War Planning and Initial Operations in the Russian Context

doi:10.1017/CBO9780511642371.004

4 - War Planning and Initial Operations in the Russian Context

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 27 January 2010

Bruce W. Menning

Edited by

Richard F. Hamilton and

Holger H. Herwig

Show author details

Richard F. Hamilton: Affiliation:
Ohio State University
Holger H. Herwig: Affiliation:
University of Calgary

Book contents

Get access

Summary

Between 1873 and 1914, Russian preparation for a European war evolved through two stages. The first was very long and the second very brief, and there was a jagged transition between the two. Some knowledgeable observers termed these stages “systems,” because in varying degrees each period gave rise to an overarching scheme with a governing strategy that flowed from geopolitical circumstance, threat assessment, alliance commitments, course of action development, detailed planning, and resource allocation. For various reasons, neither period's system fully met requirements for engagement in a Great Power war. However, only the second, sometimes called the “Sukhomlinov System” after Russia's last pre-1914 war minister, would be put to the test. When war did come, this system's inadequacies and internal inconsistencies meant that Russia would enter hostilities as it had entered nearly all its past wars, like a chess player with poor opening moves. The result during the initial period of conflict was catastrophic failure against Germany and only partial success against Austria-Hungary.

Setting the Terms

These outcomes testified to anomalies and dysfunctions that lay below the surface of the apparent system. In Russia, prevailing notions of statecraft and monarchical prerogative often inhibited the effective linking of ends, ways, and means according to a mature understanding of higher, or grand, strategy. In institutional terms, modified autocratic politics defined politico-military jurisdictions and the limits of higher-level coordinating authority in ways that precluded optimal collaboration during strategy development, war planning, and resource allocation.

Information

Type: Chapter
Information: War Planning 1914 , pp. 80 - 142

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511642371.004 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Golovin, N. N., Iz istorii kampanii 1914 goda na russkom fronte. Galitsiiskaia bitva [hereinafter Golovin, Galitsiiskaia bitva] (Paris, 1930), 25Google Scholar

Zaionchkovskii, A. M., Podgotovka Rossii k imperialisticheskoi voine (Moscow, 1926), 141–54Google Scholar

Neznamov, A. A., “Plan voiny,” Voennaia entsiklopediia, 18 vols. incomplete (St. Petersburg/Petrograd, 1911–15), XVIII, 446–49Google Scholar

Danilov, Iu. N., “Nashe strategicheskoe razvertyvanie v 1914 godu i idei, polozhennye v osnovu ego,” Voennyi sbornik [Belgrade], no. 4 (1923), 73–4Google Scholar

Fuller, Jr. William C., Strategy and Power in Russia, 1600–1914 (New York, 1992), 267Google Scholar

Vasil'ev, N. G., Transport Rossii v voine 1914–1918 gg. (Moscow, 1939), 26Google Scholar

Zolotarev, V. A., Kudrina, Iu. V., et al. (eds.), Mirovye voiny XX veka, 4 vols. (Moscow, 2002), II, 13

Zaionchkovskii, A. M., Podgotovka Rossii k mirovoi voine v mezhdunarodnom otnoshenii (Leningrad, 1926), 169–72Google Scholar

Johnson, Douglas Wilson, Topography and Strategy in the War (New York, 1917), 50–61Google Scholar

Golovin, N. N., Iz istorii kampanii 1914 goda na russkom fronte. Plan voiny [hereinafter Golovin, Plan voiny] (Paris, 1936), 4–5Google Scholar

Dobrorol'skii, S. K., Mobilizatsiia russkoi armii v 1914 godu (Moscow, 1929), 110Google Scholar

[Palitsyn, F. F. and Alekseev, M. V.] Doklad o meropriiatiiakh po oborone Gosudarstva, podlezhashchikh osushchestvleniiu v blizhaishee desiatiletie [v. sekretno] (St. Petersburg, n. d.), 53–8

Ushakov, K. P., Podgotovka voennykh soobshchenii Rossii k mirovoi voine (Moscow-Leningrad, 1928), 58–9Google Scholar

Collins, D. N., “The Franco-Russian Alliance and Russian Railways, 1891–1914,” The Historical Journal, XVI, no. 4 (December 1973)Google Scholar

Rediger, A. F., Komplektovanie i ustroistvo vooruzhennoi sily, 2 vols. (St. Petersburg, 1913), II, 161Google Scholar

