This study directly tests the ability of severalcompeting methods to identify market buy and sellorders using intra-day quote and trade prices, andidentifies factors that affect the accuracy of themethods. Lee and Ready's (1991) algorithm performsabout the same as the tick test, but the performanceof both methods is worse than expected. The resultsshow that the use of either algorithm to classifytrades can lead to significantly biased estimates ofeffective spreads and signed volume, but the ticktest provides better estimates of effective spreadsand signed volume than Lee and Ready's method.