Let M be a von Neumann algebra, let
$\varphi $ be a normal faithful state on M and let
$L^p(M,\varphi )$ be the associated Haagerup noncommutative
$L^p$-spaces, for
$1\leq p\leq \infty $. Let
$D\in L^1(M,\varphi )$ be the density of
$\varphi $. Given a positive map
$T\colon M\to M$ such that
$\varphi \circ T\leq C_1\varphi $ for some
$C_1\geq 0$, we study the boundedness of the
$L^p$-extension
$T_{p,\theta }\colon D^{\frac {1-\theta }{p}} MD^{\frac {\theta }{p}}\to L^p(M,\varphi )$ which maps
$D^{\frac {1-\theta }{p}} x D^{\frac {\theta }{p}}$ to
$D^{\frac {1-\theta }{p}} T(x) D^{\frac {\theta }{p}}$ for all
$x\in M$. Haagerup–Junge–Xu showed that
$T_{p,{\frac {1}{2}}}$ is always bounded and left open the question whether
$T_{p,\theta }$ is bounded for
$\theta \not ={\frac {1}{2}}$. We show that for any
$1\leq p<2$ and any
$\theta \in [0, 2^{-1}(1-\sqrt {p-1})]\cup [2^{-1}(1+\sqrt {p-1}), 1]$, there exists a completely positive T such that
$T_{p,\theta }$ is unbounded. We also show that if T is
$2$-positive, then
$T_{p,\theta }$ is bounded provided that
$p\geq 2$ or
$1\leq p<2$ and
$\theta \in [1-p/2,p/2]$.