Rostunov, I. I., Russkii front pervoi mirovoi voiny (Moscow, 1976), 95Google Scholar

Domanevskii, V. N. in Alekseeva-Borel', V. M., Sorok let v riadakh russkoi imperatorskoi armii: General M. V. Alekseev (St. Petersburg, 2000), 230–31Google Scholar

Rich, David Alan, The Tsar's Colonels: Professionalism, Strategy, and Subversion in Late Imperial Russia (Cambridge, MA, 1998), 162–71Google Scholar

Dobrorol'skii, S. K., “Strategicheskie plany storon k nachalu mirovoi voiny,” Voennyi sbornik [Belgrade], no. 2 (1922), 53–5Google Scholar

Zaionchkovskii, P. A., Voennye reformy 1860–1870 godov v Rossii (Moscow, 1952), 287–88Google Scholar

Airapetov, O. R., Zabytaia kar'era “Russkogo Mol'tke”: Nikolai Nikolaevich Obruchev (1830–1904) (St. Petersburg, 1998), 274–87Google Scholar

Petrov, M. A., Podgotovka Rossii k mirovoi voine na more (Moscow-Leningrad, 1926), 8–9, 22–4, 30–4, 47–52Google Scholar

Menning, Bruce W., “Neither Mahan nor Moltke: Strategy in the Russo-Japanese War,” in Steinberg, John W., et al. (eds.), The Russo-Japanese War in Global Perspective: World War Zero, 2 vols. (Leiden, 2005, 2007), I, 133–34, 139–40Google Scholar

Subbotin, Iu. F., “A. N. Kuropatkin i Dal'nevostochnyi konflikt,” in Rybachenok, I. S., Zakharova, L. G., and Ignat'ev, A. V. (eds.), Rossiia: Mezhdunarodnoe polozhenie i voennyi potentsial v seredine XIX-nachale XX veka (Moscow, 2003), 161–62Google Scholar

Shatsillo, K. F., Ot Portsmutskogo mira k pervoi mirovoi voine (Moscow, 2000), 14–25Google Scholar

Ananich, Boris, “Financing the War,” in Steinberg, et al. (eds.), The Russo-Japanese War in Global Perspective, I, 463

McDonald, David MacLaren, United Government and Foreign Policy in Russia, 1900–1914 (Cambridge, MA, 1992), 87–92, 97–102CrossRef Google Scholar

Ignat'ev, A. V., Vneshniaia politika Rossii, 1907–1914: Tendentsii. Liudi. Sobytiia (Moscow, 2000), 26–42Google Scholar

Rich, David Alan, “Russia,” in Hamilton, Richard F. and Herwig, Holger H. (eds.), The Origins of World War I (Cambridge, UK, 2003), 196–97Google Scholar

Skvortsov, A. S., Rushin, A. S., et al. (eds.), General'nyi shtab Rossiiskoi armii: Istoriia i sovremennost' (Moscow, 2006), 71–2, 77–9

Kozhevnikova, Galina, Glavnoe upravlenie General'nogo shtaba nakanune pervoi mirovoi voiny (1910–1914) (Moscow, 1998), 10–11, 113–14Google Scholar

Podsoblyaev, Evgenii F., “The Russian Naval General Staff and the Evolution of Naval Policy, 1905–1914,” The Journal of Military History, LXVI, no. 1 (January 2002), 42–3Google Scholar

Beskrovnyi, L. G., Armiia i flot Rossii v nachale XX v. (Moscow, 1986), 49–50, 64–6Google Scholar

Zaionchkovskii, P. A., “Vysshee voennoe upravlenie. Imperator i tsarstvuiushchii dom,” in Zakharova, L. G., Kukushkin, Iu. S., and Emmons, T. (eds.), P. A. Zaionchkovskii 1904–1983 gg. Stat'i, publikatsii i vospominaniia o nem (Moscow, 1998), 93–5Google Scholar

Shatsillo, K. F., Rossiia pered mirovoi voine (Moscow, 1974), 15Google Scholar

Rediger, Aleksandr, Istoriia moei zhizni, 2 vols. (Moscow, 1999), II, 9–10, 81–2Google Scholar

