examining the cross-sectional data from Project EAT (Eating Among Teens), French and colleagues(Reference French, Story, Neumark-Sztainer, Fulkerson and Hannan17) identified several correlates of adolescents’ fast-food intake such as dislike for the taste of healthy foods, perceived lack of time to eat healthy foods, sports team participation, high television usage, and lack of maternal or peer concern for healthy eating. Additional cross-sectional and longitudinal studies have identified the frequency of television viewing, and acculturation and US nativity among members of racial and ethnic minority groups, as risk factors for adolescents’ fast-food consumption(Reference Unger, Reynolds, Shakib, Spruijt-Metz, Sun and Johnson18–Reference Gordon-Larsen, Harris, Ward and Popkin20). Cross-sectional studies of adults have found that similar factors are correlated with adult’s fast-food intake, such as television viewing(Reference French, Harnack and Jeffery21), as well as additional factors such as perceived difficulty in preparing healthy foods and self-efficacy for eating fruits and vegetables(Reference Satia, Galanko and Siega-Riz22).
The current study uses data from Project EAT to build upon the previous cross-sectional analysis to identify socio-environmental, personal and behavioural factors, as suggested by Social Cognitive Theory, that longitudinally predict fast-food intake among high-school-aged adolescents. Using these data drawn from a population-based, 5-year longitudinal study, we examined the relationship between the socio-environmental, personal and behavioural factors which were reported by adolescents during middle school and their fast-food consumption during high school. The present study is one of the few theory-based, longitudinal studies to examine a diverse set of potential predictors of adolescents’ fast-food intake. By examining longitudinal relationships between the selected factors and fast-food intake, we are not only able to determine whether these factors are associated with fast-food intake among adolescents, but also whether they predict long-term increases in fast-food intake through the adolescent years.
Methods
Sample and study design
Data for the current study were drawn from Project EAT (Eating Among Teens), a prospective, population-based study designed to examine determinants of dietary intake and weight status. Project EAT surveyed middle- and high-school students in 1998–9, and then resurveyed participants again five years later in 2003–4 in order to examine how socio-environmental, personal and behavioural factors may influence adolescents during the transitions from middle to high school and high school into young adulthood. The sample used in the present analysis consisted of the 806 adolescents who were in middle school at baseline (EAT-I) and in high school at follow-up five years later (EAT-II). At baseline the mean age of participants was 12·8 (sd 0·8) years and at follow-up their mean age was 17·2 (sd 0·6) years.
For Project EAT-I (1998–9), 1672 middle-school students completed the Project EAT-I survey and FFQ in their classrooms. Five years later, Project EAT-II (2003–4) aimed to resurvey by mail all original participants for whom contact information was available. Of those in the middle-school cohort for whom contact information was available, 69·5 % completed the follow-up survey. This represents 50·1 % of the original cohort. All study protocols were approved by the University of Minnesota’s Institutional Review Board Human Subjects Committee.
Surveys and measures
The development of the baseline Project EAT-I survey was guided by Social Cognitive Theory(Reference Baranowski, Perry and Parcel23), focus group discussions with adolescents(Reference Neumark-Sztainer, Story, Perry and Casey24), an in-depth literature review and pilot testing. The majority of these items were retained without modification for the Project EAT-II follow-up survey completed by high-school students.
Outcome measure
Fast-food intake was assessed at baseline and follow-up using a single item on the Project EAT surveys: ‘In the past week, how often did you eat something from a fast-food restaurant (like McDonald’s, Burger King, Hardee’s, etc)?’ Six response categories ranged from ‘never’ to ‘more than 7 times’. Several other studies examining fast-food intake have used a similar item to measure fast-food intake among adolescents(Reference Schmidt, Affenito and Striegel-Moore14, Reference Niemeier, Raynor, Lloyd-Richardson, Rogers and Wing25). We collapsed the fast-food intake response categories into 0 times in the past week (low intake), 1–2 times in the past week (moderate intake) and 3 or more times in the past week (frequent intake)(Reference French, Story, Neumark-Sztainer, Fulkerson and Hannan17, Reference Larson, Neumark-Sztainer, Story, Wall, Harnack and Eisenberg26). Increased fast-food intake assessed using this question, and represented in these three categories, has been positively correlated with adolescents’ intakes of total energy, fat energy, saturated fat energy, Na, French fries and soft drinks(Reference French, Story, Neumark-Sztainer, Fulkerson and Hannan17).
Exposure measures
Socio-environmental, personal and behavioural characteristics were assessed at baseline during Project EAT-I. Table 1 contains these variables along with psychometric information when available.
Description of the socio-environmental, personal and behavioural measures assessed in the present study
Covariates
Race/ethnicity and socio-economic status (SES) were based on adolescents’ self-report in Project EAT-I. Race/ethnicity was assessed at baseline with the question: ‘Do you think of yourself as…?’, with responses of white, black or African-American, Hispanic or Latino, Asian-American, Hawaiian or Pacific Islander, or American Indian or Native American. Subjects could choose more than one category; responses indicating multiple categories were coded as ‘mixed or other’. Due to the small number of respondents in some of the racial/ethnic categories, Hawaiian or Pacific Islander, American Indian or Native American and mixed heritage were combined to form an ‘other’ category in the analysis. The primary determinant of SES was parental educational level, defined by the highest level of educational attainment of either parent. In addition, an algorithm was developed to take into account family eligibility for public assistance, eligibility for free or reduced-cost school meals and employment status of the mother and the father(Reference Neumark-Sztainer, Story, Hannan and Croll27).
Statistical analyses
Of the 806 high-school-aged adolescents who provided follow-up survey data, exclusions were made for those missing data on fast-food intake (n 14). Data were weighted to adjust for differential response rates to Projects EAT-I and EAT-II using the response propensity method(Reference Little28). The weighted ethnic/racial and SES proportions of the study sample were as follows: 33·3 % white, 22·9 % Asian-American, 24·2 % African-American, 6·5 % Hispanic and 13·9 % mixed or other race; whereas SES percentages were 17·2 % low, 18·6 % low–middle, 31·0 % middle, 18·3 % upper–middle and 14·9 % high.
Several analyses were conducted to examine the relationships between sociodemographic characteristics and fast-food intake. The χ 2 test was used to examine associations of the three-level fast-food intake variable with race/ethnicity in five categories and SES in five categories. ANOVA was used to compare the mean ages of participants in each of the three levels of fast-food intake.
To separately examine associations between each of the potential socio-environmental, personal and behavioural predictors assessed at baseline with follow-up fast-food intake, ordinal logistic regression analyses were conducted on the three-level dependent fast-food intake variable using two models. Model 1 controlled for baseline race/ethnicity in two categories (white/non-white) and SES in five categories. Model 2 controlled for baseline race/ethnicity, SES and fast-food intake during EAT-I. Model 1 was used to examine the total association of potential correlates with fast-food intake at follow-up, while Model 2 was used to examine associations between potential correlates and change in fast-food intake over the 5-year study period. All analyses were stratified by gender.
For Models 1 and 2, non-dichotomous personal, behavioural and socio-environmental variables were standardized to allow for relative comparisons of strength between the observed associations. Models for every potential correlate satisfied the proportionality of odds assumption for ordinal logistic regression, indicating that the odds ratios for being in either of the two higher intake categories (frequent or moderate) v. the lowest intake category (low) were not statistically different from the odds ratios for being in the highest intake category (frequent) v. either of the two lower intake categories (moderate or low). P < 0·05 from a two-sided test of significance was used to direct attention to statistically significant results. Analyses were conducted using the Statistical Analysis System (SAS) statistical software package version 8·2 (SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA).
Results
At follow-up, approximately one-third of both males (31·2 %) and females (30·9 %) reported frequent consumption of fast food (3 or more times in the past week). One-fifth of males (21·2 %) and females (21·8 %) reported low consumption of fast food (0 times in the past week). Among females, fast-food intake differed by race/ethnicity, SES and age (Table 2). A higher percentage of white and Asian girls were low fast-food consumers (26·2 % and 26·7 %, respectively) compared with girls of the other racial/ethnic backgrounds. Compared with girls from higher SES families, low-SES girls were more likely to report frequent fast-food consumption. Females in the frequent fast-food category were more likely to be older than those females in the moderate and low intake categories. Fast-food intake was not associated with any of these sociodemographic variables among males.
Time 2 fast-food Intake among male and female participants in Project EAT according to sociodemographic characteristicsFootnote *Footnote †
SES, socio-economic status.
a,b Mean values with unlike superscript letters were significantly different.
* Adjusted frequencies, means and percentages were determined using response propensity weights. Race/ethnicity and SES status were assessed at baseline. Age was assessed at follow-up.
† The sample size for different variables may vary from the total sample size because of missing responses.