Polivanov, A. A., Iz dnevnikov i vospominanii po dolzhnosti voennogo ministra i ego pomoshchnika, 1907–1916 g., ed. Zaionchkovskii, A. M. (Moscow, 1924), 18Google Scholar

Kavtaradze, A. G., “Military Reforms of 1905–12,” Great Soviet Encyclopedia, tr. 3rd ed., 31 vols. and supplement (New York, 1973–1983), V, 278–79Google Scholar

Gatrell, Peter, Government, Industry and Rearmament in Russia, 1900–1914: The Last Argument of Tsarism (Cambridge, UK, 1994), 125–52CrossRef Google Scholar

Sukhomlinov, V. A., Vospominaniia (Berlin, 1924), 235Google Scholar

Airapetov, Oleg, Vneshniaia politika Rossiiskoi imperii (1801–1914) (Moscow, 2006), 526–32Google Scholar

Shilov, D. N., Gosudarstvennye deiateli Rossiiskoi imperii (St. Petersburg, 2001), 628–31Google Scholar

Fuller, Jr. William C., The Foe Within: Fantasies of Treason and the End of Imperial Russia (Ithaca, 2006), 45–8Google Scholar

Lukomskii, A. S., “Ocherki iz moei zhizni,” Voprosy istorii, no. 8 (August 2001), 92–3Google Scholar

Kavtaradze, A. G., “Iz istorii russkogo general'nogo shtaba,” Voenno-istoricheskii zhurnal, no. 7 (July 1972), 91–2Google Scholar

Danilov, Iu. N., Na puti k krusheniiu, ed. Avdeev, V. A. (Moscow, 1992), 242–43Google Scholar

Kondzerovskii, P. K., V stavke verkhovnogo 1914–1917 (Paris, 1967), 23–4Google Scholar

Geiden, A. F., Itogi russko-iaponskoi voiny 1904–05 gg. (Petrograd, 1914), 81Google Scholar

Stevenson, David, Armaments and the Coming of War: Europe, 1904–1914 (Oxford, 1996), 146–53Google Scholar

Barsukov, E. Z., Russkaia artilleriia v mirovuiu voinu, 2 vols. (Moscow, 1938–1940), I, 18–20Google Scholar

Menning, Bruce W., “The Offensive Revisited: Russian Preparation for Future War, 1906–1914,” in Oye, David Schimmelpenninck and Menning, Bruce W. (eds.), Reforming the Tsar's Army: Military Innovation in Imperial Russia from Peter the Great to the Revolution (Cambridge, UK and New York, 2004), 216–19Google Scholar

Manikovskii, A. A., Boevoe snabzhenie russkoi armii, 3 vols. (Moscow, 1920–1923), III, 7–10Google Scholar

Jones, David R., “Imperial Russia's Forces at War,” in Millett, Allan R. and Murray, Williamson (eds.), Military Effectiveness, 3 vols. (Winchester, MA, 1988), I, 262–63Google Scholar

Golovin, N. N., Voennnye usiliia Rossii v mirovoi voine, reprint ed. (Zhukovskii-Moscow, 2001), 272Google Scholar

Menning, Bruce W., “Mukden to Tannenberg: Defeat to Defeat, 1905–1914,” in Kagan, Frederick W. and Higham, Robin (eds.), The Military History of Tsarist Russia (New York, 2002), 214–15Google Scholar

Apushkin, V. A., General ot porazhenii V. A. Sukhomlinov (Leningrad, 1925), 38Google Scholar

Luntinen, Pertti, French Information on the Russian War Plans 1880–1914 (Helsinki, 1984), 122–28Google Scholar

Alekseev, Mikhail in Voennaia razvedka Rossii, 3 vols in 4 bks. (Moscow, 1998–2001), II, 191–97Google Scholar

Marshall, Alex, “Russian Military Intelligence, 1906–1917: The Untold Story behind Tsarist Russia in the First World War,” War & History, XI, no. 4 (November 2004), 397–98Google Scholar

Schindler, John R., “Redl – Spy of the Century?” International Journal of Intelligence and Counterintelligence, XVIII, no. 3 (Fall 2005), 486–88, 490–95Google Scholar

Zolotarev, V. A., “Deistviia russkogo flota v Pervoi mirovoi voine,” Voenno-istoricheskii zhurnal, no. 1 (January 2002), 56Google Scholar