Associations of socio-environmental, personal and behavioural variables with fast-food intake at follow-up
Among males, many of the Time 1 variables that predicted fast-food intake at Time 2 were from the domain of the social environment (Table 3). After controlling for sociodemographic characteristics, socio-environmental factors that were protective against higher fast-food intake included maternal concern with her own healthy eating (Model 1: OR = 0·70, P = 0·002), maternal encouragement of the adolescent to eat healthy food (Model 1: OR = 0·80, P = 0·04) and friends’ concern for eating healthy food (Model 1: OR = 0·76, P = 0·03). For each standard deviation increase in the adolescents’ report at Time 1 that their friends cared about eating healthy food, there was a 26 % decreased odds of adolescents being in a higher fast-food intake category at Time 2, e.g. being a frequent v. moderate fast-food consumer. Availability of unhealthy food in the home was also a socio-environmental risk factor for higher fast-food intake (Model 1: OR = 1·29, P = 0·02). After adjustment for Time 1 fast-food intake (Model 2), the inverse relationship between maternal concern with her own healthy eating and adolescents’ fast-food intake remained, therefore maternal concern for healthy food was associated with a 27 % lower odds of increasing to the next higher fast-food intake category at Time 2 (OR = 0·73, P = 0·005). In addition to these socio-environmental factors, being born outside the USA was protective against increased fast-food intake among males (Model 2: OR = 0·45, P = 0·006), while Time 1 television viewing (Model 2: OR = 1·24, P = 0·04) and participating on a sports team (Model 2: OR = 2·17, P = 0·001) were risk factors for increased fast-food intake at Time 2.
Socio-environmental, personal and behavioural predictors of fast-food intake at follow-up in Project EAT participants
*Model 1 adjusted for baseline socio-economic status (SES) in five categories and race/ethnicity (white/non-white).
†Model 2 adjusted for baseline SES, race/ethnicity and fast-food intake at Time 1.
Among females, several of the personal and behavioural factors reported at Time 1 were significantly associated with both higher fast-food consumption (Model 1) and increased fast-food consumption (Model 2) at Time 2 (Table 3). Weight concerns (Model 2: OR = 0·79, P = 0·02) and using healthy weight-control strategies such as exercising and eating fruits and vegetables in order to lose weight (Model 2: OR = 0·78, P = 0·008) were protective against increased fast-food intake at Time 2. Meanwhile, preferring the taste of unhealthy foods was a risk factor for increased fast-food consumption at Time 2 (Model 2: OR = 1·28, P = 0·01). Having been born outside the USA was a strong protective factor against increased fast-food intake at Time 2, with those born outside the USA being approximately 50 % less likely to increase to a higher fast-food consumption category at Time 2 (Model 2: OR = 0·45, P = 0·004). The sole socio-environmental predictor of increased fast-food intake among females was having unhealthy food available in the home (Model 2: OR = 1·34, P = 0·004).
Discussion
The goal of the present study was to identify socio-environmental, personal and behavioural factors that longitudinally predict fast-food intake among high-school-aged adolescents. Frequent fast-food intake was common among our follow-up sample of high-school students; almost one-third of adolescents reported eating fast food at least three times in the previous week. Several socio-environmental, personal and behavioural factors, as assessed during middle school, were identified as longitudinal predictors of fast-food intake five years later during high school.
Many of the predictors of fast-food intake among males were socio-environmental factors, including friends’ concern for healthy eating and the home food environment. Of specific interest is the strong protective relationship between maternal concern for healthy eating and males’ fast-food intake, which remained after adjustment for baseline fast-food intake. Although the other significant predictors of males’ fast-food intake, being born outside the USA and participating on sports teams, were categorized as personal and behavioural based on our use of the Social Cognitive Theory, it may be that the socio-cultural aspects of these factors play a role in males’ fast-food intake. Expanding on the cross-sectional analysis of baseline data from Project EAT-I(Reference French, Story, Neumark-Sztainer, Fulkerson and Hannan17), the current study found that males’ sports team participation in middle school predicted increased fast-food intake during the high school years. Of all the factors examined in the present study, sports team participation in middle school was the strongest risk factor for fast-food intake in high school. This relationship may emerge because adolescents who are on sports teams have little time for meals at home and therefore may rely on fast food for quick meals.
Among females, a pattern of personal and behavioural predictors of fast-food intake emerged. These include weight concerns, healthy weight-control behaviours and taste preference for unhealthy foods. All of the predictors of fast-food intake among females remained after controlling for baseline fast-food intake. Therefore, they were not only associated with higher fast-food intake in high school but an increase in intake between middle and high school. Similar to males, being born outside the USA was associated with fast-food intake in high school. These findings support those of other cross-sectional and longitudinal studies which have found that first-generation immigrants and less acculturated adolescents and adults often have better dietary intake patterns, including lower consumption of fast food, compared with their US-native and acculturated peers(Reference Gordon-Larsen, Harris, Ward and Popkin20, Reference Neuhouser, Thompson, Coronado and Solomon29).
These patterns of longitudinal predictors can help guide intervention strategies to reduce adolescents’ fast-food intake. Findings from the current study suggest that both males and females may benefit from interventions that aim to decrease the availability of unhealthy foods in the home. Additionally, adolescents whose families have recently immigrated to the USA may benefit from interventions that emphasize the maintenance of healthier, culturally specific eating patterns from their native countries. Meanwhile, some gender-specific strategies may be appropriate for reducing fast-food intake. For boys, it may be important to address the strong association between sports team participation and fast-food intake. One strategy to address this may be ensuring that team practices end early enough in the evening so that families are able to prepare a family meal at home. Programmes that aim to modify girls’ personal beliefs and behaviours may be successful in reducing their fast-food intake. Interventions for girls may choose to focus on encouraging girls to use healthy weight-management strategies such as eating fruits and vegetables, choosing low-fat food options, and trying new, healthy foods in the hope of finding several that they enjoy and can integrate into their daily intake.
The results of the current study align well with the findings of previous cross-sectional studies in adolescent(Reference French, Story, Neumark-Sztainer, Fulkerson and Hannan17, Reference Utter, Scragg and Schaaf19) and adult(Reference French, Harnack and Jeffery21, Reference Satia, Galanko and Siega-Riz22) populations. In a separate analysis of longitudinal predictors of fast-food intake among the young adult population that participated in Project EAT, Larson et al.(Reference Larson, Neumark-Sztainer, Story, Wall, Harnack and Eisenberg26) similarly found that peer support for healthy eating predicted decreased consumption of fast food among males, while personal and behavioural factors such as taste preference for unhealthy foods and perceived lack of time to eat healthfully were longitudinally associated with higher fast-food intake among females. This consistency of findings across the life span lends itself to the development of population-based interventions that can use similar strategies to affect both adults’ and adolescents’ fast-food habits.
Strengths of the current study include its longitudinal design and use of a racially, ethnically and socio-economically diverse population. The large sample size of Project EAT allowed for the examination of gender-specific relationships between socio-environmental, behavioural and personal factors and fast-food intake. A limitation of the study was its dependence on a single measure of fast-food intake. While this measure has been used in several other studies(Reference Schmidt, Affenito and Striegel-Moore14, Reference French, Harnack and Jeffery21, Reference Niemeier, Raynor, Lloyd-Richardson, Rogers and Wing25), the item inquired only about the participant’s fast-food intake in the past week, assuming that this reflects usual intake. Additionally, new types of fast-food restaurants are rapidly becoming available, expanding the concept of what is considered ‘fast food’ beyond hamburgers and fried chicken and into such realms as ethnic fast foods(Reference Sloan30). This diversity adds to the complexity of accurately assessing fast-food intake. Future research is needed to gain a deeper understanding of which fast-food restaurants adolescents frequent and what food choices are made. This is especially important in light of the healthier options being offered by some fast-food chains(Reference Glanz, Resnicow and Seymour31) and the growing encouragement for fast-food restaurants to better inform their patrons of healthier meal options(Reference Wootan, Osborn and Malloy32).
Conclusions
Fast-food intake has been shown to be associated with weight gain and poor dietary choices among children, adolescents and adults(Reference Bowman, Gortmaker, Ebbeling, Pereira and Ludwig1, Reference Jeffery, Baxter, McGuire and Linde11, Reference Taveras, Berkey and Rifas-Shiman13–Reference Wiecha, Finkelstein, Troped, Fragala and Peterson16). Efforts to help adolescents reduce their fast-food intake may result in the achievement or maintenance of a healthier weight, along with better dietary intake, during a critical age where individuals increasingly need to make independent food decisions and prepare themselves for the transition into young adulthood. The results of the current, 5-year longitudinal study provide insight into strategies that may be successful to help high-school-aged adolescents decrease their fast-food intake. Our findings suggest the importance of addressing socio-environmental factors such as acculturation and home food availability. Additionally, gender-specific intervention strategies such as working with boys’ sports teams, family members and peer groups, and for girls, emphasizing the importance of healthy weight-maintenance strategies and the addition of flavourful and healthy food options, may help to reduce fast-food intake.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Mr Peter Hannan for his statistical assistance with this paper. The study was supported by Grant R40 MC 00319 (D.N.-S., Principal Investigator) from the Maternal and Child Health Bureau (Title V, Social Security Act), Health Resources and Services Administration, US Department of Health and Human Services. K.W.B. is supported by the Adolescent Health Protection Program (School of Nursing, University of Minnesota) grant number T01-DP000112 (Principal Investigator: Bearinger) from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The contents of this paper are solely the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official views of the CDC. The authors declare that they have no competing interests. K.W.B., N.I.L., M.C.N., M.S. and D.N.-S. contributed to the study design; K.W.B. conducted the statistical analysis and wrote the manuscript; and all authors edited the manuscript and read and approved the final manuscript. D.N.-S. is the Principal Investigator of Project EAT-II.