Batiushin, N. S., in Tainaia razvedka i bor'ba c nei, reprint ed. (Moscow, 2002), 79–80Google Scholar

“K voprosu o podgotovke mirovoi voiny,” Krasnyi arkhiv, no. 64 (1934), 90–3

Menning, Bruce W., “Pieces of the Puzzle: The Role of Iu. N. Danilov and M. V. Alekseev in Russian War Planning before 1914,” The International Historical Review, XXV, no. 4 (December 2003), 794–96Google Scholar

Golovine, N. N., The Russian Campaign of 1914. The Beginning of the War and Operations in East Prussia (Ft. Leavenworth, KS, 1933), 67Google Scholar

,10-i otdel General'nogo shtaba RKKA, Vostochno-Prusskaia operatsiia. Sbornik dokumentov [hereinafter Vostochno-Prusskaia operatsiia] (Moscow, 1939), 38–9Google Scholar

Tsikhovich, Ia. K. (comp.), Strategicheskii ocherk voiny 1914–1918 g.g. (Moscow, 1922), 16–20Google Scholar

Beloi, A. S., Galitsiiskaia bitva (Moscow, 1929), 23–4Google Scholar

Suvorov, A. N., “Voennaia igra starshikh voiskovykh nachal'nikov v aprele 1914 goda,” Voenno-istoricheskii sbornik, vyp. 1 (1919), 15–19, 21–2Google Scholar

Menning, Bruce W., Bayonets before Bullets: The Imperial Russian Army, 1861–1914 (Bloomington, 1992), 251–54Google Scholar

Melikov, V. A., Strategicheskoe ravertyvanie (Moscow, 1939), 275–76Google Scholar

Sanborn, Josh, “The Mobilization of 1914 and the Question of the Russian Nation: A Reexamination,” Slavic Review, LIX, no. 2 (Summer 2000), 271–73Google Scholar

Belitskii, S. M., Strategicheskie reservy (Moscow-Leningrad, 1930), 63–4Google Scholar

[Borisov, V. E.] Kratkii strategicheskii ocherk voiny 1914–1918 gg., 2 vols. (Moscow, 1918–1919), I, 18, 20Google Scholar

Vatsetis, I. I., Operatsii na vostochnoi granitse Germanii v 1914. Ch. 1-aia. Vostochnaia-Prusskaia operatsiia (Moscow-Leningrad, 1929), 27–8Google Scholar

Zuber, Terence, German War Planning, 1891–1914: Sources and Interpretations (Woodridge, Suffolk, 2004), 137–39, 144–45, 170–73Google Scholar

Showalter, Dennis E., Tannenberg, Clash of Empires (Hamden, CT, 1991), 153–59Google Scholar

Kolenkovskii, A. K., Manevrennyi period pervoi mirovoi imperialisticheskoi voiny 1914 g. (Moscow, 1940), 184–85Google Scholar

Khramov, F. A., Vostochno-Prusskaia operatsiia 1914 g. (Moscow, 1940), 41–2Google Scholar

Gromov, F. N. and Kasatonov, I. V. (eds.), Na rubezhe vekov: Tri veka Rossiiskogo flota, 3 vols. (St. Petersburg, 1996), III, 69–71Google Scholar

Stone, Norman, The Eastern Front, 1914–1917 (New York, 1975), 82, 84Google Scholar

Zaionchkovskii, A. M., Pervaia mirovaia voina, reprint ed. (St. Petersburg, 2000), 96–7Google Scholar

Kronenbitter, Günther, “Krieg im Frieden”: Die Führung der k.u.k. Armee und die Groβmachtpolitik Österreich-Ungarns 1906–1914 (Munich, 2003), 446–47CrossRef Google Scholar

Tunstall, Jr. Graydon A., Planning for War against Russia and Serbia: Austro-Hungarian and German Military Strategies, 1871–1914 (New York, 1993), 96Google Scholar

,General'nyi Shtab RKKA, Varshavsko-Ivangorodskaia operatsiia. Sbornik dokumentov (Moscow-Leningrad, 1938), 445–47Google Scholar

Hughes, Daniel J. (ed.), Moltke on the Art of War: Selected Writings, tr. Hughes, Daniel J. and Bell, Harry (Novato, CA, 1993), 45

Accessibility standard: Unknown

Accessibility compliance for the PDF of this book is currently unknown and may be updated in the future.